In a Holidaze by Christina Lauren Review
Eikna Score: 7.0/10. Recommended.
In a Holidaze is a Christmas time loop that knows exactly what kind of comfort it is selling: a snowed-in cabin, a found family with a lot of traditions and a heroine who keeps getting another chance to tell her crush the truth. The loop mechanics are thin and the love interest is close to flawless, but as a December read it is warm, funny and easy to love.
Read it if you want a cozy holiday romance with Groundhog Day energy, or you love a long, secret crush on a family friend finally paying off. Skip it if you need time travel rules that hold up, or you want a hero with real edges.
In a Holidaze at a Glance
In a Holidaze is a standalone Christmas romance by Christina Lauren, published by Gallery Books on October 6, 2020. Mae Jones narrates in first person as she relives the same family holiday at a Utah cabin, chasing her crush on family friend Andrew. Heat is mild and the ending is a happily ever after.
| Author | Christina Lauren (Christina Hobbs and Lauren Billings) |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy, holiday romance with a time loop |
| Main tropes | Friends to lovers, time loop, secret crush, holiday cabin, found family |
| Spice level | 2/5: Mild, fade to black |
| Content warnings | Car crash, alcohol and marijuana use, strong language (full list below) |
| POV | First person, Mae only |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 336 (Gallery Books; Publishers Weekly and Kirkus list 320) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Patti Murin, 7 hours 40 minutes (Simon & Schuster Audio) |
| First published | October 6, 2020 |
| Publisher | Gallery Books, an imprint of Simon & Schuster |
What Is In a Holidaze About?
Every Christmas, Maelyn Jones and her parents spend the holiday at a cabin in the Utah mountains with the same group of old friends and their kids. It is the best week of her year. This year is a disaster: she is unsure what she is doing with her life, she does something embarrassing with the wrong brother, and she learns the cabin may not be theirs much longer.
On the way home, Mae makes a wish for the universe to show her what will make her happy. Then she wakes up on the plane, heading back to the start of the same holiday. Each loop gives her another shot at telling Andrew, the family friend she has loved for years, how she feels, and at saving the tradition before it ends.
What Makes This Time Loop Christmas Romance Work
In a Holidaze works because it pairs two very old wishes: to do a bad week over, and to finally say the thing. The time loop is the excuse. The real story is a woman who has kept her feelings for Andrew quiet for years deciding to stop being careful, and the repeated holiday lets her try out braver versions of herself.
The cabin family is the other half of the appeal. Mae's parents, Andrew's family, the beloved older friend Benny and a crowd of honorary siblings all share inside jokes, snow-day rituals and competitive games. Kirkus valued the banter and Mae's bond with Benny, and Publishers Weekly praised the family subplots alongside the romance.
The loop also lets Christina Lauren play with expectation. Sarah Perchikoff at Bookish Rantings liked how selectively the repetition is used, and that restraint matters: the book skips rather than replays, so it never turns into the same day told five times. For readers who love friends to lovers romance with a long history behind it, the premise is a gift.
My Review
In a Holidaze is a better book in a snowstorm than in a heat wave. That is not a dig. It is a mood book, built to be read under a blanket, and it delivers that mood with a lot of skill: a crowded cabin, a pantry of traditions, a narrator whose embarrassment is very easy to recognize.
It is also slighter than its premise suggests. The time loop is magic with no rules, the stakes rest on property, not peril, and the romantic hero is so nice that the book has to manufacture its late conflict elsewhere. Those things kept me from loving it. They did not stop me from enjoying it.
Romance and Chemistry
Mae and Andrew have the warm, easy chemistry of two people who have known each other since childhood, and the best scenes are the ones where that familiarity becomes something else: a walk in the snow, a joke that lands differently, a look held a second too long. Patti Murin's narration makes those scenes even softer in audio.
The problem is Andrew himself. Llama Reads Books found him overly idealized, and I agree. He is kind, funny, handsome and emotionally available, which makes him lovely to read and hard to worry about. The romance generates its tension mostly from Mae's nerves and the loop, not from anything between them, and the late conflict that Llama Reads Books also questioned feels bolted on. Dini at dinipandareads enjoyed the chemistry but wondered why Theo, Andrew's brother, is so firmly sidelined after the early mix-up, and that is a fair point too.
The Characters
Mae is good company: self-deprecating, sentimental about her family and willing to make a fool of herself. Her arc is about asking for what she wants, at work and in love, and Sarah Perchikoff at Bookish Rantings singled out her growth. Danielle at No Apology Book Reviews wanted the book to show more clearly why Mae is so afraid of change, and I felt that gap as well. The fear is told more than shown.
Benny is the heart of the supporting cast, a grown-up friend Mae trusts more than almost anyone, and their scenes have real tenderness. The rest of the cabin crowd is fun but crowded. Meaghan Mains at Fully Booked found the supporting characters thin, and on a first read I had trouble keeping some of the parents straight.
Writing and Pacing
The writing is breezy and quick, with Christina Lauren's usual run of jokes, pop culture and self-aware narration. At around 330 pages the book never drags. The loops come fast early on, then settle once Mae figures out what she is doing, and the back half is mostly romance and family.
The loop is the weakest piece of craft. Meaghan Mains at Fully Booked wanted more explanation of how and why it happens, and readers looking for the internal logic of a time travel story will not find it here. I think that is a choice rather than an oversight. The book wants a Christmas wish, not a mechanism. Whether you accept that will decide how much you enjoy the middle.
In a Holidaze is a sweet, funny Christmas time loop whose cozy family setting matters more than its magic or its slightly too perfect hero. Read it in December if you want comfort, a long-awaited crush and a happy ending, and lower your expectations for the loop.
How Spicy Is In a Holidaze?
In a Holidaze is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. The romance is mostly kissing and longing, with sex arriving late and handled briefly. Reviewers disagree on how much is on the page: Cathy Carmode Lim at Rated Reads described the scenes as detailed, while Dini at dinipandareads called them fade to black. We place it at 2 because what is there is short and comes near the end.
This is one of Christina Lauren's milder books, and a reasonable pick for readers who want some heat without much explicitness. See our closed door romance list if you want even less.
Content warnings, drawn from Llama Reads Books, Rated Reads and reader reviews:
- A car crash
- Ableist language, flagged by Llama Reads Books
- Alcohol and marijuana use
- Strong language throughout
- Brief sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Who Should Read In a Holidaze?
In a Holidaze suits readers who want a cozy, funny Christmas romance with a time loop twist, a big found family and a long-held crush on a family friend. It suits readers less well if they want a grounded plot, a complicated hero or substantial heat.
Best for:
- Readers who want a holiday comfort read for December
- Fans of Groundhog Day style stories
- Anyone who loves found family and big group traditions
- Readers who like friends to lovers with years of history
Not for:
- Readers who need time travel rules that make sense
- Anyone who wants a morally grey or difficult hero
- Readers looking for a steamy holiday romance
- Those who find large casts hard to track
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
In late 2024 Netflix announced a film adaptation. The movie, directed by Tiffany Paulsen with Maddie Ziegler as Mae and Graham Phillips as Andrew, is set for release on Netflix on December 2, 2026, and the book has a media tie-in edition to match.
Where they agree. The banter and the family. Kirkus valued the jokes and Mae's bond with Benny, Publishers Weekly praised the developing relationship and the subplots, and Sarah Perchikoff at Bookish Rantings liked the selective use of the loop and Mae's growth. Carol at Reading Ladies reported a happy ending that suited the season.
Where they split. Andrew and the loop. Llama Reads Books found Andrew overly idealized and the late conflict weak, Meaghan Mains at Fully Booked wanted more explanation of the loop and more depth in the side characters, and Danielle at No Apology Book Reviews wanted Mae's fear of change shown more strongly. An r/RomanceBooks book club split on the chemistry and on how fairly Mae treats Theo.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
In a Holidaze scores 7.0 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for reread appeal as a seasonal comfort book and its lowest for characters, where an idealized hero and a crowded cabin limit the depth.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Warm, easy chemistry; Llama Reads Books finds Andrew overly idealized and the conflict thin. |
| Characters (15%) | 3 | Mae and Benny shine; Fully Booked calls the supporting cast thin. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Breezy and quick, with selective loops praised by Bookish Rantings; the magic is unexplained. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Kirkus praises the bond with Benny; the stakes stay gentle. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Mild heat suits the cozy tone; reviewers disagree on how explicit the brief scenes are. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A seasonal HEA, per Reading Ladies, though the late conflict feels added on. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 4 | Built to be reread each December, and a Netflix film in 2026 will bring readers back. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: In a Holidaze is Christina Lauren's coziest book and one of the more popular holiday romances of its year, though it is lighter than their best work, and it lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.0/10.
Is In a Holidaze a Standalone?
Yes. In a Holidaze is a standalone novel, and the Christina Lauren catalogue lists it with no series or sequel. You can read it without having read any other Christina Lauren book.
If you want more from the same authors, these standalones are reviewed on Eikna, in publication order:
- Roomies (2017)
- Love and Other Words (2018)
- The Unhoneymooners (2019)
- In a Holidaze (2020)
- The Soulmate Equation (2021)
- The True Love Experiment (2023)
Best format: the Patti Murin audiobook is under eight hours, which makes it an easy listen over a holiday week, and her warm, comic delivery suits Mae. Our series order guide covers connected romance series.
If You Loved In a Holidaze, Read These Next
If you loved In a Holidaze, look for holiday romances and second-chance stories with a touch of magic or a crowded family table.
- The Seven Year Slip by Ashley Poston: a magic apartment, a love story out of time and the same wistful tone.
- Kiss Her Once for Me by Alison Cochrun: a queer Christmas rom com with a fake engagement and a family holiday.
- The Holiday Swap by Maggie Knox: twin sisters trade lives at Christmas in a cozy small town.
- Snowed In by Catherine Walsh: a fake relationship and a snowbound Irish family Christmas.
- Love and Other Words by Christina Lauren: the same authors on a love that starts in childhood, with more heartache.
Frequently Asked Questions
In a Holidaze draws the same seasonal questions every year: is it spicy, is it a standalone, how does the time loop work and when is the Netflix movie out. Short answers below.
Is In a Holidaze spicy?
Only mildly. In a Holidaze is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with mostly kissing and a short sex scene late in the book.
Is In a Holidaze a standalone?
Yes. In a Holidaze is a standalone Christmas novel with no sequel.
Does In a Holidaze have a happy ending?
Yes. In a Holidaze ends with a happily ever after for Mae and Andrew.
Is In a Holidaze a time loop book?
Yes. Mae relives the start of the same family Christmas several times, though the book does not explain how the loop works.
Is there an In a Holidaze movie?
Yes. Netflix's In a Holidaze, directed by Tiffany Paulsen and starring Maddie Ziegler as Mae and Graham Phillips as Andrew, is set for release on December 2, 2026.
Who narrates the In a Holidaze audiobook?
Patti Murin narrates the Simon & Schuster Audio edition, which runs about 7 hours 40 minutes.
The Bottom Line
In a Holidaze earns a 7.0/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a warm, funny Christmas romance with a time loop, a big chosen family and a crush finally confessed, and who can live with a near perfect hero. The one reason to pick it up is the cabin itself: few holiday romances make you want to join the family quite this much.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- In a Holidaze audiobook, Libro.fm (narrator, length)
- In a Holidaze Netflix film release date and cast, What's on Netflix
- Holidaze cast announcement, Christina Lauren official site
- In a Holidaze to be adapted by Netflix, Weintraub Tobin (November 2024)
- Publishers Weekly and Kirkus Reviews reviews of In a Holidaze
- Llama Reads Books; Sarah Perchikoff, Bookish Rantings; Danielle, No Apology Book Reviews; Meaghan Mains, Fully Booked; Dini, dinipandareads; Carol, Reading Ladies; Cathy Carmode Lim, Rated Reads
- r/RomanceBooks book club discussion
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.