eikna romance
Menu

Call Back by Lily Morton Review

Eikna Score: 8.2/10. Recommended.

Call Back is Lily Morton at her most emotional: a war photographer, the supermodel he walked away from five years ago, and a second chance that has to survive the man who raised Xavier. The banter and the Hebridean chapters are wonderful, though the long flashback and a cartoonish villain keep it a notch below her very best.

Read it if you love second chance romance with an age gap, a grovelling older hero and Morton's snarky British dialogue. Skip it if drugging, attempted assault and a sixteen-year age gap with your best friend's son are more than you want in a comfort read.

Call Back by Lily Morton book cover

Call Back at a Glance

Call Back is Lily Morton's self-published MM contemporary romance, released June 21, 2026, and book 3 of her Model Agency series, which she says can be read as a standalone. It reunites photographer Reuben Langley and supermodel Xavier Conway in London and the Inner Hebrides, runs about 455 pages and ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorLily Morton
SeriesThe Model Agency, book 3 (new couple; the author says it reads as a standalone)
SubgenreMM contemporary romance (London and the Isle of Mull)
Main tropesSecond chance, age gap, best friend's son, photographer and model, opposites attract
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsDrug use and drugging, attempted sexual assault, war trauma, a cruel parent (full list below)
POVFirst person, alternating between Xavier and Reuben
EndingHEA
PagesAbout 455 (print length)
AudiobookNarrated by Joel Leslie
First publishedJune 21, 2026
PublisherLily Morton (self-published)

What Is Call Back About?

Call Back opens five years after Reuben Langley broke Xavier Conway's heart. Xavier was nineteen and wild when they met in a hotel bar; Reuben was a war photographer in his mid thirties and, it turned out, the best friend of Xavier's father. Their affair was short, passionate and ended badly.

Now Xavier is a supermodel and insists he has moved on. Then his life starts to come apart, and Reuben, who has traded war zones for fashion shoots, is the one who turns up. This time he does not intend to leave. The story moves between London and the Inner Hebrides, and between the present and the week that started it all.

What Makes This Second Chance Romance Work

Call Back works because both men are right to be angry. Reuben ended it cruelly; Xavier punished him for it, loudly and publicly. Morton gives each of them a case, which makes the reunion feel earned rather than inevitable, and makes Reuben's refusal to walk away a second time the real romantic act.

The age gap adds the pressure. Xavier's father, Jez, is Reuben's oldest friend, and his presence turns a love story into a family fight. Readers on Goodreads single him out as one of the most hateful figures in Morton's books, which tells you how much he matters to the plot.

Then there is the island. When the story moves to Mull, the book slows down and breathes. Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words called those chapters a love letter to the island and its people, and they are where the second chance actually happens.

My Review

I have read most of Lily Morton's books, and Call Back is the one that hurt the most. It is longer and heavier than After Felix, angrier than her rom-coms, and it asks you to love two men who behave badly to each other for a long time. I did, mostly, though the book made me work for it.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is ferocious, and the banter is pure Morton: dry, rude, very British and very funny even when the scene underneath it is grim. The reunion scene and the late emotional confrontations are the best things here; Love Bytes reviewer Ro called them powerful and gave the book 4.5 hearts, and I would not argue.

What makes the romance work is Reuben's steadiness. Xavier is spiralling, and Reuben does not try to fix him so much as stay. Not Guilty of Books praised how the age gap shows each man handling his struggles differently, Xavier blunt and young, Reuben weary from years behind a camera in war zones. That contrast is the heart of the book.

The cost is the flashback. The middle of the book is a long return to the week they first met, and while it explains everything, it also stalls the present-day story just as it gets going. Goodreads reviewers mention a long stretch of near nonstop sex in that section, and some found the time jumps disorienting. I liked the flashback on its own terms; I just wanted it shorter.

The Characters

Xavier is a great Morton hero: sharp-tongued, self-destructive, much more fragile than he will admit. Some readers found his revenge hookups made him hard to like, and the book does not soften them. I found him easy to forgive, because Morton shows exactly where the damage came from.

Reuben is quieter and harder to read, and his original breakup is genuinely cruel. Goodreads reviewers note that the five years apart are mostly off page, so we have to take his change on trust. Jez, Xavier's father, is the weak spot. Ro at Love Bytes called him one of the worst people in a Lily Morton book and could not see why Reuben stayed friends with him; several Goodreads readers found him cartoonishly villainous. I agree with both. Grey, Reuben's loyal friend, is the side character everyone loves, and fans of the Mortonverse will spot familiar faces, including Max from After Felix.

Writing and Pacing

Morton writes alternating first person with real voice, and the dialogue is the engine. The Mull chapters have a texture the London scenes lack, and the island community is lovely. One small, odd note: Scattered Thoughts, whose reviewer has owned three Irish Wolfhounds, was pulled out of the story by Bernard the wolfhound behaving like a retriever. It is a tiny thing, and it is the kind of tiny thing that sticks.

At around 455 pages, the book is long for the genre. The pacing is uneven, and the reliance on miscommunication will frustrate readers who want adults to just talk. But the last act delivers, and the ending is warm and complete.

Call Back is a big, hurting, very funny second chance romance with an overlong flashback and a villain drawn too broadly. Read it if you want Morton's banter wrapped around real pain; go in knowing the content is heavier than the jokes suggest.

How Spicy Is Call Back?

Call Back is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Most of the sex is concentrated in the flashback to Xavier and Reuben's first week together, with more once they reunite. Goodreads reviewers describe it as very spicy, though one rated the steam lower, so readers' mileage varies.

Xavier is nineteen in the flashback and 24 in the present; Reuben is about sixteen years older and his father's best friend, so the age gap and family-friend boundary are central. The author's disclaimer at the start of the book flags content some readers may find triggering. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reviews (the author's full disclaimer is printed at the front of the book):

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Call Back?

Call Back suits readers who want an emotional second chance MM romance with an age gap, a steady older hero, Lily Morton's snarky dialogue and a long, healing stretch on a Scottish island. It is less suited to readers who want a light comfort read, hate miscommunication plots, or prefer a story told in one straight line.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Call Back has been warmly received since its June 2026 release, with a 4.40 average from more than 1,100 Goodreads ratings. As with most self-published MM romance, the coverage is reader reviews and dedicated MM blogs rather than trade press.

Where they agree. The emotion, the banter and the island. Ro at Love Bytes gave it 4.5 hearts for its snark and its powerful reunion and heartbreak scenes. Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words gave it 4.5 rainbows, loving the romance and the Mull chapters. Not Guilty of Books called it a beautiful story of ups, downs and second chances.

Where they split. Structure and Jez. Goodreads reviewers flag the reliance on miscommunication, the long flashback, uneven pacing and the mostly off-page five years apart. Jez divides nobody: readers hate him, but some think he is drawn too broadly to be believable. A few also note the age gap, the assault and drugging content, and, thanks to Scattered Thoughts, a dog who does not act like his breed.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Call Back scores 8.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for romance and emotional impact and a lower mark for a long flashback that slows the middle of the book.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4.5Ferocious chemistry and a powerful reunion, per Love Bytes and Goodreads readers.
Characters (15%)4Xavier and Reuben are vivid; Jez is too broad, per Love Bytes.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Great dialogue and island chapters; the flashback stalls the middle.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5The heaviest, most moving Morton book we have read.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers steamy heat, concentrated in the flashback.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A warm, complete HEA after a slow middle.
Reread appeal (10%)4The banter and Mull chapters reward a reread.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Call Back is the strongest Model Agency book we have covered and sits near the top of Lily Morton's catalogue for emotional weight, landing at a final Eikna Score of 8.2/10.

The Model Agency Reading Order

Call Back is book 3 of Lily Morton's Model Agency series, and the author says it can be read as a standalone. Each book follows a new couple connected to the same London modelling world. Here is the order:

  1. Book 1: The Sunny Side (2022)
  2. Book 2: French Fancy (2023)
  3. Book 3: Call Back (2026): Reuben and Xavier

Morton's books share a wider world, so characters from her other series, such as Max from After Felix, turn up as cameos. Best format: ebook or the Joel Leslie audiobook; Leslie narrates many of Morton's books and the dialogue suits a performer. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved Call Back, Read These Next

If you loved Call Back, look for MM romances with a second chance, an age gap or a family-friend boundary, starting with more Lily Morton.

Frequently Asked Questions

Call Back prompts the same questions from most readers: whether it stands alone, how spicy it is, how big the age gap is and whether it ends happily. Short answers below.

Is Call Back a standalone?

Yes. Call Back is book 3 of the Model Agency series, but Lily Morton says it can be read on its own, and Reuben and Xavier's story is complete.

Is Call Back spicy?

Yes. Call Back is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with multiple explicit scenes, many of them in the flashback to the couple's first week together.

How big is the age gap in Call Back?

Xavier is nineteen when they first meet and 24 in the present, and Reuben is about sixteen years older and Xavier's father's best friend.

Does Call Back have a happy ending?

Yes. Call Back ends with a happily ever after for Reuben and Xavier.

Where is Call Back set?

Call Back is set in London and the Inner Hebrides, with a long stretch on the Isle of Mull.

Is there a Call Back audiobook?

Yes. Joel Leslie narrates the Call Back audiobook.

What order should I read the Model Agency books in?

The order is The Sunny Side, French Fancy and Call Back, but each book follows a new couple.

The Bottom Line

Call Back earns an 8.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a big, emotional second chance MM romance with an age gap, a steady older hero and Lily Morton's sharpest banter, and who can handle heavier content and a long detour into the past. The one reason to pick it up is Reuben's choice to stay: Morton makes it feel like the most romantic thing in the world.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.