Just Our Luck by Denise Williams Review
Eikna Score: 6.7/10. Recommended with reservations.
Just Our Luck has a great hook, a winning lottery ticket left behind after a one-night stand with a donut baker, and a heroine whose impulsive, scattered energy is written with real affection. The fake dating plot that follows is forced and overstuffed, so the spark between the leads has to work hard to carry 400 pages.
Read it if you want a steamy, food-filled fake dating rom-com with a heroine who is a lot and a hero who loves that about her. Skip it if you need a tight plot and a believable reason to fake a relationship, or impulsive money choices make you want to shout at the page.
Just Our Luck at a Glance
Just Our Luck is a standalone 2025 Berkley romantic comedy by Denise Williams. Sybil Sweet leaves a winning lottery ticket with Kieran Anderson after one night together; his viral attempt to return it saves his family's donut shop and leads to a three-month fake relationship. It has several open-door scenes and a happy ending.
| Author | Denise Williams |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy, contemporary |
| Main tropes | Fake dating, one-night stand first, opposites attract, sudden fortune, family business |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | A grandparent's illness, family criticism, financial strain (full list below) |
| POV | Sybil and Kieran |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 400 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Emma Ladji and Teddy Hamilton, 10 hours 10 minutes |
| First published | March 25, 2025 |
| Publisher | Berkley |
What Is Just Our Luck About?
Just Our Luck starts with Sybil Sweet, whose famous lucky streak has dried up. She has drifted between jobs and relationships, she suspects her family thinks she is aimless, and she would settle for some financial security and a good donut.
Kieran Anderson gave up on becoming a doctor to run his family's late-night donut shop, and he is exhausted and broke. After a whirlwind night together, Sybil leaves a winning lottery ticket behind. Kieran tries to return it, the gesture goes viral and customers flood the shop. To keep the business afloat and to show Sybil's family she can make good choices, the two agree to a three-month fake relationship.
What Makes This Fake Dating Romance Work
Just Our Luck works on the strength of its premise. A lottery ticket left in the wrong bed is a perfect rom-com engine, and the honest-baker-goes-viral angle gives the fake relationship a public audience from day one. People called the result impossible not to root for.
The heroine is the other draw. All About Romance praised Sybil's neurodivergent traits, her hyperfocus and impulsiveness, and the way Kieran accepts her exactly as she is. She is messy, generous and bad with money, and the book treats that with warmth instead of judgment.
Add a donut shop, a lot of sugar and Denise Williams's usual heat, and readers who love fake dating will find the setup irresistible.
My Review
Just Our Luck has one of the best first chapters of any rom-com I read this year and one of the more frustrating middles. The opening is fast and funny, the attraction is instant, and the ticket mix-up is a gem. Then the book has to explain why two adults would fake a relationship for three months, and the explanation never quite lands.
Publishers Weekly said the same thing more politely: it found the fake dating device forced and the plot crowded, but the story fun enough and the relationship sparky enough to hold interest. That is where I ended up.
Romance and Chemistry
The physical chemistry is strong. Williams writes desire generously, and the New York Times has noted that her characters want each other wholeheartedly. The early scenes at the donut shop are the most charming in the book. Courtney Tonokawa at Courtney Reads Romance loved how much the two support each other.
The emotional build is thinner. StoryGraph readers jenny_reads_a_latte, jasminejamboree and pulchri2ude all questioned the chemistry, the development or the stakes, and jenny felt the happy ending was not earned. I would not go that far, but the fake relationship rules and public appearances eat a lot of page time that could have gone to the two of them alone.
The Characters
Sybil divides readers more than anything else in the book. All About Romance admitted some of her actions are cringeworthy while loving her anyway. Becky at Bookcase and Coffee questioned her financial choices and the family dynamics. Sylvie at Sidhe Reads stopped at 37 percent because she could not warm to her. I liked Sybil and rooted for her, but her family's constant criticism is painful, and the book takes a long time to let her answer it.
Kieran is steady, tired and kind, a man who gave up one dream to keep his family's business alive. Laura Black at All About Romance valued how he accepts Sybil's differences, and the family care storyline, including a grandfather's illness, which Barb at The Reading Cafe also noted, adds weight. Booklist called them a fabulous pair, and when the book lets them just be together, they are.
Writing and Pacing
Williams's voice is warm and quick, and the food writing is a pleasure. The length is the problem. At 400 pages, the middle sags; Courtney noticed a mid-story lag and Barb found some slow passages. All About Romance made the good point that the money does not fix anyone's real problems, which keeps the book from being a wealth fantasy, but that theme gets lost among side plots. Emma Ladji and Teddy Hamilton's dual narration suits the back-and-forth, if you prefer audio.
Just Our Luck is a sweet, steamy fake dating rom-com with a terrific premise and a plot that sprawls. Read it for Sybil, Kieran and the donuts; skip it if a forced setup and a slow middle ruin a romance for you.
How Spicy Is Just Our Luck?
Just Our Luck is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Denise Williams notes multiple open-door scenes on her own book page, and All About Romance and Publishers Weekly both describe the book as steamy. The sex is explicit, consensual and part of how the leads connect.
For more books at this heat level, see our spicy romance list.
Content warnings, drawn from the author's book page and reader reviews:
- A grandparent's illness and caregiving
- Painful family criticism of the heroine
- Financial strain and a struggling family business
- Impulsive spending and money worries
- Explicit on-page sex
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Who Should Read Just Our Luck?
Just Our Luck suits readers who want a steamy, cheerful fake dating story with a neurodivergent-coded heroine and a sweet, steady baker. It is less suited to readers who need a tight plot or who find impulsive heroines hard to like.
Best for:
- Fans of fake dating with a public audience
- Readers who want open-door heat in a rom-com
- Anyone who loves bakery and food settings
- Readers who want messy heroines loved as they are
- Fans of Denise Williams's earlier books
Not for:
- Readers who need a believable fake dating motive
- Anyone frustrated by impulsive financial choices
- Readers who dislike long, saggy middles
- Closed door readers
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Just Our Luck had positive trade notices: Publishers Weekly called it charming if crowded, Booklist called the leads a fabulous pair and People praised its wit and steam. Reader reviews are more divided, mostly over Sybil and the pacing.
Where they agree. The spark and the warmth. Publishers Weekly liked the chemistry, Laura Black at All About Romance praised the acceptance of Sybil's differences, and Courtney Tonokawa loved the mutual support and representation.
Where they split. Sybil and the plot. Becky at Bookcase and Coffee questioned Sybil's choices, Sylvie at Sidhe Reads did not finish, Barb at The Reading Cafe noted slow passages, and several StoryGraph readers doubted the chemistry and stakes. Publishers Weekly itself found the fake dating device forced.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Just Our Luck scores 6.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best mark for heat that delivers what Denise Williams promises, and lower marks for characters and writing, where readers found Sybil divisive and the middle slow.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | PW finds the relationship sparky; StoryGraph readers question the emotional build. |
| Characters (15%) | 3 | All About Romance loves Sybil; Bookcase and Coffee and Sidhe Reads struggle with her. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3 | Warm voice and great food writing, but PW calls the plot crowded and readers note a lag. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Family criticism and caregiving add weight, per The Reading Cafe. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers the multiple open-door scenes the author flags, with real heat. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A clear HEA, though one StoryGraph reader found it unearned. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | The opening is rereadable; the middle is not. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Just Our Luck sits below The Fastest Way to Fall in Denise Williams's catalogue, a fun premise held back by its length, with a final Eikna Score of 6.7/10.
Is Just Our Luck a Standalone?
Yes. Just Our Luck is a standalone, as Barb at The Reading Cafe noted, and you can start Denise Williams here. Her standalone novels so far:
- How to Fail at Flirting (2020)
- The Fastest Way to Fall (2021)
- Do You Take This Man (2022)
- Love and Other Flight Delays (2023)
- Technically Yours (2023)
- Just Our Luck (2025)
- The Re-Do List (2026)
Best format: the dual-narrator audiobook from Emma Ladji and Teddy Hamilton keeps the long middle moving. Our series order guide has more.
If You Loved Just Our Luck, Read These Next
If you loved Just Our Luck, try steamy rom-coms with fake relationships, messy heroines and heroes who adore them.
- Act Your Age, Eve Brown by Talia Hibbert: a chaotic, neurodivergent heroine and a buttoned-up hero who falls hard.
- The Fastest Way to Fall by Denise Williams: Williams at her warmest, with a slow burn and a body-positive heroine.
- The Wedding Crasher by Mia Sosa: a fake relationship born of a public mix-up, with family pressure.
- The Dating Plan by Sara Desai: fake dating for money and family, with plenty of heat.
- Ready or Not by Cara Bastone: a heroine whose life gets upended after one night, and a hero who shows up.
Frequently Asked Questions
These are the questions readers ask most often about Just Our Luck.
Is Just Our Luck spicy?
Yes. Just Our Luck is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with multiple explicit open-door scenes.
Is Just Our Luck a standalone?
Yes. Just Our Luck is a standalone and needs no other Denise Williams book.
Does Just Our Luck have a happy ending?
Yes. Sybil and Kieran get a happily ever after.
Is Just Our Luck a billionaire romance?
No. The lottery win sets the plot going, but the book is about a struggling donut shop and two people short on luck, not wealth.
Who narrates the Just Our Luck audiobook?
Emma Ladji and Teddy Hamilton narrate the audiobook, which runs about 10 hours 10 minutes.
What tropes are in Just Our Luck?
Just Our Luck combines fake dating, a one-night stand at the start, opposites attract and a family business in trouble.
The Bottom Line
Just Our Luck earns a 6.7/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a steamy, sugary fake dating rom-com and can forgive a forced setup and a long middle. The one reason to pick it up is Sybil, a heroine who is too much in all the best ways, and a hero who thinks so too.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Just Our Luck, Penguin Random House
- Just Our Luck, Publishers Weekly review
- Just Our Luck, All About Romance
- Just Our Luck, The Reading Cafe
- Denise Williams books in order, Book Series in Order
- Denise Williams, official site (open-door note)
- Booklist, People and New York Times quotes as listed by Penguin Random House
- Reader reviews: Courtney Reads Romance, Bookcase and Coffee, Sidhe Reads, StoryGraph
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.