How to Fail at Flirting by Denise Williams Review
Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.
How to Fail at Flirting starts as a professor's list of new experiences and turns into a careful, often moving romance about a woman reclaiming her life after an abusive relationship. The cover promises a lighter rom-com than the book delivers, and the workplace conflict arrives late, but Naya is a heroine worth the trip.
Read it if you want a romance with real emotional weight under the banter, or an academic heroine fighting for her department and her own confidence. Skip it if intimate partner violence is a hard limit, or you want the breezy comedy the title suggests.
How to Fail at Flirting at a Glance
How to Fail at Flirting is Denise Williams's debut romance, published by Berkley in December 2020. It pairs a university professor with a visiting consultant whose work threatens her department, deals seriously with the aftermath of an abusive relationship, has moderate open-door heat and ends happily.
| Author | Denise Williams |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone; shares a world with The Fastest Way to Fall |
| Subgenre | Contemporary romance, academic workplace |
| Main tropes | A list of new experiences, casual fling turned romance, workplace conflict of interest, healing after abuse, forbidden attraction |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Intimate partner violence and gaslighting by an ex, image-based harassment, attempted sexual assault, racism (full list below) |
| POV | Centred on Naya |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 352 (US paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by January LaVoy, 9 hours 5 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio) |
| First published | December 1, 2020 |
| Publisher | Berkley, an imprint of Penguin Random House |
What Is How to Fail at Flirting About?
How to Fail at Flirting follows Naya Turner, a driven university professor whose struggling department is facing cuts. Her friends drag her out for a night on the town, and Naya writes herself a list of new experiences to try. One of them turns out to be Jake, a charming man in town on business.
What begins as a casual arrangement deepens quickly, and Jake helps Naya find a confidence her abusive ex-boyfriend tried to take from her. But Jake's business in town is tied to the future of her department, and being with him could cost her the career she has fought for.
What Makes This Workplace Romance Work
How to Fail at Flirting works as a workplace romance because the conflict of interest is real and the stakes are Naya's whole professional life. She is a woman in academia whose department might not survive, and an affair with the consultant deciding its fate is the worst possible look. The book never treats that as a cute obstacle.
The list is the playful hook. Naya's to-do list of small adventures gives the early chapters a fun, freeing energy, and Publishers Weekly praised the banter and the central courtship. Jake's empathy is the other draw; PW singled it out, and readers including Honey Roselea Reads praised the work the couple put into their relationship.
Then there is the deeper story. Naya's ex abused her emotionally and physically, and the book is about her reclaiming her agency as much as falling in love. Smexy Books valued exactly that. If you like romance where desire is part of healing, this is a strong pick.
My Review
How to Fail at Flirting is a debut with more on its mind than its candy-coloured cover lets on, and I mean that as praise. Denise Williams writes a heroine who is funny, brilliant and carrying something heavy, and the book gives her room to be all three at once.
Romance and Chemistry
Naya and Jake click fast, and the early scenes, where she is working through her list and he is game for all of it, are the most purely fun in the book. The Bookish Libra found the growing relationship compelling, and Smexy Books praised the chemistry. Jake is attentive and patient, which suits a heroine learning to trust her own judgement again.
He is also a little hard to see clearly. Kirkus found Jake difficult to read, and a StoryGraph reader thought he was too idealised; another flagged that he is separated with a divorce still in progress, which some readers will want to know going in. I liked him, but I liked him the way you like a well-designed support beam. The romance is Naya's story first.
The Characters
Naya is the reason this book lingers. Kirkus praised her characterisation, and The Bookish Libra valued her resilience and her commitment to her students. She is a teacher who loves teaching, an academic who knows exactly how precarious her position is, and a survivor who is tired of being careful. The scenes where her ex resurfaces are tense and frightening, and they make her joy in the lighter chapters feel hard-won.
Her friends are a delight. Baltimore Bibliophile and Smexy Books both valued the friendships, and the women who push Naya out the door on that first night are the book's comic backbone.
Writing and Pacing
Williams writes with warmth and wit, and PowerLibrarian enjoyed the academic detail and the puns. The pacing is uneven. Kirkus noted that the central conflicts are delayed, and the workplace tension, which the blurb sells hard, takes a long time to bite. PowerLibrarian also wondered whether the title fit the book's tone, and I share that question: this is not a light rom-com.
The abuse storyline is handled with seriousness, but its integration into a fun premise is not seamless. A StoryGraph reader felt the two tones sat awkwardly together, and Kirkus warned that the serious material may surprise readers expecting froth. Go in knowing what kind of book it is and it reads very well.
How to Fail at Flirting is a warm, sexy and serious debut with a heroine you will root for, wrapped in a cover that undersells its weight. Read it if you want a romance about healing and joy, and check the content warnings first.
How Spicy Is How to Fail at Flirting?
How to Fail at Flirting is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. Denise Williams rates it three peppers on her own heat chart, and Baltimore Bibliophile reports detailed open-door scenes. The intimacy is consensual and tied to Naya's recovery of confidence and desire.
Compare more in this range on our spicy romance list, and see the romance heat levels guide for the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from Denise Williams's content notice and reader reports:
- Intimate partner violence by an ex: physical and emotional abuse
- Gaslighting
- Image-based harassment
- Attempted sexual assault
- On-page racism
- Reference to Alzheimer's disease
- Open-door sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read How to Fail at Flirting?
How to Fail at Flirting suits readers who want a romance with emotional depth, an academic heroine and moderate heat, and who are comfortable with an abuse storyline. It is less suited to readers expecting a light rom-com or for whom intimate partner violence is a hard limit.
Best for:
- Readers who like workplace romance with real professional stakes
- Fans of academic heroines who love their students
- Anyone who values romance as healing after trauma
- Readers who want moderate open-door heat
- Audiobook listeners who enjoy January LaVoy
Not for:
- Readers avoiding intimate partner violence and harassment
- Anyone expecting a frothy comedy from the title
- Readers who dislike a hero who is still legally married
- People who want a fast-moving central conflict
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
How to Fail at Flirting earned a warm Publishers Weekly review and a more mixed Kirkus notice, and readers mostly embraced it. PW praised the banter, the courtship and Jake's empathy.
Where they agree. Naya. Kirkus, The Bookish Libra, Smexy Books and Baltimore Bibliophile all praised her resilience and the friendships around her, and Honey Roselea Reads valued how much effort the couple puts into their relationship. Smexy Books reported a satisfying happy ending.
Where they split. Tone and pacing. Kirkus found the conflicts delayed and the pacing uneven; PowerLibrarian questioned the title; StoryGraph readers were divided over whether the abuse material sits well in a rom-com frame and whether Jake is too perfect.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
How to Fail at Flirting scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top marks for Naya, the emotional weight and a satisfying ending, and its lower marks for a hard-to-read hero and uneven pacing.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Strong chemistry, per Smexy Books; Kirkus finds Jake hard to read. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Kirkus praises Naya's characterisation; her friends add warmth. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Witty and warm; Kirkus flags delayed conflict and uneven pacing. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Naya reclaiming her agency gives it weight, as Smexy Books notes. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers the open-door scenes the author's three-pepper rating promises. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A happy ending that Smexy Books and readers found satisfying. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Naya and the friendships reward a reread; the heavy material may not. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: How to Fail at Flirting is a strong debut that sits near the top of Denise Williams's catalogue, ahead of her later workplace romances, with a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.
Is How to Fail at Flirting a Standalone?
Yes. How to Fail at Flirting is a standalone with a complete romance. Denise Williams has said that it and The Fastest Way to Fall are standalones set in the same world, and she suggests reading How to Fail at Flirting first, though either works alone.
- How to Fail at Flirting (2020)
- The Fastest Way to Fall (2021)
- Do You Take This Man (2022)
- Technically Yours (2023)
- Just Our Luck (2025)
Best format: January LaVoy's audiobook is excellent for a book this voice-driven. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved How to Fail at Flirting, Read These Next
If you loved How to Fail at Flirting, try romances with smart heroines, warm friend groups and real emotional stakes.
- The Fastest Way to Fall by Denise Williams: set in the same world, with a body-positive heroine and a supportive coach.
- Take a Hint, Dani Brown by Talia Hibbert: an academic heroine, a viral misunderstanding and a lot of heart.
- The Heart Principle by Helen Hoang: a heroine trying something new in her love life, and heavy emotional material.
- Love, Theoretically by Ali Hazelwood: an academic heroine whose love life collides with her career.
- The Flatshare by Beth O'Leary: a heroine rebuilding after an emotionally abusive ex, with a gentle hero.
Frequently Asked Questions
How to Fail at Flirting prompts a few common questions: how spicy it is, what the content warnings are, whether it stands alone and how it ends. Short answers below.
Is How to Fail at Flirting spicy?
Moderately. How to Fail at Flirting is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, and Denise Williams rates it three peppers, with detailed consensual open-door scenes.
What are the content warnings for How to Fail at Flirting?
The main ones are intimate partner violence and gaslighting by the heroine's ex, image-based harassment, attempted sexual assault and on-page racism.
Is How to Fail at Flirting a standalone?
Yes. It is a standalone set in the same world as The Fastest Way to Fall, which the author suggests reading second.
Does How to Fail at Flirting have a happy ending?
Yes. Naya and Jake get a happy ending.
Is How to Fail at Flirting a light rom-com?
Not entirely. It has funny, flirty scenes, but it deals seriously with the heroine's recovery from an abusive relationship.
Who narrates the How to Fail at Flirting audiobook?
January LaVoy narrates the Penguin Random House audiobook, which runs 9 hours 5 minutes.
The Bottom Line
How to Fail at Flirting earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a sexy, funny romance with real weight underneath, led by a heroine fighting for her career and her sense of self. The one reason to pick it up is Naya: Denise Williams makes her recovery of joy the most romantic thing in the book.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- How to Fail at Flirting audiobook, Libro.fm
- How to Fail at Flirting, Penguin Random House
- Denise Williams on reading order, Goodreads Q&A
- Denise Williams books in order, Book Series in Order
- Publishers Weekly and Kirkus Reviews; Denise Williams, content notice and heat chart
- The Bookish Libra, Smexy Books, PowerLibrarian, Honey Roselea Reads and Baltimore Bibliophile reviews
- StoryGraph reader reviews
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.