Something Wilder by Christina Lauren Review
Eikna Score: 6.6/10. Recommended with reservations.
Something Wilder is Christina Lauren's swing at an adventure romance, and the Utah canyons, the treasure map and the first-love history make a great setup. The execution wobbles: once the danger arrives the romance thins out and the tone lurches, so this is a fun summer ride rather than one of the duo's best.
Read it if you want a second chance romance with a road-movie feel, real outdoor danger and a buried-treasure puzzle. Skip it if you came for Christina Lauren's usual banter-heavy rom-com, or tonal whiplash after a violent turn will bother you.
Something Wilder at a Glance
Something Wilder is a standalone second chance romance by Christina Lauren, the writing duo of Christina Hobbs and Lauren Billings, published by Gallery Books in May 2022. It follows treasure-hunt guide Lily Wilder and her first love Leo Grady on a trip through Utah's Canyonlands that turns dangerous. It has moderate open-door heat and ends happily.
| Author | Christina Lauren |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Romantic suspense and adventure romance, contemporary |
| Main tropes | Second chance, first love, forced proximity on a wilderness trip, treasure hunt, outdoor adventure |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Gun violence, injury, near drowning, on-page death, parental abandonment, strong language (full list below) |
| POV | Alternating between Lily and Leo |
| Ending | Happy ending (the 2023 paperback adds an epilogue) |
| Pages | 384 (2022 hardcover); 416 (2023 paperback with bonus epilogue) |
| Audiobook | Simon & Schuster Audio, read by Patti Murin, Jon Root and Christina Lauren, 9 hours 27 minutes |
| First published | May 17, 2022 |
| Publisher | Gallery Books (Simon & Schuster) |
What Is Something Wilder About?
Something Wilder follows Lily Wilder, daughter of the famous treasure hunter Duke Wilder. Lily makes a living running staged treasure hunts for tourists through the canyons of Utah, using her father's maps and journal as props. It pays the bills, mostly, and it lets her stay close to the desert she loves.
Then Leo Grady books a trip. Leo was Lily's first love, the boy she was supposed to build a life with until it fell apart years ago, and he arrives with a group of friends who want a real adventure. Lily wants nothing to do with him. Once they are deep in the backcountry, though, the trip goes wrong, someone else is after the treasure, and Lily and Leo have to work together to survive and maybe finally find what Duke never could.
What Makes This Second Chance Romance Work
Something Wilder works as a second chance romance because the setting forces the conversation Lily and Leo have avoided for years. There is nowhere to walk away to in a slot canyon. The history between them is laid out gradually, and the wilderness does a lot of the work that a misunderstanding would do in a city rom-com.
The hook is the genre blend. Christina Lauren are known for banter-driven contemporaries like The Unhoneymooners, and this is their attempt at something closer to an adventure film: maps, riddles, rough terrain and a threat that turns out to be real. Publishers Weekly welcomed the move toward romantic suspense, and Kirkus praised the sweltering, dusty detail of the landscape.
Leo's friends give the early chapters a light, group-trip energy. Readers who like forced proximity on the road, and who enjoyed the outdoor setting of The Simple Wild, will find the premise easy to fall for.
My Review
Something Wilder is the Christina Lauren book I most wanted to love from its premise alone. A woman who fakes treasure hunts for a living, a real treasure, and an ex who shows up with a group of slightly useless friends. That is a great movie pitch.
Kirkus called it a vivid escape that's perfect for romantic thrill-seekers, and the first half earns that. The second half is where readers split, and I split with them. Once the danger turns serious, the book never quite decides whether it is a romance with some peril or a thriller with a romance attached.
Romance and Chemistry
The chemistry between Lily and Leo is good in flashes. Their shared past is the best material: two teenagers who were sure of each other, and the specific way it fell apart. Christina Lauren are always strong on the small, private jokes of a couple who knew each other young, and those carry over here.
The present-day relationship moves fast, though. J.P. Lee's critical review argued that the book spends too little time rebuilding trust before the couple is back together, and I agree. The sex scenes are heated and well written, but they arrive before the emotional reckoning feels finished. Fae Reviews put it bluntly: the adventure overshadows the romance. By the final act, the love story is running in the background of a chase.
What I wanted was one more long night between them before the danger took over: a real fight about why they broke up, said out loud by two adults. The book gives us pieces of that conversation along the trail, and the pieces are good. There just are not enough of them.
The Characters
Lily is a strong lead: capable outdoors, prickly, funny about the absurdity of her job and carrying a real wound from her father. I liked her best when she was working, reading the land and managing a group of men who think they know more than they do. Nadine at NadsBookNook wanted Lily to have a bigger role in cracking the puzzle, and that is fair; at times the plot happens to her.
Leo is warm and steady, a nice counterweight to Lily's guardedness. Michele at Harlequin Junkie liked him a lot, and he is easy to like. He is also less specific than the duo's best heroes; I could not tell you much about his life outside the trip.
The supporting cast is the book's soft spot. Leo's friends are fun but thinly drawn, and when the story turns violent, their reactions do not quite land. Llama Reads Books objected to how quickly the group moves past a death, and that was my biggest problem too. The tone stays bright when it should darken.
Writing and Pacing
The prose is clean and the landscape writing is the best thing in the book. Christina Lauren clearly did their research on Canyonlands: heat, water, the way light changes in a canyon, the physical toll of the hike. Kirkus singled out the setting, and so did nearly every blogger.
Pacing is uneven. The setup is leisurely, the middle accelerates hard, and the final act piles on twists that strain belief. Lauren at Bookmark Lit said she nearly stopped reading when the tone shifted and was glad she finished; that is roughly my experience. The 2023 paperback adds an epilogue that gives the couple more closure, and it is worth finding if you can.
The audiobook, with Patti Murin and Jon Root alternating, is a good way to take the adventure scenes, and the authors are credited as readers too.
Something Wilder is an atmospheric, uneven adventure romance with a great setting and a rushed reunion. Read it if you want Christina Lauren in a new mode and like danger with your second chances, and pick their rom-coms if you want their best.
How Spicy Is Something Wilder?
Something Wilder is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are a few open-door, consensual sex scenes once Lily and Leo reconnect, described with some frankness but not at length. Kirkus called the romance steamy, and J.P. Lee described the scenes as fairly graphic; we place them in the moderate band because there are not many of them and the adventure takes up most of the page count.
The darker material comes from the suspense plot. There is gun violence, a near drowning, serious injury and an on-page death, along with Lily's painful history with her father. For more romances with danger, see our romantic suspense hub.
Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and reviews:
- Gun violence and threats
- Serious injury
- Near drowning
- On-page death
- Parental abandonment and a difficult father
- Misogyny from side characters
- Strong language
- Open-door sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Who Should Read Something Wilder?
Something Wilder suits readers who want a second chance romance wrapped in an outdoor adventure, with heat and some real danger. It is less suited to readers who want Christina Lauren's usual comic tone or a slow, careful rebuild of trust.
Best for:
- Readers who love wilderness settings and adventure films
- Fans of second chance and first love romances
- Anyone who wants romantic suspense with a light touch
- Christina Lauren fans curious about something different
Not for:
- Readers who want a banter-led rom-com
- Anyone who dislikes tonal shifts after violence
- Readers who want the romance to stay front and centre
- People who need tightly plotted suspense
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Something Wilder got friendly trade reviews and a split reader response. Publishers Weekly welcomed Christina Lauren's turn toward romantic suspense, and Kirkus praised the landscape, excitement and romantic tension.
Where they agree. The setting. Kirkus, Harlequin Junkie, NadsBookNook and Bookmark Lit all praise the Utah canyons and the sense of physical adventure. Most readers also enjoy the treasure-hunt premise and Lily as a heroine.
Where they split. Romance versus adventure, and tone. Fae Reviews felt the adventure overshadowed the romance, J.P. Lee found the present-day relationship thin and the escalation implausible, and Llama Reads Books objected to the group's casual response to a death. On r/RomanceBooks, opinions run from favourite to did not finish. Thindbooks reported a happy ending but weak attachment to the characters.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Something Wilder scores 6.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for romance, writing and heat, where the setting and the reunion scenes deliver, and its lowest for characters, emotional impact and reread appeal.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Good shared history; J.P. Lee finds the present-day rebuild thin. |
| Characters (15%) | 3 | Lily is strong, but NadsBookNook wanted her to drive the puzzle more. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Kirkus praises the landscape; pacing and twists are uneven. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3 | Llama Reads Books notes a death that barely registers with the group. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | A few frank, steamy scenes; fewer than fans of the duo may expect. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A happy ending, with more closure in the paperback epilogue. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | A one-time ride for most; Fae Reviews found the romance overshadowed. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Something Wilder sits in the lower half of Christina Lauren's catalogue, behind The Unhoneymooners and Josh and Hazel's Guide to Not Dating, but it is their most ambitious genre experiment and lands at a final Eikna Score of 6.6/10.
Is Something Wilder a Standalone?
Yes. Something Wilder is a standalone with no prequel or sequel. The 2023 paperback adds a bonus epilogue and a sample of The True Love Experiment, which is a separate book with new characters.
Christina Lauren standalones with Eikna reviews, in publication order: Roomies (2017), Love and Other Words (2018), Josh and Hazel's Guide to Not Dating (2018), My Favorite Half-Night Stand (2018), The Unhoneymooners (2019), In a Holidaze (2020), The Soulmate Equation (2021), Something Wilder (2022), The True Love Experiment (2023) and The Paradise Problem (2024).
Best format: the paperback, for the bonus epilogue, or the audiobook read by Patti Murin and Jon Root. Our series order guide covers connected romances.
If You Loved Something Wilder, Read These Next
If you loved Something Wilder, the closest matches are second chance and adventure romances with strong settings and a little danger.
- The Simple Wild by K.A. Tucker: Alaska, bush planes and a city heroine falling for a pilot who knows the land.
- Float Plan by Trish Doller: a grieving woman, a sailboat and an Irish sailor on a Caribbean voyage.
- The Road Trip by Beth O'Leary: exes forced together on a long drive, with a dual timeline.
- Love and Other Words by Christina Lauren: the duo's best second chance first love story.
- Meet Me at the Lake by Carley Fortune: a reunion years in the making, set at a Canadian lake resort.
Frequently Asked Questions
Something Wilder raises the same questions for most new readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, whether it ends happily and how it differs from Christina Lauren's other books. Short answers below.
Is Something Wilder spicy?
Moderately. We rate it 3 out of 5, with a few frank, consensual open-door scenes in a book mostly about the adventure.
Is Something Wilder a standalone?
Yes. It is a standalone with no sequel. The 2023 paperback adds a bonus epilogue.
Does Something Wilder have a happy ending?
Yes. Lily and Leo end together, and the paperback epilogue gives them extra closure.
Where is Something Wilder set?
In the canyons of southern Utah, around Canyonlands, where Lily runs treasure-hunt trips.
Is there a Something Wilder audiobook?
Yes. Simon and Schuster Audio published it, read by Patti Murin, Jon Root and Christina Lauren, at about 9 hours 27 minutes.
Is Something Wilder a rom-com?
Not really. It is closer to romantic suspense and adventure, with some humour but real violence and danger.
The Bottom Line
Something Wilder earns a 6.6/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a second chance romance in a vivid outdoor setting and do not mind the love story taking a back seat to danger. The one reason to pick it up is the Utah backcountry, which Christina Lauren write so well you can feel the heat.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Something Wilder, Kirkus Reviews
- Something Wilder audiobook, Libro.fm (narrators, length)
- Something Wilder, Romance.io (steam and tags)
- Publishers Weekly review; Harlequin Junkie, Fae Reviews, NadsBookNook, J.P. Lee, Bookmark Lit, Llama Reads Books, Thindbooks; r/RomanceBooks reader discussion
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.