eikna romance
Menu

Irresponsible Puckboy by Eden Finley and Saxon James Review

Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.

Irresponsible Puckboy is loud, silly and very sweet: a pining hockey player, his golden retriever of a best friend and a marriage plan so bad it loops back round to romantic. Dex's cluelessness crosses into thoughtless more than once, and Tripp deserves more page time than he gets, but the chemistry and the comedy carry it.

Read it if you love himbo heroes, bi awakenings and best friends who are already basically married. Skip it if an oblivious hero who ignores boundaries is a dealbreaker, or you want actual hockey on most pages.

Irresponsible Puckboy by Eden Finley and Saxon James book cover

Irresponsible Puckboy at a Glance

Irresponsible Puckboy is book 2 of Eden Finley and Saxon James's Puckboys series, an MM hockey romance first published on May 11, 2022. Tripp has loved his straight best friend and teammate Dex for years; Dex has a terrible idea about marriage. It has steamy heat, dual POV and a happily ever after, and Canelo Romance is reissuing it in paperback.

AuthorEden Finley and Saxon James
SeriesPuckboys, book 2 (a new couple; works as a standalone)
SubgenreSports romance (professional hockey), MM romance
Main tropesBest friends to lovers, bisexual awakening, accidental marriage, oblivious hero, pining
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsUnrequited love, alcohol, homophobia and biphobia, boundary-crossing behaviour (full list below)
POVDual POV, Tripp and Dex
EndingHEA
Pages280 (original ebook); 304 (Canelo Romance paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Iggy Toma (Tripp) and Alexander Cendese (Dex), 7 hours 5 minutes (Absolute Books, 2022)
First publishedMay 11, 2022
PublisherOriginally independent; reissued by Canelo Romance (UK paperback March 2026, US paperback December 1, 2026)

What Is Irresponsible Puckboy About?

Irresponsible Puckboy belongs to Tripp, who has spent years in love with his best friend and Las Vegas teammate Dex. Dex is straight, cheerful and completely unaware. Tripp has decided the only cure is distance.

Then Dex's latest relationship falls apart, he turns up looking for comfort, and Tripp caves. Dex has been told by a string of exes that he is irresponsible and scared of commitment, so he comes up with a solution: test out marriage with the one person he trusts. The plan is a public relations headache for team management and a private disaster for Tripp, and somewhere in the fallout Dex starts to notice what everyone else already has.

What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work

Irresponsible Puckboy works because Dex is impossible to dislike for long. Heather at NotGuiltyofBooks called the pair "an absolute mess, in the most hilarious and adorable way," and a StoryGraph reader, galleytrot, described Dex as an endlessly positive golden retriever of a himbo. He is wrong about almost everything and loves Tripp with his whole chest.

The second hook is the setup. A marriage stunt between best friends gives the book its comedy and its stakes: the press gets involved, management gets involved, and the friendship that both men lean on is suddenly public property.

The third is the Puckboys world. Larissa at Love Bytes Reviews singled out the Queer Collective, the group of LGBTQ players who look out for each other across the league, and their meddling is a big part of the fun. If you like friends to lovers with a found family cheering section, this is that.

My Review

I went into Irresponsible Puckboy fresh off Egotistical Puckboy and expecting more of the same. It is a different animal. Book 1 runs on antagonism; this one runs on pining and nonsense, and Dex is the kind of hero you either adopt on the spot or want to throw across the room. I adopted him, with reservations, and I laughed a lot.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is easy because the intimacy is already there. Tripp and Dex live in each other's pockets, finish each other's jokes and share a level of physical comfort that would raise eyebrows on any team. The book's best trick is letting Dex discover that the thing he has been looking for in girlfriends was in the next room all along.

The weaker part is the emotional honesty. Larissa at Love Bytes Reviews gave the audiobook 4.5 hearts but found the personal resolution a little anticlimactic, and Melanie at Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words felt communication gaps opened up after the marriage, just as Dex is working out that he is not as straight as he thought. I agree that the big conversation arrives late. When it does arrive, it is sweet.

The Characters

Dex is the star and the problem. He is funny, kind, endlessly enthusiastic and, at times, careless with the man who loves him. Melanie found him hard to root for and singled out one scene where he lets himself into Tripp's place and ends up in bed with Tripp and a man Tripp had hooked up with. It is played partly for comedy and it did not sit right with me either. A StoryGraph reader, kayetaz, reviewing Just Friends, called Dex more toxic than that book's hero, which is a fair warning for anyone sensitive to boundary issues.

Tripp gets less of the spotlight than he deserves. Melanie thought he was the better developed of the two and that his long held feelings were painful to read; galleytrot felt he was along for the ride. I sit between them. His pining is real and specific, but the story happens to him more than through him.

The supporting cast is the other draw. Faces from Egotistical Puckboy and the authors' other books turn up, the Queer Collective meddles constantly, and galleytrot found the cross series cameos a bit much. Larissa noted the friends' interference sometimes stretched belief. I enjoyed it, but I have read these authors before.

Writing and Pacing

Finley and James write fast, jokey prose with a lot of bickering, and the dual POV keeps the momentum up. Larissa called the book funny, irreverent and sexy, and that is the right order of priorities. The running jokes about Dex being the dumb one wear thin by the end, which Larissa noticed too.

Do not expect much hockey. galleytrot pointed out that most of the book takes place in the off-season, with little ice time until the final act. The marriage fallout, on the other hand, is handled well: Melanie found the press and management reactions believable, and they give the middle some real weight.

Irresponsible Puckboy is a chaotic, warm best friends to lovers romance with a lovable, frustrating hero and plenty of heat. Read it if you want a himbo and a bi awakening; skip it if you need a partner who respects boundaries from page one.

How Spicy Is Irresponsible Puckboy?

Irresponsible Puckboy is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Once Dex catches up with his feelings, the book has several open door scenes, and the Canelo Romance edition is sold as a steamy hockey romance. The heat is playful and curious, built around Dex discovering what he likes.

Consent between the leads is clear once they are together. The earlier scene where Dex barges in on Tripp and another man is the moment most likely to bother readers, and it is worth knowing about going in. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reviews and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Irresponsible Puckboy?

Irresponsible Puckboy suits readers who want a funny, steamy MM hockey romance with best friends to lovers, a bi awakening and a fake marriage gone wrong. It is less suited to readers who need an emotionally aware hero, a lot of on-ice action or a quiet, low drama read.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Irresponsible Puckboy is one of the most read books in the Puckboys series, with a Goodreads average of about 4.0 from close to 28,000 ratings. Coverage is mostly MM review blogs and reader reviews, and almost everyone loves Dex or argues about him.

Where they agree. The humour and the energy. Larissa at Love Bytes Reviews gave the audiobook 4.5 hearts and wrote that "Dex's character is so sweet you want to hug him." Heather at NotGuiltyofBooks gave it five stars and called the narration perfect for the roles. Melanie at Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words, the most critical voice, still praised Tripp's development and called the ending a sweet HEA.

Where they split. Dex. Melanie gave it four out of five but found him oblivious, unreflective and less developed than Tripp, and liked the couple less than book 1's Ezra and Anton. galleytrot on StoryGraph adored him and felt Tripp was the thinner character. Readers also disagree on the cameos, which some find warm and others find tiring.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Irresponsible Puckboy scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with strong marks for chemistry, heat, a satisfying ending and reread appeal, and lower marks for a hero whose obliviousness can tip into thoughtlessness.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Lived-in intimacy and real pining; the big honest conversation comes late, per Love Bytes Reviews.
Characters (15%)3.5Dex is lovable but careless; Tripp is underused, per Scattered Thoughts and StoryGraph readers.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Quick, funny dual POV; the dumb-jock jokes wear thin.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Tripp's pining hurts in a good way; the payoff is softer than the setup.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the steamy, playful heat the series promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A sweet HEA, per Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words.
Reread appeal (10%)4A comfort reread for Puckboys fans, especially on audio.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Irresponsible Puckboy is one of the funniest entries in the Puckboys series, a step softer than Egotistical Puckboy, with a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.

Puckboys Reading Order

Irresponsible Puckboy is book 2 of Eden Finley and Saxon James's Puckboys series. Each book follows a new couple, so it works on its own, but the friend group carries over and the cameos land better if you have read book 1.

  1. Egotistical Puckboy (2022): Ezra and Anton
  2. Irresponsible Puckboy (2022): Tripp and Dex
  3. Shameless Puckboy (2022): Oskar and Lane
  4. Foolish Puckboy (2023): Aleks and Gabe
  5. Clueless Puckboy (2023): Quinn and Vance
  6. Bromantic Puckboy (2024): Cody and Miles
  7. Forbidden Puckboy (2024): Easton and Knox
  8. Possessive Puckboy (2025): Connor and Parker
  9. Stubborn Puckboy (2025): Colby and Radimir
  10. Charming Puckboy (2026)

Start with Egotistical Puckboy if you can. The authors also write the CU Hockey college series, which begins with Power Plays & Straight A's, and you do not need it first. Best format: the dual narrated audiobook by Iggy Toma and Alexander Cendese, which Heather at NotGuiltyofBooks thought was perfectly cast. Our series order guide covers more romance series.

If You Loved Irresponsible Puckboy, Read These Next

If you loved Irresponsible Puckboy, look for MM sports romances with best friends, bi awakenings and plenty of heat, starting with the rest of the series.

Frequently Asked Questions

Irresponsible Puckboy prompts the same questions from most new readers: how spicy it is, whether you need book 1, how it ends and what order the series goes in. Short answers below.

Is Irresponsible Puckboy spicy?

Yes. Irresponsible Puckboy is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit scenes once Dex and Tripp get together.

Do I need to read Egotistical Puckboy first?

No. Irresponsible Puckboy follows a new couple and stands alone, but book 1 introduces the friend group and makes the cameos more fun.

Does Irresponsible Puckboy have a happy ending?

Yes. Tripp and Dex get a happily ever after, and no cliffhanger.

Is Irresponsible Puckboy a fake marriage romance?

Partly. Dex decides to test out marriage with his best friend, and the stunt becomes a PR problem that drives the plot.

Is there an Irresponsible Puckboy audiobook?

Yes. It is narrated by Iggy Toma and Alexander Cendese and runs about 7 hours 5 minutes.

What order should I read the Puckboys series in?

Start with Egotistical Puckboy, then Irresponsible Puckboy, Shameless Puckboy, Foolish Puckboy, Clueless Puckboy, Bromantic Puckboy, Forbidden Puckboy, Possessive Puckboy, Stubborn Puckboy and Charming Puckboy.

The Bottom Line

Irresponsible Puckboy earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a loud, steamy MM hockey romance with a himbo hero, a pining best friend and a marriage stunt that goes sideways, and who can forgive Dex for being Dex. The reason to pick it up is the comedy: few books in the genre are this willing to be ridiculous and still land the feelings.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.