eikna romance
Menu

Off the Map by Trish Doller Review

Eikna Score: 7.0/10. Recommended.

Off the Map sends a woman who never stays anywhere on a winding drive across Ireland with the one man who has never left, and the scenery alone makes the trip worthwhile. It is the steamiest and most restless Beck Sisters book, with a sharp, sometimes abrasive heroine and a father-daughter thread that hits harder than the romance.

Read it if you want a travel romance with gorgeous Irish backroads, early heat and a heroine who is blunt to a fault. Skip it if you need a slow build before the first sex scene, or a prickly heroine will wear on you.

Off the Map by Trish Doller book cover

Off the Map at a Glance

Off the Map is the third and final Beck Sisters novel by Trish Doller, published by St. Martin's Griffin on March 7, 2023. Nomadic traveler Carla Black arrives in Ireland for her best friend's wedding and takes a long way round with the groom's brother. It is steamy, reads on its own and ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorTrish Doller
SeriesBeck Sisters, book 3 (reads as a standalone)
SubgenreContemporary romance, travel romance
Main tropesRoad trip, opposites attract, one night first, commitment-shy heroine, wedding setting
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsParent with dementia, parental abandonment, parental death (full list below)
POVSingle point of view, Carla
EndingHEA
Pages272 (St. Martin's Griffin paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Sarah Naughton, 6 hours 37 minutes (Macmillan Audio)
First publishedMarch 7, 2023
PublisherSt. Martin's Griffin, an imprint of St. Martin's Publishing Group (Macmillan)

What Is Off the Map About?

For about ten years Carla Black has lived on the move, driving a vintage Jeep around the world and never staying anywhere long enough to need a forwarding address. She was raised by her father after her mother walked out, and since his dementia diagnosis he has insisted that she keep traveling.

Now she has landed in Dublin for her best friend Anna's wedding to Keane, and the groom has sent his brother to collect her at the airport. Eamon Sullivan is a digital mapmaker who has done everything his family expected and is quietly miserable about it. Carla and Eamon fall into bed almost at once, then set off across Ireland toward the wedding by the longest possible route, and the detours start to change them both.

What Makes This Road Trip Romance Work

Off the Map works because the road trip is also an argument. Carla thinks a life without roots is freedom, and Eamon has never been allowed to want anything outside his duties. Each one is the cure for the other's particular stuckness, and Publishers Weekly praised how the book uses the adventure to explore home, family and purpose.

The other hook is Ireland itself. Kayne Spooner at All About Romance praised the scenery and the backcountry travelogue, and BookPage said the book would leave readers craving adventure and called it romantic, whimsical and sexy. Doller's descriptions of narrow lanes, pubs and wild coastline make this the most transporting book in the series.

Finally, the book flips the usual order. The leads sleep together on day one and fall in love afterward. For readers who are tired of 400 pages of waiting, that is a relief. For others it removes the tension. Either way, it is a deliberate choice.

My Review

I have a soft spot for heroines who are a bit much, and Carla is a lot. She is direct, confident, funny and occasionally rude. Kayne Spooner at All About Romance quoted Eamon's line that Carla has "the tactfulness of a machete," and the book means it as both a criticism and a compliment. I mostly enjoyed her company.

What I did not expect was how much of the book belongs to her father. The flashbacks and present-day worry about a dad whose memory is going are the emotional center of Off the Map, and they are written with real care. Heather Adores Books singled out the father-daughter flashbacks, and they are the part I remember most.

Romance and Chemistry

Carla and Eamon have immediate physical chemistry, and the book wastes no time on it. Stacy Gold enjoyed the pairing of a capable heroine with a hero willing to learn from her, and Eamon is good at that: he is curious about her life rather than threatened by it. Boston Books and Bubbles praised the mix of humor, chemistry and family pressure.

Where the romance falls short is depth. Kayne Spooner at All About Romance found it undersold, and Jeeves Reads Romance, listening on audio, found the early intimacy jarring and the emotional buildup thin. alpha_315 on The StoryGraph saw little growth beyond attraction and travel. I would not go as far as Jeeves, but the love story is lighter than the family story, and in a book this short the balance matters.

The Characters

Carla divides people. Kayne Spooner found her boastful and blunt and liked these leads less than the couples in Doller's earlier books, while Stacy Gold loved a heroine who is so plainly good at life. Some StoryGraph readers tired of Carla resisting commitment. I liked her best in the scenes about her father, where the armor drops.

Eamon is pleasant and a little underdrawn: the dutiful son, the man who never chased his own idea. His family obligations give the book its stakes in Ireland, and Kaetrin at Dear Author valued the mature conversations between the two leads. Anna and Keane from Float Plan are around the edges, as is a wedding party waiting for the couple to show up.

Writing and Pacing

Doller's prose is clean and vivid, especially on landscape. At under three hundred pages and under seven hours in audio, Off the Map moves quickly. Amanda at Amanda's Book Corner valued both the travel and caregiving halves of the story but found the balance uneven, and that is my main craft note: the road trip and the dementia storyline sometimes feel like two books sharing a car.

Kayne Spooner also found Eamon's willingness to delay the wedding with detours irresponsible, and Kaetrin at Dear Author questioned some of the premise. Those are fair objections. The detours are the point of the book, though, and I was happy to take them.

Off the Map is a fast, sexy Irish road trip carried by beautiful scenery and a moving father-daughter story, with a romance that runs lighter than its heat. Read it if you want travel, early chemistry and a blunt heroine, and do not expect a slow burn.

How Spicy Is Off the Map?

Off the Map is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The leads sleep together very early, and there are several open-door, consensual sex scenes through the trip, some of them outdoors. Kayne Spooner at All About Romance called it spicy, Heather Adores Books noted the frequency, and BookPage called it steamier than the two earlier Beck Sisters books.

The scenes are frank without being the focus of the plot. Readers who came from the low-heat Suite Spot should expect a big jump. For more in this range, see our spicy romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from the publisher excerpt and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read Off the Map?

Off the Map suits readers who want a short, steamy travel romance with strong scenery, a blunt nomad heroine and a moving family storyline. It suits readers less well if they want a slow burn, a softer heroine or a romance with more emotional depth than heat.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Off the Map earned positive trade reviews, including a starred review from BookPage and a warm one from Publishers Weekly, which said readers would not want to put it down. Reader response is more mixed than for the earlier Beck Sisters books.

Where they agree. The setting and the family story. BookPage and All About Romance both praised the Irish scenery, Publishers Weekly valued the exploration of home and family, and Heather Adores Books praised the father-daughter flashbacks. Amanda at Amanda's Book Corner valued both halves of the book, and Boston Books and Bubbles enjoyed its humor and chemistry.

Where they split. Carla and the romance. Kayne Spooner at All About Romance gave a qualified recommendation, finding the heroine harsh and the romance undersold; Stacy Gold was strongly positive about the same heroine. Jeeves Reads Romance found the early intimacy jarring and skimmed the second half, while Kaetrin at Dear Author valued the mature conversations and reported a happy ending.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Off the Map scores 7.0 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for emotional impact and heat, and its lowest for characters and reread appeal, where a divisive heroine and a thin romance hold it back.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Strong early chemistry; All About Romance finds the romance undersold.
Characters (15%)3Carla divides readers, harsh to All About Romance and admirable to Stacy Gold.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Vivid scenery praised by BookPage; Amanda's Book Corner finds the halves uneven.
Emotional impact (15%)4The father-daughter storyline, praised by Heather Adores Books, carries real weight.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the steamier heat BookPage and All About Romance describe.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A HEA confirmed by Dear Author, though the romance resolves quickly.
Reread appeal (10%)3Worth revisiting for Ireland; the romance has less to rediscover.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Off the Map is the steamiest and most divisive Beck Sisters book, more vivid than The Suite Spot but less emotionally full than Float Plan, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 7.0/10.

Beck Sisters Reading Order

Off the Map is book 3 and the final novel in Trish Doller's Beck Sisters series. Amanda at Amanda's Book Corner read it without the earlier books and had no trouble, but the wedding at its center belongs to Anna and Keane from Float Plan, so reading in order gives that event more weight:

  1. Book 1: Float Plan (2021): Anna and Keane
  2. Book 2: The Suite Spot (2022): Rachel and Mason
  3. Book 3: Off the Map (2023): Carla and Eamon

Best format: Sarah Naughton narrates the whole series for Macmillan Audio, and this book is a short listen at under seven hours. Print is better if you want to linger over the scenery. Our series order guide covers more connected series.

If You Loved Off the Map, Read These Next

If you loved Off the Map, look for romances built around a journey, a wedding or a heroine who has to decide whether to stop running.

Frequently Asked Questions

Off the Map draws the same handful of questions: how spicy it is, whether you need the earlier Beck Sisters books, where it is set and how it ends. Short answers below.

Is Off the Map by Trish Doller spicy?

Yes. Off the Map is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several open-door, consensual scenes that start very early in the book.

Do I need to read Float Plan and The Suite Spot first?

No. Off the Map reads as a standalone, but the wedding belongs to Anna and Keane from Float Plan, so reading in order adds context.

Where is Off the Map set?

Off the Map is set mostly on the road in Ireland, from Dublin to the countryside wedding venue.

Does Off the Map have a happy ending?

Yes. Off the Map ends with a happily ever after for Carla and Eamon.

Who narrates the Off the Map audiobook?

Sarah Naughton narrates the Macmillan Audio edition, which runs 6 hours 37 minutes.

What are the content warnings for Off the Map?

The main ones are a parent with dementia, a mother who abandoned the family, parental death and explicit sex.

The Bottom Line

Off the Map earns a 7.0/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a short, steamy road trip romance with Irish scenery, a blunt nomad heroine and a moving storyline about her father. The one reason to pick it up is the journey: Doller makes every detour across Ireland worth taking.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.