eikna romance
Menu

Season of Love by Helena Greer Review

Eikna Score: 7.8/10. Recommended.

Season of Love is a sapphic Christmas romance with more grief and trauma under the tinsel than its cover suggests, and it is better for it. Miriam and Noelle's slow pull toward each other is full of pining and believable obstacles, though the opening drags and the door closes just when the tension peaks.

Read it if you want a queer holiday romance with emotional weight, a Jewish family running a ridiculous Christmas tree farm and a fat butch heroine. Skip it if you want a light, fluffy December read, or you were hoping the long sexual tension would pay off on the page.

Season of Love by Helena Greer book cover

Season of Love at a Glance

Season of Love is Helena Greer's debut and book 1 of her Carrigan's Christmasland series, a sapphic contemporary holiday romance published by Forever on October 11, 2022. It follows a woman who inherits part of her family's Christmas tree farm in the Adirondacks and the grieving, sober manager who runs it, with dual POV, fade to black heat and a happily ever after.

AuthorHelena Greer
SeriesCarrigan's Christmasland, book 1 (a complete couple story)
SubgenreLGBTQ romance (sapphic small-town holiday romance, Adirondacks)
Main tropesGrumpy sunshine, inheritance plot, found family, return to hometown, slow burn pining
Spice level2/5: Mild, fade to black
Content warningsDeath of a relative, grief, alcoholism and sobriety, family abuse in backstory (full list below)
POVDual, Miriam and Noelle
EndingHEA
Pages384 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Barrie Kreinik and Emily Lawrence, about 9 hours 45 minutes (Hachette Audio)
First publishedOctober 11, 2022
PublisherForever (Hachette Book Group)

What Is Season of Love About?

Miriam Blum left her family's Christmas tree farm, Carrigan's Christmasland, years ago and built a life in the city. When the great-aunt she loved dies and leaves her a share of the business, she has to go back to the small Adirondack town and the relatives she has spent years avoiding.

Running the farm day to day is Noelle Northwood, a sober, grieving and deeply unfestive woman who is not pleased to see an absentee heir arrive. The business is in trouble, the holidays are coming, and Miriam and Noelle have to work together to save the place, whatever they feel about each other.

What Makes This Sapphic Holiday Romance Work

Season of Love works because it lets its holiday romance be about something heavy. The Lesbrary's Danika Ellis called it a story about grief, trauma and the damage that comes with it, and the Christmas trimmings sit on top of real wounds: a death in the family, an abusive past, a hard-won sobriety.

The setting is the second hook. A Jewish family running an over-the-top Christmas tree farm is a gloriously specific idea, and Kirkus, reviewing the audiobook, liked the range of religious holiday detail. The farm, the town and the eccentric relatives give the book a found family warmth that balances the sadder material.

Finally, there is the representation. The Lesbrary pointed out how rarely sapphic romance centers a fat butch woman as a romantic lead, and Noelle is written as desirable without the book making a lesson of it.

My Review

I came to Season of Love for the Christmas tree farm and stayed for the grief. It is a holiday romance that knows people come home for the holidays carrying things, and it takes those things seriously. It is not a perfect book, but it is a sincere one.

Romance and Chemistry

Miriam and Noelle start from mutual suspicion. Noelle sees a city heir who abandoned the farm; Miriam sees a gatekeeper with a chip on her shoulder. The shift from friction to longing is slow and full of pining, and the Lesbrary praised the chemistry and the way the obstacles grow out of each woman's trauma rather than out of contrived misunderstandings.

My reservation is the turn itself. Noelle moves from hostility to devotion faster than the slow opening led me to expect, and a StoryGraph reviewer made the same complaint. Then, after all that tension, the book fades to black. Danika Ellis called the closed-door payoff a minor disappointment given the build-up, and I felt it too.

The Characters

Miriam is the book's real arc. She has to face a family history that hurt her, and Kirkus's print review found her personal growth the strongest element, at times outshining the romance. That is true, and I did not mind. Her healing is what makes the romance believable.

Noelle is a terrific grump with reasons. Her sobriety and grief are handled with care, never as quirks. The supporting cast of relatives and townspeople is lively, though some readers wanted more depth for the secondary characters' grief, which the book raises and then moves past.

Writing and Pacing

Greer's prose is warm and observant, and the farm feels like a real, slightly chaotic workplace. The opening is slow, though. Kirkus noted the sluggish start, and it takes a while for the business plot and the romance to pick up speed.

The business crisis also resolves more easily than it should; the StoryGraph reviewer felt the same. The audiobook is a good way to ride through the slow patches. Kirkus credited Barrie Kreinik and Emily Lawrence with conveying the characters' trauma and longing for acceptance.

Season of Love is a tender, grief-aware sapphic Christmas romance with a memorable setting and a lovely grump, held back by a slow start and a closed door that arrives too soon. Read it if you want your holiday romance with some weight; skip it if you want pure fluff or open-door heat.

How Spicy Is Season of Love?

Season of Love is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. There is plenty of attraction, kissing and sexual tension, but when the relationship becomes physical, the scene closes. The Lesbrary tagged it closed door and fade to black.

Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reviews, reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Season of Love?

Season of Love suits readers who want a sapphic holiday romance with emotional depth, a Jewish family at the center of a Christmas setting and a slow grumpy sunshine dynamic. It is less suited to readers who want a light rom com, a fast start or open-door heat.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Season of Love was warmly received. Kirkus praised the cozy Adirondack setting and the characters, the Lesbrary's Danika Ellis highly recommended it, and Kirkus's audiobook review called it a unique holiday story. The reservations are about pacing and the closed door.

Where they agree. The emotional depth and the setting. Reviewers consistently mention the grief and trauma under the holiday surface and the delight of a Jewish-run Christmas tree farm.

Where they split. Pacing and payoff. Kirkus found the start slow and felt Miriam's growth sometimes overshadowed the romance. The Lesbrary wished the long tension had ended on the page. A StoryGraph reviewer found Noelle's change of heart abrupt and the business crisis too easily solved.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Season of Love scores 7.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for emotional impact, romance and characters, and lower scores for a slow opening and a heat level some readers found anticlimactic.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Strong chemistry and organic obstacles per the Lesbrary; Noelle's turn is abrupt per StoryGraph.
Characters (15%)4Miriam's growth is the standout per Kirkus; Noelle is a well-drawn grump.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Warm prose; a slow start per Kirkus.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5Grief, trauma and sobriety handled with real care, per the Lesbrary.
Heat level (10%)3.5Fade to black after long tension, a letdown for the Lesbrary.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A warm HEA, though the business crisis resolves easily.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A cozy December reread once you know the slow start is worth it.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Season of Love sits among the better sapphic holiday romances of recent years, deeper than most and a good launch for the Carrigan's Christmasland series, with a final Eikna Score of 7.8/10.

Carrigan's Christmasland Reading Order

Season of Love is book 1 of Helena Greer's Carrigan's Christmasland series, and Miriam and Noelle's story is complete in this volume. Later books follow other characters connected to the farm, so start here.

  1. Season of Love (2022): Miriam and Noelle
  2. For Never & Always (2023)
  3. Hers for the Weekend (2024)

Best format: the dual-narrator audiobook, with Barrie Kreinik and Emily Lawrence, matches the alternating POV well. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved Season of Love, Read These Next

If you loved Season of Love, look for queer holiday romances with found family, real feelings and a cozy setting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Season of Love raises a few common questions: how spicy it is, whether it is part of a series, how it ends and what content to expect. Short answers below.

Is Season of Love spicy?

Mildly. Season of Love is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with lots of tension and kissing but a fade to black when things turn physical.

Is Season of Love part of a series?

Yes. It is book 1 of Helena Greer's Carrigan's Christmasland series, followed by For Never & Always and Hers for the Weekend, but it works as a standalone.

Does Season of Love have a happy ending?

Yes. Miriam and Noelle get a happily ever after.

Is Season of Love sapphic?

Yes. It is a romance between two women, Miriam Blum and Noelle Northwood, told from both of their points of view.

What are the content warnings for Season of Love?

Expect the death of a relative and grief, alcoholism and sobriety, and an abusive family history.

Is there a Season of Love audiobook?

Yes. Hachette Audio's version is narrated by Barrie Kreinik and Emily Lawrence and runs about 9 hours 45 minutes.

The Bottom Line

Season of Love earns a 7.8/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a sapphic Christmas romance that makes room for grief, sobriety and family damage alongside the twinkle lights, and who do not mind a closed door. The reason to pick it up is Noelle: a grieving, sober, fat butch grump who gets to be the romantic lead and is loved exactly as she is.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.