New Year's Kiss by Lee Matthews Review
Eikna Score: 6.5/10. Recommended with reservations.
New Year's Kiss is a short, sweet young adult romance about a cautious girl, a boy with a broken leg and a list of ten brave things to do before midnight on New Year's Eve. The two leads are lovely together, but the book piles on obstacles and family drama until the romance has trouble breathing.
Read it if you want a quick, clean YA read for the week between Christmas and New Year's, or you like bucket-list stories about stepping out of your comfort zone. Skip it if insta-love bothers you, or you lose patience with romances that keep inventing reasons to stall.
New Year's Kiss at a Glance
New Year's Kiss is a standalone young adult romance by Lee Matthews, published in paperback by Penguin Random House's Underlined line on December 1, 2020. It is told in first person by Tess over one week at a Vermont ski resort, keeps the romance to kisses and ends on a hopeful note with an epilogue.
| Author | Lee Matthews |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone (Underlined paperback line) |
| Subgenre | Young adult holiday romance (contemporary) |
| Age range | Young adult; Kirkus suggests 13 to 17 |
| Main tropes | Bucket list, New Year's Eve deadline, shy girl and charming boy, snowbound resort, sibling conflict |
| Spice level | 1/5: Kisses only / closed door |
| Content warnings | Parental separation, injury, harsh family dynamics (full list below) |
| POV | First person, Tess |
| Ending | Happy for now, with an epilogue |
| Pages | 256 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Lillie Ricciardi, 7 hours 4 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio) |
| First published | December 1, 2020 |
| Publisher | Underlined, Penguin Random House |
What Is New Year's Kiss About?
New Year's Kiss follows Tess, a cautious list-maker who has promised herself the new year will be epic. The old year is ending badly: her parents are separating, and she and her older sister Lauren have been sent to spend the holidays at their stern grandmother's snowy resort in Vermont.
There Tess meets Christopher, a boy stuck at the lodge with a broken leg. Together they draw up a list of ten bold goals for the week, from karaoke to skiing to a possible midnight kiss. Lauren, who starts out hostile, gets pulled in too. But Christopher is hiding something, and the week is short.
What Makes This Bucket List Romance Work
New Year's Kiss works as a bucket list romance because the list gives a shy heroine permission to be brave. Tess would never sing karaoke on her own, but with a list and a partner she can. Each item is a small dare, and each one shows a little more of who she might be.
The deadline helps. Everything points toward midnight on New Year's Eve, which gives a short book a built-in clock and a satisfying target. School Library Journal liked the list structure and the family context, and the week-long frame keeps the story tight.
Christopher is a good partner for it. A broken leg keeps him off the slopes, which makes him a natural cheerleader for someone else's adventures. Kirkus found their conversations charming, and the scenes with just the two of them are the book at its best.
My Review
New Year's Kiss is a cosy book with a crowded plot. When it is just Tess and Christopher talking in a snowy lodge, it is lovely. When it remembers it has a grandmother subplot, a sister subplot, a parents subplot and a secret to reveal, it gets busy in a way a 256-page book cannot really hold.
Kirkus called it "a charming romance held back by one too many holdups," and I cannot improve on that. The romance is charming. The holdups are real.
Romance and Chemistry
Tess and Christopher click quickly, and their back-and-forth is warm and funny. Kirkus singled out their conversations, and Books, Teacup and Reviews enjoyed the voice and atmosphere. A week is not long, though, and Random Reads with Sam objected to what felt like insta-love. I understand that, but it is a holiday book for teenagers, and a week of intense company at a snowed-in resort is how a lot of teenage crushes actually feel.
My problem is less the speed than the interruptions. Kirkus felt the author added too many obstacles, and Jill's Book Blog called the late obstacle manufactured. I agree. The final conflict feels designed to keep the leads apart for a chapter rather than coming out of who they are. The romance stays sweet and clean throughout, building to a kiss-centred finish and an epilogue.
The Characters
Tess is a relatable heroine, anxious and organised, and her growth across the week is the book's real arc. Her relationship with Lauren is the strongest secondary thread: two sisters who have grown apart, slowly remembering they are on the same side while their parents' marriage ends.
The grandmother is where the book falters. Kirkus called her subplot weak, and Random Reads with Sam found the family reversals abrupt. Anna's Book Nook wanted deeper backstories across the board, and The Geekish Brunette felt the family drama was overdone. Christopher is charming but thin beyond his charm, partly because his secret keeps him from being fully known until late.
Writing and Pacing
The writing is light, readable and seasonal, with a strong sense of the snowy resort. The Southern Bookseller Review called it a brisk seasonal read and suggested it for younger teens, which feels right. It is a one or two sitting book.
Structure is the weak spot. Kirkus said the stack of obstacles gives the book an awkward shape that nearly derails it, and a half-developed subplot about Christopher's injury does not help. The ending is solid, as Kirkus also noted, and the epilogue sends readers off on a hopeful note.
New Year's Kiss is a sweet, clean YA holiday romance with charming leads and one obstacle too many. Read it for Tess and Christopher's conversations and a cosy week in the snow, and forgive the clutter.
How Spicy Is New Year's Kiss?
New Year's Kiss is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. It is a young adult novel, and the romance stays at conversation, feelings and the midnight kiss of the title.
Readers describe it as a clean romance suitable for younger teens. For more at this heat level, see our closed door romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from critic and reader reports:
- Parental separation
- A broken leg and related medical detail
- Harsh or cold family interactions
- Sibling conflict
- A past toxic relationship, mentioned by one reader
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read New Year's Kiss?
New Year's Kiss suits teen readers, especially younger teens, who want a quick, clean New Year's romance with a bucket list and a snowy resort. It is less suited to readers who dislike fast romances or busy plots full of obstacles.
Best for:
- Younger teens looking for a clean holiday romance
- Readers who love bucket list or dare structures
- Anyone wanting a short read for the week after Christmas
- Readers who enjoy sister stories alongside romance
Not for:
- Readers who dislike insta-love
- Anyone frustrated by contrived late obstacles
- Readers wanting rich backstories and deep family drama
- Those looking for adult romance heat
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
New Year's Kiss drew reviews from Kirkus and School Library Journal and a spread of YA blog coverage. Critics agree on the charm of the leads and split on the plotting.
Where they agree. The central pair and the setting. School Library Journal was positive about the list structure and family context, Kirkus praised the conversations and the ending, and Books, Teacup and Reviews enjoyed the voice and atmosphere. The Southern Bookseller Review called it a brisk seasonal read.
Where they split. Obstacles and depth. Kirkus found too many holdups and a weak grandmother subplot. Jill's Book Blog called the late obstacle manufactured, The Geekish Brunette found the drama excessive, Anna's Book Nook wanted deeper backstories, and Random Reads with Sam objected to the insta-love and abrupt family changes. StoryGraph readers are similarly mixed.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
New Year's Kiss scores 6.5 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top marks for heat, emotion and the ending, where the clean romance and the epilogue deliver, and its lowest for romance, characters, writing and reread appeal, where critics find the obstacles contrived and the backstories thin.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3 | Kirkus finds the talks charming; Random Reads with Sam sees insta-love. |
| Characters (15%) | 3 | Tess grows; Anna's Book Nook wants deeper backstories. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3 | Brisk per The Southern Bookseller Review; Kirkus calls the structure awkward. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | The sister thread and parents' split add weight, per SLJ. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers the clean, kiss-centred romance its title and age range promise. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | Kirkus calls the ending solid; Jill's Book Blog finds the late obstacle forced. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | A short seasonal read; StoryGraph readers are mixed. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: New Year's Kiss is one of the lighter YA holiday romances we cover, sweeter and simpler than Dash & Lily's Book of Dares, with a final Eikna Score of 6.5/10.
Is New Year's Kiss a Standalone?
Yes. New Year's Kiss is a standalone young adult novel with a complete story and an epilogue, so you can start here with no prior reading. It was published in Penguin Random House's Underlined paperback line, which groups books by different authors rather than forming a series.
Best format: the audiobook narrated by Lillie Ricciardi runs about seven hours and suits the first-person voice; the paperback is short enough for a single snowy afternoon. Our series order guide covers longer romance series.
If You Loved New Year's Kiss, Read These Next
If you loved New Year's Kiss, look for other clean YA holiday romances with deadlines, dares and family drama in the background.
- Dash & Lily's Book of Dares by Rachel Cohn and David Levithan: two teens daring each other across New York over the holidays.
- So, This Is Christmas by Tracy Andreen: a YA small-town Christmas with separated parents and a family inn.
- The Holiday Switch by Tif Marcelo: YA coworker rivals at a holiday inn with a secret book blog.
- Let It Snow by John Green, Maureen Johnson and Lauren Myracle: three linked YA stories in a snowbound town.
- Make My Wish Come True by Rachael Lippincott and Alyson Derrick: a sapphic YA Christmas with twelve fake holiday dates.
Frequently Asked Questions
New Year's Kiss raises the same questions for most new readers: what age it suits, whether it is clean, whether it is part of a series and whether there is an audiobook. Short answers below.
What age is New Year's Kiss for?
New Year's Kiss is a young adult novel. Kirkus suggests ages 13 to 17, and reviewers recommend it for younger teens.
Is New Year's Kiss clean?
Yes. New Year's Kiss is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, with kisses only and no sexual content.
Is New Year's Kiss part of a series?
No. New Year's Kiss is a standalone novel from Penguin Random House's Underlined paperback line.
Where is New Year's Kiss set?
New Year's Kiss is set at the heroine's grandmother's snowy resort in Vermont during the week before New Year's Eve.
Is there a New Year's Kiss audiobook?
Yes. The audiobook is narrated by Lillie Ricciardi and runs about 7 hours 4 minutes.
The Bottom Line
New Year's Kiss earns a 6.5/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for teen readers, especially younger ones, who want a short, clean holiday romance about finding the nerve to try new things. The one reason to pick it up is the list: ten small acts of courage that turn a shy girl's worst holiday into a week she will remember.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- New Year's Kiss, Kirkus Reviews
- New Year's Kiss, Penguin Random House
- New Year's Kiss audiobook, Libro.fm
- New Year's Kiss, Goodreads
- School Library Journal review; The Southern Bookseller Review
- Books, Teacup and Reviews; Anna's Book Nook; The Geekish Brunette; Jill's Book Blog; Random Reads with Sam; StoryGraph reader reviews
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.