eikna romance
Menu

Mangos and Mistletoe by Adriana Herrera Review

Eikna Score: 7.3/10. Recommended.

Mangos and Mistletoe is a short, sexy sapphic holiday novella about two Dominican bakers forced to share a team, a hotel room and a bed at a baking competition in Scotland. The food, the heat and the cultural texture are terrific; the romance moves so fast that the emotional turn and the late conflict feel squeezed.

Read it if you want a Great British Bake Off style romance with real spice, or two Latina leads arguing about what home means. Skip it if you need a slow build, or a novella's compressed ending always leaves you hungry.

Mangos and Mistletoe by Adriana Herrera book cover

Mangos and Mistletoe at a Glance

Mangos and Mistletoe is Adriana Herrera's 2019 self-published sapphic holiday novella, a standalone. It follows two Dominican women teamed up on a holiday baking competition in Scotland, alternates between their points of view, and ends happily. The paperback runs 150 pages.

AuthorAdriana Herrera
SeriesStandalone novella
SubgenreSapphic contemporary romance, holiday novella
Main tropesGrumpy sunshine, only one bed, competition teammates, rivals to lovers, foodie romance
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsFamily homophobia and rejection, tokenization (full list below)
POVDual, Kiskeya and Sully
EndingHappy ending
Pages150 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Lacy Laurel, 3 hours 27 minutes
First publishedDecember 2019
PublisherIndependently published (Adriana Herrera)

What Is Mangos and Mistletoe About?

Mangos and Mistletoe drops two very different bakers into a holiday baking challenge in a snowy Scottish setting. Kiskeya Burgos is a professional pastry chef with a lot riding on the win and a family that has made her pay for being gay. Sully Morales is a home baker, outgoing and warm, who is finally doing something for herself after years of putting other people first.

They are paired as a team, and they do not get along. Then a shortage of beds at the hotel puts them in the same room and the same bed for the length of the competition. Between showstoppers, they argue about technique, about their shared Dominican heritage and about what each of them is willing to risk.

What Makes This Grumpy Sunshine Romance Work

Mangos and Mistletoe works because the grumpy sunshine dynamic is rooted in something real. Kiskeya is not prickly for the sake of a trope; she is guarded because her family has rejected her, and the competition is the one place she has control. Sully's warmth reads as a challenge, not a fix.

The second hook is the forced proximity. Aarya at Smart Bitches, Trashy Books gave the one bed setup a rave, noting that it lasts for several nights rather than one, which is exactly how this trope should be used.

The third is the culture. Both women are Dominican, but one grew up in the United States and one in the Dominican Republic, and the novella takes their different relationships to the island seriously. Kayla Bell at the Lesbrary praised how it holds love for a culture alongside the pain of homophobia within it, and that is what lifts this above a cute baking romance.

My Review

I read Mangos and Mistletoe in one sitting, which is both the point and the problem. Adriana Herrera packs a lot into 150 pages: a reality show, a culture clash, a family wound, a career on the line and a lot of sex. Most of it works. A few of those things needed another forty pages to land, and I closed the book wanting more of these two women.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is immediate and physical. Kiskeya and Sully clash over the bench, and the tension turns hot quickly once they are sharing a bed. Kini at Smexy Books called it a super sexy story, and Aarya at Smart Bitches, Trashy Books found the sexual payoff satisfying. I agree on both counts.

The emotional shift is faster. Kiskeya goes from wary to all in within a few days of competition, and several StoryGraph readers felt the change was rushed or not quite convincing. I believed the attraction completely. I believed the love about two thirds of the way, which for a novella is not bad, but it is the gap between good and great here.

The black moment is where I stumbled most. Aarya found the production mistake that drives the late conflict implausible for how baking shows really work, and the grovel too brief. Kini thought one plot point was thrown in and never developed. Both are right; the ending arrives a beat too soon.

The Characters

Kiskeya is the heart of the book, and she is a great grump: disciplined, proud and quietly hurting. Her backstory gives her edges a reason, and the scenes where she lets Sully see that hurt are the strongest in the novella.

Sully is harder to pin down. She is the sunshine, generous and talkative, and an Everand listener found her extroversion grating. I liked her more than that, mostly because Herrera gives her a life outside the romance: years of caregiving behind her and her own ambitions just starting. Kayla Bell praised both women's backstories, and wished, as I did, for more time with them.

The competition itself is a good supporting character. The Lesbrary review noted how the reality show setting lets the book poke at tokenization and the packaging of culture for television, which gives the stakes a sharper edge than a trophy.

Writing and Pacing

Herrera writes food like someone who loves to eat. Aarya called the baking descriptions mouthwatering, and the bakes are where the book is happiest. The prose is quick, warm and confident.

The pacing is a novella's pacing. A Lesbrary roundup of Herrera's holiday novellas gave this one 3.5 stars and noted that most of the conflict is external, which leaves less room for the relationship's own tension. That matches my read: the plot keeps the couple busy, and the book sometimes uses that busyness in place of conversation.

If you listen, the audiobook runs under three and a half hours with Lacy Laurel narrating, which makes it a neat holiday afternoon.

My honest wish list is short. I wanted one more quiet scene between the two women away from the cameras, one more conversation about Kiskeya's family, and a final act with room to breathe. None of that would stop me recommending it for a December evening with something sweet in the oven. Herrera's full length novels give her more room, and this novella is a quick, low risk way to find out whether her voice is for you. If the grump and the sunshine both click, you will know which of her longer books to try next.

Mangos and Mistletoe is a hot, flavorful sapphic holiday novella with two leads worth a full length book. Read it for the bed, the bakes and the culture; skip it if compressed endings frustrate you.

How Spicy Is Mangos and Mistletoe?

Mangos and Mistletoe is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Once Kiskeya and Sully stop fighting, there are several vivid open door sex scenes, and for a 150 page novella the heat takes up a good share of the book.

The scenes are consensual and mutual, and both women are adults with a clear sense of what they want. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from the publisher, reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Mangos and Mistletoe?

Mangos and Mistletoe suits readers who want a short, steamy sapphic holiday romance with a baking competition, two Latina leads and a one bed setup that lasts. It is less suited to readers who need a slow, fully developed emotional arc or a carefully built final conflict.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Mangos and Mistletoe has been a holiday pick in sapphic romance circles since 2019. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books gave it a B minus, Smexy Books a C, and the Lesbrary has covered it twice, once in a full review by Kayla Bell and once in a roundup of Herrera's holiday novellas. Coverage beyond that is mostly reader reviews.

Where they agree. The heat, the food and the culture. Almost every review praises the sexiness and the baking, and both Lesbrary pieces single out how the novella handles Dominican identity, immigration and homophobia without losing its holiday sparkle.

Where they split. The length and the ending. Kayla Bell simply wanted more pages. Aarya found the black moment implausible and the grovel brief, Kini thought one thread was never resolved, and StoryGraph readers split between those who loved the dual perspectives and those who found the emotional turn rushed or the two voices too alike. On Everand, one listener says she rereads it every holiday season.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Mangos and Mistletoe scores 7.3 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with strong marks for chemistry, characters and heat, and lower scores for a rushed ending and a romance that needed more room.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Immediate chemistry and a multi-night one bed setup, per Smart Bitches, Trashy Books.
Characters (15%)4Rich backstories for both leads, per Kayla Bell at the Lesbrary.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Mouthwatering bakes; novella pacing leaves the conflict thin, per the Lesbrary roundup.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Family homophobia hits hard; the emotional turn is rushed, per StoryGraph readers.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers several vivid open door scenes, per Smexy Books.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3A happy ending reached through a black moment Smart Bitches found implausible.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5Short enough for a yearly holiday reread, as one Everand listener does.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Mangos and Mistletoe is one of the most loved short sapphic holiday romances and a fine introduction to Adriana Herrera, though less complete than her full length novels, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.3/10.

Is Mangos and Mistletoe a Standalone?

Mangos and Mistletoe is a standalone novella. It does not belong to any of Adriana Herrera's numbered series, and Kiskeya and Sully's story needs no other book.

Herrera has written other sapphic holiday stories, including the erotic novella Her Night with Santa and a novella in the anthology Amor Actually, but none are direct sequels. Best format: the ebook or paperback for the baking detail, or Lacy Laurel's audiobook, at about three and a half hours. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved Mangos and Mistletoe, Read These Next

If you loved Mangos and Mistletoe, look for sapphic romances with food, forced proximity, competitions and holiday settings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Mangos and Mistletoe prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, how long it is and whether there is really only one bed. Short answers below.

Is Mangos and Mistletoe spicy?

Yes. Mangos and Mistletoe is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several vivid open door sex scenes.

How long is Mangos and Mistletoe?

Mangos and Mistletoe is a novella of about 150 pages in paperback, and the audiobook runs 3 hours 27 minutes.

Is there only one bed in Mangos and Mistletoe?

Yes. A shortage of beds at the competition hotel leaves Kiskeya and Sully sharing a bed for several nights.

Is Mangos and Mistletoe a standalone?

Yes. Mangos and Mistletoe is a standalone holiday novella.

Does Mangos and Mistletoe have a happy ending?

Yes. Mangos and Mistletoe ends happily for Kiskeya and Sully.

Who narrates the Mangos and Mistletoe audiobook?

Lacy Laurel narrates the unabridged audiobook, released in December 2020.

The Bottom Line

Mangos and Mistletoe earns a 7.3/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a short, steamy sapphic holiday romance with real food, real culture and a one bed setup that earns its keep, and who can forgive a novella for rushing its ending. The reason to pick it up is Kiskeya and Sully arguing over a bench in Scotland about what it means to come from the same island.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.