eikna romance
Menu

The Suite Spot by Trish Doller Review

Eikna Score: 6.9/10. Recommended with reservations.

The Suite Spot is a gentle, grown-up romance about a single mother rebuilding her life by rebuilding a half-finished hotel on a Lake Erie island. The setting, the slow trust and the plus-size heroine are lovely; the custody subplot is rushed and the hero is almost too good to be true.

Read it if you want a low-drama, small-town romance with a capable single mom, a fixer-upper hotel and a kind, quiet hero. Skip it if you want steam or high stakes, or a custody crisis solved in a hurry will annoy you.

The Suite Spot by Trish Doller book cover

The Suite Spot at a Glance

The Suite Spot is the second Beck Sisters novel by Trish Doller, published by St. Martin's Griffin on March 8, 2022. Rachel Beck narrates as she takes a job managing a brewery hotel on Kelleys Island and falls for its reclusive owner. It is low heat, reads on its own and ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorTrish Doller
SeriesBeck Sisters, book 2 (reads as a standalone)
SubgenreContemporary romance, small-town romance
Main tropesSingle mom, workplace romance, fixer-upper hotel, island community, slow trust
Spice level2/5: Mild, fade to black
Content warningsSexual harassment and assault, grief, custody conflict (full list below)
POVSingle point of view, Rachel
EndingHEA
Pages288 (St. Martin's Griffin paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Sarah Naughton, 7 hours 42 minutes (Macmillan Audio)
First publishedMarch 8, 2022
PublisherSt. Martin's Griffin, an imprint of St. Martin's Publishing Group (Macmillan)

What Is The Suite Spot About?

Rachel Beck has worked her way up in luxury hotels in Miami Beach while raising her young daughter, Maisie, on her own. When she loses that job after an incident at work, she needs something steady, fast.

The offer comes from a long way north: managing a new hotel attached to a brewery on Kelleys Island, in Lake Erie. Rachel moves with Maisie, sight mostly unseen, and finds that the hotel is far from finished and that its owner, a reserved brewer named Mason Brown, knows a great deal about beer and very little about running a hotel. Rachel has to build the business almost from scratch, with the man she reports to, while working out whether this island can be home.

What Makes This Single Mom Workplace Romance Work

The Suite Spot works because the romance grows out of shared work. Rachel and Mason fall for each other while choosing paint, arguing about rooms and figuring out what a brewery hotel should be. Publishers Weekly found the tension effective as the two work and live in close quarters, and that slow, practical intimacy is the book's pleasure.

It is also a romance for readers who are tired of drama. Dolly Sickles at All About Romance praised the mature partnership, and Kaetrin at Dear Author valued the book's kindness and the room it gives to grief. Rachel and Mason are adults who talk to each other.

Then there is the island. Kelleys Island in the off season, with its tiny community, ferries and lake weather, is a setting that readers keep praising, from witchbuns on The StoryGraph to Caroline at Bookends. If you like small-town romance with a real place under it, this is a strong pick.

My Review

The Suite Spot is the kind of book I recommend to readers who say they want a romance that feels like a long exhale. Nothing explodes. A woman who has been knocked down picks up her kid, moves to an island and does very good work, and a quiet man notices.

That restraint is the strength and the limit. Jeeves Reads Romance, reading an early copy, wanted more depth and more time with the couple, and I understand the wish: the romance sometimes shares the page with paint swatches. But I liked it. I liked Rachel, and I liked the version of a second chance at life that this book believes in.

Romance and Chemistry

Rachel and Mason build trust slowly, through work and through small acts of care for Maisie, and All About Romance read their relationship as friends to lovers. Kaetrin at Dear Author valued the gradual trust between them, and the book is good at showing two cautious people deciding, step by step, to risk something.

Mason is the issue. He is patient, generous, good with a small child and emotionally available despite his own grief, and Dedra at A Book Wanderer found him potentially too ideal. I had the same reaction. Because he never really fails Rachel, the romance has little friction, and the conflict has to come from outside: from Rachel's past and from Maisie's father.

The Characters

Rachel is the best reason to read. She is competent, a little prickly, a devoted mother and a plus-size woman whose body is part of her life without becoming her story. jenspeck84 on The StoryGraph praised exactly that, and Lisa at Bookshelf Fantasies liked her body confidence. Her professional comeback is as satisfying as the romance.

Maisie is nearly four and written like one. The island community, from bartenders to neighbors, is warm and lightly sketched, and Phoebe Wright at Read & Wright enjoyed the side characters. witchbuns on The StoryGraph wanted a little more about how a small child adjusts so fast to a new family, and that is fair.

Writing and Pacing

Doller writes plainly and warmly, with good dialogue and a light touch on the island's texture. The book is short, under three hundred pages, and moves quickly. Publishers Weekly had a reservation about the extended furnishing detail, and the renovation material does sometimes slow things down.

The weak point is the custody subplot in the last act. Lisa at Bookshelf Fantasies strongly objected to its logic and to how fast it resolves, and I agree it feels like a crisis brought in to give the ending stakes, then cleared away in a few chapters. rereadsromance on The StoryGraph reported a happy ending and wished for an epilogue. So did I. The book ends a beat early.

The Suite Spot is a kind, low-drama romance with a terrific single mom heroine and a setting you will want to visit, held back by a too-perfect hero and a rushed custody plot. Read it if you want comfort and competence more than heat or high stakes.

How Spicy Is The Suite Spot?

The Suite Spot is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. There is attraction and some sensuality, but the sex is brief and mostly off the page. Phoebe Wright at Read & Wright described it as closed door or low steam, All About Romance labeled it at the kisses level, and Kaetrin at Dear Author noted sensuality without much explicitness.

It is the mildest of the three Beck Sisters books; BookPage called the next one, Off the Map, steamier than its predecessors. See our closed door romance list for more in this range.

Content warnings, drawn from Kaetrin at Dear Author, Phoebe Wright at Read & Wright and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read The Suite Spot?

The Suite Spot suits readers who want a calm, adult, small-town romance about a single mother and a hotel coming to life, with little heat. It suits readers less well if they want dramatic conflict, a flawed hero or open-door scenes.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Suite Spot was well received by trade critics and romance bloggers, with Publishers Weekly, All About Romance and Dear Author all positive. Most of the remaining coverage is reader reviews, which are warm with a few firm objections.

Where they agree. The setting and the maturity. Dolly Sickles at All About Romance praised the adult partnership and the pace, Kaetrin at Dear Author valued the kindness and space for grief, and witchbuns on The StoryGraph and Caroline at Bookends loved the island and the fixer-upper hotel. jenspeck84 on The StoryGraph praised a plus-size heroine written as more than her size.

Where they split. Mason, depth and the custody plot. Dedra at A Book Wanderer found Mason too ideal, Jeeves Reads Romance wanted more depth and couple time, and Lisa at Bookshelf Fantasies objected to the custody crisis and its rapid resolution. In audio, Caroline at Bookends criticized the German pronunciation in the narration but not the writing.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Suite Spot scores 6.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best mark for emotional impact, where grief and a fresh start land gently, and its lowest for ending and reread appeal, where a rushed custody plot costs it.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Slow, mature trust praised by Dear Author; Dedra at A Book Wanderer finds Mason too ideal.
Characters (15%)3.5A standout plus-size single mom per jenspeck84; the island cast is lightly drawn.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Warm, quick prose; Publishers Weekly notes heavy furnishing detail.
Emotional impact (15%)4Grief and a fresh start handled with kindness, as Kaetrin at Dear Author notes.
Heat level (10%)3.5Low steam that matches the gentle tone, per Read & Wright and All About Romance.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3A HEA, but Bookshelf Fantasies objects to the rushed custody resolution.
Reread appeal (10%)3Comforting, but short on scenes that reward a second read.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Suite Spot is the quietest of the three Beck Sisters books, gentler than Float Plan and less steamy than Off the Map, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 6.9/10.

Beck Sisters Reading Order

The Suite Spot is book 2 of Trish Doller's Beck Sisters series, three loosely connected romances. All About Romance found it readable on its own, with Anna and Keane from Float Plan making occasional appearances. Reading in publication order gives you the cameos in sequence:

  1. Book 1: Float Plan (2021): Anna and Keane
  2. Book 2: The Suite Spot (2022): Rachel and Mason
  3. Book 3: Off the Map (2023): Carla and Eamon

Best format: Sarah Naughton narrates all three books for Macmillan Audio, and this one runs under eight hours. One listener disliked her German pronunciation, but the performance otherwise suits Rachel's warmth. Our series order guide covers more connected series.

If You Loved The Suite Spot, Read These Next

If you loved The Suite Spot, look for gentle, setting-rich romances about starting over, ideally with a business to build.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Suite Spot raises a handful of practical questions: how spicy it is, whether you need Float Plan first, where it is set and how it ends. Short answers below.

Is The Suite Spot spicy?

Not very. The Suite Spot is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with sensuality and brief, mostly off-page intimacy.

Do I need to read Float Plan before The Suite Spot?

No. The Suite Spot works as a standalone, though Anna and Keane from Float Plan make occasional appearances.

Where is The Suite Spot set?

The Suite Spot is set mainly on Kelleys Island in Lake Erie, where Rachel takes a job at a brewery hotel.

Does The Suite Spot have a happy ending?

Yes. The Suite Spot ends with a happily ever after, though some readers wished for an epilogue.

Who narrates The Suite Spot audiobook?

Sarah Naughton narrates the Macmillan Audio edition, which runs 7 hours 42 minutes.

Is the heroine of The Suite Spot plus-size?

Yes. Rachel is a plus-size heroine, and readers have praised how the book treats her body with confidence.

The Bottom Line

The Suite Spot earns a 6.9/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a kind, low-heat, small-town romance about a single mother finding her feet, and who do not mind a hero with no rough edges. The one reason to pick it up is Rachel, a competent, funny heroine whose fresh start is as satisfying as her love story.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.