eikna romance
Menu

The Christmas Wish by Lindsey Kelk Review

Eikna Score: 6.7/10. Recommended with reservations.

The Christmas Wish is a chatty, very British Groundhog Day Christmas comedy that is really about a woman repairing her family, with a boy-next-door romance arriving late. It is funny and occasionally moving, but the repetition, the pop culture overload and the slow-to-start romance will test readers who came for a love story.

Read it if you like Bridget Jones-style heroines, family chaos and time loop comedies, and do not mind the romance taking a back seat. Skip it if you want the love story front and center, or crude humor and wall-to-wall references grate on you.

The Christmas Wish by Lindsey Kelk book cover

The Christmas Wish at a Glance

The Christmas Wish is a standalone Christmas romantic comedy by British author Lindsey Kelk, published by HarperCollins in November 2022. It traps newly single lawyer Gwen Baker in a repeating Christmas at her family's village home, with her teenage crush Dev next door, kisses-only heat and a romance that resolves late in a hopeful ending.

AuthorLindsey Kelk
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreRomantic comedy (British Christmas time loop, village setting)
Main tropesTime loop, boy next door, teenage crush, fresh start after a breakup, family secrets
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsInfidelity (backstory), family conflict, loneliness and grief, crude humor (full list below)
EndingHopeful and happy, with the romance arriving late
Pages384 (US trade paperback, per Publishers Weekly)
AudiobookNarrated by Kristin Atherton, about 10 hours 31 minutes (HarperCollins)
First publishedNovember 2022 (US edition November 15, 2022)
PublisherHarperCollins

What Is The Christmas Wish About?

Gwen Baker is a lawyer, newly single after discovering her boyfriend has been cheating, and heading home to her family's village for Christmas to lick her wounds. Home means her parents, a prickly relationship with her sister Cerys and Dev, the boy next door she had a crush on as a teenager, who has grown up to be just as appealing as she remembered.

Then Gwen wakes up and it is Christmas Day again. And again. Stuck reliving the same holiday, she starts to see her family, her choices and Dev differently, and has to work out what the loop wants from her before she can move on to December 26.

What Makes This Time Loop Christmas Comedy Work

The Christmas Wish works because of its voice. Gwen's voice is self-deprecating and rapid-fire, and Publishers Weekly compared the mix to Groundhog Day crossed with Bridget Jones, calling it an utterly adorable rom com. If you enjoy a heroine who is a bit of a mess and knows it, her company is a lot of fun.

The second hook is the time loop. Reliving one Christmas lets Gwen try different versions of the same day: the good, the disastrous and the ridiculous. JoJo's Modern Life said the loop drives the plot and gives Gwen the chance to reconnect with her family, which is where the emotional weight sits.

Finally, there is the British Christmas texture: family arguments, small village life and a steady stream of pop culture references. For readers who want a festive comedy with some heart rather than a pure romance, that is the appeal.

My Review

I liked The Christmas Wish more as a family comedy than as a romance, and I suspect most readers will. Kelk is very funny, and the time loop lets her play. But a Christmas love story where the love story barely starts until the last quarter is a hard sell, however charming the boy next door.

Romance and Chemistry

Dev is lovely: kind, grown-up and patient with Gwen in a way her ex never was. The trouble is page time. JoJo's Modern Life noted that the romance does not really begin until about three quarters of the way through, partly because Gwen is too wrapped up in her own crisis to notice what is in front of her. Publishers Weekly also observed that the romance takes a back seat to family and personal growth.

When Gwen and Dev do connect, the scenes are sweet, and the slow realization that she has been overlooking him has its own satisfaction. JoJo's Modern Life counted only a couple of kissing scenes, though, so readers hoping for a swoony holiday romance should adjust expectations.

The Characters

Gwen is the book. She is selfish at the start, funny throughout and genuinely changed by the end, and the loop gives her room to grow without feeling preachy. Her family is the real supporting cast, especially her strained relationship with her sister Cerys, which JoJo's Modern Life found weighed on the holiday mood early on.

Not every reader connects with them. Audrey at Ocean Writer Reads gave the book three stars and said she did not latch on to any of the characters. The family members are broadly drawn, and if Gwen's voice does not work for you, there is little else to hold on to.

Writing and Pacing

Kelk writes breezy, joke-dense prose with a lot of pop culture, and that cuts both ways. Ocean Writer Reads found the constant references annoying and the humor vulgar at times for a Christmas story. Publishers Weekly found the book slightly twee. I laughed a lot in the first half and less in the second.

Repetition is built into a time loop, and Kelk varies the days well, but the structure still drags in places. JoJo's Modern Life found the first fifty pages slow. Kristin Atherton's audiobook narration suits the comic tone, if you prefer to listen.

The Christmas Wish is a funny, warm, very British time loop comedy about family, with a sweet but late romance. Read it for Gwen and the loop; look elsewhere if you need the love story to lead.

How Spicy Is The Christmas Wish?

The Christmas Wish is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. JoJo's Modern Life counted only a couple of kissing scenes. The humor can be crude, though, with plenty of swearing and frank talk, and the same reviewer suggested it is not for readers under 18.

Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reviews, reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Christmas Wish?

The Christmas Wish suits readers who want a funny British Christmas comedy with a time loop, a messy heroine and a family at its center, and who are happy with a late, sweet romance. It is less suited to readers who want the romance from page one, or who dislike crude humor and heavy pop culture references.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Christmas Wish drew mostly positive reviews with consistent caveats. Publishers Weekly called it an utterly adorable rom com and a sweet, slightly sentimental treat, and JoJo's Modern Life gave it four stars for its comedy and its honesty about grief and loneliness.

Where they agree. The humor and the family story. Reviewers praise Gwen's voice, the British setting and the way the loop pushes her back toward her family.

Where they split. The romance and the tone. Publishers Weekly and JoJo's Modern Life both note the romance arrives late and stays secondary. Audrey at Ocean Writer Reads gave it three stars, finding the references annoying, the humor vulgar, the plot clichéd and the characters hard to connect with.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Christmas Wish scores 6.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with fair marks for characters, writing and emotional impact, and a lower romance score because the love story arrives so late.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3Sweet when it arrives, but it starts three quarters in, per JoJo's Modern Life.
Characters (15%)3.5Gwen grows convincingly; Ocean Writer Reads did not connect with anyone.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Funny and adorable per Publishers Weekly; twee and reference-heavy for some.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Honest about loneliness and family, per JoJo's Modern Life.
Heat level (10%)3.5Kisses only, as promised, though the crude humor may surprise.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A warm ending, if the romance feels rushed in.
Reread appeal (10%)3The loop and jokes lose their surprise on a reread.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Christmas Wish sits in the middle of the holiday rom com pack, funnier than most but lighter on romance than In a Holidaze, with a final Eikna Score of 6.7/10.

Is The Christmas Wish a Standalone?

Yes. The Christmas Wish is a standalone novel with a complete story, so you can start here with no prior reading of Lindsey Kelk's other books.

Best format: the audiobook, narrated by Kristin Atherton, is a good match for the comic tone and makes the repeated days pass quickly. Our series order guide covers connected holiday romances if you want something longer.

If You Loved The Christmas Wish, Read These Next

If you loved The Christmas Wish, look for holiday comedies with time loops, family chaos and boy-next-door romance.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Christmas Wish prompts a few common questions: whether it is a romance, how spicy it is, whether it stands alone and how the time loop works. Short answers below, without spoilers.

Is The Christmas Wish a romance?

Partly. It is a Christmas comedy about family and personal growth, with a boy-next-door romance that becomes central only in the last part of the book.

Is The Christmas Wish spicy?

No. It is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, with a couple of kisses, though the humor and language can be crude.

Is The Christmas Wish a time loop book?

Yes. Gwen keeps waking up on the same Christmas Day, in a Groundhog Day-style loop.

Is The Christmas Wish a standalone?

Yes. It is a complete standalone novel.

Who is the love interest in The Christmas Wish?

Dev, the boy next door and Gwen's teenage crush, who has grown up into a kind and patient man.

Is there a The Christmas Wish audiobook?

Yes. It is narrated by Kristin Atherton and runs about 10 hours 31 minutes.

The Bottom Line

The Christmas Wish earns a 6.7/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a funny, very British Christmas time loop comedy about a messy heroine and her family, and who are happy for the romance to wait. The reason to pick it up is Gwen's voice: chaotic, self-mocking and, by the last loop, surprisingly wise.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.