eikna romance
Menu

A Holly Jolly Diwali by Sonya Lalli Review

Eikna Score: 6.8/10. Recommended with reservations.

A Holly Jolly Diwali is a holiday rom com about a cautious woman who finally says yes to life, set over Diwali in Mumbai and a wedding party in Goa. The setting and Niki's self-discovery are lovely, but the romance with a London musician moves too fast to feel fully earned.

Read it if you want a sweet, closed door holiday romance that travels, with an Indian American heroine reconnecting with her roots. Skip it if you need a slow-built love story, or you expect Diwali to drive the plot rather than color it.

A Holly Jolly Diwali by Sonya Lalli book cover

A Holly Jolly Diwali at a Glance

A Holly Jolly Diwali is a standalone contemporary holiday rom com by Sonya Lalli, published by Berkley on October 5, 2021. It follows Niki Randhawa, 29 and newly laid off, on an impulsive trip to India for a friend's wedding, where Diwali in Mumbai and a London musician named Sam shake up her safe life, with closed door heat and a hopeful ending.

AuthorSonya Lalli
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreRomantic comedy (Diwali holiday romance, Mumbai and Goa)
Main tropesOpposites attract, vacation romance, destination wedding, career reset, finding your roots
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsJob loss, family and cultural pressure, harassment in a public setting (full list below)
EndingHopeful, with a choice about her future
Pages336 (trade paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Richa Moorjani, about 7 hours 13 minutes (Penguin Audio)
First publishedOctober 5, 2021
PublisherBerkley (Penguin Random House)

What Is A Holly Jolly Diwali About?

Niki Randhawa is 29, a data analyst and someone who has always played it safe. When she is laid off, she does something completely out of character: she books a last-minute flight to India for her friend Diya's wedding.

She arrives in time for Diwali in Mumbai, then joins the group honeymoon in Goa, and somewhere along the way she meets Sameer "Sam" Mukherji, a musician from London who encourages her to take risks, reconnect with her creative side and explore her Indian roots. Then a new job offer comes from home, and Niki has to decide which version of her life she wants.

What Makes This Holiday Rom Com Work

A Holly Jolly Diwali works best as a travel story. Seeing India through Niki's eyes on her first real visit gives the book a sense of discovery, and Publishers Weekly praised its rich depictions of South Asian culture and its gentle look at the gap between Indian Americans and people from India.

The second hook is Niki's reset. A careful woman who loses her job at 29 and decides, for once, to say yes is a premise many readers recognize. Phoebe Wright at Read and Wright said Niki's story of starting over in her late twenties resonated strongly with her.

Then there is the holiday itself. Diwali romances are still rare, and a festive rom com that runs from the festival of lights toward Christmas is a welcome change from yet another snowy small town.

My Review

I enjoyed traveling with A Holly Jolly Diwali more than I enjoyed its romance. Niki's journey toward a bolder life is the real story, and when the book focuses on her, her family and India, it is warm and specific. Sam is charming, but I never quite believed how fast they got there.

Romance and Chemistry

Niki and Sam are classic opposites: she plans, he improvises; she plays safe, he lives on instinct. Their early scenes have a nice spark, and Sam's encouragement is the push Niki needs. The problem is time. Read and Wright found the romance a little insta-lovey, and Publishers Weekly said the love story's clunky pacing weakens its emotional impact.

There are also fewer obstacles than you might expect until the end, when the job offer forces a choice. Some StoryGraph readers felt the courtship was rushed and underdeveloped. I agree, though the book is honest that this is a holiday-season romance and the ending reflects that.

The Characters

Niki is sympathetic and recognizable: a woman who has done everything right and has a layoff to show for it. Her relationship with her sister and her questions about identity are some of the best material in the book, and Utopia State of Mind singled out the sister thread and the Indian and American identity themes.

Sam is appealing on the page, a musician with warmth and charm who sees the bolder person Niki could be. Both leads can feel a little thin, though, and some readers wanted more of Sam's inner life. The wedding party and the aunties add color without taking much space.

Writing and Pacing

Lalli's prose is easy and the settings are vivid. The pacing is uneven. Utopia State of Mind took a while to fall for the book and said the last quarter took them by storm, while Read and Wright felt the pacing was rushed and left little time for the supporting cast.

The book is short, and you feel it: the middle meanders through the trip, and the ending arrives quickly. If you listen, Kirkus praised Richa Moorjani's range on the audiobook, from judgmental aunties to motherly ones.

A Holly Jolly Diwali is a sweet, closed door holiday rom com with a lovely sense of place and a heroine worth cheering for, and a romance that moves faster than it should. Read it for the trip and for Niki; temper expectations for the love story.

How Spicy Is A Holly Jolly Diwali?

A Holly Jolly Diwali is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. Read and Wright called it a sweet, closed door romance, and the physical side stays at kisses and attraction. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reviews, reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read A Holly Jolly Diwali?

A Holly Jolly Diwali suits readers who want a sweet, closed door holiday romance with travel, an Indian American heroine and a story about starting over at 29. It is less suited to readers who want a slow-burn romance, heat or a festival-centered plot.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

A Holly Jolly Diwali drew mixed but generally friendly reviews. Publishers Weekly called it an unsteady holiday rom com that works better as an escape than a romance, Kirkus praised the audiobook performance, Read and Wright gave it 3.5 stars and Utopia State of Mind came around to loving its final quarter.

Where they agree. The setting and Niki's journey. Reviewers praise the colorful depiction of India and the honesty of a heroine starting over.

Where they split. The romance and pacing. Publishers Weekly found the love story clunky, Read and Wright found it insta-lovey and rushed, and some StoryGraph readers found both leads thin. Utopia State of Mind, by contrast, found the ending a highlight after a slow start.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

A Holly Jolly Diwali scores 6.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for heat delivery, characters and emotional impact, and a lower romance score because the courtship moves too fast.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3Sparks early, but clunky pacing per Publishers Weekly and insta-love per Read and Wright.
Characters (15%)3.5Niki resonates per Read and Wright; both leads feel thin to some readers.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Vivid settings per Publishers Weekly; rushed pacing per Read and Wright.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Niki's reset and identity questions land, per Utopia State of Mind.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the sweet, closed door romance the cover promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A hopeful ending that won Utopia State of Mind over, if quick.
Reread appeal (10%)3A pleasant one-time holiday trip rather than a reread.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: A Holly Jolly Diwali sits in the middle of recent holiday rom coms, stronger on setting and identity than on romance, with a final Eikna Score of 6.8/10.

Is A Holly Jolly Diwali a Standalone?

Yes. A Holly Jolly Diwali is a standalone novel with a complete story, so you can start here with no prior reading of Sonya Lalli's other books.

Best format: the audiobook, narrated by Richa Moorjani, is a strong choice; Kirkus praised her range across the book's many voices, and at about 7 hours it is a quick listen. Our series order guide covers connected romances if you want something longer.

If You Loved A Holly Jolly Diwali, Read These Next

If you loved A Holly Jolly Diwali, look for holiday and wedding romances with cultural texture, family and a heroine finding her way.

Frequently Asked Questions

A Holly Jolly Diwali prompts a few common questions: how spicy it is, where it is set, whether it stands alone and how it ends. Short answers below, without spoilers.

Is A Holly Jolly Diwali spicy?

No. It is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, a sweet, closed door romance with kisses on the page.

Where is A Holly Jolly Diwali set?

Mostly in India: Niki arrives in Mumbai for Diwali and a friend's wedding, then joins the group honeymoon in Goa.

Is A Holly Jolly Diwali a Christmas book?

It is a holiday book that centers Diwali, with the season running toward Christmas; the festival colors the story more than it drives the plot.

Is A Holly Jolly Diwali a standalone?

Yes. It is a complete standalone novel.

Does A Holly Jolly Diwali have a happy ending?

It ends on a hopeful note, after Niki makes a choice about her future.

Is there an A Holly Jolly Diwali audiobook?

Yes. Penguin Audio's version is narrated by Richa Moorjani and runs about 7 hours 13 minutes.

The Bottom Line

A Holly Jolly Diwali earns a 6.8/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a sweet, closed door holiday rom com that travels to Mumbai and Goa, with a cautious heroine learning to take a chance on herself. The reason to pick it up is Niki's trip: the moment a woman who always played it safe finally gets on the plane.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.