eikna romance
Menu

Once Upon a December by Amy E. Reichert Review

Eikna Score: 6.9/10. Recommended with reservations.

Once Upon a December has one of the loveliest premises in recent holiday romance: a magic Christmas market that moves city to city and a baker who remembers every December with a woman who forgets him each year. The idea outruns the execution, though, and the uneven memories, the sacrifice it asks of Astra and a late pregnancy twist leave the romance on shakier ground than the setting.

Read it if you want a cosy, food-filled Christmas fantasy set in Milwaukee, or you love heroines with a strong circle of friends. Skip it if magic rules that bend to the plot drive you mad, or you dislike romances where one partner is asked to give up their whole life.

Once Upon a December by Amy E. Reichert book cover

Once Upon a December at a Glance

Once Upon a December is a standalone holiday romance with a magical twist by Amy E. Reichert, published by Berkley on October 4, 2022. Set mostly in Milwaukee, it pairs a newly divorced librarian with a baker from an enchanted Christmas market, keeps the heat behind a closed door and ends happily.

AuthorAmy E. Reichert
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreContemporary romance with magical realism, Christmas setting
Main tropesMagical Christmas market, one partner remembers and one forgets, fresh start after divorce, holiday deadline, found family of friends
Spice level2/5: Mild, fade to black
Content warningsDivorce and a hostile ex, an unplanned pregnancy, giving up one's life for a partner (full list below)
POVThird person, alternating between Astra and Jack
EndingHEA
Pages336 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Sharon Freedman, 9 hours 32 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio)
First publishedOctober 4, 2022
PublisherBerkley

What Is Once Upon a December About?

Once Upon a December follows Astra Noel Snow, a Milwaukee librarian freshly out of a marriage and still fighting her ex-husband over custody of their dog. One December she wanders into the Julemarked, a Christmas market, and meets Jack Clausen, whose family bakes kringle there.

Jack knows her already. The Julemarked appears somewhere new each December, and anyone who visits forgets it once the month ends. Jack has met Astra again and again over the years and remembers every time; she remembers none of it. With the market closing before Christmas, the two have a few weeks to figure out whether a life together is even possible.

What Makes This Magical Christmas Romance Work

Once Upon a December works best as a setting. The Julemarked is a genuinely charming invention: a market that slips between places, run by families who live inside December, with bakeries, kringle and snow that seems to fall on cue. Library Journal called the book a blend of a sweet love story and Christmas magic, and the market is where that magic lives.

The romantic hook is the memory gap. Jack has been in love with Astra for years, as far as he is concerned, while she is meeting a handsome stranger who seems to know her a little too well. That asymmetry gives the early chapters a lovely ache, and Reichert lets Astra's curiosity drive her back to the market night after night.

It also sets up the book's biggest problem, which we get to below. For readers who like their holiday romance with a dash of the impossible, the premise alone is reason enough to try it.

My Review

Once Upon a December won me over in its first third and lost me a little in its last. The opening is everything I want from a Christmas novel: a heroine whose life has just cracked open, a place that feels like it might rescue her and a man who looks at her as if she were the rescue. Then the rules of the magic arrive, and the book has to make them carry a romance they are not quite strong enough to hold.

The reviews I read split along the same line. Harlequin Junkie loved its whimsy and its ending, while Smexy Books gave it a C minus and could not get past the imbalance at its centre. I land in between.

Romance and Chemistry

Jack and Astra are sweet together. Their first real date, a night of dancing, shifts the book from flirtation into romance, and Reichert writes their attraction with warmth rather than heat. Jack is kind, steady and very sure.

That sureness is the trouble. He remembers years of history with her; she has a few weeks with him. Smexy Books found it strange that Jack holds all the memories, and Jill Jemmett felt he was too quick to ask Astra to give up everything for him. I felt that too. The emotional weight is uneven for most of the book, and when Astra does start to catch up, the late arrival of an unplanned pregnancy forces the decision rather than letting the couple reach it. Smexy Books and Jill Jemmett both called that twist unnecessary, and I agree.

The Characters

Astra is the reason to read. She is funny and stubborn and newly free, and her campaign to win her dog back from her ex is the best subplot in the book. Her three best friends are a real presence, and Harlequin Junkie singled out those friendships as a highlight. They feel like people Astra would actually confide in, not chorus members.

Jack is thinner. His family and his relationship with his brothers, praised by Smexy Books, give him some texture, but his inner life is mostly longing for Astra. A hero who has loved someone for years should feel weightier than this.

Writing and Pacing

Reichert writes food and atmosphere beautifully, as you would expect from the author of The Kindred Spirits Supper Club. The bakery scenes will send you looking for kringle, and the cold feels real. The prose is easy and warm.

The magic system is where the pacing stalls. Readers including Jill Jemmett and a commenter on Harlequin Junkie found the time and memory rules confusing at first, and Smexy Books felt that the Milwaukee sense of place was weaker than in Reichert's earlier novels. Library Journal noted that the couple's path takes a while to figure out, which is a kind way of saying the final act spends a lot of time on logistics.

Once Upon a December is a cosy, beautifully set Christmas romance with a premise more magical than its love story. Read it if atmosphere and a lovable heroine matter more to you than airtight magic rules.

How Spicy Is Once Upon a December?

Once Upon a December is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. The romance has kisses, attraction and frank talk, but reviewers report that the sex happens off the page. It is a comfortable choice for readers who want a warm holiday romance without explicit scenes.

For more romances at this heat level, see our closed door romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Once Upon a December?

Once Upon a December suits readers who want a gentle Christmas romance with magic, food and friendship at its heart. It is less suited to readers who need balanced emotional stakes between the leads or a magic system that holds up to close reading.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Once Upon a December drew a mixed response. Critics and readers agree the Julemarked is a charming, original setting; they split sharply over the memory imbalance, Jack's demands and the pregnancy twist.

Where they agree. The concept and the atmosphere. Library Journal called it a cosy blend of love story and Christmas magic with a satisfying, best-of-both-worlds ending. Harlequin Junkie found it whimsical, funny and emotional. Even Smexy Books, the toughest review we read, called the market unique and praised Astra's friendships.

Where they split. The romance's fairness. Smexy Books found the one-sided memories uncomfortable and the pregnancy unnecessary, and would not recommend it widely. Jill Jemmett disliked how quickly Jack asked Astra to give up her life and found the rules confusing. Readers who suspend disbelief easily, like Harlequin Junkie, enjoyed the ride.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Once Upon a December scores 6.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its setting and heroine lift it, its closed-door heat suits the book, and it loses points for an uneven romance, a forced late twist and magic rules that confuse many readers.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Sweet chemistry, but Smexy Books finds the one-sided memories uncomfortable.
Characters (15%)3.5Astra and her friends shine, per Harlequin Junkie; Jack stays thin.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Warm, sensory prose; Jill Jemmett finds the rules confusing early on.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Harlequin Junkie found it moving; the imbalance blunts it for others.
Heat level (10%)3.5A closed-door romance that keeps its promise of warmth without explicit scenes.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5Library Journal calls the HEA satisfying; the pregnancy twist forces it.
Reread appeal (10%)3A seasonal comfort read for fans; the logic gaps show more the second time.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Once Upon a December sits in the middle of this season's magical holiday romances, more inventive than most but less satisfying than its premise promises, with a final Eikna Score of 6.9/10.

Is Once Upon a December a Standalone?

Yes. Once Upon a December is a standalone novel with a complete love story and a happy ending, so you can read it without any of Amy E. Reichert's other books. It is a good December read in any year, since nothing ties it to a particular season beyond Christmas itself.

Best format: print or ebook if you want to keep track of the Julemarked's rules, or the Sharon Freedman audiobook if you want a gentle listen while you wrap presents. Our series order guide covers holiday series if you want something longer.

If You Loved Once Upon a December, Read These Next

If you loved Once Upon a December, look for holiday romances with a touch of magic, a cosy setting or a heroine starting over.

Frequently Asked Questions

Once Upon a December raises a few common questions: how spicy it is, whether it is a standalone, how the magic works and how it ends. Short answers below.

Is Once Upon a December spicy?

Not really. Once Upon a December is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with kissing and attraction on the page and sex kept off the page.

Is Once Upon a December a standalone?

Yes. Once Upon a December is a standalone holiday romance and is not part of a series.

Does Once Upon a December have a happy ending?

Yes. Astra and Jack get a happily ever after, though it takes a while for the book to work out how.

What is the Julemarked in Once Upon a December?

The Julemarked is an enchanted Christmas market that appears in a new place each December. Visitors forget it once the month ends, which is why Astra cannot remember Jack.

Where is Once Upon a December set?

Once Upon a December is set mainly in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, where the Julemarked appears the December Astra meets Jack.

Is there a Once Upon a December audiobook?

Yes. Sharon Freedman narrates the Penguin Random House Audio edition, which runs about 9 hours 32 minutes.

The Bottom Line

Once Upon a December earns a 6.9/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a closed-door Christmas romance with a magical market, a lot of baking and a heroine worth cheering for, and who can let the logic go. The one reason to pick it up is the Julemarked itself, one of the most charming holiday settings in recent romance.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.