The Christmas Orphans Club by Becca Freeman Review
Eikna Score: 7.4/10. Recommended.
The Christmas Orphans Club is a found family novel first and a romance second: four friends, a decade of New York Christmases and one last holiday before the group breaks up. The friendships feel lived in and the queer love story is tender, but the jumping timeline gives away some surprises and Hannah can be hard to like.
Read it if you want a Christmas book about the family you choose, with a slow queer romance woven through, or you love stories told across many years. Skip it if you want a romance front and center from page one, or you dislike timelines that hop back and forth.
The Christmas Orphans Club at a Glance
The Christmas Orphans Club is Becca Freeman's debut, a standalone contemporary Christmas novel published by Penguin Books on September 26, 2023. It follows four friends without families to go home to across a decade of holidays in New York, with a friends to lovers queer romance and a straight relationship in the mix, closed door heat and a hopeful ending.
| Author | Becca Freeman |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Contemporary Christmas fiction with romance (queer romantic subplot, New York City) |
| Main tropes | Found family, friends to lovers, unspoken feelings, last Christmas together, nonlinear timeline |
| Spice level | 1/5: Kisses only / closed door |
| Content warnings | Death of parents, family rejection after coming out, homophobia, grief (full list below) |
| Ending | Hopeful; the friendship story is the main arc |
| Pages | 368 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by André Santana and Brittany Pressley, about 9 hours 24 minutes (Penguin Audio) |
| First published | September 26, 2023 |
| Publisher | Penguin Books (Penguin Random House) |
What Is The Christmas Orphans Club About?
Hannah and Finn met when they were both stuck on campus over a college Christmas break. Hannah's parents have died, and Finn's family cut him off after he came out. With nowhere else to go, they invented their own holiday traditions, and when they moved to New York, the club grew to include Hannah's roommate Priya and Theo, a former hookup of Finn's who became a friend.
Now Finn has a job in Los Angeles, and this may be the last Christmas the four of them spend together. Hannah wants to make it unforgettable, even as her boyfriend, David, pushes her toward commitment and his own family's holiday. Finn has to decide whether to leave without ever telling Theo how he feels.
What Makes This Found Family Christmas Story Work
The Christmas Orphans Club works because the friendships are specific. These are not generic besties exchanging wisdom over cocoa. They have rituals, in-jokes, costume parties and pancake feasts, and Publishers Weekly praised how much feeling Freeman puts into the way relationships change over time.
The structure is the second hook. The story moves back and forth across many Christmases, so you watch the club form, fracture and patch itself together. Kirkus, reviewing the audiobook, thought the shifting timeline worked well for showing the characters grow; Publishers Weekly found it disorienting. Either way, it is a different shape from the usual one-December holiday romance.
And then there is Finn and Theo. Their friends to lovers thread, built on years of not saying the thing, is the book's most romantic element, and it gives a found family story a love story to root for.
My Review
I read The Christmas Orphans Club expecting a holiday romance and got something closer to a holiday friendship novel with romance running through it. Once I adjusted, I enjoyed it a great deal. It is warm without being saccharine, and it is honest about how scary it is when the people you chose start choosing other lives.
Romance and Chemistry
There are two romantic threads, and they are not equal. Finn and Theo's slow, unspoken attraction is the one that lands. It has history, a deadline in the form of Finn's move and the particular tension of two people who have decided not to risk a friendship. Library Journal described the novel as less about romance and more about friends growing up, which is fair, but the Finn and Theo scenes carry real charge.
Hannah and David are a harder sell. David wants commitment and a conventional holiday, Hannah wants to protect the club, and for long stretches the book makes their relationship feel like an obstacle rather than a romance. If you come for a love story centered on Hannah, you may be disappointed.
The Characters
Finn is the heart of the book, funny and wounded by a family that rejected him. Hannah is more complicated. Her grief explains her fierce grip on the club, but she can also be self-absorbed. Yvonne at Me and My Books, who gave the book two and a half stars, found her self-centered and liked her less as it went on. I liked her more by the end than at the start, which may be the point.
Priya is the weak link. Phoebe Wright at Read and Wright, who gave the book five stars, still wanted more of Priya, who feels the least developed of the four. Theo, by contrast, comes through clearly despite having less page time, largely because Finn sees him so vividly.
Writing and Pacing
Freeman writes easy, conversational prose and an affectionate New York; Library Journal said the city is fondly portrayed. The jokes are frequent and mostly land, and the holiday atmosphere is generous without tipping into Hallmark parody.
The timeline is the book's gamble. Hopping between Christmases builds a sense of history, and Read and Wright found it worked well for the reveals. Publishers Weekly called it a rocky but heartfelt debut and thought the jumps created gaps and gave away surprises. I sided with Publishers Weekly on a couple of reveals that I saw coming, but the payoff in the final Christmas still worked on me.
The Christmas Orphans Club is a warm, funny found family novel with a lovely queer slow burn and a heroine who takes some getting used to. Read it if friendship is your favorite love story; look elsewhere if you want romance as the main event.
How Spicy Is The Christmas Orphans Club?
The Christmas Orphans Club is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. Read and Wright rated it zero spice, and the romantic moments stay at kisses, closeness and confessions, with no explicit scenes. There are adult references to past hookups and drinking.
Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from reviews, reader reports and our own read:
- Death of parents and ongoing grief
- Family rejection after coming out
- Homophobia, moderate and mostly in backstory
- Fear of abandonment and friendships under strain
- Alcohol use
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read The Christmas Orphans Club?
The Christmas Orphans Club suits readers who want a cozy but emotional Christmas story about chosen family, with a queer friends to lovers romance as a strong subplot. It is less suited to readers who want a classic one-couple holiday romance, or who find nonlinear timelines frustrating.
Best for:
- Readers who love found family above all
- Fans of queer friends to lovers and slow burn
- Anyone spending the holidays away from family
- Readers who enjoy stories told across many years
- Fans of closed door romance
Not for:
- Readers who want romance as the main plot
- Anyone who dislikes back-and-forth timelines
- Readers who need every friend in an ensemble fully developed
- Anyone wanting heat (try our spicy picks)
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
The Christmas Orphans Club drew warm reviews with one recurring reservation. Publishers Weekly called it a rocky but heartfelt debut, Library Journal recommended it to fans of found family and twentysomething stories, and Kirkus praised the audiobook's steady performance by André Santana and Brittany Pressley.
Where they agree. The friendships and the feeling. Publishers Weekly said Freeman's take on how relationships evolve is full of feeling, and Read and Wright compared the book to Sunday brunch with friends.
Where they split. The timeline and Hannah. Kirkus and Read and Wright found the nonlinear structure effective; Publishers Weekly found it disorienting and spoiler-prone. Yvonne at Me and My Books found Hannah self-centered, Priya barely present and the humor forced, and several note that the romance is secondary to the friendship story.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
The Christmas Orphans Club scores 7.4 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with high marks for characters, emotional impact and ending, and a lower romance score because the love stories sit behind the friendship plot.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3 | Finn and Theo charm, but Library Journal notes it is less about romance than friendship. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Vivid, evolving friendships per Publishers Weekly; Priya is thin per Read and Wright. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Warm and funny; the timeline gives away surprises, per Publishers Weekly. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | A real ache about losing chosen family, praised across reviews. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers the closed door warmth a cozy Christmas novel promises. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A satisfying final Christmas that pays off the decade of build-up. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | A strong December comfort read once you know the reveals. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Christmas Orphans Club sits near the top of recent found family holiday novels, more emotional than most Christmas rom coms but lighter on romance, with a final Eikna Score of 7.4/10.
Is The Christmas Orphans Club a Standalone?
Yes. The Christmas Orphans Club is a standalone novel and Becca Freeman's debut, with a complete story and no required reading.
Best format: the audiobook is a strong choice. André Santana and Brittany Pressley split the narration, and Kirkus felt the back-and-forth timeline worked well in audio. In print, keep an eye on the year headings so the jumps stay clear. Our series order guide covers connected holiday romances if you want more.
If You Loved The Christmas Orphans Club, Read These Next
If you loved The Christmas Orphans Club, look for holiday stories with chosen family, queer romance and plenty of heart.
- The Holiday Trap by Roan Parrish: two queer characters swap homes for the holidays, with found family and two romances.
- You're a Mean One, Matthew Prince by Timothy Janovsky: an M/M Christmas redemption romance with forced proximity and a small-town found family.
- Season of Love by Helena Greer: a sapphic Christmas tree farm romance about grief, trauma and the family you build.
- Kiss Her Once for Me by Alison Cochrun: a sapphic Christmas fake engagement with more heat and plenty of longing.
- Boyfriend Material by Alexis Hall: a funny queer rom com with a big-hearted friend group, if you want romance in the lead.
Frequently Asked Questions
The Christmas Orphans Club leaves readers with a few common questions: whether it is a romance, how spicy it is, whether it stands alone and who ends up together. Short answers below, without spoilers.
Is The Christmas Orphans Club a romance?
Partly. It is mainly a found family novel, with a queer friends to lovers romance between Finn and Theo and Hannah's relationship with David as major threads.
Is The Christmas Orphans Club spicy?
No. It is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, with kisses and no explicit scenes.
Is The Christmas Orphans Club a standalone?
Yes. It is Becca Freeman's debut and a complete standalone story.
Is The Christmas Orphans Club LGBTQ?
Yes. Finn is gay, and his slow-burn feelings for Theo are one of the book's main romantic storylines.
Why is the timeline confusing in The Christmas Orphans Club?
The story jumps between Christmases across about a decade, so the club's history unfolds out of order alongside the present-day final holiday.
Is there a The Christmas Orphans Club audiobook?
Yes. Penguin Audio's version is narrated by André Santana and Brittany Pressley and runs about 9 hours 24 minutes.
The Bottom Line
The Christmas Orphans Club earns a 7.4/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a warm, slightly bittersweet Christmas story about the family you choose, with a tender queer romance threaded through it. The reason to pick it up is the club itself: four people who built a holiday out of nothing, and have to decide whether it can survive them growing up.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- The Christmas Orphans Club, Penguin Random House (edition and audiobook details)
- The Christmas Orphans Club, Publishers Weekly
- The Christmas Orphans Club, Library Journal
- The Christmas Orphans Club audiobook, Kirkus Reviews
- Review: The Christmas Orphans Club, Read and Wright (Phoebe Wright)
- The Christmas Orphans Club review, The Reading Cafe
- Yvonne's Shorties: The Christmas Orphans Club, Me and My Books
- The Christmas Orphans Club audiobook, Audible
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.