Common Goal by Rachel Reid Review
Eikna Score: 7.2/10. Recommended.
Common Goal is the Game Changers book about starting late: a veteran goalie near the end of his career, freshly divorced and dating men for the first time, and the much younger grad student who offers to show him around. It is generous about bisexuality and very open-door, but the age gap and Kyle's past get less care than they need.
Read it if you want a later-in-life bisexual awakening with lots of explicit, kinky fun, or you are working through the series behind Heated Rivalry. Skip it if age gaps with a power history make you uneasy, or you want the tension and pining of Shane and Ilya's books.
Common Goal at a Glance
Common Goal is book 4 of Rachel Reid's Game Changers series, an MM hockey romance first published by Carina Press in September 2020. Veteran goalie Eric Bennett and grad student Kyle Swift start as friends with benefits. It has very explicit open-door heat, a sizeable age gap and a happy ending.
| Author | Rachel Reid |
|---|---|
| Series | Game Changers, book 4 (each book follows a new couple) |
| Subgenre | MM romance, sports romance (hockey) |
| Main tropes | Age gap, friends with benefits, later-in-life bisexual awakening, retiring athlete, friends to lovers |
| Spice level | 5/5: Very explicit, sex central to the plot |
| Content warnings | Age gap, past relationship with an older married boss, leaked images, bondage (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, third person (Eric and Kyle) |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 320 (2024 Carina Press paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Cooper North, 9 hours 53 minutes (Harlequin) |
| First published | September 21, 2020 |
| Publisher | Carina Press (Harlequin) |
What Is Common Goal About?
Common Goal follows Eric Bennett, a veteran goaltender for the New York Admirals who can see the end of his career from the crease. His divorce is done, quietly and kindly, and he has decided it is time to stop pretending he is not attracted to men. He just has no idea where to begin.
Kyle Swift is a graduate student who tends bar in Manhattan and has promised himself he is done with older men. Then he meets Eric. The plan Kyle comes up with is simple: show Eric the ropes, enjoy himself, walk away. Eric is an eager student. Kyle is the one who starts wanting more, and the walking away part gets harder each week.
What Makes This Age Gap Romance Work
Common Goal works because its age gap romance flips the usual dynamic. Eric is the older, famous, financially settled man, and he is also the beginner. Kyle, roughly fifteen years younger, is the one with the experience and the confidence, and he sets the terms. That reversal gives the friends with benefits setup a real charge.
The other hook is tone. Eric's bisexuality is treated as a plain fact rather than a crisis, and his marriage is not written off as a lie. The Cannonball Read reviewer liked exactly that: Eric is valid, and his past is not a mistake to be erased. For a coming out story about a man past forty, that is a welcome kind of calm.
And there is the team. Carter Vaughan, Eric's loud and loyal teammate, is the ally everyone wants, and Ilya Rozanov wanders in to say something blunt and correct.
My Review
Common Goal is the Game Changers book I like more than I rate. It is warm, funny and open about sex in a way that feels freeing, and I enjoyed almost every scene between Eric and Kyle. It also has a structural problem it never quite fixes, and the problem is Kyle's past.
Rachel Reid writes these books in a plain, quick style, and Common Goal is no exception. The hockey is background noise. What she cares about is two people working out what they want, and here that working out happens mostly in bed.
Romance and Chemistry
The friends with benefits arrangement is the plot, and Reid commits to it. Kyle teaches, Eric learns, and the lessons get more adventurous, including some bondage. Stop and Smell the Books gave the heat five peppers and said the bondage was handled well, and I agree that the sex scenes are doing character work. Eric is discovering himself; Kyle is discovering that he can be trusted.
The emotional side is slower. Both men are slow to say what they feel, and the late conflict depends on that silence. Goodreads readers who complain about miscommunication and a rushed ending have a point. I wanted one more honest conversation before the final turn.
The Characters
Eric is lovely. He is disciplined, a little awkward, quietly into abstract art, and so courteous that his inexperience reads as sweet rather than comic. Reid also gives him a real non-romantic worry: his body is aging, a younger backup goalie is coming for his net, and retirement is a cliff he can see.
Kyle is the harder case. He was introduced in Game Changer as Kip's funny, flirty coworker, and here we learn why he swore off older men. At eighteen he had a secret relationship with his older, married boss, it became a public scandal, and he left town. The book treats this as the root of his fear, which it plainly is, but it does not do much more with it. Stop and Smell the Books felt the age gap was not handled with enough care and that Kyle's trauma stayed on the surface, and that matches my read. A romance can be about a man healing from something like that, but this one mostly lets the new relationship do the healing.
Writing and Pacing
At 320 pages in the current paperback it moves well. Reid's dialogue is the best thing on the page, and the team scenes, with Carter, Scott Hunter and a brief Ilya, are pure pleasure. The Paper Worlds blogger ranked Eric and Kyle her second favorite couple in the series after Shane and Ilya, and on chemistry alone I understand why. The pacing sags in the middle, when the arrangement is going well and nobody is saying anything true.
Common Goal is a warm, very explicit and refreshingly calm bisexual awakening romance that skims over the harder material it raises. Read it if you want an affectionate age gap story with a lot of heat, and skip it if Kyle's history needs more care than the book gives it.
How Spicy Is Common Goal?
Common Goal is a 5 out of 5 on our scale: Very explicit, sex central to the plot. The relationship begins as a sexual arrangement, the scenes are frequent and detailed, and they include light bondage and a teacher and student dynamic in which the younger man leads. Everything between Eric and Kyle is consensual and both are adults: published summaries put Eric at about 40 and Kyle at about 25.
Kyle's backstory involves an older, married employer who had a secret relationship with him when he was 18, and leaked images from that time. It is discussed rather than shown. For more books in this heat range, see our spicy romance list and the romance heat levels guide.
Content warnings, drawn from the publisher description and reader reviews:
- Age gap of roughly fifteen years
- Past relationship between an 18-year-old and his older, married boss (backstory)
- Leaked intimate images and public scandal (backstory)
- Bondage and kink
- Divorce
- Retirement anxiety and an aging body
- Homophobic rival player (minor)
- Very explicit on-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Common Goal?
Common Goal suits readers who want an MM hockey romance about a bisexual man coming out after a long marriage, told with warmth and a lot of heat. It is less suited to readers who want a careful treatment of grooming and age gaps, or a slow burn with high angst.
Best for:
- Readers who want bisexual representation that is calm and affirming
- Fans of older, inexperienced heroes and confident younger partners
- Game Changers readers who loved the Admirals locker room
- Anyone who wants explicit, playful, kink-friendly sex scenes
Not for:
- Readers uneasy with large age gaps or past power imbalance
- Anyone who wants trauma handled in depth
- Readers who dislike late-book miscommunication
- People looking for the rivalry and secrecy of Heated Rivalry
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Common Goal has been read far more widely since the Heated Rivalry adaptation reached screens in late 2025, and it now has close to 120,000 Goodreads ratings. Its 3.64 average sits below other books in the series, which tells you something about how it divides people.
Where they agree. The supporting cast and the bisexual representation. The Cannonball Read reviewer gave it four stars, loved Carter as the supportive himbo ally and praised the way Eric's bisexuality is treated as valid. Stop and Smell the Books, also four stars, singled out the bi and demisexual representation and Ilya's fairy godmother role. Goodreads readers return to the banter and the cameos.
Where they split. The age gap and the depth. Stop and Smell the Books felt the age gap was not handled carefully enough and found both leads inward-looking. Goodreads readers frequently cite a slow middle, miscommunication, a rushed ending and sex scenes that crowd out the relationship. The Paper Worlds blog, by contrast, put Eric and Kyle second only to Shane and Ilya in the series.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Common Goal scores 7.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for heat, where the explicit arrangement delivers exactly what it promises, and its lowest for the ending, which readers on Goodreads find rushed and built on miscommunication.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Charming chemistry; Stop and Smell the Books finds the age gap under-examined. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Eric and the team shine, per Cannonball Read; Kyle's trauma stays shallow. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Quick dialogue and good team scenes; Goodreads readers report a slow middle. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Eric's coming out is affecting, though the heavier backstory is skimmed. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4.5 | Very explicit and playful; Swooon rates it 4 of 5, Stop and Smell the Books 5 of 5. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3 | A happy ending reached through late miscommunication readers call rushed. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | The team scenes and cameos reward a reread for series fans. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Common Goal sits in the middle of the Game Changers series, warmer and steamier than most of its siblings but less tense than Heated Rivalry, and earns a final Eikna Score of 7.2/10.
Game Changers Reading Order
Common Goal is book 4 of Rachel Reid's Game Changers series. Each book follows a new couple in the same fictional league, so Common Goal can be read alone, but Kyle first appears in Game Changer and the Admirals cast carries over from it.
- Game Changer (2018): Scott Hunter and Kip Grady
- Heated Rivalry (2019): Shane Hollander and Ilya Rozanov
- Tough Guy (2019): Ryan Price and Fabian Salah
- Common Goal (2020): Eric Bennett and Kyle Swift
- Role Model (2021): Troy Barrett and Harris Drover
- The Long Game (2022): Shane and Ilya again, several years on
- Unrivaled (scheduled for June 1, 2027): Shane and Ilya's third book
Best start: Game Changer if you want Kyle's first appearances, or Heated Rivalry if you are here from the show. Best format: print or ebook, though Cooper North's Harlequin audiobook is a steady listen at just under ten hours. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved Common Goal, Read These Next
If you loved Common Goal, the closest matches are MM romances with a later-in-life awakening, an age gap or the same hockey world.
- Heated Rivalry by Rachel Reid: the series favorite, two rival captains in a secret relationship that lasts years.
- Role Model by Rachel Reid: the next book, with Troy Barrett, who appears in Common Goal.
- The Quarterback by Tal Bauer: an injured college quarterback and an older single dad, with a bisexual awakening on both sides.
- In Step by Jay Hogan: a fourteen-year age gap, a visiting choreographer and a man with a past he regrets.
- Game Misconduct by Ari Baran: hockey rivals in bed, with an aging enforcer facing the end of his career.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common Goal raises the same questions for most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how big the age gap is, and how it connects to Heated Rivalry. Short answers below.
Is Common Goal spicy?
Very. Common Goal is a 5 out of 5 on our scale, with frequent explicit scenes, including light bondage, built into a friends with benefits plot.
Can I read Common Goal as a standalone?
Yes. It follows a new couple, Eric Bennett and Kyle Swift, though Kyle and several Admirals players first appear in Game Changer.
How old are Eric and Kyle in Common Goal?
Published summaries put Eric at about 40 and Kyle at about 25, an age gap of roughly fifteen years. Both are adults throughout.
Does Common Goal have a happy ending?
Yes. Eric and Kyle end the book together after a late misunderstanding.
Is Common Goal related to Heated Rivalry?
Yes. It is book 4 of the same Game Changers series, and Ilya Rozanov makes brief appearances.
Is there a Common Goal audiobook?
Yes. The Harlequin audiobook is narrated by Cooper North and runs 9 hours 53 minutes.
The Bottom Line
Common Goal earns a 7.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a very explicit, affectionate MM hockey romance about a man coming out after forty, with a confident younger partner leading the way. The one reason to pick it up is Eric: a kind, inexperienced hero whose bisexuality the book never treats as a problem.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Common Goal (Game Changers #4), Goodreads (first published date, ratings, reader reviews)
- Common Goal 2024 paperback, Bookshop.org (publisher, pages)
- Common Goal audiobook, Libro.fm (narrator, length, publisher description)
- Common Goal, Swooon (tropes, heat rating)
- Common Goal character list, SuperSummary (ages, backstory)
- Common Goal review, Cannonball Read
- Common Goal by Rachel Reid, Stop and Smell the Books
- Common Goal (Game Changers #4), The Paper Worlds
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.