So, This Is Christmas by Tracy Andreen Review
Eikna Score: 6.7/10. Recommended with reservations.
So, This Is Christmas is a young adult holiday comedy about a girl who oversold her tiny hometown online and now has to deliver a perfect American Christmas to the boarding school classmate who believed her. It starts slowly and its heroine is hard work at first, but the family threads and the ending give it more heart than its Hallmark setup suggests.
Read it if you want a clean, small-town YA Christmas full of holiday movie references, or you like stories where the family plot matters as much as the romance. Skip it if a self-absorbed narrator wears you out early, or you want a romance that is fully settled by the last page.
So, This Is Christmas at a Glance
So, This Is Christmas is a young adult holiday romance by Tracy Andreen, first published by Viking Books for Young Readers in October 2021. It follows sixteen-year-old Finley Brown home to Christmas, Oklahoma, keeps the romance to kisses, and continues in a sequel, So, This Is Love.
| Author | Tracy Andreen |
|---|---|
| Series | Book 1 of 2; the sequel So, This Is Love continues Finley and Arthur's story |
| Subgenre | Young adult holiday romance (small town) |
| Age range | Young adult; Kirkus suggests 14 to 18 |
| Main tropes | Small-town Christmas, rivals to sweethearts, oversold hometown, family inn, holiday movie homage |
| Spice level | 1/5: Kisses only / closed door |
| Content warnings | Parental separation, toxic friendship, teen pregnancy discussion (full list below) |
| POV | Finley |
| Ending | Hopeful; the relationship continues in the sequel |
| Pages | 368 |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Helen Laser, 9 hours 22 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio) |
| First published | October 2021 (hardcover); paperback October 11, 2022 |
| Publisher | Viking Books for Young Readers |
What Is So, This Is Christmas About?
So, This Is Christmas follows Finley Brown, sixteen, home for the holidays from her Connecticut boarding school to the town of Christmas, Oklahoma. Home is not what it was. Her parents have separated, her former best friend Mia is dating Finley's ex, and the town is a lot less magical than the version Finley has been describing to her classmates.
Then Arthur, a classmate she barely gets along with, shows up with his aunt, booked into her grandmother's inn and expecting the picture-perfect Christmas Finley promised online. Now she has to fake one, while dealing with family secrets and old drama she would rather avoid.
What Makes This Small Town Christmas Romance Work
So, This Is Christmas works as a small-town Christmas romance because it knows exactly which movie it is imitating and pokes fun at it. A town literally called Christmas, an inn, a grandmother, a city visitor with impossible expectations: Kirkus noted the many Christmas movie references, and the book leans into them with a wink.
The engine is Finley's lie. She sold Christmas, Oklahoma as a holiday wonderland, and Arthur arrives believing it. Trying to stage the perfect holiday for someone she does not even like gives the book its comedy and its slow thaw, as the two of them move from friction to something warmer.
Underneath, the family story does the real work. Finley's parents' separation, her grandmother's own secrets and a fractured friendship give the romance a backdrop with weight, which is what Kirkus credited for lifting the book past its opening.
My Review
So, This Is Christmas is a book I almost gave up on and was glad I did not. The first chapters are its weakest, and Finley is prickly and self-involved in a way that makes everyone around her look like a cartoon. Then, somewhere in the middle, the book relaxes into its family story, and the people around Finley start to feel real.
Kirkus summed it up as "a quaint romance that succeeds after an opening stumble." That is exactly my experience, and it is a fair warning to readers who judge a book by its first fifty pages.
Romance and Chemistry
The romance between Finley and Arthur is a slow, low-key thaw rather than a spark. They start out irritated with each other, and the business of faking a perfect Christmas forces them into each other's company. Some readers describe it in rivals to lovers terms; I would call it rivals to tentative sweethearts.
The chemistry is gentle and age appropriate, with kisses at most. Kirkus felt Arthur in particular was drawn broadly because the story is filtered through Finley's self-absorption, and I agree he takes a while to become a person rather than a plot device. When he does, the romance improves. The ending is hopeful rather than conclusive, and the sequel picks up the question of whether this holiday romance becomes a relationship.
The Characters
Finley is the book's biggest risk. She is defensive and slow to see past herself. That is realistic for a sixteen-year-old whose family is coming apart, and it gives her room to grow, but it makes the opening hard going. Kirkus found the supporting cast cartoonish early on for exactly this reason.
The secondary cast is where the book earns its warmth. Grandma Jo is the standout, and her own storyline, including a coming-out thread, gives the book an unexpected emotional layer. Kirkus praised how the ending deepens the characters, especially the secondary ones. Side characters such as Esha and Ayisha, and Finley's fallout with Mia, add texture, though a StoryGraph reader flagged some uncomfortable handling around a secondary relationship.
Writing and Pacing
Andreen's prose is breezy and comic, full of holiday movie in-jokes and small-town colour. The multiple plotlines, though, take a long time to get going: Kirkus noted they need time to develop, and the first act spends a lot of pages setting up pieces.
Some humour has not aged well. The book has a comic setup involving homelessness that several readers found uncomfortable, and I did too. The back half moves faster and lands better, and by the end the book has more substance than its premise promised.
So, This Is Christmas is a clean, comic YA holiday story that stumbles early and finds its heart in its family plot. Read it if you can be patient with Finley, and keep the sequel handy if you want the romance resolved.
How Spicy Is So, This Is Christmas?
So, This Is Christmas is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. It is a young adult novel with teenage leads, and the romance stays at banter, feelings and, at most, kisses.
For more romance at this heat level, see our closed door romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from critic and reader reports:
- Parental separation
- Toxic or hostile friendship
- Discussion of teen pregnancy
- A comic setup involving homelessness that some readers find uncomfortable
- Minor homophobia and infidelity around a secondary relationship
- Coming out dynamics involving an older family member
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read So, This Is Christmas?
So, This Is Christmas suits teen readers, and adults who enjoy YA, who want a clean, funny small-town Christmas story with family drama and a slow-thaw romance. It is less suited to readers who need a likeable narrator from page one or a romance with a definite ending.
Best for:
- Fans of Hallmark-style Christmas movies who enjoy the references
- Readers who like family plots alongside romance
- Teens looking for a clean holiday read
- Readers who will happily continue into a sequel
Not for:
- Readers put off by a self-absorbed narrator
- Anyone wanting strong romantic chemistry from the start
- Readers who need a fully resolved couple in book one
- Those looking for adult romance heat
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
So, This Is Christmas drew a measured Kirkus review and coverage from YA book blogs including The Nerd Daily, YA Books Central, Pages Unbound and The Candid Cover. The consensus is that it is cosy and funny once it gets going.
Where they agree. The holiday setting and the family. Kirkus called it a pleasant romance built on a solid character study, with an ending that adds depth to the secondary cast. Bloggers and readers enjoy the small-town Christmas atmosphere and the movie references.
Where they split. Finley and the opening. Kirkus found the opening chapters the weakest and Finley's self-absorption a drag on the other characters. Some StoryGraph readers struggled with her, and one flagged uncomfortable handling of a secondary relationship. Readers also differ on the ending: some like its open, hopeful feel, while others wanted the romance settled in this book.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
So, This Is Christmas scores 6.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top marks for characters, emotional impact and the ending, where Kirkus credits the family plot and secondary cast, and its lowest for romance, writing and reread appeal, where the opening stumbles and the romance stays faint.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3 | A gentle thaw; Kirkus finds Arthur broadly drawn through Finley's eyes. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Kirkus praises how the ending deepens the secondary cast. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3 | Breezy, but Kirkus calls the opening chapters the weakest. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Family separation and Grandma Jo's story add weight, per Kirkus. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers the clean, kisses-only romance its YA audience expects. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | Kirkus says the ending gives the book substance; the romance stays open. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | A seasonal comfort read once, with a slow start to revisit. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: So, This Is Christmas sits in the middle of the YA holiday shelf, funnier and more family-focused than New Year's Kiss but less polished than Dash & Lily's Book of Dares, with a final Eikna Score of 6.7/10.
So, This Is Christmas Reading Order
So, This Is Christmas is the first of two books about Finley and Arthur. Start here, then read the sequel if you want to know whether their Christmas romance lasts.
- So, This Is Christmas (2021)
- So, This Is Love: the sequel, continuing Finley and Arthur's story
Best format: the audiobook narrated by Helen Laser suits the comic first-person voice, and the 2022 paperback is the easiest print edition to find. Our series order guide covers more romance series.
If You Loved So, This Is Christmas, Read These Next
If you loved So, This Is Christmas, look for other clean YA holiday romances with small towns, family drama and a bit of fakery.
- Make My Wish Come True by Rachael Lippincott and Alyson Derrick: a sapphic YA fake dating Christmas in a holiday-obsessed small town.
- The Holiday Switch by Tif Marcelo: YA coworker rivals at a holiday inn, with a strong family thread.
- Dash & Lily's Book of Dares by Rachel Cohn and David Levithan: a bookish New York Christmas told in alternating voices.
- Let It Snow by John Green, Maureen Johnson and Lauren Myracle: three linked YA Christmas stories in a snowbound town.
- New Year's Kiss by Lee Matthews: a YA family-resort romance built around a list of bold goals.
Frequently Asked Questions
So, This Is Christmas raises the same questions for most new readers: what age it suits, whether it is clean, whether there is a sequel and how it ends. Short answers below.
What age is So, This Is Christmas for?
So, This Is Christmas is a young adult novel. Kirkus suggests ages 14 to 18, and the heroine is sixteen.
Is So, This Is Christmas clean?
Yes. So, This Is Christmas is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, with kisses at most and no sexual content.
Is there a sequel to So, This Is Christmas?
Yes. So, This Is Love continues Finley and Arthur's story after the Christmas romance.
Does So, This Is Christmas have a happy ending?
So, This Is Christmas ends on a hopeful note for Finley and Arthur, with the question of their relationship picked up in the sequel.
Is there a So, This Is Christmas audiobook?
Yes. The audiobook is narrated by Helen Laser and runs about 9 hours 22 minutes.
The Bottom Line
So, This Is Christmas earns a 6.7/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for teen and adult readers who want a clean, comic small-town Christmas with a family story underneath, and who can wait out a rocky opening. The one reason to pick it up is Grandma Jo's household, which turns a Hallmark spoof into something warmer by the end.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- So, This Is Christmas, Kirkus Reviews
- So, This Is Love, Kirkus Reviews (sequel)
- So, This Is Christmas audiobook, Libro.fm
- So, This Is Christmas, Brightly (Penguin Random House)
- Penguin Teen hardcover listing (ISBN 9780593353127)
- The Nerd Daily, YA Books Central, Read & Wright, Bookends, Pages Unbound and The Candid Cover reviews; StoryGraph reader reviews
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.