Deal Maker by Lily Morton Review
Eikna Score: 8.3/10. Recommended.
Deal Maker is one of the funniest MM romances I know: a sharp-tongued model takes a live-in assistant job with an actor who despises models, then sets out to be the worst employee in London. Under the jokes is a tender found family story with a five-year-old who steals every scene, though the sabotage plot strains belief and the separation in the second half hits harder than some readers want.
Read it if you want British banter, a grumpy single dad and a child character who actually sounds like a child, or you like boss and assistant romance where the assistant has all the power of the punchline. Skip it if a hero who deliberately does his job badly will annoy you, or you dislike a noticeable age gap and a painful mid-book breakup.
Deal Maker at a Glance
Deal Maker is book 2 of Lily Morton's Mixed Messages series, a self-published British MM romance first released in December 2017. Model Jude Bailey becomes the live-in assistant of actor and single dad Asa Jacobs, with steamy open-door scenes and a happily ever after capped by an epilogue.
| Author | Lily Morton |
|---|---|
| Series | Mixed Messages, book 2 (can be read as a standalone) |
| Subgenre | MM romance, romantic comedy |
| Main tropes | Boss and employee, live-in assistant, single dad, age gap, found family |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | Age gap, workplace power imbalance, a bitter ex, a widowed parent, press intrusion (full list below) |
| POV | Jude |
| Ending | HEA, with an epilogue |
| Pages | 326 (paperback); about 318 in the Kindle edition |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Joel Leslie, 11 hours 8 minutes (2019) |
| First published | December 22, 2017 (ebook); paperback January 2018 |
| Publisher | Self-published by Lily Morton |
What Is Deal Maker About?
Deal Maker starts when a neighbor's bathtub comes through Jude Bailey's ceiling and ruins his London flat. Jude is a successful underwear model with no interest in relationships, and his friend Dean finds him a stopgap: a room in the house of Dean's stepbrother, actor Asa Jacobs, provided Jude works as Asa's personal assistant for the summer.
Asa has very low opinions of models and makes them obvious. So Jude gives him exactly the airhead he expects, and makes the job as hard as possible for both of them. The plan falls apart because of Billy, Asa's five-year-old son, and because Asa sees through Jude much faster than Jude would like.
What Makes This Boss and Employee Romance Work
Deal Maker works as a boss and employee romance because the employee is running the show. Jude's revenge plan flips the usual power imbalance on its head, and the comedy comes from watching a famous, controlled man lose an argument to his assistant several times a day.
Lily Morton opens every chapter with a piece of fan mail, a running joke that reviewers at Love Bytes Reviews and Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words both singled out. The banter is fast and very British, and the supporting cast, including housekeeper Peggy, chauffeur Amos and Dylan and Gabe from Rule Breaker, keeps the house loud.
Billy is the hook under the hook. Several reviewers, and many Goodreads readers, call him one of the most believable small children in romance. Once Jude starts caring for him, the book stops being a prank war and becomes a found family story.
My Review
Deal Maker is properly laugh-out-loud funny, which is rarer in romance than the cover copy of most romcoms would have you believe. Jude's voice is the reason. He is vain, funny, sharper than anyone gives him credit for, and he narrates his own sabotage with the glee of a man who knows he is being petty and has decided to enjoy it.
The book is also more emotional than its first act suggests, and the second half is where it earns its reputation.
Romance and Chemistry
The romance between Jude and Asa runs on irritation turning into fascination. The Novel Approach praised how the chemistry builds through friendship, and Lisa there wrote that Deal Maker romanced her in all the very best ways. I agree that the slow shift is well done, and that it runs through Billy: the two men fall for each other partly by watching how the other treats a small boy.
Then a news story forces them apart. Some Goodreads readers found the breakup scenes harsh and out of character, and I understand why; the second half is less funny and more raw. I think the pain is earned, and the reunion and the epilogue, which readers repeatedly name as a highlight, pay it back.
The Characters
Jude is the star, and Billy is a close second. Asa is a gruff, guarded man, a gruff teddy bear in the words of Sadonna at Love Bytes Reviews, still carrying the death of Billy's mother, Eve. Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words gives his age as 44, and Jude is in his late twenties by reader accounts, so this is an age gap romance even though the book rarely makes a fuss about it.
The weak point is the premise. A StoryGraph reader did not finish it because Jude's deliberate bad work and Asa's decision to keep him made no sense to them. That is fair. If you need workplace logic to hold, the setup will grate. A few Goodreads readers also found Jude too stubborn and the evil ex subplot familiar.
Writing and Pacing
Morton's prose is quick and quotable, built for dialogue. The first half moves at sitcom speed; the middle slows, and some Goodreads readers felt it dragged, especially once the book trades jokes for feelings. The trip to Devon to meet Jude's family is a warm change of scene, singled out by Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words. The book has little plot beyond the romance, one reader noted, and that is true. It does not need more.
Deal Maker is a laugh-out-loud MM romcom with a real heart, a grumpy single dad and the best five-year-old in the genre. Read it if banter is your love language and you can forgive a premise that does not survive close inspection.
How Spicy Is Deal Maker?
Deal Maker is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The opening third is all sparring, and the explicit scenes come once Jude and Asa stop pretending; All About Romance noted more than one graphic sex scene and plenty of swearing.
Both men are adults: Asa is 44 and Jude is in his late twenties by reader accounts. Asa is technically Jude's employer, and the house and the job come as a package, so the power imbalance is real even if the book treats it lightly. The intimacy itself is consensual. Our heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the publisher copy and reader and critic reports:
- Age gap of about fifteen years
- Boss and employee relationship with housing tied to the job
- Death of a parent in backstory (Billy's mother)
- A manipulative ex and past betrayal
- Brief drug use and discussion of past drug use
- Press intrusion and a public scandal
- Mistreatment of a child by an adult (side plot, per reader reports)
- Explicit on-page sex and frequent swearing
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Deal Maker?
Deal Maker suits readers who want a funny, British MM romance with a grumpy single dad, a mouthy hero and a found family that includes a scene-stealing child. It is less suited to readers who need a plausible workplace setup or dislike an emotional breakup in the second half.
Best for:
- Fans of banter-heavy romcoms
- Readers who love single dad romance with a well-written child
- Anyone who enjoys boss and assistant role reversals
- Readers who like British settings and humor
- Audiobook listeners: Joel Leslie's narration is widely praised
Not for:
- Readers who cannot stand a hero who does his job badly on purpose
- Anyone who wants a romance with no breakup
- Readers uneasy with an employer and live-in employee pairing
- Readers who want a plot-driven book
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Deal Maker has no trade coverage that we could find, but it is a long-running favorite on MM romance blogs and with readers. On Goodreads it averages 4.33 from more than 7,600 ratings as of November 2026, and the blog reviews are close to unanimous.
Where they agree. The humor. Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words gave it 5 out of 5 and called it a comfort read; The Novel Approach gave it 4.5 stars; Love Bytes Reviews gave the audiobook 4.5 hearts and called Joel Leslie the perfect narrator. All About Romance's audio review put it simply: "Deal Maker is the real deal in happily ever afters." Billy and the fan-mail chapter openers come up everywhere.
Where they split. The premise and the second half. A StoryGraph reader gave up over Jude's work sabotage. Goodreads readers who were less taken found the middle slow, the first half funnier than the second and the breakup scenes harsh. All About Romance thought Leslie's Billy did not quite sound five.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Deal Maker scores 8.3 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, just short of Highly Recommended. Its top marks go to romance, ending and reread appeal, where reviewers praise the chemistry and the epilogue, and its lowest to writing and pacing, held back by a saggy middle and a premise that strains belief.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4.5 | Irritation into devotion, praised by The Novel Approach; the breakup divides readers. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Jude and Billy shine; a StoryGraph reader found the premise behavior implausible. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Quick, funny prose; Goodreads readers find the middle slow. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | The second half hurts, then heals; Scattered Thoughts calls it a comfort read. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers explicit scenes once the sparring ends, per All About Romance. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4.5 | An HEA with an epilogue that readers repeatedly name as a highlight. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 4.5 | Built for rereads and relistens; reviewers call it a comfort favorite. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Deal Maker is among the funniest books in Lily Morton's catalogue, which also includes After Felix and Oz, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 8.3/10.
Mixed Messages Reading Order
Deal Maker is book 2 of Lily Morton's Mixed Messages series. Each main book has a new couple and the author says Deal Maker can be read alone, but Love Bytes Reviews recommends starting with Rule Breaker because Deal Maker spoils its romance.
- Book 1: Rule Breaker (2017): Dylan and Gabe
- Book 2: Deal Maker (2017): Jude and Asa
- Book 3: Risk Taker (2018)
- Book 4: Vow Maker (2022)
The series also has a run of short stories and novellas, including Jude's Intervention (numbered 1.3) and Jude's Christmas (2.7), for fans who want more of the same household. Best format: the Joel Leslie audiobook, about 11 hours, because his voices for Asa, Gabe and Peggy are a big part of the fun. Morton's other series include Model Agency, home to Call Back. Our series order guide covers more series.
If You Loved Deal Maker, Read These Next
If you loved Deal Maker, the best next reads are banter-heavy romances with a grumpy single parent, an employee who will not behave or a found family that forms around a child. These Eikna reviews are the closest matches.
- Rule Breaker by Lily Morton: the series opener, another boss and assistant romance, with Dylan and Gabe.
- After Felix by Lily Morton: a gentler, sadder Morton romance about grief and a second chance.
- Heartless by Elsie Silver: a grumpy single dad and a live-in nanny who will not be cowed.
- By a Thread by Lucy Score: a grumpy boss and a sunshine employee in a workplace romcom.
- On the Edge by Annabeth Albert: an MM age gap romance with a houseful of kids and a quieter heart.
Frequently Asked Questions
Deal Maker raises the same few questions for most new readers: whether you need to read Rule Breaker first, how spicy it gets, how old Jude and Asa are, whether it ends happily and who narrates the audiobook. Short answers below.
Do I need to read Rule Breaker before Deal Maker?
No. Deal Maker works as a standalone, but it spoils Rule Breaker's romance, so read that first if you plan to read both.
Is Deal Maker spicy?
Yes. Deal Maker is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit scenes once Jude and Asa get together.
How old are Jude and Asa in Deal Maker?
Asa is 44 and Jude is in his late twenties, so there is an age gap of about fifteen years.
Does Deal Maker have a happy ending?
Yes. Deal Maker ends with a happily ever after and an epilogue set about two years later.
Who narrates the Deal Maker audiobook?
Joel Leslie narrates the audiobook, which runs about 11 hours 8 minutes.
The Bottom Line
Deal Maker earns an 8.3/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a funny, warm MM romance with a grumpy single dad, a mouthy hero and a little boy who makes the whole house feel like home. The one reason to pick it up is Jude's voice: few romance narrators are this entertaining while being this petty.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Deal Maker by Lily Morton (audio review), All About Romance
- Audio Book Review: Deal Maker (Mixed Messages #2), Love Bytes Reviews
- Review: Deal Maker (Mixed Messages #2), Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words
- Review: Deal Maker by Lily Morton, The Novel Approach
- Deal Maker (Mixed Messages #2), Goodreads (ratings, reader reviews)
- Deal Maker audiobook, Audible
- Mixed Messages series, LibraryThing
- Lily Morton, FantasticFiction (series years)
- Lily Morton official Deal Maker page, the Amazon paperback record, the Joyfully Jay review and StoryGraph reader criticism.
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.