Overall ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ 4.17 Goodreads average, about 1.46 million ratings
- ✓ Highest average in the Off-Campus series
- ✓ Source of Prime's 2026 Off Campus series
- ✓ Coercive opening dominates low-star reviews
The Deal Review: Spice, Content Notes and Off-Campus Order
This review contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Eikna Romance earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A funny, fast college hockey romance with banter readers adore and a hero who earns his fan base, held back by a pushy opening that critics call coercive and a casual locker-room sexism that dates it.
Best for: Readers who want a fake dating setup that turns real at a good clip, explicit scenes with real feeling behind them and a hockey team worth meeting, and who can forgive a 2015 new adult voice and a hero who won't take no for an answer in the first chapters.
Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5, explicit; romance.io's band could not be confirmed, so we scored it from Bookish Goblin's 4 of 5 spice rating across seven spicy chapters and ScreenWise's note that the scenes are detailed and frequent)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.9/5, a 4.17 Goodreads average across about 1.46 million ratings, pulled down because the one-star and two-star reviews keep naming the same two problems: Garrett pressuring Hannah into the deal, and the book's casual misogyny)
Tropes: Fake dating, Tutoring deal, College hockey captain, Jock and the music major, Sexual assault survivor heroine, Abusive sports father, Friends to lovers, Hockey team found family, Dual first-person POV, Third-act breakup.
The Deal is the first of Elle Kennedy's five Off-Campus novels, a new adult sports romance set at the fictional Briar University in which Hannah Wells, a music student who keeps her guard up for good reasons, agrees to tutor Garrett Graham, the hockey captain who needs a pass in ethics to stay on the ice, in exchange for a fake relationship meant to catch the attention of the guy she actually likes.
The numbers are huge. Goodreads shows a 4.17 average from about 1.46 million ratings and more than 122,000 written reviews, the highest average and the largest count in the series. Kennedy first published it herself in February 2015; it now carries a Piatkus tie-in edition marked as an Amazon Prime original series and a Sourcebooks collector's hardcover from July 2025. Prime Video's Off Campus adaptation premiered on May 13, 2026, and Amazon said it reached 36 million viewers in its first 12 days. Readers agree the book is fun. They argue about whether the hero is charming or coercive, and that argument is the thing worth understanding before you start.
What Is The Deal About?
This is a campus comedy with a serious spine. Most of the page time goes to study sessions, parties, hockey house banter and two people who are funnier together than either expected. Kennedy writes in first person and alternates between Hannah and Garrett, so the reader hears both the jock swagger and the second thoughts behind it, which is a big part of why readers who expected a stock athlete hero end up praising him.
Underneath the jokes sit two heavy backstories. Hannah is a survivor of a sexual assault in her teens, and the book treats her recovery, and how she approaches sex and trust, as part of the romance rather than a footnote. Garrett's father is a former hockey star who controls and abused him. Readers who come for the fake dating get a book that spends real time on both, and how well it handles that weight is where praise and criticism split.
What Makes This College Hockey Fake Dating Romance Work
- The banter: Banter and dialogue are the most named strengths in the five-star Goodreads reviews we checked, ahead of the hero himself.
- Garrett as narrator: His chapters show the doubt under the swagger, and several reviewers call him one of the best heroes they've read.
- Hannah's recovery: Under the Covers praises how Hannah faces her fears head on, and Book Binge says Garrett handles her history with care.
- The hockey house: Logan, Dean and Tucker win readers over fast, and fans say they went straight on to the sequels for them.
- Speed of the read: Reviewers keep calling it addictive and fast, and a Barrie Public Library teen reviewer even wished it slowed down.
Book Synopsis
Briar University. Hannah Wells is a music student with a showcase to prepare for, a tight circle of friends and a crush she hasn't acted on: Justin Kohl, a football player who barely knows she exists. She has her reasons for keeping men at a distance, and she has gotten good at it. What she hasn't planned for is the hockey captain who sits near her in Philosophical Ethics.
Garrett Graham is Briar's hockey captain, a player with a pro future and a father who once played the same game at the same level and never lets him forget it. He has just failed an ethics exam, and if he can't pass the retake, he loses his place on the team. Hannah is doing well in the class, so Garrett asks her to tutor him. She says no. He asks again, and keeps asking, with a persistence she finds more irritating than flattering.
Then Garrett finds the leverage. He has noticed who Hannah keeps watching, and he knows how guys like Justin think: nothing makes a woman more interesting to a man than another man's interest. So he makes an offer. Hannah tutors him through the retake, and in return Garrett pretends to date her where Justin can see it. She agrees, and the arrangement goes better than either of them planned. The study sessions turn into long conversations, the fake dates turn into real fun, and the attraction neither of them planned makes it very hard to remember who the performance is for.
Our Review
The banter is the reason this book has 1.46 million ratings, and it holds up. Kennedy gives Hannah a dry, defensive wit and Garrett a cocky one, and their early fights are the funniest stretch in the book. In the five-star Goodreads reviews we sampled, banter and chemistry come up more than anything else, and the word readers keep reaching for is addictive. This is a book people finish in a sitting and then buy the next one.
We may earn a commission from purchases through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The second strength is how the book handles Hannah's past. Her assault is recounted rather than shown in the present story, and the romance is built around Garrett learning to follow her lead. Under the Covers singles out Hannah for facing her fears head on, Book Binge says Garrett handles her history with care, and that care is what lifts a fairly standard jock hero into a fan favourite. The dual first-person POV helps here: we hear Garrett working out what he's allowed to want.
Where it struggles is the opening, and that is the dominant complaint by a distance. Garrett refuses to accept Hannah's no about the tutoring and pushes until she gives in, and the one-star and two-star reviews on Goodreads name this again and again as harassment framed as romance. Behind it come the secondary problems: several critical reviewers count casual misogyny and slut-shaming in the hockey players' talk, at least four object to how the book treats a survivor's recovery, including scenes where Hannah is pressed to drink, and the trigger warning database lists blackmail and domestic violence. One reader also flags a Nazi Germany reference in an ethics assignment as glib.
Reset one expectation before you start. The TikTok marketing and the Prime tie-in covers sell a fluffy campus romance. It's funny, but it's a 2015 new adult novel with an explicit sex life, an abusive father and a rape backstory, and ScreenWise calls it an adult book for readers 17 or 18 and up despite the college setting. If you came from the show, know that the book is first person, rougher in its humor and more focused on one couple. If you've only heard it's problematic, know that the critics are a loud minority under a 4.17 average.
The third act divides readers less than the first, but it's the familiar shape. A forced separation late in the book is driven by outside pressure rather than a fight between the leads, and readers who dislike third-act breakups will groan. The payoff is a full happy ending and a father plot that resolves rather than lingers.
It is also the high point of the series by the numbers. The Deal sits at 4.17 on Goodreads; The Score is the only other main book above 4, at 4.11, while The Mistake sits at 3.91 and The Goal at 3.82.
Our honest note: A funny, warm, explicit college romance whose hero only becomes lovable after a first act that a vocal minority of readers can't get past. Read it if you want the Off-Campus original and the source of the show; skip it if a man who ignores a no in chapter one ruins the rest for you.
| Element | In The Deal |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Hannah Wells, a music student and assault survivor, and Garrett Graham, Briar's hockey captain |
| Core tropes | Fake dating, tutoring deal, jock and artist, sports father villain, third-act breakup |
| Setting | Briar University, a fictional college, and its hockey house |
| Heat level | 4/5, explicit, roughly seven spicy chapters starting around the halfway point |
| Series | Off-Campus #1 of 5 main books plus two novellas; the couple resolves here, no cliffhanger |
| Content notes | Past sexual assault of a teenager (recounted, with a flashback), physical and emotional child abuse, domestic violence, blackmail, alcohol pressure, misogyny and slut-shaming, off-page death of a parent from cancer |
How Spicy Is The Deal?
Spicy, and more than the cover suggests. Bookish Goblin rates it 4 of 5 for spice and lists seven spicy chapters, 16, 24, 25, 27, 29, 36 and 37, and ScreenWise says the sex is detailed and frequent rather than faded to black. The first half runs on tension and a few kisses; once the fake relationship turns physical, the scenes come regularly and are on the page. We score it 4. It isn't wall to wall, but it is fully explicit.
The heat is tied to Hannah's story, which matters for how you read it. Her early scenes with Garrett are about her deciding what she wants after an assault, and fans read them as tender and careful. Some critics read the same thread as the old idea of a man fixing a damaged woman with sex. If that framing is a concern, our content warnings guide explains how we flag this kind of material, and the show is a different, ensemble take on the same story.
Who Should Read This Book?
You'll likely love it if: you want a fake dating romance with real banter, you like hockey teams and the friendships inside them, you want explicit scenes with feeling, and you came to the book from the Prime show.
You may want to skip it if: a hero who badgers the heroine until she agrees is a dealbreaker, locker-room talk about women will spoil the jokes for you, or a rape backstory isn't something you want in a romance right now.
In short: the book that started the college hockey boom, funnier and hotter than its imitators, with a 2015 attitude problem you should know about going in.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)
The conversation around The Deal has had three lives. It started as a 2015 self-published new adult hit, became a TikTok backlist favourite that publishers now market by that name, and since May 2026 has been the source of a Prime Video series. Amazon renewed Off Campus for a second season in February 2026, three months before the first premiered, and TVLine reports a Rotten Tomatoes critics score of 93 percent. Each wave has brought new readers who arrive expecting different books. We could not open Reddit or StoryGraph for this review, so the discussion here comes from Goodreads reviews, blogs, a trigger warning database and parent guides.
Why readers love it: Readers love Garrett and they love the jokes. Five-star reviews name the banter and the chemistry most, and Garrett's mix of arrogance and care gets repeated praise as the best version of the jock hero. Hannah gets credit for intelligence and for refusing to let him walk over her, which Book Binge calls out directly. The hockey house is the third draw: Logan, Dean and Tucker make the found family feel lived in, and a lot of readers say they started The Mistake the same night.
What readers argue about and complain about: The complaint is Garrett's persistence, and it isn't close. Goodreads reviewers including Whitney Atkinson and manju describe him ignoring Hannah's refusals until she gives in, and one notes that she knows she's being pressured and agrees anyway. The second recurring complaint is misogyny: talk about women's bodies and intelligence that nobody in the book challenges. A third group, smaller but serious, objects to the survivor plot, arguing that pressure to drink and a man healing a broken woman are tropes a book about assault shouldn't lean on. Fans answer that Garrett's arc moves away from that opening and that the book is a product of its year; both camps agree the first chapters are the weakest.
The series question worth asking first: This one stands on its own. Hannah and Garrett get a full happy ending and there's no cliffhanger. The Off-Campus order is The Deal, The Mistake, The Score, The Goal and The Legacy, with two novellas, The Pact (2.5) and The Incident (3.5), and each main book follows a different couple from the same circle. The Mistake, Logan's book, has a 3.91 average from about 854,000 ratings, and The Score, with Dean and Allie, rebounds to 4.11. Goodreads also lists a Briar U spin-off. You can stop after book one, but most readers don't.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Deal by Elle Kennedy spicy?
Yes. It's explicit, with about seven spicy chapters by Bookish Goblin's count, most in the second half. We score it 4 out of 5.
Does The Deal have a sexual assault storyline?
Yes. Hannah was raped as a teenager before the story begins. It's recounted rather than happening in the present, with a flashback, and her recovery shapes the romance. Domestic violence and child abuse also feature through Garrett's father.
What is the Off-Campus reading order?
The Deal, The Mistake, The Score, The Goal, then The Legacy. The novellas The Pact and The Incident sit at 2.5 and 3.5. Each book follows a new couple, so you can read them as standalones.
Is The Deal on Amazon Prime?
Yes. Prime Video's Off Campus adapts The Deal in season 1, which premiered all eight episodes on May 13, 2026, with Ella Bright as Hannah and Belmont Cameli as Garrett. Season 2 was renewed in February 2026, and TVLine expects it around spring 2027.
Is The Deal appropriate for teens?
Not for younger teens. ScreenWise calls it an adult book for readers 17 or 18 and up because of the explicit sex and the assault backstory, even though it's set at college.
Does The Deal have a happy ending?
Yes. Hannah and Garrett end together with a full happily ever after and no cliffhanger, after a late separation driven by outside pressure.
If You Loved The Deal, Read These Next
For more college hockey with the heat turned up, read Icebreaker, another spicy BookTok college hockey romance. If you want the same sport with a professional league and a longer burn, try Heated Rivalry. And for a hockey romance told by a grown-up couple instead of college kids, pick up Mile High.
Browse more in fake dating romance, sports romance and spicy romance.
The Bottom Line
The Deal sets out to make a fake dating comedy carry a survivor's story, and it mostly pulls it off. What works: the banter, Garrett's chapters and a hockey house you want to spend five books with. What doesn't: a hero who badgers the heroine into the deal, locker-room sexism nobody answers, and a third-act breakup you'll see coming. If you can read it as a 2015 new adult book and enjoy it on those terms, it's the best of its series and the source of the show. If that opening will sour you, start with the Prime adaptation instead.
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, The Deal ranks as a genre-defining college sports romance, strongest in its banter and its care with Hannah's past, constrained by a coercive opening and dated sexism, and best approached as a fun, explicit series opener rather than a model of modern consent.
The Evidence Scorecard
Eight dimensions, each scored out of 5 from the reader and critic evidence above. Overall is anchored on the reader ratings and adjusted for how much the recurring complaints cost the reading experience. Heat describes how explicit the book is; it is not a quality judgement. Every line marked ✓ is a checked finding, including the limits. How we assess books.
Romance ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ Banter and chemistry most named in raves
- ✓ Fake dating turns real at a good pace
- ✓ Dual POV shows both sides falling
- ✓ Garrett's pressure in act one sours it for critics
Characters ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Garrett called one of the best heroes
- ✓ Hannah praised for standing up to him
- ✓ Logan, Dean and Tucker win readers fast
- ✓ Hockey players' sexism goes unchallenged
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Fast, funny first-person voice
- ✓ Readers call it addictive in one sitting
- ✓ Humor praised across a decade of reviews
- ✓ Dated new adult phrasing and jokes
Emotional impact ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ Hannah's recovery praised by blog reviewers
- ✓ Abusive father thread gives Garrett depth
- ✓ Both backstories resolve on the page
- ✓ Critics object to man-fixes-survivor framing
Heat level ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Bookish Goblin rates spice 4 of 5
- ✓ Seven spicy chapters, from chapter 16
- ✓ ScreenWise: detailed and frequent, not faded
- ✓ First half mostly tension and kisses
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Full HEA, no cliffhanger
- ✓ Father plot resolves rather than lingers
- ✓ Couple's story closes in this book
- ✓ Third-act breakup follows a familiar shape
Re-read value ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ 1.46 million ratings and still growing
- ✓ Readers move straight on to The Mistake
- ✓ New tie-in and collector's editions since 2023
- ✓ Low-star readers rarely give it a second try
Sources We Checked
- Goodreads: The Deal (Off-Campus #1)
- Goodreads: The Deal two-star reviews
- Goodreads: The Deal five-star reviews
- Goodreads: Off-Campus series page (ratings for all books)
- Hachette New Zealand: The Deal (Piatkus editions)
- Indigo: The Deal Collector's Edition (Sourcebooks, 2025)
- Wikipedia: Elle Kennedy
- TV Insider Swooon: Off Campus books ranked (couples per book)
- Bookish Goblin: The Deal summary and review (dual POV)
- Newsweek: Off Campus season 1 release date and how to watch
- TheWrap: Prime Video renews Off Campus ahead of premiere
- TVLine: Off Campus and Heated Rivalry
- Serienjunkies: Off Campus reaches 36 million viewers
- ComingSoon: Off Campus early reviews
- Vocal Geeks: differences between The Deal and Off Campus season 1
- Trigger Warning Database: The Deal
- ScreenWise: The Deal parent review
- Bookish Goblin: The Deal summary, review and spicy chapters
- Under the Covers: Is The Deal worth the hype
- Book Binge: The Deal review
- Book Binge: Summer Reading Challenge review of The Deal
- Barrie Public Library teen review: The Deal
- romance.io (blocked to our fetcher; steam band not confirmed)
- Reddit r/RomanceBooks (blocked to our fetcher; not used)
Checked October 6, 2026. Ratings and counts change; the numbers above are as of that date.
Affiliate disclosure: Eikna Romance is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.