Just Like Magic by Sarah Hogle Review
Eikna Score: 7.5/10. Recommended.
Just Like Magic is a holiday rom-com about a disgraced influencer who accidentally summons the literal spirit of the holidays and recruits him as her fake fiance. It starts abrasive and overstuffed, with a heroine many readers will want to shake, then turns into something unexpectedly tender about family, failure and what you owe the people who love you.
Read it if you like a flawed heroine with a real redemption arc, magical holiday whimsy and a sunshine hero straight out of Elf. Skip it if an unlikeable lead in the opening chapters is a deal-breaker, or you want the romance front and centre on every page.
Just Like Magic at a Glance
Just Like Magic is a standalone magical holiday rom-com by Sarah Hogle, published by G.P. Putnam's Sons on October 4, 2022. A struggling influencer conjures Holiday Spirit into human form and passes him off as her fiance at a family Christmas. The heat stays mild and behind a closed door, and the ending is happy.
| Author | Sarah Hogle |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy with holiday magic |
| Main tropes | Fake engagement, grumpy and sunshine, magical being in human form, redemption arc, holiday deadline |
| Spice level | 2/5: Mild, fade to black |
| Content warnings | Family dysfunction, public humiliation and online fame, revenge schemes, intoxication (full list below) |
| POV | Bettie (single narrator on audio) |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 368 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Tavia Gilbert, about 11 hours (Penguin Audio) |
| First published | October 4, 2022 |
| Publisher | G.P. Putnam's Sons |
What Is Just Like Magic About?
Just Like Magic follows Bettie Hughes, an Instagram influencer whose life is falling apart. Her perfume, jewellery and lipstick ventures have failed, and her sponsors vanished after a very public breakup with Lucas, a famous singer. Her family has no idea how bad things are, and she intends to keep it that way through the holidays.
Then she plays a Mariah Carey song backwards and accidentally conjures Holiday Spirit himself: a cheerful, green-eyed man in his twenties who calls himself Hall E. Day and is very new to granting wishes. Bettie decides he will make the perfect fake fiance. Hall has a deadline, though. Once Bettie has enough holiday cheer, he has to go.
What Makes This Fake Engagement Romance Work
Just Like Magic works because its fake engagement is not really about fooling the family; it is about Bettie being forced to look at herself through someone who sees only the best in people. Hall is exuberant and kind, and All About Romance compared him to Buddy from Elf, which is exactly right. Put him next to a heroine who lies for a living and the book's comedy and heart come from the same place.
The magic gives the romance a clock. Hall cannot stay, and the more Bettie softens, the sooner he has to leave. That bittersweet engine is what lifts the back half, and it is a big part of why Ahana Rao at The Nerd Daily gave it a perfect score.
Readers who want grumpy and sunshine energy with a supernatural twist will find a version here where the grump has to earn her happy ending.
My Review
Just Like Magic is a book I almost gave up on and am glad I did not. The first act is loud, crowded and mean in places, and Bettie is a hard person to spend time with. Then, somewhere past the first third, the book finds its feelings, and by the end I was more moved than I expected to be by a novel whose hero was summoned with a backwards Mariah Carey song.
Reviews split almost exactly along that line. The Nerd Daily called it a ten out of ten and said the pace improves after about 30 percent; All About Romance gave it a B minus and found the early revenge plotting a drag. Both are describing the same book.
Romance and Chemistry
Bettie and Hall are a grumpy and sunshine pairing pushed to its extreme: she is cynical, image-obsessed and dishonest, he is pure goodwill. The Nerd Daily enjoyed that dynamic, and so did I once Bettie stopped treating Hall as a prop. His defence of her in front of her family and his looming departure give the relationship real stakes.
The problem is space. All About Romance wanted more romance and less of the drawn-out fake engagement subplot, and readers on r/RomanceBooks felt the redemption and family repair got more room than the couple. I agree. The love story is lovely when it gets the floor; it just does not get it often enough in the first half.
The Characters
Bettie is deliberately unlikeable at the start, and Hogle commits to it. She is selfish, vain and quick to scheme, and The Nerd Daily admitted she is hard to warm to at first. Her movement toward generosity is the spine of the book, and when she finally starts rebuilding her career on her own terms, All About Romance found it one of the most enjoyable parts.
Hall can feel one-note early, as some Reddit readers complained, but his innocence pays off later. Bettie's family, grandparents included, bicker and are rude to Hall, and The Nerd Daily noted the cast is large enough that names blur together.
Writing and Pacing
Hogle's prose is the book's best asset. Ahana Rao wrote that her writing is her most precious asset, and the voice is sharp, funny and full of pop culture. There are lovely set pieces, including an ice-skating outing All About Romance singled out.
The opening is the weak spot. The revenge wishes against Bettie's ex feel mean-spirited and random, All About Romance said, and the dense references and family chaos slow things down. Stick with it: the long, satisfying ending, which All About Romance also praised, makes up a lot of ground.
Just Like Magic is a messy, funny, eventually tender holiday romcom about a terrible person learning to be a better one, with a magical hero who deserves more page time. Read it if you can forgive a rough start for a warm finish.
How Spicy Is Just Like Magic?
Just Like Magic is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. All About Romance rates its sensuality as warm, and there is very little bedroom action on the page. The romance is carried by banter, longing and Hall's deadline rather than explicit scenes.
It is a comfortable pick for readers who want holiday romance without steam. For more at this heat level, see our closed door romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from reviews:
- Family dysfunction and rudeness at holiday gatherings
- A public breakup and fallout from online fame
- Revenge wishes and mean-spirited schemes early on
- Intoxication during the conjuring scene
- Career failure and financial stress
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Just Like Magic?
Just Like Magic suits readers who enjoy flawed heroines with real redemption arcs, whimsical holiday magic and a sweet, low-heat romance. It is less suited to readers who need a likeable lead from page one, a romance-first plot or a quieter, simpler cast.
Best for:
- Fans of unlikeable heroines who grow
- Readers who loved Elf and want a romcom version
- Anyone who wants a closed-door holiday read
- Readers who like fake engagements with a magical twist
- Sarah Hogle fans who enjoy her voice
Not for:
- Readers who give up on abrasive openings
- Anyone who wants the couple in nearly every scene
- Readers who dislike dense pop culture references
- Those looking for steam
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Just Like Magic split readers and reviewers. Most agree Hogle's writing is strong and the ending tender; they divide over Bettie's abrasive early chapters, the revenge subplot and how much room the romance gets.
Where they agree. The writing and the finish. The Nerd Daily's Ahana Rao gave it ten out of ten for its humour and emotion, and All About Romance praised its lovely scenes, Bettie's career rebuild and a long, satisfying ending.
Where they split. The opening and the heroine. All About Romance gave it a B minus, finding the revenge schemes mean-spirited and the fake engagement drawn out, and liked it less than Twice Shy. Readers on r/RomanceBooks found Hall one-note at first and Bettie hard to care about, and The Nerd Daily also flagged the slow start before deciding it was worth it.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Just Like Magic scores 7.5 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its writing, emotional payoff and ending score well, and it loses ground on an abrasive opening, a crowded cast and a romance that shares too much space with the redemption plot.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Sweet and bittersweet; All About Romance wanted more of it. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Bettie's arc is strong; Reddit readers find her hard to care about early. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | The Nerd Daily calls the writing Hogle's greatest asset; slow first third. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Humour and emotion blend in the back half, per The Nerd Daily. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Warm, closed-door romance that suits the whimsy. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A long, satisfying HEA, per All About Romance. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Better on a reread once you know Bettie gets there. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Just Like Magic is a step below Twice Shy in Hogle's catalogue but one of the more original magical holiday romcoms of its year, with a final Eikna Score of 7.5/10.
Is Just Like Magic a Standalone?
Yes. Just Like Magic is a standalone novel with a complete story and a happy ending, and it does not connect to Sarah Hogle's other books. You can read it in any order alongside her catalogue.
Best format: the audiobook, narrated by Tavia Gilbert, runs about 11 hours and handles the comedy well; print is easier if you want to keep the big family cast straight. Our series order guide covers holiday series if you want something longer.
If You Loved Just Like Magic, Read These Next
If you loved Just Like Magic, look for more of Hogle's voice or for holiday romances with a magical twist.
- Twice Shy by Sarah Hogle: an anxious dreamer inherits a house and has to share it with its grumpy groundskeeper.
- You Deserve Each Other by Sarah Hogle: an engaged couple who can't stand each other try to sabotage their way out, and fall back in love.
- Once Upon a December by Amy E. Reichert: a magical Christmas market and a baker who remembers every December.
- In a Holidaze by Christina Lauren: a Christmas wish sends the heroine back through the same holiday until she gets love right.
Frequently Asked Questions
Just Like Magic raises a few common questions: how spicy it is, who Hall is, whether it is a standalone and how it ends. Short answers below.
Is Just Like Magic spicy?
Not really. Just Like Magic is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with a warm, closed-door romance and very little on the page.
Who is Hall in Just Like Magic?
Hall is Holiday Spirit in human form, accidentally conjured by Bettie. He calls himself Hall E. Day and agrees to pose as her fiance.
Is Just Like Magic a standalone?
Yes. Just Like Magic is a standalone novel and is not part of a series.
Does Just Like Magic have a happy ending?
Yes. Just Like Magic ends with a happily ever after, after a long and emotional final stretch.
Is the heroine of Just Like Magic unlikeable?
At first, deliberately. Bettie starts out selfish and dishonest, and her growth toward generosity is the heart of the book.
Is there a Just Like Magic audiobook?
Yes. Tavia Gilbert narrates the Penguin Audio edition, which runs about 11 hours.
The Bottom Line
Just Like Magic earns a 7.5/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who can stick with a prickly heroine through a chaotic opening and want a whimsical, closed-door holiday romcom with a real emotional payoff. The one reason to pick it up is Hall, a hero so earnestly kind that he makes the whole messy book glow.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.