In Step by Jay Hogan Review
Eikna Score: 7.8/10. Recommended.
In Step gives the former bully of the Painted Bay series his own love story, and pairs him with a silver fox choreographer who is only in town for six weeks. Jay Hogan earns Kane's redemption with patience and warmth, though the age gap romance runs on low conflict until a late family confrontation that not every reader will cheer.
Read it if you love redemption arcs, small town found family and a sensual older hero who dances tango. Skip it if you cannot root for a man who once bullied a gay classmate, or you want high tension throughout.
In Step at a Glance
In Step is book 3 and the conclusion of Jay Hogan's Painted Bay series, an MM small town romance set in New Zealand and published by Southern Lights Publishing in February 2022. Kane, 30, falls for Abe, a 44-year-old visiting choreographer. It runs 344 pages in paperback, has steamy open-door scenes and ends with an HEA.
| Author | Jay Hogan |
|---|---|
| Series | Painted Bay, book 3 (series conclusion; new couple) |
| Subgenre | MM romance, small town romance, contemporary |
| Main tropes | Age gap, redemption arc, temporary visitor, found family, dance and tango |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | Past bullying, past child abuse, a violent homophobic father, closeting (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, Kane and Abe |
| Ending | HEA, with an epilogue six months later |
| Pages | 344 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Gary Furlong, 10 hours 16 minutes |
| First published | February 10, 2022 |
| Publisher | Southern Lights Publishing |
What Is In Step About?
In Step follows Kane Martin, who is thirty, broke, closeted and back in Painted Bay, the small New Zealand town where he once helped make Judah Madden's school years miserable. Kane is not proud of that. He was sleeping in his car with a litter of kittens until the Maddens, of all people, gave him work on the family's mussel boats.
Abe Tyler is a London-based choreographer who spends most of the year on contracts around the world. He has come to Painted Bay for a six-week working holiday, helping Judah prepare a dance recital for physically disabled children. Abe does not do long-term. Kane does not do anything at all. Six weeks should be safe. It is not.
What Makes This Age Gap Romance Work
In Step works because its age gap romance pairs two men who both think they are not built for staying. Abe is fourteen years older, glamorous and rootless by choice; Kane is younger, stuck and convinced he has not earned anything good. The six-week limit gives them permission to start, and the book watches that permission turn into a problem.
The redemption angle is the real draw. Kane was one of Judah's bullies, and Hogan does not soften it. Valerie at Love Bytes Reviews noted how ashamed Kane is of his past and how much of his history the book saves for later, and that slow reveal is what lets a reader move from wary to protective.
Then there is the tango. Abe's passion for dance gives the romance a physical language, and their lessons are some of the sexiest scenes in the book without anyone undressing.
My Review
In Step is a book I trusted more as it went on. I started it wary of Kane, which is exactly what Jay Hogan intends, and finished it protective of him, which is the book's real achievement. Getting there takes patience, and the romance is gentler than the backstory suggests.
If you have read Off Balance, you remember Kane as one of the boys who made Judah's life hard. Hogan does not ask you to forget that. The book asks you to watch a man who is ashamed of it try to become someone else, and it gives him plenty of reasons why he was who he was.
Romance and Chemistry
The chemistry between Kane and Abe is instant, which Love Bytes noted, and Hogan has fun with it: Abe in body-hugging dance gear is an obstacle Kane is not equipped for. The romance itself is low conflict. They agree to keep their feelings in check because Abe is leaving, and they mostly manage, which makes the first two thirds warm rather than tense. The reviewer jackiehorne on StoryGraph liked that low-conflict setup, and so did I, but it does mean the stakes come late.
The age gap is handled without much fuss. Kane is 30 and Abe 44, both settled adults, and the difference shows up as perspective rather than power. Abe has seen more of the world; Kane has survived more of it.
The Characters
Kane is the reason to read this. Hogan builds him out of guilt, poverty, loneliness and a stubborn decency that he keeps hidden, and his relationship with a litter of rescued kittens tells you more about him than his dialogue does. The cause of his past is his father, a violent, homophobic man whose shadow hangs over the whole book. jackiehorne found the redemption believable because of that abuse, though underdeveloped, and that is fair: Kane's guilt is sometimes all he gets to be.
Abe is lovelier on paper than in practice. He is supposed to be a restless wanderer, and jackiehorne felt his wanderlust never shows on the page, so his move toward settling down feels familiar. I agree that he is the less vivid of the two. He is kind, sexy and patient, which is what Kane needs, and not much more.
The supporting cast is where Painted Bay shines. Leroy and Fox from On Board supply most of the humor, Judah's generosity toward Kane is quietly moving, and the town works as a found family that Kane has to learn to accept.
Writing and Pacing
Hogan writes New Zealand with real affection; Love Bytes compared the cold winter coast and farmland to a travelogue. The pacing is steady and a little slow in the middle. The final act brings a confrontation with Kane's father that jackiehorne criticized for ending in a punch, which the reviewer thought sent the wrong message in a book about bullying and violence. I understood the catharsis, but it sits awkwardly with everything the book says about Kane outgrowing his father.
In Step is a warm, sensual age gap romance whose real subject is a former bully earning his place in a town he hurt. Read it if you love redemption arcs and small town found family, and start with Off Balance if you want the full weight of Kane's past.
How Spicy Is In Step?
In Step is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The attraction is instant, the sex is open door and very sensual, and it is consensual between adults (Kane is 30, Abe 44). The heat is part of the relationship rather than the point of it.
For more in this range, see our spicy romance list; the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the publisher description and reader reviews:
- Past homophobic bullying by the main character
- Past child abuse by a parent
- A violent, homophobic father, including threats to Kane and his pets
- Physical confrontation with a parent
- Homelessness and poverty
- Closeting
- Age gap of fourteen years
- Explicit on-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read In Step?
In Step suits readers who want a gentle, sensual MM small town romance about redemption, with an older hero, a strong sense of place and a warm community. It is less suited to readers who want high-stakes drama or who find bully redemption arcs hard to accept.
Best for:
- Readers who love redemption arcs for former antagonists
- Fans of small town romance with a found family cast
- Anyone drawn to silver fox heroes and age gaps between adults
- Readers who enjoyed Off Balance and On Board
- People who like dance as a romantic language
Not for:
- Readers who cannot forgive a bully, even a remorseful one
- Anyone looking for tight, high-tension plotting
- Readers bothered by a violent climax with a parent
- People who want a book that stands entirely apart from its series
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
In Step is a small-press title, so its reception lives with MM review blogs and readers rather than trade journals. The pattern is clear: blogs love it, while some readers on StoryGraph and Goodreads are cooler.
Where they agree. Kane and the setting. Love Bytes Reviews gave both the ebook and the audiobook 4.75 hearts, praising the balance of humor, romance and heavier themes, the New Zealand setting and the found family that offsets the heartbreak. Its audio reviewer called Gary Furlong a superb narrator. Readers repeatedly mention the tango and the epilogue.
Where they split. Depth and the ending. jackiehorne on StoryGraph gave it three stars, finding neither lead vivid, Kane's redemption underdeveloped and the final confrontation with his father a misstep. Love Bytes' audio reviewer admitted bully romances are a hard sell for her and said this one won her over anyway.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
In Step scores 7.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for the characters, led by Kane's redemption, and its lowest for writing and pacing, heat and reread appeal, where readers note a slow middle and a low-conflict romance.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Instant, sensual chemistry; jackiehorne on StoryGraph likes the low-conflict setup. |
| Characters (15%) | 4.5 | Kane's redemption carries the book; Love Bytes praises Hogan's characterization. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | A vivid setting, per Love Bytes, with a slow middle stretch. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Kane's past and the found family hit hard, per Love Bytes. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Sensual and explicit, though the heat is secondary to the story. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A true HEA with an epilogue, per Love Bytes; the climax divides readers. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | The town and side cast reward series fans on a reread. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: In Step is a satisfying close to the Painted Bay trilogy, quieter than On Board and deeper on redemption, and earns a final Eikna Score of 7.8/10.
Painted Bay Reading Order
In Step is book 3 and the conclusion of Jay Hogan's Painted Bay series. Each book follows a new couple, so In Step can be read alone, but Kane's history with Judah comes from Off Balance and his turn toward redemption begins in On Board.
- Off Balance: Judah Madden and Morgan Wipene
- On Board: Leroy Madden and Fox Carmody
- In Step (2022): Kane Martin and Abe Tyler
Best start: Off Balance, then On Board, then In Step, so the redemption has its full weight. Best format: the audiobook narrated by Gary Furlong, about ten hours, which Love Bytes praised for its voices and New Zealand feel. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved In Step, Read These Next
If you loved In Step, the closest matches are MM romances with an age gap, a hero carrying regret or a lot of heat between adults at different stages of life.
- Common Goal by Rachel Reid: a fifteen year age gap and a man starting over late, with more heat and less angst.
- The Quarterback by Tal Bauer: an older single dad, an injured younger man and a slow, tender burn.
- Loathed: Lagan by Nora Phoenix: an older professor, a younger law student and a found family of foster brothers.
- For Real by Alexis Hall: a wide age gap between two men, told with wit and a lot of feeling.
Frequently Asked Questions
In Step raises the same questions for most readers: how spicy it is, how old Kane and Abe are, whether you need the earlier books and how it ends. Short answers below.
Is In Step spicy?
Yes. In Step is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several sensual, explicit and consensual open-door scenes.
How old are Kane and Abe in In Step?
Kane is 30 and Abe is 44, an age gap of fourteen years. Both are adults throughout.
Do I need to read the other Painted Bay books first?
No, but it helps. In Step follows a new couple, yet Kane's past as Judah's bully comes from Off Balance and his redemption starts in On Board.
Does In Step have a happy ending?
Yes. Kane and Abe get an HEA, with an epilogue set six months later.
What is the Painted Bay reading order?
Off Balance, On Board, then In Step, which concludes the series.
Is there an In Step audiobook?
Yes. It is narrated by Gary Furlong and runs 10 hours 16 minutes.
The Bottom Line
In Step earns a 7.8/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a warm, sensual MM age gap romance with a former bully learning to forgive himself and a small New Zealand town that helps him do it. The one reason to pick it up is Kane: few romance heroes start this far in the hole, and Hogan makes his climb out worth following.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Painted Bay series, Jay Hogan (order, couples)
- In Step: A Painted Bay Story, Bookshop.org (publisher, date, pages)
- Release Day Review: In Step, Love Bytes Reviews (Valerie)
- Audio Book Review: In Step, Love Bytes Reviews (Larissa; narrator and length)
- In Step review by jackiehorne, StoryGraph (ages, criticism)
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.