Best Laid Plans by Roan Parrish Review
Eikna Score: 6.9/10. Recommended with reservations.
Best Laid Plans gives Charlie Matheson, the generous older brother from Better Than People, a sweet and low-angst romance with a prickly drifter and a falling-down house. It is warm and easy company, but the conflict barely exists and the relationship never digs as deep as Charlie deserves.
Read it if you want a gentle small-town MM romance about caretaking, house repair and cats, or you fell for Charlie in book 1 and want him happy. Skip it if you need real conflict and emotional depth from Roan Parrish, or a money imbalance between the leads bothers you when the book does not examine it.
Best Laid Plans at a Glance
Best Laid Plans is book 2 of Roan Parrish's Garnet Run series, published by Carina Adores on February 23, 2021. Set in small-town Wyoming, it pairs hardware store owner Charlie Matheson with Rye Janssen, a near-homeless newcomer who inherits a wrecked house. It alternates both men's points of view and ends happily.
| Author | Roan Parrish |
|---|---|
| Series | Garnet Run, book 2 (a new couple; works as a standalone) |
| Subgenre | MM romance, small-town contemporary |
| Main tropes | Grumpy sunshine, fixer-upper house, caretaker hero, close quarters, newcomer in a small town |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Housing insecurity, parental death, anxiety and panic, homophobic family (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, alternating between Charlie and Rye |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 304 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Greg Boudreaux, about 8 hours 2 minutes |
| First published | February 23, 2021 |
| Publisher | Carina Adores (Harlequin) |
What Is Best Laid Plans About?
Best Laid Plans opens with Rye Janssen out of options. He has spent years moving around and couch-surfing, and he is close to homeless when he learns he has inherited a house in Garnet Run, Wyoming, from a grandfather he never met. He drives in from Seattle and finds the place in terrible shape.
Charlie Matheson runs the town hardware store. He gave up his own plans as a teenager to raise his younger brother Jack after their parents died, and he has rarely done anything for himself since. When the prickly newcomer walks into his store, Charlie offers help, a temporary place to stay and his toolbox. Rye does not trust kindness. Charlie does not know how to stop offering it.
What Makes This Grumpy Sunshine Romance Work
Best Laid Plans works, when it works, because of Charlie. He is a man who has spent his whole adult life looking after other people, and the book is gentle about how much that cost him. Jules at The Novel Approach called him goodness on the page, and for readers who met him in Better Than People, seeing him finally get something of his own is the hook.
The pairing gives it shape. Rye is wary, sharp and sexually confident; Charlie is open-hearted and inexperienced. That is a classic grumpy sunshine setup, and fixing the house together gives them a reason to share space and hands-on work. Add two cats, Rye's Marmot and Charlie's Jane and a small-town setting, and you have a very soft book.
Publishers Weekly saw it as a story about two men becoming partners in healing. That is the best version of what the book is doing, and in its better chapters it gets there.
My Review
I wanted to love Best Laid Plans more than I did. Charlie was the quiet heart of Better Than People, and I was ready for Roan Parrish to break him open. Instead she wrote a pleasant, sunny book that keeps backing away from its own hardest material, and I finished it fond of both men and unsure why they were together beyond attraction.
Romance and Chemistry
The attraction is real and arrives fast. They meet when Rye comes into the hardware store for supplies, and the push and pull between a man who refuses help and a man who cannot stop giving it is pleasant to watch. The house repairs give them plenty of shared scenes.
The trouble is what sits under the attraction. Caz Owens at All About Romance could not see what drew the leads together beyond chemistry, and I had the same feeling. There is almost no conflict, and the one real fight resolves quickly; Owens and the reader Geoff Whaley both felt it fizzled. Owens also flagged something I kept noticing: Charlie supports Rye financially for much of the book, and the power imbalance in that goes largely unexamined.
When the book slows down, it can be lovely. Jules praised Rye's growth from wary to devoted, and there are tender moments, especially around Charlie letting himself want something. They are just spread thin.
The Characters
Charlie is the best thing here. A man who stopped his own life at seventeen or eighteen to raise his brother and keep a family business going is rich material, and Publishers Weekly noted that he still struggles with anxiety, panic and loneliness. Owens said her heart hurt for him, and his changing relationship with Jack is one of the book's strongest threads.
Rye is harder to warm to. Jules admitted it took a while to like him, and Owens found his characterisation sketchy. He has a homophobic family in his past and a life of near-constant instability, but Whaley felt the family history was only vaguely sketched, and I agree. Rye's prickliness reads more as a starting point than as something the book really explores.
Writing and Pacing
Parrish's prose is warm and smooth, and Jules called the dual point of view well crafted. The small-town texture is nicely done, and Whaley enjoyed a few comic beats, including a haunted house scene and a stray comparison to Bob's Burgers.
The pacing is the problem. The renovation goes more easily than it should, and Owens wondered how a broke man pays for the supplies. The last quarter turns to a new project for the house and drags. Whaley summed it up as underwhelming for this author, and while I would not go that far, it is the slightest book of hers I have read.
Best Laid Plans is a kind, cozy small-town romance with a lovely hero and almost no friction. Read it if you want low-angst comfort and more of Garnet Run; skip it if you expect the emotional depth of Better Than People.
How Spicy Is Best Laid Plans?
Best Laid Plans is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are on-page sex scenes, which Caz Owens called steamy, but Jules at The Novel Approach described the heat as more of a smolder, and it sits below Better Than People.
Charlie is sexually inexperienced and Rye is not, and Owens felt the scenes arrived abruptly given that gap. Both leads are adults. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and our own read:
- Housing insecurity and near homelessness
- Death of parents in a car accident, in the backstory
- Anxiety, panic and loneliness
- A homophobic family in the hero's past
- A financial imbalance between the leads
- On-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Best Laid Plans?
Best Laid Plans suits readers who want a gentle, low-angst small-town MM romance with a caretaker hero, a fixer-upper house and cats, especially fans of Better Than People. It is less suited to readers who want strong conflict or a deeply examined relationship.
Best for:
- Fans of Better Than People who want Charlie's story
- Readers who love grumpy sunshine pairings
- Anyone looking for low-angst comfort reading
- Readers who enjoy renovation and homemaking plots
- Cat people
Not for:
- Readers who need a real third act conflict
- Anyone bothered by an unexamined money imbalance
- Readers who want Parrish at her most emotionally intense (try Rend)
- Anyone wanting high, frequent heat (try our spicy picks)
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Best Laid Plans divided its reviewers more than Better Than People did. Publishers Weekly was wholly positive, calling it "heartrending, swoon-worthy, and extremely well-told," and Jules at The Novel Approach gave it four stars. Caz Owens at All About Romance called it a miss.
Where they agree. Charlie. Every reviewer warms to him, from Publishers Weekly's sympathy for the brother who gave up his scholarship to Owens saying her heart hurt for him. Jules and Owens both liked his relationship with Jack, and Jules said readers do not need book 1 first.
Where they split. Depth and conflict. Jules enjoyed the low angst and the small-town warmth; Owens found the plot practically non-existent and the romance underdeveloped. Geoff Whaley, who read a publisher copy, missed the emotional punch he expects from Parrish and felt the conflict fizzled quickly.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Best Laid Plans scores 6.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with steady but middling marks across the board: a lovable hero and a warm mood, held back by thin conflict and a relationship that never goes deep.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Sweet attraction, but Caz Owens saw little beyond chemistry. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Charlie shines; Rye feels sketchy, per All About Romance. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Warm dual POV per The Novel Approach; last quarter drags. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Charlie's sacrifice hurts, but Geoff Whaley missed the depth. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Moderate, smoldering heat that suits the cozy tone. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A soft HEA after a conflict that resolves too fast. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | Pleasant, but easy to forget next to book 1. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Best Laid Plans is a gentler, slighter follow-up to Better Than People and sits in the middle of Roan Parrish's catalogue, landing at a final Eikna Score of 6.9/10.
Garnet Run Series Reading Order
Best Laid Plans is book 2 of Roan Parrish's Garnet Run series. Each book follows a new couple, so you can read it on its own, but Charlie and Jack's relationship lands harder if you start with Better Than People.
- Better Than People (2020): Jack Matheson and Simon Burke
- Best Laid Plans (2021): Charlie Matheson and Rye Janssen
- The Pride of Garnet Run (2022, novella, book 2.5)
- The Lights on Knockbridge Lane (2021)
- The Rivals of Casper Road (2022)
- Shelter in Garnet Run (2023)
Best format: ebook or print suits this quick, cozy read, and the Greg Boudreaux audiobook, about eight hours, is a relaxed option for listeners. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved Best Laid Plans, Read These Next
If you loved Best Laid Plans, look for MM romances with caretaker heroes, homemaking and small-town warmth, starting with the book that introduced Charlie.
- Better Than People by Roan Parrish: Garnet Run book 1, with Jack, Simon and a cabin full of rescue animals.
- The Remaking of Corbin Wale by Roan Parrish: a gentle holiday romance with a bakery and a lonely, unusual hero.
- The Hate Project by Kris Ripper: intimacy built through shared domestic space.
- Rule Breaker by Lily Morton: an abrasive man, a caring one and much funnier sparring.
- The Holiday Trap by Roan Parrish: Parrish in small-town holiday mode, built around a house swap.
Frequently Asked Questions
Best Laid Plans raises the same questions from most readers: whether you need book 1, how spicy it is, how it ends and who it follows. Short answers below.
Do I need to read Better Than People before Best Laid Plans?
No. Best Laid Plans follows a new couple and stands on its own, though Charlie and his brother Jack are introduced in Better Than People.
Is Best Laid Plans spicy?
Moderately. Best Laid Plans is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with some open-door scenes and less heat than Better Than People.
Does Best Laid Plans have a happy ending?
Yes. Best Laid Plans ends with a happily ever after for Charlie and Rye.
Who are the main characters in Best Laid Plans?
Charlie Matheson, who runs the Garnet Run hardware store, and Rye Janssen, a newcomer who inherits a run-down house.
Is there a Best Laid Plans audiobook?
Yes. The unabridged audiobook is narrated by Greg Boudreaux and runs about 8 hours 2 minutes.
What order should I read the Garnet Run series in?
Start with Better Than People, then Best Laid Plans, then continue with the later Garnet Run books in series order.
The Bottom Line
Best Laid Plans earns a 6.9/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a soft, low-angst small-town MM romance about a caretaker finally being cared for, with a fixer-upper house, two cats and a grumpy newcomer, and who do not need much conflict along the way. The reason to pick it up is Charlie Matheson, who deserved his happy ending even if his book is lighter than the one that introduced him.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Best Laid Plans, Publishers Weekly
- Review: Best Laid Plans, The Novel Approach (Jules)
- Best Laid Plans, All About Romance (Caz Owens)
- Book 794: Best Laid Plans, Geoff Whaley
- Best Laid Plans audiobook, AudiobooksNow (narrator and length)
- Roan Parrish bibliography and Garnet Run order, Fantastic Fiction
- Harlequin audiobook listing for the audiobook ISBN 9781488210822
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.