eikna romance
Menu

The Quarterback by Tal Bauer Review

Eikna Score: 8.2/10. Recommended.

The Quarterback is a slow, tender age gap romance about two lonely men: an injured college quarterback with an NFL future in doubt and the divorced, supposedly straight dad who helps him recover. Tal Bauer makes the friendship so convincing that the romance feels inevitable, even when the third act leans on a breakup the book did not need.

Read it if you want a long, aching slow burn with hurt and comfort, or you love older heroes who take care of people. Skip it if a twenty year age gap with family ties bothers you, or third act breakups built on silence drive you up the wall.

The Quarterback by Tal Bauer book cover

The Quarterback at a Glance

The Quarterback is book 2 of Tal Bauer's The Team series, a self-published MM sports romance released in August 2021. College quarterback Colton Hall falls for Nick Swanscott, the much older father of his best friend's boyfriend. It runs 372 pages in paperback, has steamy open-door scenes after a slow burn and ends with an HEA.

AuthorTal Bauer
SeriesThe Team, book 2 (follows The Jock; new couple)
SubgenreMM romance, sports romance (college football)
Main tropesAge gap, slow burn, friends to lovers, hurt and comfort, bisexual awakening
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsSerious sports injury, age gap with family ties, internship at the older man's company, abandonment (full list below)
POVDual, Colton and Nick
EndingHEA, with an epilogue
Pages372 (paperback)
AudiobookAvailable, about 11 hours 21 minutes
First publishedAugust 7, 2021
PublisherIndependently published

What Is The Quarterback About?

The Quarterback follows Colton Hall, a college quarterback projected as a top NFL pick who chose to stay for his senior year. Then his shoulder goes, and with it the only future he has ever planned for. He is facing surgery, rehab and the very real chance that he never plays again.

Nick Swanscott is the one who shows up. He is the father of Justin, the boyfriend of Colton's best friend Wes, a divorced single dad everyone assumes is straight, Nick included. He helps Colton through recovery, finds him an internship and becomes the person Colton talks to at night. Colton falls first and assumes it is hopeless. It is not, but the age gap, the family ties and Colton's career make it complicated.

What Makes This Slow Burn Romance Work

The Quarterback works because its slow burn romance is built on a friendship you would want to read about even without the romance. Colton is lonely in a way his teammates never see, and Nick is lonely in a quieter, more settled way. Larissa at Love Bytes Reviews put it simply: both men are lonely, and the book is about them noticing each other.

The hurt and comfort frame does the rest. A shoulder injury puts a star athlete in the position of needing help with ordinary things, and Nick is the kind of man who quietly does them. That turns caretaking into intimacy long before anyone touches anyone.

Readers who like slow burn stories where the first kiss is a genuine event will find this one rewarding.

My Review

The Quarterback surprised me. I expected an age gap romance with a sports gloss, and instead got a long, patient book about two men who have organized their whole lives around other people and have nothing left for themselves. Tal Bauer takes his time, and the time is the point.

It is also a sequel to The Jock, and the couple from that book, Wes and Justin, are central to the conflict here. You can follow everything without reading it, but you will understand the shape of Justin's reaction better if you have.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance is a true slow burn. Colton and Nick spend a long stretch as friends, then as something unnamed, and Bauer lets the tension build through small things: rides to physical therapy, late meals, a hand on a good shoulder. Love Bytes called the book a writing tour de force that surpassed The Jock, and for the first two thirds I would agree without hesitation.

Both men are discovering an attraction to men for the first time, and this is where some Goodreads readers push back: the double bisexual awakening happens without much exploration of what it means to either of them. I felt that too. The book is more interested in who they are to each other than in labels, which is a fair choice, but Nick in particular moves from certainty to certainty quickly.

The third act uses a breakup driven by miscommunication and family pressure. StoryGraph readers were confused by Justin's reaction and by how Nick treats Colton in that stretch, and a lot of Goodreads reviewers call it out. It hurts, which is the intent. It also felt avoidable to me.

The Characters

Colton is the heart of it. He is a golden boy with an absent father and a fear of being left that shapes every choice he makes, and Bauer writes his vulnerability without making him pitiful. Nick is warm and solid, the dad who shows up, and the book is honest that some of what Colton feels for him is tangled up with what Colton never had. Some Goodreads readers find that dynamic uncomfortable and feel the father issues are left unresolved. I think the book knows exactly what it is doing there; whether it does enough with it is another matter.

The power question is real. Nick is about twenty years older, a parent figure in Colton's circle and, for a while, the person who arranges Colton's internship at his company. Both are adults (reviewers put Colton at 22 and Nick at 43), and the book does not hide the imbalance. It is worth knowing before you start.

Writing and Pacing

Bauer's prose leans emotional and interior, with long paragraphs of feeling. One StoryGraph reader said the long paragraphs slowed them down, and some Goodreads reviewers found the internal monologues repetitive. I mostly sank into them. The football subplot is lighter than the title suggests: the injury and the draft matter, the games mostly do not.

The Quarterback is a moving, carefully paced age gap slow burn that lands its emotion even when its third act gets messy. Read it if you want hurt and comfort with two lonely men at the center, and know going in that the age gap and family ties are a real part of the story.

How Spicy Is The Quarterback?

The Quarterback is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The first half is almost entirely tension. Once Colton and Nick get together, the sex is open door, explicit and frequent enough that readers call the love scenes heated. Everything is consensual and between adults.

For more in this range, see our spicy romance list; the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from the publisher description and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Quarterback?

The Quarterback suits readers who want a long, emotional MM slow burn with hurt and comfort, a caretaking older hero and a younger man learning to be looked after. It is less suited to readers who want a light sports romance or who are wary of age gaps with family entanglements.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Quarterback holds a 4.18 average from more than 8,700 Goodreads ratings, and a good share of readers rank it above The Jock. Like most self-published MM romance, it has little trade press coverage, so the conversation lives with blogs and readers.

Where they agree. The emotional writing and the slow burn. Love Bytes Reviews gave it five hearts and praised the depth, the pacing and Colton's loneliness. Goodreads and StoryGraph readers single out Nick's warmth, Colton's vulnerability, the chemistry and the epilogue.

Where they split. The third act and the dynamic. Goodreads readers frequently criticize the miscommunication breakup, Justin's immature reaction and bisexual awakenings that feel rushed. Some find Colton's father issues and the parent-figure dynamic uncomfortable, while others call the book cathartic. Love Bytes saw the messiness of Wes and Justin as a strength rather than a flaw.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Quarterback scores 8.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top marks for the romance and emotional impact, where the slow burn earns its payoff, and its lowest for writing and pacing, which readers find heavy with repetitive interior monologue.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4.5A patient, convincing slow burn; Love Bytes calls it a tour de force.
Characters (15%)4Colton is vivid; Goodreads readers find Justin and Wes frustrating.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Emotional prose, though StoryGraph and Goodreads readers note long, repetitive passages.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5Loneliness and recovery hit hard; readers call it cathartic.
Heat level (10%)4Explicit, heated scenes that pay off the long tension.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A warm HEA and epilogue after a breakup many readers dislike.
Reread appeal (10%)4High ratings and fond reader reviews suggest strong reread appeal.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Quarterback is the stronger of Tal Bauer's two The Team books, according to many readers and to us, and earns a final Eikna Score of 8.2/10.

The Team Reading Order

The Quarterback is book 2 of Tal Bauer's two-book The Team series. It follows a new couple, so it can be read alone, but Wes and Justin from The Jock play a big part in the conflict and their history makes it easier to follow.

  1. The Jock (2021): Wes and Justin
  2. The Quarterback (2021): Colton Hall and Nick Swanscott

Best start: The Jock, then The Quarterback, though plenty of readers start here. Best format: ebook or print, since the long interior passages are easier to pace yourself through on the page. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved The Quarterback, Read These Next

If you loved The Quarterback, the closest matches are MM romances with an age gap, a late awakening or an athlete whose career is on the line.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Quarterback raises the same questions for most readers: how spicy it is, how big the age gap is, whether it stands alone and how it ends. Short answers below.

Is The Quarterback spicy?

Yes. The Quarterback is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: a slow burn first half, then several explicit, consensual open-door scenes.

How old are Colton and Nick in The Quarterback?

Reviewers put Colton at 22 and Nick at 43, an age gap of about twenty years. Both are adults throughout.

Do I need to read The Jock before The Quarterback?

No, but it helps. The Quarterback follows a new couple, yet Wes and Justin from The Jock are central to its conflict.

Does The Quarterback have a happy ending?

Yes. After a third act breakup with no cheating, Colton and Nick get an HEA and an epilogue.

Who is Nick in The Quarterback?

Nick Swanscott is Justin's father. Justin is dating Wes, Colton's best friend, so Nick is part of Colton's close circle.

Is there a The Quarterback audiobook?

Yes. An audiobook edition is available, running about 11 hours 21 minutes.

The Bottom Line

The Quarterback earns a 8.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a long, tender MM slow burn about an injured athlete and the older man who takes care of him, with real heat once it gets there. The one reason to pick it up is the friendship: Tal Bauer makes two lonely men finding each other feel both inevitable and earned.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.