Conventionally Yours by Annabeth Albert Review
Eikna Score: 7.5/10. Recommended.
Conventionally Yours is a sweet, slow MM rivals to lovers road trip about two card-game players driving to Las Vegas together, and Alden, a neurodivergent hero, is one of the most lovingly written leads in Annabeth Albert's catalogue. The middle of the drive drags and the heat is low, but the tenderness between Conrad and Alden is the real thing.
Read it if you want a gentle new adult romance with geek culture, one bed on a road trip and two leads who learn to be honest with each other. Skip it if you want Albert's usual heat, or a tight pace from the first mile to the final round.
Conventionally Yours at a Glance
Conventionally Yours is book 1 of Annabeth Albert's True Colors series, an MM new adult romance published by Sourcebooks Casablanca on June 2, 2020. Rival gamers Conrad Stewart and Alden Roth, both in their early twenties, share a cross-country drive to a Las Vegas tournament. It runs 400 pages, keeps the heat mild and ends with a happily ever after.
| Author | Annabeth Albert |
|---|---|
| Series | True Colors, book 1 (a complete couple; works as a standalone) |
| Subgenre | MM romance, new adult contemporary |
| Main tropes | Rivals to lovers, road trip, one bed, forced proximity, slow burn |
| Spice level | 2/5: Mild, fade to black |
| Content warnings | Family rejection for being gay, financial hardship, ableist assumptions (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, alternating Conrad and Alden |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 400 (trade paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Kirt Graves and Joel Froomkin, 10 hours 43 minutes (Dreamscape Media) |
| First published | June 2, 2020 |
| Publisher | Sourcebooks Casablanca |
What Is Conventionally Yours About?
Conventionally Yours follows two members of the same gaming group who cannot stand each other. Conrad Stewart is charming, chaotic and broke, cut off by his family for being gay and desperate for prize money to finish college. Alden Roth is serious, guarded and neurodivergent, and still adrift after medical school turned him down.
Both play Odyssey, a fictional collectible card game, and both have a shot at a big tournament in Las Vegas. Conrad cannot afford to fly and Alden does not fly, so the group plans a road trip. Then an accident and a family emergency thin the car out, and the two rivals are left to drive across the country together, with a lot of motel rooms and one very small bed ahead.
What Makes This Rivals to Lovers Romance Work
Conventionally Yours works because the rivalry is about something both men care about. Odyssey is not a backdrop; it is how Conrad and Alden understand themselves, and Publishers Weekly found the game descriptions inventive and fun. Losing to each other matters, which makes the slow switch from opponents to teammates satisfying.
The road trip does the rest. A car and a string of hotel rooms are classic forced proximity, and Albert uses them to make two very different people listen to each other. Kirkus called the romance sweet and slow and compared it favorably to Red, White & Royal Blue.
It is also Albert at her gentlest. Readers who know her from hotter series like the one that includes On the Edge should expect something closer to the new adult end of the shelf.
My Review
Conventionally Yours won me over through Alden. He is literal, anxious, precise and kind, and Albert writes his way of seeing the world with real care instead of turning it into a quirk. Conrad took longer. By the time the two of them were arguing about deck strategy in a motel in the middle of nowhere, I was completely on their side, but getting there took more miles than it needed to.
Romance and Chemistry
The romance is a soft one. There is no big blow-up between the leads, just two people who start out sure they know each other and slowly find out they do not. Caz Owens at All About Romance singled out Conrad's acceptance of Alden's neurodivergence as especially moving, and that is the emotional core: Conrad learns how Alden works and simply adjusts, without fuss.
What I liked most is the honesty. Once they start talking, Conrad and Alden tell each other what they want and what scares them, and the book does not invent a misunderstanding to keep them apart. Caz found the romance low-key despite being front and center, and I can see why. If you want sparks, this is a candle.
The Characters
Alden is the standout. He is Jewish, gay and neurodivergent, and the book treats all three as part of him rather than the plot. Conrad's story is harder: a family that has cut him off, money problems that never go away, and a habit of performing confidence he does not feel. Erin at The Smut Report noted a late self-worth obstacle for Conrad, and it is earned by everything before it.
The side cast includes Payton, a non-binary member of the gaming group, and the broader friend set gives the trip some texture. Both Caz and Cannonball Read's reviewer felt the leads sometimes read younger than their early twenties, and I agree. The book sits right on the line between YA and adult, which Kirkus meant as a compliment when it called it a great bridge between the two.
Writing and Pacing
The chapters alternate between Conrad and Alden, and the dual POV earns its keep because the two men see the same events so differently. The tournament scenes are genuinely exciting, which surprised me for a game I have never played.
The problem is the middle. Publishers Weekly found the setup overlong, Caz said the pacing drags, and Library Journal called the book slightly overstuffed with scenery and minor characters. The road trip has a few too many stops. The final convention act tightens everything up again, and the ending is neat in a way I found comforting rather than cheap.
Conventionally Yours is a kind, slow-burning MM road trip romance with a lovely neurodivergent hero and a middle that wanders. Read it if you want tenderness and geek culture over heat; skip it if you came for classic Albert steam.
How Spicy Is Conventionally Yours?
Conventionally Yours is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. There is kissing and building attraction across the trip, and one sex scene about two thirds of the way through that Cannonball Read's reviewer described as not terribly graphic. All About Romance called the sex fade to black, and Publishers Weekly called the book relatively chaste.
Both leads are adults in their early twenties, and the intimacy is mutual, careful and talked through. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from critic and reader reports and our own read:
- Family rejection and disownment for being gay
- Financial insecurity and pressure to pay for college
- Social isolation and anxiety
- Other characters' assumptions about neurodivergence, which some readers found uncomfortable
- A car accident and a family emergency (no lasting harm to the leads)
- Mild sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Conventionally Yours?
Conventionally Yours suits readers who want a gentle MM new adult romance with geek culture, a road trip and a neurodivergent hero written with care. It is less suited to readers who want high heat, a fast pace or the more adult tone of Annabeth Albert's other series.
Best for:
- Readers who love gaming, cons and fandom settings
- Fans of road trips, one bed and slow-building rivals to lovers
- Readers looking for neurodivergent and Jewish MM representation
- Anyone wanting a crossover read between YA and adult romance
Not for:
- Readers who want explicit heat (try our spicy picks)
- Anyone impatient with a slow middle
- Readers expecting the tone of Albert's adult series
- Readers who need high angst or big conflict
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Conventionally Yours got unusually broad trade coverage for an MM new adult romance, with reviews from Kirkus, Publishers Weekly and Library Journal, plus All About Romance and a range of reader blogs.
Where they agree. The characters and the warmth. Kirkus praised the careful characterization and tight pacing, Library Journal called it a captivating, nerdy romance with a satisfying happily ever after, and Love Bytes' Valerie gave it 4.5 hearts. Carole V. Bell called it a sweet and tender slow burn.
Where they split. Pacing and tone. Publishers Weekly found the setup overlong and the competition drama somewhat contrived, Caz Owens at All About Romance gave only a qualified recommendation because the middle drags and the leads read young, and Cannonball Read's reviewer gave it 3 stars, finding the voices not very distinct and the ending a bit too neat.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Conventionally Yours scores 7.5 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for romance, characters and emotional impact, and lower marks for a slow middle and modest heat.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Sweet and slow, per Kirkus, with honest communication between the leads. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Alden is a standout; All About Romance found the leads young for their ages. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Exciting tournament scenes; PW found the setup overlong. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Conrad's family wounds and Alden's acceptance land, per All About Romance. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Delivers the mild, careful intimacy it promises. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A satisfying HEA per Library Journal, if a bit neat for Cannonball Read. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Comforting to revisit, though the middle stretch is easy to skim. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Conventionally Yours is one of the gentlest books in Annabeth Albert's backlist and a warm start to the True Colors series, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.5/10.
True Colors Reading Order
Conventionally Yours is book 1 of Annabeth Albert's True Colors series. Each book follows a different couple connected to the world of Odyssey, the fictional card game, so you can read either on its own, but starting here sets up the game and the convention scene.
- Book 1: Conventionally Yours (2020): Conrad and Alden
- Book 2: Out of Character (2021): Milo and Jasper
Out of Character follows Milo, a closeted jock, and Jasper, his estranged childhood best friend, through cosplay and an Odyssey tournament. Best format: the Dreamscape audiobook, with Kirt Graves and Joel Froomkin voicing the two leads, suits the alternating chapters well. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved Conventionally Yours, Read These Next
If you loved Conventionally Yours, look for MM romances with rivals, forced proximity and two people learning each other slowly.
- Red, White & Royal Blue by Casey McQuiston: the rivals to lovers book Kirkus compared it to, with more politics and more heat.
- The Charm Offensive by Alison Cochrun: a tender romance with an anxious, neurodivergent hero and a patient love interest.
- On the Edge by Annabeth Albert: Albert in her more adult, hotter mode, with hurt and comfort in a small town.
- The Hate Project by Kris Ripper: frenemies, a found family of friends and a frank, kind portrait of anxiety.
- The Dating Experiment by Briar Prescott: two men who clash in person and connect through an online word game.
Frequently Asked Questions
Conventionally Yours prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it is YA, how it ends and what to read next in the series. Short answers below.
Is Conventionally Yours spicy?
Not very. Conventionally Yours is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with one brief, not very graphic sex scene and a lot of slow-building attraction.
Is Conventionally Yours YA?
No. It is a new adult romance with leads in their early twenties, though Kirkus and Publishers Weekly both noted its crossover appeal for older YA readers.
Does Conventionally Yours have a happy ending?
Yes. Library Journal confirms a satisfying happily ever after for Conrad and Alden.
Is Conventionally Yours a standalone?
Yes. It is book 1 of the True Colors series, but Conrad and Alden's story is complete in this book.
What comes after Conventionally Yours?
Out of Character, book 2 of True Colors, follows Milo and Jasper in the same Odyssey gaming world.
Is there a Conventionally Yours audiobook?
Yes. Dreamscape Media published it narrated by Kirt Graves and Joel Froomkin, running 10 hours 43 minutes.
Is there one bed in Conventionally Yours?
Yes. The road trip includes a hotel room with a single bed, and Love Bytes tags the book for a shared hotel room.
The Bottom Line
Conventionally Yours earns a 7.5/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a soft, slow MM rivals to lovers road trip with gaming, found friends and a neurodivergent hero written with real tenderness, and who are happy with low heat and a meandering middle. The reason to pick it up is Alden, and the way Conrad learns to love him exactly as he is.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Conventionally Yours, Kirkus Reviews
- Conventionally Yours, Publishers Weekly
- Conventionally Yours, Library Journal
- Conventionally Yours, All About Romance (Caz Owens)
- Conventionally Yours, Cannonball Read (coffeeshopreader)
- Review: Conventionally Yours, Carole V. Bell
- Release day review: Conventionally Yours, Love Bytes (Valerie)
- Conventionally Yours audiobook, Libro.fm (narrators, length)
- True Colors series, Audible
- Out of Character, Publishers Weekly
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.