eikna romance
Menu

The Matzah Ball by Jean Meltzer Review

Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.

The Matzah Ball is a warm, crowded, very Jewish holiday rom com whose best pages belong to Rachel's chronic illness and her family, not to the romance. The reunion with her camp rival runs on a backstory that is thinner than the book thinks, but the heart is real and the Hanukkah setting is rare enough to be worth the trip.

Read it if you want a Hanukkah romance written from inside Jewish family life, or a heroine with a chronic illness whose love story never treats her body as the obstacle. Skip it if a heroine who keeps a big secret from everyone grates on you, or you need a tight, fast plot.

The Matzah Ball by Jean Meltzer book cover

The Matzah Ball at a Glance

The Matzah Ball is Jean Meltzer's debut, a standalone contemporary holiday rom com published by MIRA on September 28, 2021. It follows a secret Christmas romance novelist with ME/CFS as she reunites with her childhood camp rival over a Hanukkah ball in New York, keeps the bedroom door closed and ends happily ever after.

AuthorJean Meltzer
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreRomantic comedy (Hanukkah holiday romance, New York City)
Main tropesSecond chance, childhood rivals, summer camp history, secret identity, forced teamwork
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsChronic illness (ME/CFS), medical dismissal, lying to family, grief (full list below)
EndingHEA
Pages336 (US trade paperback, per Publishers Weekly)
AudiobookNarrated by Dara Rosenberg, about 10 hours 15 minutes
First publishedSeptember 28, 2021
PublisherMIRA (Harlequin, HarperCollins)

What Is The Matzah Ball About?

Rachel Rubenstein-Goldblatt is close to her Jewish family, rooted in her community and, under a pen name, a successful author of Christmas romances. Nobody in her family knows. Her publisher wants a Hanukkah book next, and Rachel, who has never felt the same spark for her own holiday, needs inspiration fast.

The answer is the Matzah Ball, a lavish Hanukkah party in New York run by Jacob Greenberg, the boy who broke her heart at Jewish summer camp when they were twelve. Rachel lives with myalgic encephalomyelitis, also called chronic fatigue syndrome, and has to ration every bit of energy. Volunteering for Jacob's event, and keeping her secrets, will cost her more than he knows.

What Makes This Second Chance Holiday Romance Work

The Matzah Ball works because it is a Hanukkah romance written from the inside. Shabbat dinners, family guilt, Yiddish that is left untranslated and a heroine who loves Christmas lights without wanting to convert: the texture is specific, funny and affectionate, and it is still rare on the holiday romance shelf.

The second hook is Rachel's illness. Meltzer has ME/CFS herself, and Rachel's days are measured in spoons, rest and the quiet math of what she can afford to do. Publishers Weekly noted that the illness shapes her choices without defining her or blocking her happy ending, and that is exactly the balance the book strikes.

Then there is the second chance setup. Rachel and Jacob share a camp history and an eighteen-year grudge, so every conversation comes loaded. Whether that grudge is believable is where readers split, but it does give the banter a running start.

My Review

I went into The Matzah Ball hoping for a holiday rom com that would let Jewish readers be the main characters for once, and on that front it delivers generously. The family scenes are the best thing in it. The romance is pleasant, occasionally sweet and never quite as strong as everything around it.

Romance and Chemistry

Rachel and Jacob have the bones of a good pairing: two stubborn people who remember exactly how the other one hurt them. The problem is that the hurt happened when they were twelve. Dear Author's Jayne, who stopped halfway, could not believe that two thirty-year-olds would still be nursing a camp breakup, and I understand the objection. The early chapters return to that summer so often that the grudge starts to feel like a plot device rather than a feeling.

When the book lets them simply be adults working on a stressful event together, the chemistry improves. Jacob does not know about Rachel's illness at first and keeps asking her to do things her body cannot handle, which Kirkus, reviewing the audiobook, singled out as a real source of tension. Watching him learn to see her limits without pitying her is the most romantic thread in the book.

The Characters

Rachel is likeable and frustrating in equal measure. She is funny and warm, and Meltzer writes her exhaustion, her doctor visits and her careful pacing with authority. She also lies, to her parents about her career and to Jacob about her health, for most of the novel. All About Romance found her secret-keeping and Jacob's disregard for boundaries hard going but still loved the book for its chemistry and cultural detail. That matches my read.

The supporting cast is where The Matzah Ball shines. Publishers Weekly picked out Jacob's grandmother and Rachel's best friend Mickey as standouts, and Rachel's parents get real scenes rather than walk-ons. Not every portrait lands, though. Dear Author flagged Mickey as a stock gay best friend and Rachel's mother as leaning on Jewish mother clichés, and some readers objected to a joke about Mossad later in the book.

Writing and Pacing

Meltzer writes with energy and plenty of jokes, and the Jewish detail is woven in naturally. All About Romance called the cultural side of the book spectacular, and I would not argue. The pacing is another matter. The middle repeats its backstory and its misunderstandings, and at over three hundred pages the story could lose fifty without missing anything.

The audiobook is a good option here. Kirkus praised Dara Rosenberg for New York accents that avoid stereotype and for handling the Hebrew and Yiddish smoothly, and the book's chatty rhythm suits being read aloud.

The Matzah Ball is a big-hearted Hanukkah rom com with excellent family scenes, honest chronic illness representation and a romance that leans too hard on a childhood grudge. Read it for Rachel and her world, and forgive the middle for wandering.

How Spicy Is The Matzah Ball?

The Matzah Ball is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. The romance stays at kissing, flirting and longing on the page, and any intimacy beyond that happens off it. It is a comfortable pick for readers who want a sweet holiday romance. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reviews, reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Matzah Ball?

The Matzah Ball suits readers who want a closed door holiday rom com rooted in Jewish family life, with a chronically ill heroine and a big, noisy supporting cast. It is less suited to readers who need a tight plot, distrust childhood-crush backstories or dislike heroines who hide the truth for most of a book.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Matzah Ball was a well-reviewed debut. Publishers Weekly called it a charming holiday romance and praised its supporting cast and its handling of chronic illness, Kirkus recommended the audiobook, and All About Romance admired the cultural detail. Most of the pushback concerns the romance's foundations and the pacing.

Where they agree. The Jewish representation and the illness. Even Dear Author's Jayne, who did not finish, praised the family Shabbat scenes and the untranslated Hebrew, and valued how Rachel's ME/CFS is portrayed.

Where they split. The romance and the lying. All About Romance found the leads' chemistry strong enough to carry Rachel's secrets and Jacob's boundary problems. Dear Author found the camp backstory unconvincing, the adult reunion closer to instalust and the repeated backstory glacially slow, and noted reader objections to some stereotypes.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Matzah Ball scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for characters, emotional impact and ending, and lower scores for a romance and pacing that rely on a thin childhood grudge.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Pleasant chemistry per All About Romance; Dear Author found the camp grudge unconvincing.
Characters (15%)4Rachel and the supporting cast are vivid, per Publishers Weekly, despite some stock figures.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Lively and funny, but the middle repeats itself, per Dear Author.
Emotional impact (15%)4Rachel's ME/CFS is handled with care and real stakes, per Publishers Weekly and Kirkus.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the sweet, closed door romance a holiday rom com promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A warm HEA that resolves both the romance and the family secrets.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A comfort reread for December, slowed by its baggy middle.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Matzah Ball sits among the more distinctive holiday rom coms of recent years for its Jewish setting and chronic illness rep, even if the romance is middle of the pack, with a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.

Is The Matzah Ball a Standalone?

Yes. The Matzah Ball is a standalone novel with a complete story and a happy ending, so you can start here with no prior reading. It was Jean Meltzer's debut; her later novels are separate stories.

Best format: the audiobook, narrated by Dara Rosenberg, suits the book's chatty voice and handles the Hebrew and Yiddish well. Print or ebook works just as nicely if you like to skim the slower middle. Our series order guide covers connected romances if you want something longer.

If You Loved The Matzah Ball, Read These Next

If you loved The Matzah Ball, look for holiday romances with a strong cultural setting, family at the center and low to moderate heat.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Matzah Ball raises the same handful of questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and how it handles chronic illness. Short answers below.

Is The Matzah Ball spicy?

No. The Matzah Ball is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, with kissing on the page and any further intimacy kept behind a closed door.

Is The Matzah Ball a standalone?

Yes. It is Jean Meltzer's debut and a complete standalone novel.

Does The Matzah Ball have a happy ending?

Yes. Rachel and Jacob get a happily ever after.

What illness does Rachel have in The Matzah Ball?

Rachel has myalgic encephalomyelitis, also known as chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS). Jean Meltzer lives with the same condition.

Is The Matzah Ball a Hanukkah book?

Yes. The plot centers on a Hanukkah ball in New York, though Rachel secretly writes Christmas romances and loves the season's trappings.

Is there a The Matzah Ball audiobook?

Yes. The unabridged audiobook is narrated by Dara Rosenberg and runs about 10 hours 15 minutes.

How old are Rachel and Jacob in The Matzah Ball?

They are adults, around thirty. Their camp romance ended when they were twelve, eighteen years before the story begins.

The Bottom Line

The Matzah Ball earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a closed door holiday rom com set inside Jewish family life, with a heroine whose chronic illness is part of her story rather than the obstacle to her happy ending. The reason to pick it up is the world around Rachel: her parents, her friends and a Hanukkah that finally gets its own romance.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.