A Merry Little Meet Cute by Julie Murphy and Sierra Simone Review
Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.
A Merry Little Meet Cute drops a plus-size adult film star into a wholesome family Christmas movie opposite the former boy band heartthrob she crushed on as a girl, and the result is filthy, funny and genuinely sex-positive. Bee is a delight, the heat is relentless, and the romance underneath it is lighter than the premise deserves.
Read it if you want a very explicit holiday romcom with bisexual leads, fat representation and a heroine who is proud of her work. Skip it if you want a slow, emotionally deep courtship, or explicit sex on nearly every other page is more than you are after.
A Merry Little Meet Cute at a Glance
A Merry Little Meet Cute is the first Christmas Notch novel by Julie Murphy and Sierra Simone, published by Avon on September 20, 2022. An adult film star and a disgraced former boy band singer fall for each other while secretly hooking up on the set of a family Christmas movie in Vermont. It is very explicit and ends with a happily ever after.
| Authors | Julie Murphy and Sierra Simone |
|---|---|
| Series | Christmas Notch, book 1 (each book follows a new couple) |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy, holiday contemporary |
| Main tropes | Movie set romance, celebrity crush, secret relationship, mutual pre-existing attraction, forbidden on-set fling |
| Spice level | 5/5: Very explicit, sex central to the plot |
| Content warnings | Explicit sex, sex work, fatphobia and slut-shaming, a parent with bipolar disorder (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, alternating between Bee and Nolan |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 432 (trade paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Joy Nash and Sebastian York, 11 hours 5 minutes (Avon) |
| First published | September 20, 2022 |
| Publisher | Avon (HarperCollins) |
What Is A Merry Little Meet Cute About?
A Merry Little Meet Cute follows Bee Hobbes, who performs as Bianca Von Honey and has a loyal following on her adult content site. Her producer, Teddy Ray Fletcher, lands a very different job: a family-friendly Christmas movie for the conservative Hope Channel, shooting in Christmas Notch, Vermont. He casts Bee as the lead, and nobody can know who she really is.
Her co-star is Nolan Shaw, once of the boy band INK and the object of Bee's teenage crush, now trying to rescue a career wrecked by scandal so he can support his mother and younger sister. Nolan knows exactly who Bianca Von Honey is. The attraction is mutual and immediate, and keeping it secret on a wholesome set becomes the comedy and the risk.
What Makes This Movie Set Romance Work
A Merry Little Meet Cute works because of its central collision: adult film meets family Christmas movie, and both worlds take themselves very seriously. Dear Author, which gave the book an A minus, found that collision very funny, and the on-set hookups between takes of a squeaky-clean holiday script give the book a farce engine.
The deeper draw is Bee. She is a fat, bisexual woman who chose her career, is good at it and has parents who support her. Dear Author praised the way the book handles sex work as both a positive choice and an industry with predators, and The Contented Reader, otherwise lukewarm, applauded a plus-size heroine whose body is never treated as a problem.
For readers who want spicy romance with a sense of humour and a big heart about sex, this is one of the more distinctive holiday options.
My Review
A Merry Little Meet Cute is a joyful book. It is horny, warm, unapologetic and often laugh-out-loud funny, and it treats a sex worker heroine with more respect than most romances manage. It is also, as several reviewers noticed, more convincing as a celebration of sex than as a love story.
The critical range is wide. Dear Author gave it an A minus; Publishers Weekly called it "cheery holiday fluff" that works fine as fun; The Contented Reader gave it two stars. I sit closer to Dear Author on the book and closer to the skeptics on the romance.
Romance and Chemistry
The physical chemistry is undeniable. Bee and Nolan want each other from the first page, and the secret hookups are the book's comic and erotic engine. Consent is foregrounded throughout, which Dear Author singled out, and Nolan's complete acceptance of Bee's work is one of the most attractive things about him.
The emotional side is thinner. Because both leads already have crushes on each other, the romance skips most of the getting-to-know-you stage. The Contented Reader found it too quick and said the romance fell flat, and Publishers Weekly called it superficial. I liked them together, but I never quite felt the moment when lust turned into love; it arrives because the plot needs it to.
The Characters
Bee is wonderful. She is lively, sharp, confident in her body and her career, and very funny, and every reviewer we read liked her. Both she and Nolan are bisexual, and Dear Author praised that representation.
Nolan is decent but less vivid. His backstory is moving: he needs this job to support a mother who cannot work because of bipolar disorder and a seventeen-year-old sister, and Dear Author found the mental health representation careful. But Publishers Weekly noted that Nolan and Bee sound nearly identical on the page, and I felt that too. The co-written chapters are seamless, which Dear Author praised, at the cost of distinct voices.
Writing and Pacing
The comic writing is the highlight. The Hope Channel script, the small-town set and Teddy Ray Fletcher's schemes provide plenty of set pieces, and the Vermont holiday trappings are played for gentle satire. Dear Author quoted its description of "the softest duke who'd ever softed" as a taste of the humour, and the book is full of lines like it.
At 432 pages, it runs long. Some readers find the external conflict arrives late, and the middle is a lot of sex and not much story. The epilogue switches to Teddy's point of view, which Dear Author wished had stayed with Bee and Nolan.
A Merry Little Meet Cute is a hilarious, explicit and refreshingly sex-positive holiday romcom with a terrific heroine and a love story that relies on heat more than depth. Read it if you want laughs and steam in equal measure.
How Spicy Is A Merry Little Meet Cute?
A Merry Little Meet Cute is a 5 out of 5 on our scale: Very explicit, sex central to the plot. The authors label it a very spicy adult romance for readers 18 and up. The secret sex between Bee and Nolan on and around the movie set drives the plot, and the scenes are frequent, detailed and consensual.
Bee's work in adult film is discussed openly and positively. For more at this heat level, see our spicy romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the authors and Dear Author:
- Frequent, very explicit sex between adults
- Sex work and the adult film industry, including its predatory side
- Fatphobia, slut-shaming and misogyny (handled lightly)
- A parent with bipolar disorder
- A referenced sex scandal in the hero's past
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read A Merry Little Meet Cute?
A Merry Little Meet Cute suits readers who want a very explicit, funny, sex-positive Christmas romcom with queer and fat representation. It is less suited to readers who want a slow emotional courtship, lower heat or a wholesome Hallmark-style holiday story.
Best for:
- Readers who want a sex worker heroine treated with respect
- Fans of bisexual and plus-size leads
- Anyone who loves Hollywood and movie set romances
- Readers who want maximum heat at Christmas
Not for:
- Readers who prefer closed-door or mild romance
- Anyone who wants a slow-building emotional love story
- Readers uncomfortable with frank discussion of the adult film industry
- Those looking for a short holiday read
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
A Merry Little Meet Cute split critics more than most holiday romances. Everyone praises Bee, the humour and the sex positivity; the disagreement is whether the romance has enough emotional substance beneath the heat.
Where they agree. Bee and the premise. Dear Author praised the comedy, the handling of sex work, the bisexual and mental health representation and a believable HEA. Publishers Weekly found the premise entertaining and credited the authors with engaging feminist themes. Even The Contented Reader loved Bee's humour and the body-positive portrayal.
Where they split. The love story. Publishers Weekly found the romance superficial and the voices hard to tell apart, and suggested readers wanting substance look elsewhere. The Contented Reader gave it two stars because the romance moved too fast and fell flat. Dear Author, by contrast, found the HEA convincing and wished only that the epilogue had stayed with the couple.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
A Merry Little Meet Cute scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its heat, characters and ending score well, and it loses ground on a romance that leans on attraction and on co-written voices that blur together.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Hot and consensual; Publishers Weekly and The Contented Reader find it shallow. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Bee wins every reviewer over; Nolan is less vivid, per Publishers Weekly. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Very funny, per Dear Author; long, with a late conflict. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Nolan's family adds weight; the love story stays light. |
| Heat level (10%) | 5 | Delivers exactly the very spicy adult romance the authors promise. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | Dear Author finds the HEA believable; the epilogue drifts to Teddy. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Favourite scenes reward revisiting; the full length less so. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: A Merry Little Meet Cute is one of the most explicit and most original holiday romcoms of recent years, ahead of most on representation and behind the best on emotional depth, with a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.
Christmas Notch Reading Order
A Merry Little Meet Cute is the first book in the Christmas Notch series, and each novel follows a new couple. Start here; the later books build on people and places introduced in this one.
- A Merry Little Meet Cute (2022): Bee and Nolan
- Snow Place Like LA (2023): a Christmas Notch in July novella
- A Holly Jolly Ever After (2023)
- Seas and Greetings (2024): a Christmas Notch in July novella
- A Jingle Bell Mingle (2024)
Best format: the audiobook, narrated by Joy Nash and Sebastian York, which runs about 11 hours and gives Bee and Nolan separate voices, something Publishers Weekly felt the page sometimes lacks. Our series order guide covers more holiday series.
If You Loved A Merry Little Meet Cute, Read These Next
If you loved A Merry Little Meet Cute, look for holiday or Hollywood romances with queer leads, humour and serious heat.
- The Holiday Trap by Roan Parrish: two queer couples, a house swap and explicit scenes over the winter holidays.
- The Christmas Deal by Keira Andrews: an M/M fake dating holiday romance with a bi awakening and steam.
- The Geek Who Saved Christmas by Annabeth Albert: a steamy grumpy and sunshine M/M Christmas romance.
- How to Fake It in Hollywood by Ava Wilder: two actors fake a relationship for publicity, with an industry setting and heat.
Frequently Asked Questions
A Merry Little Meet Cute raises a few common questions: how spicy it is, whether it is part of a series, what the premise is and whether the audiobook is worth it. Short answers below.
How spicy is A Merry Little Meet Cute?
Very. A Merry Little Meet Cute is a 5 out of 5 on our scale, and the authors describe it as a very spicy romance for readers 18 and up.
Is A Merry Little Meet Cute part of a series?
Yes. It is the first Christmas Notch book, followed by A Holly Jolly Ever After and A Jingle Bell Mingle, plus two novellas.
Is A Merry Little Meet Cute a Hallmark-style romance?
Only on the surface. The leads are filming a wholesome Christmas movie, but the book itself is a very explicit adult romcom.
Are the leads in A Merry Little Meet Cute bisexual?
Yes. Both Bee and Nolan are bisexual, and the book also centres a plus-size heroine.
Does A Merry Little Meet Cute have a happy ending?
Yes. Bee and Nolan get a happily ever after, followed by an epilogue told from Teddy Ray Fletcher's point of view.
Who narrates the A Merry Little Meet Cute audiobook?
Joy Nash and Sebastian York narrate the audiobook, which runs about 11 hours 5 minutes.
The Bottom Line
A Merry Little Meet Cute earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a very explicit, very funny Christmas romcom with a proud sex worker heroine and queer leads, and who care more about laughs and heat than a slow emotional build. The one reason to pick it up is Bee Hobbes, a heroine who makes the whole wholesome Christmas machine look ridiculous.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- A Merry Little Meet Cute, Julie Murphy (official page)
- A Merry Little Meet Cute, Julie and Sierra (official page)
- A Merry Little Meet Cute, HarperCollins
- A Merry Little Meet Cute, Publishers Weekly review
- A Merry Little Meet Cute review, Dear Author
- A Merry Little Meet Cute review, The Contented Reader
- A Merry Little Meet Cute audiobook, Libro.fm
- Christmas Notch series, Audible
- A Christmas Notch series order, Margins
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.