eikna romance
Menu

Make the Yuletide Gay by Ivy L. James Review

Eikna Score: 6.6/10. Recommended with reservations.

Make the Yuletide Gay is a short, sweet and slightly steamy sapphic Christmas novella that strands a junior editor and her guarded boss at a snowbound bed and breakfast with one bed. The tropes are cozy and the second half finds real feeling, but a slow, telling start and a rushed finish keep it from being more than a pleasant holiday snack.

Read it if you want an ice queen boss thawing over Christmas, or a snowed in, only one bed novella you can finish in an evening. Skip it if a workplace power imbalance between lovers bothers you, or you want a conflict with room to develop.

Make the Yuletide Gay by Ivy L. James book cover

Make the Yuletide Gay at a Glance

Make the Yuletide Gay is Ivy L. James's 2020 sapphic Christmas novella, first published as an ebook by NineStar Press and later reissued in paperback. It is a standalone that pairs a junior editor with the senior editor she is assisting, tags itself as an age gap romance, and ends happily.

AuthorIvy L. James
SeriesStandalone novella
SubgenreSapphic contemporary romance, Christmas novella
Main tropesBoss and assistant, only one bed, snowed in, ice queen, age gap
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsChildhood emotional abuse and neglect, workplace power imbalance (full list below)
POVDual, Grace and Nicola
EndingHappy ending
PagesNovella length
AudiobookNone
First publishedDecember 14, 2020 (ebook)
PublisherNineStar Press

What Is Make the Yuletide Gay About?

Make the Yuletide Gay follows Grace Taylor, a junior editor who has been made temporary assistant to senior editor Nicola Valentine. Grace has a secret crush on her new boss, which is awkward, and a work conference means she will miss Christmas with her family, which is worse.

Then a snowstorm diverts the two of them to a small bed and breakfast with a single room and a single bed. Nicola is cool, exacting and very private, and sharing a room with an assistant she is trying not to notice tests her composure. As the snow keeps falling, the walls she has built since childhood start to give.

What Makes This Boss and Assistant Romance Work

Make the Yuletide Gay works, when it works, because of Nicola. The ice queen boss is a beloved sapphic type, and James gives her a reason for the ice: a childhood of emotional abuse and neglect that left her unable to take affection at face value. Grace's crush matters because Nicola cannot quite believe anyone would feel it.

The second hook is the trope stack. Holiday travel, a snowstorm, a bed and breakfast, one room and one bed is about as cozy a setup as the genre offers, and the StoryGraph reader lezreadalot enjoyed the sheer number of tropes, the humor and the chapter titles.

The third is length. This is a novella you can read in one sitting with a hot drink, and the NetGalley listing even tags it with hot chocolate. Readers who want a quick holiday fix with a little heat will find one.

My Review

I wanted to love Make the Yuletide Gay more than I did. The setup is catnip for me, the snowbound inn is cozy, and Nicola, once she lets you in, is a genuinely affecting character. But the first chapters tell me how everyone feels instead of showing me, the best material arrives late, and the ending wraps up faster than the feelings underneath it.

Romance and Chemistry

The attraction is clear from the first page, and the shared bed does exactly what it should. The scenes once the two women stop pretending are tender and a little steamy, and gillesbianreads on StoryGraph enjoyed the sexy age gap Christmas romance on its own terms.

The speed is the problem. krunkjess on StoryGraph doubted the pace of the relationship and the believability of the first kiss, and flintsloveofbooks wished the pair had been stuck at the inn longer. I agree with both. A couple of days snowed in is a lovely premise, and the book does not quite use them.

I also could not shake the boss and assistant question. Nicola has real power over Grace's job, and the novella acknowledges it more than it wrestles with it. Some readers will not care; if you do, this will sit uneasily.

The Characters

Nicola is the reason to read. Her backstory turns her from a cold boss into a woman who has never been safe being loved, and the scenes where she tries anyway are the best in the book. The reviewer at Lez Review Books found her ornery rather than icy until the midpoint gave her depth, and that matches my experience.

Grace is sweeter and simpler. She is eager and warm, and gillesbianreads felt she was overly eager for such a short timeline. althea on StoryGraph struggled to tell the two narrators apart and sometimes lost track of who was the editor and who was the assistant, which is a real issue in a dual point of view novella.

The side cast is thin, as you would expect at this length. lostinbooks2001 found the characters lovable and their flaws a focus, while also noting a cast that is not especially diverse.

Writing and Pacing

The prose is plain and pleasant, and the humor works in small doses. Lez Review Books gave it 3.25 stars and called it a solid debut that found its feet after a rocky beginning, which is generous and fair.

The pacing is uneven. The opening is slow and leans on telling, the middle at the inn is the strongest stretch, and the ending moves too fast. lezreadalot liked the first half best and felt the novella's length left the main conflict underdeveloped, and 00leah00 on StoryGraph disliked how quickly the conflict was resolved. I would have traded the opening chapters for another day of snow.

Make the Yuletide Gay is a cozy, short sapphic Christmas romance with a boss worth thawing and a story that needed more time at the inn. Read it for the tropes and Nicola; skip it if workplace power dynamics or rushed endings bother you.

How Spicy Is Make the Yuletide Gay?

Make the Yuletide Gay is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The novella has on-page intimacy once Grace and Nicola get together, and StoryGraph readers describe it as sweet and a little sexy rather than scorching.

Both leads are adults and the intimacy is consensual, but the relationship crosses a workplace hierarchy: Nicola is Grace's boss for the length of the story. The book also tags itself as age gap, without making the gap a central theme. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from the publisher, reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Make the Yuletide Gay?

Make the Yuletide Gay suits readers who want a quick, cozy sapphic Christmas romance with an ice queen boss, a snowed in inn and only one bed. It is less suited to readers who are uneasy with workplace power imbalances or who want a fully developed conflict.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Make the Yuletide Gay is a small press novella, and its coverage is mostly reader reviews. Lez Review Books gave it 3.25 stars, and the StoryGraph reviews we read cluster between three and four stars, with an average of about 3.5.

Where they agree. The tropes and the coziness. Most readers describe it as sweet, festive and lighthearted, and several, including lezreadalot and lostinbooks2001, enjoyed the humor and the characters.

Where they split. The pacing and the leads. Lez Review Books and lezreadalot both found the opening or the conflict underdeveloped; krunkjess doubted the speed of the romance; althea found the two narrators hard to tell apart; gillesbianreads found some motivations unclear. Others, like jmontg18, found it funny and relaxing with well developed characters.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Make the Yuletide Gay scores 6.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with fair marks for its cozy romance and Nicola's arc, and lower scores for a slow start, blurred narrators and a rushed ending.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5A cozy one bed setup that moves too fast, per StoryGraph reader krunkjess.
Characters (15%)3.5Nicola gains depth at the midpoint, per Lez Review Books; Grace is thinner.
Writing and pacing (15%)3A slow, telling opening per Lez Review Books, and blurred voices per althea.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Nicola's history of neglect gives the thaw real weight.
Heat level (10%)3.5Delivers the sweet, moderate heat readers describe.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3A happy ending reached through a conflict resolved too quickly.
Reread appeal (10%)3A pleasant seasonal snack, but readers rarely mark it as a reread.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Make the Yuletide Gay sits in the middle of the sapphic holiday novella pack, cozier than it is memorable, landing at a final Eikna Score of 6.6/10.

Is Make the Yuletide Gay a Standalone?

Make the Yuletide Gay is a standalone novella. Grace and Nicola's story is complete, and no other Ivy L. James book is needed.

Several other books share the title, including an MM holiday anthology and a novella by Adriana Herrera in the Amor Actually anthology, so check the author name when you buy. Best format: ebook, which is how NineStar Press first released it; there is no audiobook edition. Our series order guide covers connected romances if you want something longer.

If You Loved Make the Yuletide Gay, Read These Next

If you loved Make the Yuletide Gay, look for sapphic romances with snowstorms, guarded heroines and a little workplace tension.

Frequently Asked Questions

Make the Yuletide Gay prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether there is only one bed and how it ends. Short answers below.

Is Make the Yuletide Gay spicy?

Moderately. Make the Yuletide Gay is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with some on-page intimacy that readers describe as sweet and a little sexy.

Is there only one bed in Make the Yuletide Gay?

Yes. A snowstorm strands Grace and Nicola at a bed and breakfast with one room and one bed.

Does Make the Yuletide Gay have a happy ending?

Yes. Make the Yuletide Gay ends happily for Grace and Nicola.

Is Make the Yuletide Gay a boss and employee romance?

Yes. Grace is a junior editor working as temporary assistant to senior editor Nicola Valentine.

Who wrote Make the Yuletide Gay?

This sapphic novella is by Ivy L. James and was published by NineStar Press in December 2020. Other books with the same title are by different authors.

Is there a Make the Yuletide Gay audiobook?

No. The Ivy L. James novella has no audiobook edition; it is available as an ebook and in paperback.

The Bottom Line

Make the Yuletide Gay earns a 6.6/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a short, cozy sapphic Christmas romance with a snowstorm, one bed and an ice queen boss, and who can accept a slow start and a fast finish. The reason to pick it up is Nicola, a woman who has never been safe being loved, slowly letting someone try.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.