eikna romance
Menu

The Mistletoe Motive by Chloe Liese Review

Eikna Score: 7.0/10. Recommended.

The Mistletoe Motive is a warm, bookish holiday novella with a sharp rivals premise and some of the most considerate disability and neurodivergent representation in the genre. It is also too short for everything it wants to do, and the ending arrives in a hurry.

Read it if you love workplace rivals, secret pen pals and a bookshop at Christmas, or you already read Chloe Liese for her inclusive romances. Skip it if you want a long slow burn with room to breathe, or you find bickering leads more tiring than fun.

The Mistletoe Motive by Chloe Liese book cover

The Mistletoe Motive at a Glance

The Mistletoe Motive is a standalone holiday novella by Chloe Liese, first published by Kobo Originals on December 1, 2021. It is a contemporary rivals to lovers romance set in an independent bookshop, with moderate open door heat and a happily ever after followed by an epilogue.

AuthorChloe Liese
SeriesStandalone holiday novella
SubgenreContemporary romance (holiday, workplace)
Main tropesEnemies (rivals) to lovers, workplace rivals, anonymous online pen pals, bookshop setting, Christmas
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsAbleism, a pushy ex, near car accidents (full list below)
POVDual, Gabby and Jonathan
EndingHEA, with an epilogue
Pages185 (Kobo Originals ebook)
AudiobookKobo Originals audiobook, about 5 hours 28 minutes
First publishedDecember 1, 2021 (paperback July 2022)
PublisherKobo Originals

What Is The Mistletoe Motive About?

The Mistletoe Motive is set at Bailey's Bookshop, an independent store that is losing ground to bigger chains. Gabriella Di Natale, known as Gabby, and Jonathan Frost share the work of running it, and they cannot stand each other. When the owner sets up a December sales contest and makes it clear the shop may only be able to keep one of them, the rivalry stops being petty and starts being about rent.

Meanwhile Gabby has a friend she has never met: an anonymous, bookish correspondent online who understands her better than anyone at work. Between the contest, the holiday rush and an ex who refuses to stay gone, Gabby starts to wonder whether she has read Jonathan wrong.

What Makes This Rivals to Lovers Romance Work

The Mistletoe Motive works because its rivals to lovers romance is about two people who misread each other, not two people who are cruel. Gabby is bright, loud and warm; Jonathan is reserved, precise and easily overwhelmed by touch and smell. Each one experiences the other's way of being as hostility, and the book slowly lets both of them see it differently.

The anonymous pen pal thread is borrowed from The Shop Around the Corner and You've Got Mail, and Liese knows that you know. The fun is not the reveal, which most readers will guess early, but watching Gabby argue with a man in person while confiding in him in writing. Alex's Books felt the move from dislike to attraction came naturally despite the short length.

The setting is the other draw. Megan at Weeds + Wildflowers loved the festive bookstore atmosphere, and Andrea Reid at The Nerd Daily picked out a ladder moment straight out of Beauty and the Beast as a favourite. There is cocoa, there are shelves, and there is a chapter by chapter holiday song list. If you want a cosy setting with your enemies to lovers romance, this is it.

My Review

I liked The Mistletoe Motive more for its people than its plot. Chloe Liese has made her name with romances where disabled and neurodivergent characters get to be desirable, funny and difficult, and this novella does that in miniature. Gabby is demisexual and neurodivergent, as Liese has said, and Jonathan has type 1 diabetes. Neither is a lesson. Both are simply how these two people move through a crowded shop in December.

Where it falls short is room. At 185 pages, the book has to do a contest, a pen pal plot, an ex, a bookshop in trouble, a romance and a happy ending. It does all of them, but some only just. The Nerd Daily found it too short and the early bickering too long, and those two complaints go together: the opening spends pages on friction that the ending could have used.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is good once it starts. Jen at Under the Covers praised the slow burn and the physical pull, and Kellisa Mirabel at K-Squared Reads called it steamy and praised the banter. I agree with both about the second half. The first half is where opinions split. Some StoryGraph readers did not buy the turn from rivals to lovers and found the leads more irritated than charged. The early arguments do repeat, and I wanted one more scene of the two of them being kind to each other before they kissed.

Jonathan is the stronger lead. His care is shown in small practical things, and the details Under the Covers praised, from the tubing of his insulin pump to his sensitivity to touch and smell, make the love scenes feel specific to him.

The Characters

Gabby is a lot, on purpose. She talks fast, feels fast and assumes the worst about Jonathan for a long time. The anonymous friend plot keeps her from looking foolish, because we see what she can be with someone she trusts. Megan at Weeds + Wildflowers singled out the vulnerability and humour in both leads, and I think that balance is Liese's real skill.

The supporting cast is thin, which is normal for a novella. The ex who will not take no for an answer is more device than person, and Llama Reads Books flagged him as a content note rather than a character. The shop's owner and coworkers sketch the stakes and then step aside.

Writing and Pacing

Liese's prose is clean and warm, and the dual point of view does what it should: each chapter corrects the misreadings of the last. The pacing is uneven. The setup is leisurely, the middle is good, and the ending crams a lot into a few chapters. Kellisa Mirabel found the ending rushed, and I share that view. The epilogue, which Andrea Reid at The Nerd Daily enjoyed, helps a lot by giving the couple some settled time together.

The Mistletoe Motive is a sweet, steamy and thoughtfully inclusive bookshop romance squeezed into a novella that is slightly too small for it. Read it if you want a quick, cosy holiday story with real representation, and do not expect the depth of a full Liese novel.

How Spicy Is The Mistletoe Motive?

The Mistletoe Motive is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. Most of the book is tension and banter. Once the couple gets together there is consensual, on-page intimacy between the adult leads, which K-Squared Reads called steamy, though The Nerd Daily noted fewer steamy scenes than in Liese's Bergman Brothers books.

Some StoryGraph readers felt the shift into sexual intimacy came quickly after the rivalry. For more at this level, see our spicy romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from Kobo's description and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Mistletoe Motive?

The Mistletoe Motive suits readers who want a short, cosy, steamy holiday romance with bookish leads and honest representation. It is less suited to readers who want a slow burn with time to develop, or a full length novel's worth of plot.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Mistletoe Motive was reviewed mainly by romance bloggers and readers, not trade journals, and the response is broadly warm. The Nerd Daily gave it 9 out of 10, and most bloggers named the representation and the bookshop as highlights.

Where they agree. The setting and the representation. Under the Covers, Weeds + Wildflowers and K-Squared Reads all praised how Gabby's neurodivergence and Jonathan's diabetes are written, and The Nerd Daily called it a short, fun and festive holiday read. Alex's Books found the shift from dislike to attraction natural.

Where they split. Pacing and chemistry. K-Squared Reads and The Nerd Daily both felt the ending came too fast, and The Nerd Daily found the early bickering overlong and the pen pal identity too obvious. Some StoryGraph readers rejected the enemies to lovers label altogether and found the chemistry and the turn to intimacy unconvincing. Llama Reads Books stuck to the festive appeal and flagged the content notes.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Mistletoe Motive scores 7.0 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its highest mark is for characters, where reviewers praise the representation, and its lowest is for the ending, which K-Squared Reads and The Nerd Daily both found rushed.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Strong second half chemistry per Under the Covers; some StoryGraph readers unconvinced early.
Characters (15%)4Specific, warmly written representation praised by Weeds + Wildflowers and K-Squared Reads.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Clean dual POV; The Nerd Daily finds the bickering overlong.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Cosy and tender rather than deep, as a novella this short must be.
Heat level (10%)3.5Delivers the steam K-Squared Reads promised, lighter than the Bergman books.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3A clear HEA and epilogue, but the final chapters feel rushed.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A quick seasonal reread for the bookshop setting and playlist.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Mistletoe Motive is a pleasant side dish next to Chloe Liese's full length Bergman Brothers novels rather than one of her best books, and it lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.0/10.

Is The Mistletoe Motive a Standalone?

The Mistletoe Motive is a standalone holiday novella with no series number and no required reading. It is not part of Chloe Liese's Bergman Brothers series, so you can read it with no background at all.

Best format: the ebook, which is short enough to read in an evening, or the Kobo Originals audiobook at about five and a half hours. A paperback followed in July 2022. If you finish it wanting more of Liese's style, the Bergman Brothers books are the next step. Our series order guide covers longer series if you want something to binge after.

If You Loved The Mistletoe Motive, Read These Next

If you loved The Mistletoe Motive, look for romances with workplace rivals, bookish or holiday settings and leads who start out misreading each other.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Mistletoe Motive raises a handful of common questions, mostly about how it ends, how spicy it is and whether it belongs to a series. Short answers below, without major spoilers.

How does The Mistletoe Motive end?

The Mistletoe Motive ends with a happily ever after for Gabby and Jonathan, followed by an epilogue set after they are together. Reviewers agree the ending is happy but some found it rushed.

Does The Mistletoe Motive have an epilogue?

Yes. The epilogue jumps ahead past the main story and shows the couple settled, which The Nerd Daily singled out as a highlight.

Is The Mistletoe Motive spicy?

Moderately. It is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with consensual open door intimacy in the second half, lighter than Chloe Liese's Bergman Brothers novels.

Is The Mistletoe Motive part of the Bergman Brothers series?

No. It is a standalone holiday novella with its own characters and no required reading.

Is The Mistletoe Motive like You've Got Mail?

Yes, in shape. Two bookshop rivals clash in person while one of them confides in an anonymous online friend, much like The Shop Around the Corner and You've Got Mail.

Is there a Mistletoe Motive audiobook?

Yes. Kobo Originals released an audiobook that runs about five and a half hours.

The Bottom Line

The Mistletoe Motive earns a 7.0/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a short, steamy, bookish Christmas romance with leads who are rarely written this well. The one reason to pick it up is Jonathan and Gabby themselves: two people who have been misreading each other for years, finally getting the chance to read each other properly.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.