The Holiday Trap by Roan Parrish Review
Eikna Score: 7.4/10. Recommended.
The Holiday Trap gives you two queer romances for the price of one: a sapphic love story in New Orleans and a gay slow burn on an island in Maine, linked by a house swap. Truman and Ash's half is tender and earned, Greta and Carys's half moves too fast, and at 448 pages the whole thing could lose a subplot or two.
Read it if you want a big, warm, explicit queer holiday book with found family on both coasts, or you love hurt and comfort. Skip it if you want one tight romance, low heat or a book that actually feels like Christmas from start to finish.
The Holiday Trap at a Glance
The Holiday Trap is a standalone queer holiday romance by Roan Parrish, published by Sourcebooks Casablanca on September 6, 2022. Two strangers swap homes between Maine and New Orleans for the winter holidays, and each falls in love: Greta with Carys, Truman with Ash. Both stories are explicit and end happily.
| Author | Roan Parrish |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | LGBTQ+ romance, holiday contemporary (one F/F and one M/M couple) |
| Main tropes | House swap, slow burn (Truman and Ash), insta-attraction (Greta and Carys), hurt and comfort, found family |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | Infidelity by an ex, a parent with dementia, controlling family, explicit sex (full list below) |
| POV | Alternating between Greta and Truman |
| Ending | HEA for both couples |
| Pages | 448 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Natalie Duke, Pete Cross and Hillary Huber, 12 hours 22 minutes (Dreamscape Media) |
| First published | September 6, 2022 |
| Publisher | Sourcebooks Casablanca |
What Is The Holiday Trap About?
The Holiday Trap starts with two people who need to be somewhere else. Greta lives on a small island in Maine, inside a large, loving family that has opinions about everything she does. Truman lives in New Orleans and has just discovered that his boyfriend of about a year has a husband and a daughter.
A mutual friend sets up a month-long house swap over the holidays. Greta heads to New Orleans, where she walks Truman's dog, Horse, meets the bold and unpredictable Carys and falls in with a group of older gardeners. Truman lands on Owl Island, meets Ash and, along the way, starts to suspect that his favourite author once lived there. Both of them have a month to work out who they are away from home.
What Makes This Found Family Romance Work
The Holiday Trap works because each half of the swap gives its lead a new community as well as a love interest. Greta, who has never had space to decide anything for herself, gets a city full of strangers who take her seriously. Truman, who has just been lied to by the person closest to him, gets an island where people show up for each other. Cannonball Read singled out the found family on both sides as the book's heart, and the gardening club in New Orleans was that reviewer's favourite part.
The doubled structure is the other draw. Faintingviolet at Cannonball Read argued that the two romances comment on each other: one couple tumbles in fast while the other circles, unsure whether the feelings are returned. Reading them side by side, you notice how differently love can arrive.
For readers who want found family with their holiday romance, there are few books that offer two families at once.
My Review
The Holiday Trap is a generous book, and I mean that both ways. Parrish gives you two couples, two towns, two found families, a literary mystery, a parent's illness and a few business ventures, and most of it is good. It is also a lot. By the last hundred pages I was invested in Truman and Ash, fond of Greta and checking how many pages were left.
The two halves are not equal, and most readers agree on which one wins.
Romance and Chemistry
Truman and Ash are the reason to read. Their relationship is a true slow burn with a hurt and comfort core: Truman is raw from betrayal and Ash carries the weight of caring for a parent with dementia. Neither is sure the other feels the same, and Parrish lets that uncertainty breathe. Cannonball Read described it as a slow burn between characters unsure their feelings are requited, and the payoff, when it comes, feels earned.
Greta and Carys move much faster. Carys is everything Greta is not, loud and certain and impulsive, and that contrast is useful for Greta's self-discovery. But the romance goes from meeting to serious in a hurry, and Cannonball Read called it a very fast arc. Bookshelf Fantasies went further and found both romances hard to believe given how many personal epiphanies get packed into a month. I would not go that far for Truman and Ash, but I felt it with Greta.
The Characters
Truman is the most lovable character in the book. Bookshelf Fantasies, otherwise lukewarm, called him endearing, and his mix of hurt and humour carries his chapters. Ash's caregiving storyline is handled with care: Cannonball Read's reviewer, writing from personal experience, found the dementia material well done, though it may be hard going for some readers.
Greta is quieter. Her family is suffocating in a believable, affectionate way, and her growth is real, but Cannonball Read noted that her side of the story has fewer people willing to tell her hard truths, and it shows. The supporting casts, especially the gardeners and the islanders, are warm and specific.
Writing and Pacing
Parrish writes place well. New Orleans and the Maine island feel distinct, and the gardening, flowers and community scenes have texture. Publishers Weekly praised the specificity of both settings and the way the alternating structure broadens the book's representation.
The pacing is the real issue. Bookshelf Fantasies called the book far too long, and Cannonball Read found the pacing uneven because the two couples move at such different speeds. The epilogue, which Cannonball Read said went a bit off the rails, will split readers too. The title also oversells the holiday: Bookshelf Fantasies pointed out that it is not especially Christmassy and nobody is really trapped.
The Holiday Trap is a big-hearted queer romance with one excellent love story, one rushed one and more subplot than it needs. Read it for Truman and Ash and for the found family, and be ready for a long, explicit ride.
How Spicy Is The Holiday Trap?
The Holiday Trap is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Both couples have open-door sex, and Bookshelf Fantasies warned that the scenes are graphic and described step by step. All of it is consensual and between adults.
Readers who prefer understated steam should know that going in. For more in this range, see our spicy romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from reviews:
- Infidelity: Truman's boyfriend has a secret husband and child
- A parent with dementia and the strain of caregiving
- Overbearing, controlling family dynamics
- Emotional aftermath of betrayal
- Explicit consensual sex between adults
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read The Holiday Trap?
The Holiday Trap suits readers who want a long, explicit queer holiday romance with two couples, strong community and a hurt and comfort slow burn. It is less suited to readers who want one focused love story, low heat or a festive Christmas atmosphere throughout.
Best for:
- Readers who want sapphic and gay romance in the same book
- Fans of house swap and fish out of water stories
- Anyone who loves hurt and comfort and slow burns
- Readers who value found family and small communities
Not for:
- Readers who prefer closed-door or low-heat romance
- Anyone who dislikes insta-love
- Readers who want a short, tight holiday read
- Those for whom dementia storylines are too close to home
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
The Holiday Trap drew warm but mixed reviews. Critics praise its settings, queer community and Truman and Ash's slow burn; readers split over its length, the faster Greta and Carys romance and the epilogue.
Where they agree. Truman and community. Publishers Weekly praised the specificity of Maine and New Orleans and the two found families. Cannonball Read loved the gardeners, the slow burn and the handling of dementia. Even Bookshelf Fantasies, the coolest review we read, found Truman endearing and the book entertaining.
Where they split. Length and believability. Bookshelf Fantasies gave it three stars and called it too long, with too many implausible plot points and too many characters fixing each other's problems. Cannonball Read, at three and a half stars, found Greta's half less engaging and the epilogue off the rails, though that reviewer liked the paired structure more than splitting the stories would have been.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
The Holiday Trap scores 7.4 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its characters, emotional weight and heat score well, and it loses ground on a lopsided romance, a long middle and a divisive epilogue.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Truman and Ash's slow burn lands; Cannonball Read calls Greta and Carys very fast. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Truman is endearing even to Bookshelf Fantasies; strong supporting casts. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Publishers Weekly praises the settings; Bookshelf Fantasies finds it far too long. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Betrayal and dementia carry weight, per Cannonball Read. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Explicit as Bookshelf Fantasies warns, in both storylines. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | Both couples end happy; Cannonball Read finds the epilogue off the rails. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Worth revisiting for Truman and Ash; the length makes a full reread a commitment. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Holiday Trap is one of the more ambitious queer holiday romances of its year, stronger in its M/M half than its F/F half, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 7.4/10.
Is The Holiday Trap a Standalone?
Yes. The Holiday Trap is a standalone novel, and both romances are complete with happy endings, so you need nothing else by Roan Parrish to enjoy it. It is not connected to her Garnet Run series.
Best format: the Dreamscape audiobook uses three narrators, Natalie Duke, Pete Cross and Hillary Huber, which helps keep the two storylines apart over twelve hours. If you prefer to skim the subplots, print or ebook gives you more control. Our series order guide covers Parrish's series if you want more of her.
If You Loved The Holiday Trap, Read These Next
If you loved The Holiday Trap, look for queer holiday romances with found family, a little heartbreak and real heat.
- The Geek Who Saved Christmas by Annabeth Albert: a grumpy and sunshine M/M holiday romance with steam and a happy ending.
- Make the Season Bright by Ashley Herring Blake: a sapphic second chance holiday romance with a hard-won happy ending.
- Season of Love by Helena Greer: a sapphic romance at a family Christmas tree farm, built on community.
- You're a Mean One, Matthew Prince by Timothy Janovsky: a queer Christmas romcom with a prickly hero who needs a reset.
- Best Laid Plans by Roan Parrish: more of Parrish's small-town M/M romance and found family.
Frequently Asked Questions
The Holiday Trap raises a few common questions: how spicy it is, who the couples are, whether it is a standalone and how it ends. Short answers below.
Is The Holiday Trap spicy?
Yes. The Holiday Trap is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with explicit open-door scenes for both couples.
Who are the couples in The Holiday Trap?
There are two separate couples: Greta and Carys, a sapphic pairing in New Orleans, and Truman and Ash, a gay pairing on Owl Island in Maine. It is not a polyamorous romance.
Is The Holiday Trap a standalone?
Yes. The Holiday Trap is a standalone novel and does not connect to Roan Parrish's other series.
Does The Holiday Trap have a happy ending?
Yes. Both couples get a happy ending, followed by an epilogue that some readers love and others find over the top.
Is The Holiday Trap a Christmas book?
Partly. The Holiday Trap takes place over the winter holidays, but reviewers note it is less festive than the title suggests and focuses more on community and starting over.
Is there a The Holiday Trap audiobook?
Yes. Dreamscape Media's audiobook is narrated by Natalie Duke, Pete Cross and Hillary Huber and runs about 12 hours 22 minutes.
The Bottom Line
The Holiday Trap earns a 7.4/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a long, explicit, community-rich queer holiday romance and don't mind one of its two love stories moving faster than the other. The one reason to pick it up is Truman and Ash, a slow burn with enough hurt and tenderness to carry the whole book.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.