At First Spite by Olivia Dade Review
Eikna Score: 8.2/10. Recommended.
At First Spite is Olivia Dade at her warmest and funniest: a jilted heroine moves into a ten-foot-wide spite house next to the man who talked her fiancé out of marrying her, and her revenge campaign of loud, racy audiobooks turns into a tender romance about depression and grief. It runs long and some jokes overstay, but the emotional honesty makes it one of her best.
Read it if you love prank-war enemies to lovers, a kind hero with real regret and a romance that takes mental health seriously. Skip it if you want a short, frothy rom-com, or the hero being the ex-fiancé's brother is a dealbreaker.
At First Spite at a Glance
At First Spite is Olivia Dade's 2024 contemporary romance and book 1 of her Harlot's Bay series, published by Avon on February 13, 2024. It follows a jilted heroine in a tiny spite house and the brother of her ex-fiancé next door, and it ends with a happily ever after. The trade paperback runs 400 pages.
| Author | Olivia Dade |
|---|---|
| Series | Harlot's Bay, book 1 (a complete love story) |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy, small town |
| Main tropes | Enemies to lovers, neighbors, ex-fiancé's brother, revenge pranks, slow build |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | Clinical depression, grief for a sibling who died in infancy, accidental overdose (past), frequent profanity (full list below) |
| POV | Third person, Athena and Matthew |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 400 (trade paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Joy Nash, 12 hours 42 minutes (Avon) |
| First published | February 13, 2024 |
| Publisher | Avon |
What Is At First Spite About?
At First Spite opens at Athena Greydon's engagement party, where she meets Matthew Vine and only later learns he is her fiancé's older brother, and that he has been working to stop the wedding. Eight months later, the engagement is over, and Athena has sunk her savings into a tiny house in Harlot's Bay that was meant to be a wedding gift.
The house is a spite house, ten feet wide and wedged between her ex's property and Matthew's, and Athena moves in anyway. She plans to make Matthew's life miserable, starting with racy audiobooks played very loudly. Matthew, though, keeps turning out to be kind and helpful, and he is quietly struggling with feelings for the woman he talked his brother out of marrying.
What Makes This Enemies to Lovers Romance Work
At First Spite works because the spite is funny and the hurt is real. Athena has every right to be angry, and her pranks are petty in the best way. Matthew earns her contempt and then, slowly, her trust, and the shift is built from many small acts of care rather than one grand gesture. Publishers Weekly called the book equal parts hilarious and heartfelt.
The second hook is the depth. Athena is living with clinical depression she has not yet named, and Matthew is still grieving a baby brother who died decades ago. Maria Rose at All About Romance praised the portrayal of therapy alongside Matthew's support, and Kirkus, while mixed on the romance, valued the depiction of depression.
Third, the setting. Harlot's Bay is a small town with a sense of humor about its own name, and the spite house itself is a perfect romance object: absurd, symbolic and very hard to move out of.
My Review
At First Spite is the kind of romance I want to hand to people who think the genre is all fluff. Olivia Dade has written a book that is genuinely silly, with a heroine blasting erotic audiobooks at her neighbor, and genuinely serious about how depression hides in plain sight. That it manages both without whiplash is a real achievement.
Romance and Chemistry
The enemies to lovers arc is a slow thaw. Athena's hostility is earned and Matthew's guilt is real, so their early exchanges have bite. What makes the romance work is that Matthew pays attention: he notices what Athena needs before she does, and Publishers Weekly praised the deep understanding of each other's anxieties that grows between them. Sofia at Inked Odyssey saw the two helping each other change, and that is the shape of it.
Kirkus found the romance uneven, and there is something to that. The book is long, and the middle loops. Kristina at Bookish Delights liked Matthew but questioned whether his boundaries get the same care he gives Athena's, which is a sharp point I had not considered until I read it. Book bruin praised the tenderness but found the book long and had reservations about the ex-fiancé's late return to the conflict.
The Characters
Athena is wonderful: furious, funny, frightened of her own sadness and stubbornly alive. Dade writes her depression without melodrama, from the vague wish to disappear to the slow decision to seek help, and Maria Rose found that growth credible. Matthew is a careful, buttoned-up man carrying old grief, and his kindness reads as a choice rather than a personality default.
Lieselotte, commenting at All About Romance, valued the characters' lives outside the romance, and the supporting cast does give the town texture. Harlequin Junkie praised the complexity of both protagonists.
The brothers' history is the quiet engine under the comedy. Matthew carries an old family loss, and Dade lets that grief shape him without excusing what he did to Athena. Athena does not forgive him because his reasons are sad; she forgives him because he keeps showing up and doing better. That distinction is why the romance feels earned rather than convenient.
Writing and Pacing
Dade's voice is warm, wordy and very funny, with frequent profanity used, in her own words, lovingly. Kirkus felt some jokes and pop culture references ran on too long, and I agree that the book could lose fifty pages without losing anything essential. Beereadsbooks at Cannonball Read did not finish, unconvinced by the premise and a protective gesture early on. If the spite house setup does not charm you in the first chapters, the book may not either.
At First Spite is a funny, generous and emotionally brave small-town romance about revenge, depression and the kindness that undoes both. Read it if you want laughs and real feeling; skip it if you need your rom-coms short and light.
How Spicy Is At First Spite?
At First Spite is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Olivia Dade's own content guidance describes the book as steamy, with graphic sex scenes and other sexual references, and the racy audiobooks Athena plays add plenty of suggestive humor. The love scenes are consensual and arrive after a long build.
One reader, Kristina at Bookish Delights, disliked some of the sexual dialogue, so know that the talk is frank. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the author's content guidance and reviews:
- Clinical depression, including a passive wish to disappear (no suicidal ideation, per the author), and seeking treatment
- Grief over the hero's infant brother, who died of an accidental drug overdose about thirty years earlier
- A broken engagement and family conflict
- Frequent strong language
- Graphic sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read At First Spite?
At First Spite suits readers who want a funny, steamy enemies to lovers romance in a small town, with a kind hero, a heroine living with depression and real emotional depth. It is less suited to readers who prefer short, light rom-coms or are uneasy with a romance involving an ex's brother.
Best for:
- Fans of prank-war enemies to lovers
- Readers who want depression portrayed honestly in romance
- Anyone who loves a gentle, attentive hero
- Readers who enjoy quirky small town settings
Not for:
- Readers who want a short, breezy read
- Anyone uncomfortable with a hero who is the ex-fiancé's brother
- Readers who dislike frequent profanity
- Anyone looking for closed-door romance (try our closed door picks)
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
At First Spite was warmly received. Publishers Weekly called it the adorable opener to the Harlot's Bay series, and All About Romance, Harlequin Junkie and Inked Odyssey were all positive, while Kirkus was more mixed.
Where they agree. The emotional depth and the humor together. Maria Rose at All About Romance praised the therapy portrayal and the happy ending; Harlequin Junkie loved the mix of playfulness and difficult feelings; Sofia at Inked Odyssey valued the blend of humor and hard material. Even Kirkus admired the depiction of depression.
Where they split. Length and the romance's balance. Kirkus found the romance uneven and some jokes overextended. Book bruin thought the book long and questioned the ex's late return. Kristina at Bookish Delights wanted Matthew's boundaries considered as carefully as Athena's and disliked some sexual dialogue. Beereadsbooks at Cannonball Read did not finish, unconvinced by the premise.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
At First Spite scores 8.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for characters and emotional impact and a lower score for a long, loose middle.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Deep mutual understanding per Publishers Weekly; uneven per Kirkus. |
| Characters (15%) | 4.5 | Credible growth for both leads, per All About Romance. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Warm and very funny, but long, with jokes that overstay per Kirkus. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4.5 | Depression and grief handled with honesty and care. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Steamy and graphic, as the author's guidance promises. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A satisfying HEA, praised by Maria Rose at All About Romance. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 4 | The pranks and the tenderness both hold up on a second read. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: At First Spite is one of Olivia Dade's strongest books and a top-tier small-town rom-com of 2024, with a final Eikna Score of 8.2/10.
Harlot's Bay Reading Order
At First Spite is book 1 of Olivia Dade's Harlot's Bay series, and its love story is complete. The next book follows a different couple in the same town.
- At First Spite (2024)
- Second Chance Romance
Start here. Best format: print or ebook if you like to savor Dade's jokes, or the audiobook narrated by Joy Nash, which runs 12 hours 42 minutes and suits a book whose plot involves audiobooks. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved At First Spite, Read These Next
If you loved At First Spite, look for funny, emotionally honest romances with kind heroes and heroines who refuse to shrink.
- Teach Me by Olivia Dade: Dade's earlier slow-burn romance between two teachers, just as kind and quieter.
- Chick Magnet by Emma Barry: neighbors in a small town and a hero facing depression with help.
- The Hating Game by Sally Thorne: the modern classic of petty, escalating enemies to lovers warfare.
- The Heart Principle by Helen Hoang: burnout, grief and a romance that treats mental health seriously.
- Get a Life, Chloe Brown by Talia Hibbert: a prickly heroine, the building superintendent she misjudges and lots of humor.
Frequently Asked Questions
At First Spite raises the same questions for most readers: how spicy it is, what the spite house is and what the series order is. Short answers below.
Is At First Spite spicy?
Yes. At First Spite is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, and the author describes it as steamy, with graphic sex scenes.
Is At First Spite enemies to lovers?
Yes. Athena starts out waging a prank war on Matthew, the man who talked her fiancé out of marrying her.
Does At First Spite have a happy ending?
Yes. Athena and Matthew get a happily ever after.
What is a spite house in At First Spite?
It is Athena's tiny, ten-foot-wide house, squeezed between her ex's property and Matthew's.
Is At First Spite part of a series?
Yes. At First Spite is book 1 of Olivia Dade's Harlot's Bay series, followed by Second Chance Romance.
Who narrates the At First Spite audiobook?
Joy Nash narrates the audiobook, which runs 12 hours 42 minutes.
The Bottom Line
At First Spite earns an 8.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a steamy, funny enemies to lovers romance with real emotional weight, a gentle hero and a heroine finding her way through depression. The reason to pick it up is the spite house itself: a ten-foot-wide act of revenge that becomes the place two people learn to be kind.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Harlot's Bay series, Olivia Dade (author site)
- Content guidance, Olivia Dade (author site)
- At First Spite, Hachette UK
- At First Spite, Publishers Weekly review
- At First Spite audiobook, Libro.fm (narrator, length)
- At First Spite, Kirkus Reviews
- At First Spite, All About Romance (Maria Rose)
- Review: At First Spite, book bruin
- At First Spite book review, Bookish Delights (Kristina)
- Review: At First Spite, Harlequin Junkie
- Review: At First Spite, Inked Odyssey (Sofia)
- At First Spite and Second Chance Romance, Cannonball Read (beereadsbooks)
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.