eikna romance
Menu

Better Than People by Roan Parrish Review

Eikna Score: 8.0/10. Recommended.

Better Than People is a kind, funny and quietly brave MM romance about two men who find people exhausting and animals easy, and it treats anxiety with more care than most of the genre. The house full of rescue pets gets crowded and the third act conflict feels manufactured, but Simon and Jack are worth every page.

Read it if you want a soft small-town romance with real mental health representation, or a grumpy injured hero who has to let someone help him. Skip it if a houseful of dogs and cats sounds more distracting than charming, or you need a big external plot to stay interested.

Better Than People by Roan Parrish book cover

Better Than People at a Glance

Better Than People is the first book in Roan Parrish's Garnet Run series, published by Carina Adores on August 25, 2020. Set in small-town Wyoming, it pairs a grumpy children's book illustrator with a severely anxious designer who walks his dogs, alternates between both men's points of view and ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorRoan Parrish
SeriesGarnet Run, book 1 (each book follows a new couple)
SubgenreMM romance, small-town contemporary
Main tropesGrumpy and gentle pairing, injured hero needs help, pet-sitting meet cute, anxious hero, animal found family
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsSocial anxiety and panic attacks, depression, professional betrayal, injury, parental death (full list below)
POVDual, alternating chapters between Jack and Simon
EndingHEA
Pages336 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by James Cavenaugh, about 7 hours 20 minutes
First publishedAugust 25, 2020
PublisherCarina Adores (Harlequin)

What Is Better Than People About?

Better Than People follows Simon Burke, a graphic designer whose anxiety has shaped his whole life. He is more comfortable with animals than with people, and when his plan to adopt a dog stalls, he signs up with a pet-sharing app instead.

That is how he meets Jack Matheson, a children's book illustrator living in a cabin outside Garnet Run, Wyoming, with a crowd of rescue dogs and cats. Jack has broken his leg and cannot walk his pack himself. He is grumpy, proud and still raw from a betrayal by a friend and business partner. Simon needs space and quiet. Jack needs help he hates asking for. The question is what happens when the leg heals.

What Makes This Grumpy Hero Romance Work

Better Than People works because neither man tries to fix the other. Jack is prickly and Simon can barely speak to strangers, and the book never pretends love cures either. Melinda at Smexy Books put it well: each wants to make the other's life better, not to change who he is.

The second hook is the communication. When talking is too hard for Simon, the two men text, and that space gives a shy hero room to be funny and direct. It is a small device that does a lot of work, and it makes the slow courtship feel natural.

Then there are the animals. Jack's dogs and cats are not decoration. They help him manage his own anxiety, they force the leads into each other's company and they give the book its warmth. Reading Reality's Marlene Harris said the animals feel like real characters with their own quirks. If you read MM romance for comfort, this is a very comforting book.

My Review

I expected Better Than People to be sweet. I did not expect it to be this precise about anxiety. Simon's chapters are hard to read in places, because Parrish puts you inside the panic and the silence and the self-blame, and then she lets him be loved anyway. That combination is the book's real achievement.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry builds out of routine. Simon comes to walk the dogs, Jack resents needing him, and the resentment wears down into curiosity and then into something warmer. The texting phase is my favorite part: Simon is braver on a screen, and Jack is softer when he does not have to perform being fine.

Once the relationship turns physical it turns hot. Caz Owens at All About Romance, reviewing the audiobook, described the romance as sweet, tender and steamy, and the love scenes are frequent and on the page. They also feel like part of the story, a place where Simon is not anxious, rather than a break from it.

My one real complaint is the late conflict. Owens found the third act a bit contrived, and I agree. After a book that handled its problems with such care, the final obstacle feels imported from a more conventional romance. It does not undo anything, but it is the weakest stretch.

The Characters

Simon is one of the best anxious heroes I have read. His shyness goes back to childhood, he sometimes cannot speak at all, and Parrish never turns that into a quirk. Publishers Weekly praised the portrayal of his anxiety and his wish for a healthy relationship, and Smexy Books liked how it contrasts with Jack's own anxiety and depression.

Jack is a good grump. He is irritable, wounded and secretly very gentle, and his frustration at not being able to soothe Simon's fears is one of the most honest threads in the book, which Publishers Weekly also noted. The supporting cast is excellent: Simon's grandmother Jean steals her scenes, and Jack's protective older brother Charlie is set up so well that he gets the next book.

Writing and Pacing

Parrish writes clean, warm prose here, less lyrical than in some of her earlier books and very readable. The alternating chapters keep the balance right; Marlene Harris found Jack easier to relate to and Simon's sections more painful, which matches my read.

The pacing is leisurely. Caz Owens liked that unhurried pace, and so did I, but readers who want plot will feel it. The other split is the animals. Owens thought four dogs and three cats in one house was too many, and Em Wittmann, also at All About Romance, found the pets distracting enough to lower her enjoyment. Melinda at Smexy Books loved them but wished there were fewer so her favorites, like the fearful dog Puddles, got more time.

Better Than People is a tender, steamy and unusually careful MM romance about anxiety, with a crowded house and a weak third act. Read it if you want comfort with real emotional stakes; skip it if pets on every page sound like chaos.

How Spicy Is Better Than People?

Better Than People is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The courtship is slow, but once Simon and Jack get together, the book describes an intense, passionate affair with several open-door love scenes.

Both leads are adults, and the intimacy grows out of trust built slowly over the dog walks. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Better Than People?

Better Than People suits readers who want a gentle, steamy small-town MM romance with honest anxiety representation, a grumpy but kind hero and a lot of animals. It is less suited to readers who want a fast plot or who find big casts of pets distracting.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Better Than People was well received by trade and blog reviewers. Publishers Weekly called it an appealing queer romance and closed with a line worth quoting: "This sensitive tale will leave readers with big smiles on their faces." Smexy Books and Reading Reality both gave it a B plus, and both Love Bytes reviewers gave it 4.5 hearts.

Where they agree. The characters and the care. Publishers Weekly praised Simon's anxiety and Jack's frustration, plus Grandma Jean and Charlie. Love Bytes singled out the same side characters, and Smexy Books praised the mental health representation for both leads and Jack's brother.

Where they split. The animals and the ending. Em Wittmann at All About Romance found the pets distracting, Melinda at Smexy Books felt overwhelmed by the number of them, and Caz Owens thought the late conflict contrived. Owens still liked the book enough to expect a reread, and she praised James Cavenaugh's narration, especially his handling of Simon's stammer.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Better Than People scores 8.0 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best mark for emotional impact and strong marks across the board, held back by a contrived third act conflict.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4A slow, text-led courtship that turns steamy, per All About Romance.
Characters (15%)4Simon's anxiety is drawn with care, per Publishers Weekly; great side cast.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Warm, readable prose; leisurely pace and crowded pet cast, per Smexy Books.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5Simon's chapters hurt and then heal; the book's biggest strength.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the passionate, open-door heat its romance promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A true HEA, reached through a third act Caz Owens found contrived.
Reread appeal (10%)4A comfort reread for animal lovers; Owens expected to revisit it.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Better Than People is the strongest start to Roan Parrish's Garnet Run series and one of the better anxiety-centered MM romances of 2020, landing at a final Eikna Score of 8.0/10.

Garnet Run Series Reading Order

Better Than People is book 1 of Roan Parrish's Garnet Run series, set in a small Wyoming town. Each book follows a new couple, so the series is easy to dip into, but starting here sets up Jack's brother Charlie, who leads book 2.

  1. Better Than People (2020): Jack Matheson and Simon Burke
  2. Best Laid Plans (2021): Charlie Matheson and Rye Janssen
  3. The Pride of Garnet Run (2022, novella, book 2.5)
  4. The Lights on Knockbridge Lane (2021)
  5. The Rivals of Casper Road (2022)
  6. Shelter in Garnet Run (2023)

Best format: the James Cavenaugh audiobook is a strong choice, since All About Romance praised how he differentiates the leads and handles Simon's stammer; print or ebook works just as well for the texting scenes. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved Better Than People, Read These Next

If you loved Better Than People, look for MM romances with gentle pacing, anxious or grumpy heroes and found family, starting with the next Garnet Run book.

Frequently Asked Questions

Better Than People prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and where it fits in the Garnet Run series. Short answers below.

Is Better Than People spicy?

Yes. Better Than People is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit open-door scenes once Simon and Jack get together.

Is Better Than People a standalone?

It is book 1 of the Garnet Run series, but Simon and Jack's story is complete and later books follow new couples.

Does Better Than People have a happy ending?

Yes. Better Than People ends with a happily ever after for Simon and Jack.

Where is Better Than People set?

Better Than People is set around Jack's cabin near the small town of Garnet Run, Wyoming.

Is there a Better Than People audiobook?

Yes. The unabridged audiobook is narrated by James Cavenaugh and runs about 7 hours 20 minutes.

What should I read after Better Than People?

Read Best Laid Plans next. It is Garnet Run book 2 and follows Jack's older brother, Charlie Matheson.

The Bottom Line

Better Than People earns an 8.0/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a soft, steamy small-town MM romance with a grumpy injured hero, a deeply anxious one and a cabin full of rescue animals, and who can forgive a third act that reaches for drama. The reason to pick it up is Simon: few romance heroes have their anxiety written with this much honesty and this much hope.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.