How to Excavate a Heart by Jake Maia Arlow Review
Eikna Score: 7.8/10. Recommended.
How to Excavate a Heart is a funny, sharp-tongued sapphic holiday rom com about two Jewish college freshmen who keep crashing into each other in a snowy Washington, D.C. Shani's voice is the star, and the book handles a painful past with real care, though the late reveal and some prickly behavior will not suit every reader.
Read it if you want a young adult queer holiday romance with banter, fossils, a corgi and Jewish leads, or you love a narrator with a running commentary. Skip it if abrasive teenage characters wear on you, or you would be blindsided by a past sexual assault surfacing late in the story.
How to Excavate a Heart at a Glance
How to Excavate a Heart is a standalone young adult sapphic rom com by Jake Maia Arlow, published by HarperTeen on November 1, 2022, for readers 14 and up. Narrated in first person by college freshman Shani, it follows her winter internship at the Smithsonian and her run-ins with a girl named May, keeps the romance mild and ends on a hopeful, happy for now note.
| Author | Jake Maia Arlow |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | LGBTQ romance (young adult sapphic holiday rom com, Washington, D.C.) |
| Age range | Young adult, 14 and up (publisher); Kirkus 14 to 18; School Library Journal grade 9 and up |
| Main tropes | Enemies to lovers, meet-ugly, forced proximity in a snowstorm, holiday romance, coming out |
| Spice level | 2/5: Mild, fade to black |
| Content warnings | Past sexual assault (recounted), past controlling relationship, antisemitism, alcohol (full list below) |
| POV | First person, Shani |
| Ending | Happy for now, fitting for college freshmen |
| Pages | 384 (hardcover) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Hope Newhouse (HarperCollins) |
| First published | November 1, 2022 (paperback November 28, 2023) |
| Publisher | HarperTeen (HarperCollins) |
What Is How to Excavate a Heart About?
Shani Levine has just survived her first semester of college and a breakup with her first girlfriend days before winter break. Her plan is to spend the holidays alone in Washington, D.C., buried in a monthlong internship studying fossil fish at the Smithsonian, and as far as possible from her mom and her heartbreak.
Then she hits a girl named May with her mom's Subaru. Not hard, but hard enough. May keeps turning up, through a dog-walking job, a corgi and a snowstorm, and the two girls, who started out annoyed with each other, start to feel something else. Shani is not out to her mom, and she is carrying more from her last relationship than she has told anyone.
What Makes This Sapphic Holiday Rom Com Work
How to Excavate a Heart works because of Shani's voice. She is anxious, nerdy and very funny, narrating her disasters with a stream of asides about fish fossils and her own bad decisions. Booklist called the book hysterically funny and credited Shani's witty asides, and Publishers Weekly praised its dialogue-rich, sharply funny style.
The second hook is the setting and the leads' shared identity. Both girls are Jewish, the city is snowed in, and the holiday backdrop is not Christmas by default. Kirkus valued the leads' shared Ashkenazi Jewish heritage, and the Smithsonian internship gives the book a workplace full of eccentric adults, including Aunt Bea, the older lesbian mentor the Lesbrary called the wise lesbian we all wish we had.
Finally, the book is willing to be heavy. Under the banter is a story about leaving a controlling relationship, and Kirkus praised how sensitively it handles the sexual assault in Shani's past.
My Review
How to Excavate a Heart made me laugh out loud more than any YA romance I have read in a while, mostly at Shani's expense. It also caught me off guard in its last act. I think it is a very good book for older teens and a slightly uneven romance, and both things can be true.
Romance and Chemistry
Shani and May start badly, with a car bumper, and stay prickly for a while. The banter is quick, and the snowstorm and the corgi do their jobs, pushing two stubborn people into the same room. Leah's Books loved the enemies to lovers arc, and when it works, it really works: the girls tease each other in a way that reads like real flirting rather than scripted sparring.
The weaker part is the turn. Some StoryGraph readers felt the move from hostility to big declarations came too fast, and that May remains less developed than Shani. Seeing everything through Shani's eyes means May stays a little mysterious. The romance stays mild, at kissing and closeness, which suits a young adult book.
The Characters
Shani is a wonderfully specific narrator, defensive and self-deprecating and smarter than she gives herself credit for. Her fraught relationship with her mother, and her fear of coming out to her, gives the book a second emotional thread that is as important as the romance.
The supporting cast is the hidden pleasure. Aunt Bea, Shani's mentor at the museum, gets some of the best scenes, and Raphael the corgi steals several more; Leah's Books named him a favorite. Some readers did find both leads abrasive, and Shani's self-absorption is part of the point, so your patience with a college freshman acting like one will shape how much you enjoy her.
Writing and Pacing
Arlow's comic timing is excellent, and the science, Shani's love of ancient fish, is woven in with enthusiasm. A few readers found the paleontology sections skimmable; I found them charming, but they do slow the middle.
The structural choice that splits readers is the reveal of Shani's past assault by her ex-girlfriend, which comes late in the book. Kirkus found the handling compassionate, and The Queer Agenda noted that the survivor's experience is validated. Others felt the disclosure arrived too late and became a plot device for the climax. I thought it was handled with care, but readers who need warning should read the content notes below first.
How to Excavate a Heart is a laugh-out-loud sapphic holiday rom com with a great narrator, Jewish leads and a serious core handled with care. Hand it to older teens and adults who love YA; check the content notes before you do.
How Spicy Is How to Excavate a Heart?
How to Excavate a Heart is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. It is a young adult novel for readers 14 and up, and the romance between the two college freshmen stays at kissing and closeness, with nothing explicit on the page.
The past sexual assault is recounted, not shown, and is never presented as romantic. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from reviews, reader reports and our own read:
- Sexual assault in the narrator's past, recounted late in the book (off-page)
- A past controlling and emotionally abusive relationship
- Antisemitism
- Alcohol consumption
- An elderly relative hospitalized after a fall
- Fear of coming out to a parent
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read How to Excavate a Heart?
How to Excavate a Heart suits readers 14 and up, and adults who enjoy YA, who want a funny sapphic holiday romance with Jewish characters, a nerdy narrator and an emotional core about healing from a bad relationship. It is less suited to readers who dislike abrasive characters, or who would be distressed by a late disclosure of past sexual assault.
Best for:
- Older teens looking for queer, Jewish holiday romance
- Fans of enemies to lovers banter
- Readers who love a funny, self-deprecating first-person narrator
- Science nerds and museum lovers
- Librarians and teachers looking for a sapphic YA rom com for grade 9 and up
Not for:
- Readers who want a gentle, conflict-free holiday read
- Anyone who struggles with abrasive teenage characters
- Readers for whom a sexual assault disclosure is a hard limit
- Readers who want the holiday itself at the center of the plot
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
How to Excavate a Heart was well reviewed by trade outlets and queer book blogs. Kirkus praised the romance, the first-person voice and the sensitive handling of assault, Publishers Weekly called it cozy and sharply funny, Booklist called it hysterically funny, and School Library Journal recommended it for teen collections where romance is popular.
Where they agree. The humor and the voice. Almost every review mentions Shani's asides, and the Lesbrary called it sweet yet angsty, with an Aunt Bea every reader will love.
Where they split. The romance and the late reveal. Leah's Books and the Lesbrary were won over by the leads. Some StoryGraph readers found the romance rushed, May thin and the science skimmable, and some felt the assault disclosure came too late. The Queer Agenda suggested readers far from the college freshman experience may find the leads' immaturity harder to enjoy.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
How to Excavate a Heart scores 7.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with strong marks for writing, characters and emotional impact, and slightly lower scores for a romance that turns fast and a tentative ending.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Funny, real flirting per Leah's Books; the turn is fast per StoryGraph readers. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Shani and Aunt Bea shine per the Lesbrary; May is thinner. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Hysterically funny per Booklist; the science slows the middle for some. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Assault and recovery handled with compassion, per Kirkus. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers the mild, non-explicit romance its YA age range promises. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A hopeful, happy for now ending suited to freshmen, if tentative. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | The voice rewards a reread; the late reveal lands hardest once. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: How to Excavate a Heart sits among the funniest sapphic YA holiday romances, sharper and heavier than most, with a final Eikna Score of 7.8/10.
Is How to Excavate a Heart a Standalone?
Yes. How to Excavate a Heart is a standalone young adult novel with a complete story, so you can start here with no prior reading.
Best format: print or ebook lets you enjoy the jokes at your own pace; the audiobook, narrated by Hope Newhouse, is a good option for listeners who like a comic first-person voice. It reads best in December or January, when the snowstorm and the holiday break feel close. Our series order guide covers connected romances.
If You Loved How to Excavate a Heart, Read These Next
If you loved How to Excavate a Heart, the closest matches are young adult queer rom coms with banter and heart. The last two picks are adult sapphic holiday romances, for older readers only.
- Hani and Ishu's Guide to Fake Dating by Adiba Jaigirdar: YA, kisses only. A sapphic fake dating story with family and identity at its core.
- She Drives Me Crazy by Kelly Quindlen: YA, kisses only. Two rival girls stuck carpooling, with sharp banter.
- The Holiday Switch by Tif Marcelo: YA, kisses only. A clean holiday rivals story at a bookish inn.
- Season of Love by Helena Greer: adult, 2/5 spice. A Jewish heroine, a Christmas tree farm and a grieving grump; for adult readers.
- Kiss Her Once for Me by Alison Cochrun: adult, 4/5 spice. A sapphic Christmas fake engagement; for adult readers.
Frequently Asked Questions
How to Excavate a Heart prompts a few common questions: what age it suits, how spicy it is, how it ends and what the content warnings are. Short answers below.
What age is How to Excavate a Heart for?
The publisher lists it for ages 14 and up, Kirkus for 14 to 18 and School Library Journal for grade 9 and up. The leads are college freshmen.
Is How to Excavate a Heart spicy?
Only mildly. It is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with kissing and closeness and nothing explicit.
Is How to Excavate a Heart sapphic?
Yes. It is a romance between two young women, Shani and May, who are both Jewish.
Does How to Excavate a Heart have a happy ending?
Yes, a hopeful one. It ends happy for now, which suits two college freshmen at the start of a relationship.
What are the content warnings for How to Excavate a Heart?
The main one is a past sexual assault by the narrator's ex-girlfriend, recounted late in the book. There is also a past controlling relationship, antisemitism and alcohol use.
Is How to Excavate a Heart a Christmas book?
It is a winter holiday book set over winter break in a snowy Washington, D.C., with two Jewish leads, so Christmas is background rather than the focus.
Is there a How to Excavate a Heart audiobook?
Yes. The audiobook is narrated by Hope Newhouse.
The Bottom Line
How to Excavate a Heart earns a 7.8/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers 14 and up, and adults who love YA, who want a sapphic winter rom com with Jewish leads, a corgi, a snowstorm and a narrator who never stops talking. The reason to pick it up is Shani: anxious, hilarious and braver than she knows, digging her way out of a bad year one fossil at a time.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- How to Excavate a Heart, Kirkus Reviews
- How to Excavate a Heart, Barnes and Noble (editorial reviews from Publishers Weekly, Booklist and SLJ)
- How to Excavate a Heart, School Library Journal
- Nat reviews How to Excavate a Heart, the Lesbrary
- How to Excavate a Heart, Leah's Books
- How to Excavate a Heart, The Queer Agenda (Shohreh Davoodi)
- How to Excavate a Heart, Cannonball Read
- How to Excavate a Heart, Trigger Warning Database
- StoryGraph reader reviews tagging sexual violence
- How to Excavate a Heart hardcover listing (ISBN 9780063078727)
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.