eikna romance
Menu

Just Friends by Saxon James Review

Eikna Score: 7.4/10. Recommended.

Just Friends is a soft, warm best friends to lovers story that gets the friendship exactly right: Roo and Tanner have the shorthand of two people who grew up in each other's pockets. The romance takes the long way round, and Tanner's obliviousness tests your patience, but the payoff is sweet and the bisexual awakening is handled with real kindness.

Read it if you want low angst MM friends to lovers with a bi awakening, or a homecoming romance where the history does half the work. Skip it if an oblivious love interest drives you up the wall, or you need a tight plot instead of a slow, circling one.

Just Friends by Saxon James book cover

Just Friends at a Glance

Just Friends is Saxon James's 2020 MM contemporary romance and book 1 of the Never Just Friends series, first published by May Books on August 21, 2020. Roo comes home to Sunbury, Oregon after five years in Australia and falls for his best friend Tanner all over again. It has moderate heat and a happy ending.

AuthorSaxon James
SeriesNever Just Friends, book 1 (connected standalones, a new couple in each)
SubgenreMM romance, contemporary small town
Main tropesBest friends to lovers, bisexual awakening, oblivious friend, one bed, homecoming
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsEpilepsy and seizures, past brain surgery, school bullying, a controlling parent, learning disability struggles (full list below)
POVDual POV, Roo and Tanner
EndingHEA
Pages293 (Kindle edition listing)
AudiobookNarrated by Alexander Cendese (Tanner) and Kirt Graves (Roo), 7 hours 17 minutes (Tantor Audio, 2021)
First publishedAugust 21, 2020
PublisherMay Books (independent)

What Is Just Friends About?

Just Friends opens with Roo coming home. Five years ago he left the small town of Sunbury, Oregon, for epilepsy surgery in Australia, and left his best friend Tanner behind. Now he is back with a plan: tell Tanner how he has always felt, get the closure he needs, and leave for good.

The plan does not survive contact with Tanner. Tanner never stopped missing Roo and has no intention of losing him a second time, even if he has not yet worked out why the thought of Roo leaving hurts so much. What follows is a slow, sometimes clumsy shift from best friends to something else, with one shared bed, a lot of small town noise and a surprising number of kangaroo jokes.

What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work

Just Friends works because the friendship comes first and stays first. Roo and Tanner have years of history: school bullies, hospital worries, private jokes. When the book turns romantic, it feels like an extension of that bond rather than a replacement for it. Love Bytes Reviews' Valerie called the bond between them intense and tender, and that is the right word order.

The second hook is Tanner's bisexual awakening. He questions things out loud and talks to Roo about them, which takes a lot of the sting out of a trope that can turn painful. Nobody is cruel about it, least of all Tanner.

And it is gentle. Tension comes from two men who will not say the obvious thing, not from villains or a big misunderstanding. If you want friends to lovers that feels like a weighted blanket, this is a good one to reach for.

My Review

I picked up Just Friends for the premise, a man coming home to confess and then leave, and stayed for the way Saxon James writes two people who have known each other forever. It is not a perfect book. It circles more than it needs to, and I wanted to shake Tanner more than once. But I finished it smiling, and that counts for a lot in this subgenre.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is affection first and heat second. Roo has loved Tanner for years and knows it; Tanner loves Roo and has not filed it under the right heading yet. The best scenes are the ordinary ones, the two of them falling back into old routines as if no time has passed, until one small touch lasts too long.

The problem is the back and forth. Once things start, the book has them step forward and back several times, and Melanie at Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words found that on again, off again stretch dragged and left her emotionally detached. I felt it too, around the middle. Valerie at Love Bytes Reviews felt the opposite: a couple of minor misunderstandings, nothing that bothered her, and a story that earned all five hearts. Where you land depends on how much pining you can take.

The Characters

Roo is the more interesting of the two. He is Australian, sharp, funny and carrying the long tail of a childhood shaped by epilepsy and bullying. Melanie praised the attention to detail around his condition, and I agree: his seizures and his surgery are part of who he is, not a plot switch to flip when the story needs drama.

Tanner is harder work. He is warm, loyal and a little slow on the uptake, and his obliviousness is half the trope and half the frustration. He also has dyslexia, which stands between him and the permanent firefighting job he wants, because he cannot pass the written exams. The book takes that seriously, but Melanie found his reasons for refusing help unconvincing, and I did not fully buy them either. A StoryGraph reader, kayetaz, put him in the same box as Dex from Irresponsible Puckboy, an obsessive best friend, though far less toxic. That is a fair comparison, and it is a point in Tanner's favour.

The side cast is good company. Sunbury feels like a real place near Portland, full of people who know too much of your business. The exception is Roo's mother, who is controlling and unkind, and Melanie felt the book let her off too lightly. I would not argue.

Writing and Pacing

Saxon James writes clean, easy prose with a lot of humour in the dialogue, and the dual POV gives you both men's heads at the moments that matter. It reads quickly. The flashback moments to their school years, which kayetaz singled out, give the friendship weight without slowing things down.

The pacing is the weak spot. Tanner's realisation is drawn out, and Melanie called that stretch repetitive. Things pick up once the two of them stop dancing around it, and the last act lands on a happy ending I believed.

Just Friends is a tender, funny best friends to lovers romance whose friendship is stronger than its plot. Read it if you love pining and a kind bi awakening; go in ready to be patient with Tanner.

How Spicy Is Just Friends?

Just Friends is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The early book is about longing and near misses. Once Tanner works out what he wants, there are on-page scenes, and Valerie at Love Bytes Reviews described the couple's sexual experimentation as steamy. A StoryGraph reader rated it two peppers out of five, which tells you it is warm rather than scorching.

The intimacy is consensual and talky in a good way: Tanner asks questions, Roo answers them, and the bi awakening plays out with a lot of care. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reviews and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Just Friends?

Just Friends suits readers who want a cosy, low angst MM best friends to lovers romance with a bisexual awakening, a small town setting and moderate heat. It is less suited to readers who find an oblivious love interest exhausting, or who want a book with more plot than pining.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Just Friends is a well liked indie MM romance with a Goodreads average of about 3.9 from more than 9,000 ratings. Coverage comes mostly from MM review blogs and reader reviews rather than trade outlets, and the reaction splits on pacing more than on the couple.

Where they agree. The friendship and the bi awakening. Valerie at Love Bytes Reviews gave it five hearts and wrote: "This is the cutest bisexual-awakening story ever." Even Melanie at Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words, the coolest of the reviews we read, liked the well defined leads, the town and the care around Roo's epilepsy.

Where they split. Pacing and Tanner. Melanie gave it 3.75 out of 5, frustrated by the drawn out awakening, Tanner's obliviousness and the on again, off again middle. On StoryGraph, kayetaz gave it five stars despite a slow start, loving the unrequited love and the one bed scene. The audiobook divides people too: Larissa at Love Bytes Reviews admired both narrators but felt the casting was reversed, with Alexander Cendese's quick, sharp voice suiting Roo better than Tanner.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Just Friends scores 7.4 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for the friendship-driven romance and a satisfying ending, and lower marks for a middle stretch that circles and a hero whose obliviousness wears thin.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Deep, tender bond praised by Love Bytes Reviews; the friendship carries the romance.
Characters (15%)3.5Roo is layered; Tanner is lovable but his choices frustrate, per Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Easy, funny prose; the awakening drags in the middle.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Warm rather than wrenching; one reviewer felt detached.
Heat level (10%)3.5Delivers moderate, consensual heat after a long build.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A happy ending that feels earned once the dance stops.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A comfort reread for friends to lovers fans, less so for others.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Just Friends is a solid, sweet start to Saxon James's Never Just Friends series and sits in the middle of the low angst MM friends to lovers pack, with a final Eikna Score of 7.4/10.

Never Just Friends Reading Order

Just Friends is book 1 of Saxon James's Never Just Friends series, four connected standalones set around the same group of friends. Each book follows a new couple, so you can read any of them alone, but starting here introduces the town and the cast.

  1. Just Friends (2020): Roo and Tanner
  2. Fake Friends (2020): Circus and Rowan
  3. Getting Friendly (2021): Leon and Auggie
  4. Friendly Fire (2021): Rafe and Cam

Best format: ebook or print if you are sensitive to narrator casting. The dual narrated audiobook is well performed, but Love Bytes Reviews felt the voices were matched to the wrong characters, so try a sample first. Saxon James also writes the Puckboys hockey series with Eden Finley and the Accidental Love series, which starts with The Husband Hoax. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved Just Friends, Read These Next

If you loved Just Friends, look for MM romances where years of friendship turn into love, ideally with a bi awakening and plenty of affection, starting with Saxon James's co-written hockey books.

Frequently Asked Questions

Just Friends raises the same handful of questions for most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and which order the series goes in. Short answers below.

Is Just Friends by Saxon James spicy?

Moderately. Just Friends is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with a slow build and some open door scenes once Roo and Tanner get together.

Is Just Friends a standalone?

Yes. It is book 1 of the Never Just Friends series, but Roo and Tanner have a complete story and each later book follows a new couple.

Does Just Friends have a happy ending?

Yes. Just Friends ends with a happy ending for Roo and Tanner, with no cliffhanger.

Is Just Friends a bisexual awakening story?

Yes. Tanner realises he is attracted to Roo during the book, and the awakening is gentle and talked through.

Is there a Just Friends audiobook?

Yes. Tantor Audio released it in 2021, narrated by Alexander Cendese and Kirt Graves, running about 7 hours 17 minutes.

What order should I read the Never Just Friends series in?

Read Just Friends, then Fake Friends, Getting Friendly and Friendly Fire.

The Bottom Line

Just Friends earns a 7.4/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a soft, low angst MM best friends to lovers romance with a kind bi awakening and a small town full of nosy people, and who can be patient with a hero who takes his time. The reason to pick it up is the friendship: Roo and Tanner feel like they have known each other forever, and that makes the ending land.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.