eikna romance
Menu

Make My Wish Come True by Rachael Lippincott and Alyson Derrick Review

Eikna Score: 7.8/10. Recommended.

Make My Wish Come True is a sapphic young adult Christmas rom com about a teen actor and the former best friend she abandoned, faking a hometown romance over twelve holiday dates. It is cosy, funny and more honest about broken friendships than most holiday romances, with a few familiar beats and a celebrity plot that sometimes runs on autopilot.

Read it if you want a sapphic YA fake dating story with second chance feelings, or you love small towns that take Christmas very seriously. Skip it if celebrity and tabloid plots bore you, or you want a romance with adult heat.

Make My Wish Come True by Rachael Lippincott and Alyson Derrick book cover

Make My Wish Come True at a Glance

Make My Wish Come True is a standalone sapphic young adult holiday romance by Rachael Lippincott and Alyson Derrick, published by Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers on October 1, 2024. It alternates between its two leads, keeps the romance to kisses and ends happily, in a way that fits its teenage characters.

AuthorsRachael Lippincott and Alyson Derrick
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreLGBTQ romance (sapphic young adult holiday rom com)
Age rangeYoung adult; publisher lists grades 9 and up, ages 14 and up
Main tropesFake dating, second chance, best friends to lovers, celebrity and small-town girl, Christmas and Hanukkah
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsFriendship abandonment, tabloid pressure, family estrangement (full list below)
POVAlternating first person, Arden and Caroline
EndingHappy, fitting for teen leads
Pages320 (hardcover); 336 (paperback, 2025)
AudiobookNarrated by Krystal Hammond and Natalie Naudus, 9 hours 25 minutes (Simon & Schuster Audio)
First publishedOctober 1, 2024
PublisherSimon & Schuster Books for Young Readers

What Is Make My Wish Come True About?

Make My Wish Come True follows Arden James, a reckless teen Hollywood actor whose latest tabloid scandal has cost her a dream audition. Her team needs a softer image fast, and the plan is a sweet hometown romance in Barnwich, the small, Christmas-obsessed town she left four years ago.

The girl she needs is Caroline Beckett, her former best friend and first crush, whom Arden left behind without much of a goodbye. Caroline has her own reason to agree: a byline in a major magazine that could strengthen her journalism application. So they set up twelve staged holiday dates, and the old feelings neither of them dealt with start to come back.

What Makes This Fake Dating Romance Work

Make My Wish Come True works as a fake dating romance because the fake relationship is built on a real wound. Arden and Caroline were best friends, Arden left, and the silence that followed hurt. Pretending to be in love forces them to spend time together before they have talked about any of that, which makes every staged date a little dangerous.

The twelve holidates give the book a clear, festive shape. Each one is a set piece in a town that goes all in on the season, and Publishers Weekly praised the cosy seasonal atmosphere. The fresh twist, PW said, is how the book handles familiar tropes, and the second chance angle is a big part of that.

The authors, who are also a married couple, wrote She Gets the Girl together, and their alternating chapters give both girls real interiority. Readers who like fake dating with a second chance underneath will find this an easy hook.

My Review

Make My Wish Come True is a holiday rom com that understands friendship breakups hurt as much as romantic ones. That is what lifts it above a lot of the YA Christmas shelf. The fake dating scheme is fun, but the book's real subject is two girls working out whether they can forgive each other for growing up apart.

Booklist, in a starred review, wrote that "forgiveness, friendship, and vulnerability all shine as brightly as holiday lights." Publishers Weekly called it a winning and satisfying love story, and Kirkus called it swoon-worthy. I agree with all three, with a few reservations about the Hollywood side.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is built on history, and it shows. Arden and Caroline know each other's habits, in-jokes and weak spots, so their banter has a familiarity that most fake dating pairs lack. When the performance starts to feel real, it is because some of it always was.

The second chance element gives the romance its tension. Caroline has every reason to stay guarded, and the book does not rush her forgiveness. The fake dating beats land where you expect them to, and a contrary StoryGraph reviewer was not won over. For me the emotional groundwork was strong enough that the predictable beats felt earned rather than lazy. The romance stays sweet and age appropriate, with kisses at most.

The Characters

Arden is the more complicated lead. She is a teen actor who has made real mistakes, and the book lets her be defensive, self-destructive and genuinely sorry. Her situation, including her independence from her family at a young age, adds a layer of loneliness that explains a lot about why she left.

Caroline is the steadier one: ambitious, rooted in her family and her town, and hurt in a quiet way she has never said out loud. Publishers Weekly noted the leads' backgrounds, Arden part Korean and Caroline part Jewish, and the book's Christmas and Hanukkah threads give her mixed Jewish and Catholic family real texture. PW found both girls believable as teenagers, which is not always true in YA celebrity stories.

Writing and Pacing

The writing is warm and easy, and the alternating chapters keep both girls' secrets in view. The twelve-date structure keeps things moving, with a new set piece every few chapters.

The celebrity plot is the weaker half. Tabloids, publicists and auditions are necessary to set up the fake relationship, but they are less vivid than the small-town scenes, and I found that thread the most generic part of the book. At 320 pages in hardcover the book is a comfortable length, and it rarely drags.

Make My Wish Come True is a cosy, heartfelt sapphic YA Christmas romance that cares as much about mending a friendship as starting a romance. Read it for Arden and Caroline's history and the twelve holidates, and forgive the paint-by-numbers Hollywood subplot.

How Spicy Is Make My Wish Come True?

Make My Wish Come True is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. It is a young adult novel for readers 14 and up, and the romance stays at banter, feelings and, at most, kisses.

For more romance at this heat level, see our closed door romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from the publisher, critics and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Make My Wish Come True?

Make My Wish Come True suits teen readers aged 14 and up, and adults who enjoy YA, who want a sapphic Christmas fake dating story with second chance feelings and a cosy small town. It is less suited to readers bored by celebrity plots or wanting adult heat.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Make My Wish Come True drew strong trade reviews, including a Booklist star, a positive Publishers Weekly review and praise from Kirkus. Readers mostly agree on its warmth and split on how fresh it feels.

Where they agree. The heart and the setting. Booklist praised its forgiveness, friendship and vulnerability, PW called it winning and satisfying with believable teens, and Kirkus called it swoon-worthy. PW also singled out the cosy small-town holiday atmosphere.

Where they split. Predictability and the celebrity thread. StoryGraph reaction is warmer than not but includes contrary and mixed reviews, and the book leans on familiar fake dating beats that PW credits as fresh and others may find predictable. The Hollywood thread is thinner than the Barnwich scenes.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Make My Wish Come True scores 7.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top marks for romance, characters, emotion and the ending, where Booklist and PW praise the forgiveness story and believable teens, and its lowest for writing and reread appeal, where the celebrity plot and familiar beats hold it back.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Kirkus calls it swoon-worthy; history gives the fake dating real stakes.
Characters (15%)4PW finds both teens believable; Arden's flaws are handled with care.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Warm and quick; the celebrity thread is the weaker half.
Emotional impact (15%)4Booklist's star praises forgiveness, friendship and vulnerability.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the sweet, closed door YA romance its age range promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4PW calls it a winning and satisfying love story.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A cosy seasonal reread, though the beats are familiar.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Make My Wish Come True is one of the stronger YA holiday romances we cover and a warm companion to Hani and Ishu's Guide to Fake Dating, with a final Eikna Score of 7.8/10.

Is Make My Wish Come True a Standalone?

Yes. Make My Wish Come True is a standalone young adult novel with a complete romance, so you can start here with no prior reading. Rachael Lippincott and Alyson Derrick's earlier joint novel, She Gets the Girl, is a separate story.

Best format: the audiobook with Krystal Hammond and Natalie Naudus, because two narrators suit the alternating chapters. The 2025 paperback is the easiest print edition to find. Our series order guide covers longer romance series.

If You Loved Make My Wish Come True, Read These Next

If you loved Make My Wish Come True, look for other sapphic YA romances, fake dating stories and holiday books with a small-town heart.

Frequently Asked Questions

Make My Wish Come True raises the same questions for most new readers: what age it suits, whether it is sapphic, how spicy it is and whether it is part of a series. Short answers below.

What age is Make My Wish Come True for?

Make My Wish Come True is a young adult novel. The publisher lists it for grades 9 and up, ages 14 and up.

Is Make My Wish Come True sapphic?

Yes. Make My Wish Come True is a romance between two girls, Arden and Caroline, former best friends who fake a relationship.

Is Make My Wish Come True spicy?

No. Make My Wish Come True is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, with kisses at most and no sexual content.

Is Make My Wish Come True part of a series?

No. Make My Wish Come True is a standalone novel. The authors' earlier book She Gets the Girl is unrelated.

Is there a Make My Wish Come True audiobook?

Yes. The Simon & Schuster Audio edition is narrated by Krystal Hammond and Natalie Naudus and runs 9 hours 25 minutes.

The Bottom Line

Make My Wish Come True earns a 7.8/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for teen and adult readers who want a cosy sapphic Christmas romance with fake dating on the surface and a mended friendship underneath. The one reason to pick it up is Arden and Caroline's history, which turns twelve staged holidates into something tender and real.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.