eikna romance
Menu

The Husband Hoax by Saxon James Review

Eikna Score: 7.7/10. Recommended.

The Husband Hoax is a bright, silly, very likeable MM rom com that turns a fake wedding date into a fake marriage and gets most of its warmth from the chaotic roommates around the couple. The plot is ridiculous on purpose and the family villains are flat, but the two leads fit together so well that I stopped minding.

Read it if you want a low-angst fake dating and marriage of convenience romance with a found family, or you like a clumsy, lovable disaster of a hero. Skip it if cringe comedy makes you put a book down, or you want parents and antagonists drawn with the same care as the leads.

The Husband Hoax by Saxon James book cover

The Husband Hoax at a Glance

The Husband Hoax is the first book in Saxon James's Accidental Love series, an MM contemporary rom com self-published in February 2023. It alternates between Christian and Émile, runs on fake dating and a marriage of convenience, has moderate open-door heat and ends happily ever after.

AuthorSaxon James
SeriesAccidental Love, book 1 (each book follows a new couple)
SubgenreLGBTQ romance (MM romantic comedy, contemporary)
Main tropesFake dating, marriage of convenience, inheritance clause, opposites attract, found family
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsFamily estrangement, homophobia, death of a grandparent, classism, explicit sex (full list below)
POVDual first person, Christian and Émile
EndingHEA
Pages282 (paperback); 284 (Kindle)
AudiobookNarrated by James Joseph and Teddy Hamilton, 7 hours 23 minutes
First publishedFebruary 9, 2023
PublisherSelf-published by Saxon James

What Is The Husband Hoax About?

The Husband Hoax starts with a wedding invitation Christian would rather burn. His parents cut him off ten years ago, and now his cousin is getting married and the whole family will be there. Christian, a self-described walking trainwreck who shares a place with four roommates, hires a date so he can at least look like he has it together. The date cancels.

Enter Émile, who is wealthy, unflappable and stuck with a problem of his own: his late grandfather's will says he has to marry to inherit, and the money is meant to do some good. One fake date turns into a deal. They marry, split the benefits and go their separate ways. That is the plan, anyway.

What Makes This Fake Dating Romance Work

The Husband Hoax works because it stacks two tropes and lets the second raise the stakes of the first. A fake date for one wedding is a weekend's lie. A fake marriage to satisfy a will is paperwork, a shared address and a family that now has opinions about both of you. Saxon James uses that escalation for comedy first and feelings second, which is the right order for this book.

The other draw is the contrast. Christian trips over furniture and his own mouth; Émile is calm, rich and quietly amused by him. Love Bytes Reviews said the pair work as a real match rather than mere attraction, and that is the hook: Émile likes Christian exactly as messy as he is.

Then there is the found family. Christian's roommates and their nosy neighbor turn every scene at home into a group chat come to life, and they set up the rest of the series. Readers who love marriage of convenience stories with a lighter touch will find this an easy yes.

My Review

The Husband Hoax is the kind of book I read in one go on a Sunday and then recommend with a small warning label. It is fun, it is warm, and Saxon James knows that the joke of a fake marriage is how quickly it stops being fake. It is also built from familiar parts, and a few of them creak.

Love Bytes Reviews called it a "virtually no-angst, joyful read," and gave it four and a half hearts while admitting the plot is predictable and often ridiculous. Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words went further, with a full five out of five. My view is closer to Love Bytes: the characters make up for the plot, mostly.

Romance and Chemistry

Christian and Émile are a good pairing because they need different things from each other. Christian needs someone who is not embarrassed by him. Émile needs someone who is not impressed by his money. The dual first person narration lets you see each of them misread the other in ways that are funny rather than painful, and the early scenes at the wedding have the best comic timing in the book.

The fake marriage gives the romance a domestic second act, and that is where it softens into something sweet. I liked the small moments: Émile being patient, Christian realizing that patience is not pity. What I liked less is the third act. Several Goodreads readers found the late conflict rushed or melodramatic, and I agree. It arrives because the structure says it should, not because these two men would really fall apart that way.

The Characters

Christian is the love-him-or-cringe lead. He is clumsy, self-deprecating and prone to disaster, and James plays it for slapstick. Some Goodreads readers found the clumsiness excessive and the second-hand embarrassment hard to sit through. I laughed more than I winced, but I can see the line from here.

Émile is easier to like and harder to know. He is steady and kind, and his reasons for honoring his grandfather's wishes give him some depth, but he is more the calm center of the story than a person with his own mess. The roommates steal scenes whenever they appear, and Love Bytes and Scattered Thoughts both singled out the found family as a highlight.

The weak spot is the families. Christian's parents and the wedding crowd are there to be awful, and they are awful in one register. Goodreads readers called them one-dimensional villains, which is fair. A rom com can get away with cartoon antagonists, but the estrangement is the emotional engine of Christian's arc and it deserved a little more texture.

Writing and Pacing

The pace is quick. On StoryGraph, readers most often tag the book lighthearted and fast, and at under 300 pages it never sits still for long. The voice is chatty and crude in places, with plenty of swearing. The downside of a chatty voice is repetition: some readers felt the internal monologue went over the same ground, and I noticed it in the middle third, where Christian worries about the same thing in the same words more than once.

The audiobook comes up often in reader reviews, and with two narrators it suits a book this dialogue-heavy. If you are on the fence about Christian's voice on the page, it may be the better way in.

The Husband Hoax is a breezy, big-hearted MM rom com whose found family and well-matched leads outweigh a flat set of villains and a hurried last act. Read it if you want low angst and high silliness, and you are happy to forgive a few clichés.

How Spicy Is The Husband Hoax?

The Husband Hoax is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are explicit, consensual sex scenes between Christian and Émile, and StoryGraph readers tag the sexual content as graphic, but the book spends more time on comedy and feelings than on the bedroom. Some Goodreads readers who know Saxon James's other books noted it is less spicy than they expected.

For more in this heat range, see our spicy romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from StoryGraph reader reports and reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Husband Hoax?

The Husband Hoax suits readers who want a light, funny MM romance with a fake relationship that becomes a fake marriage, a clumsy hero and a noisy found family. It is less suited to readers who dislike slapstick, want complex antagonists or need a tightly plotted third act.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Husband Hoax has around 13,000 ratings on Goodreads with an average of about 4.0, and coverage comes almost entirely from MM romance blogs and reader sites rather than trade reviewers.

Where they agree. The fun. Love Bytes Reviews gave it four and a half hearts for its joyful, low-angst tone, the real match between the leads and the found family of roommates. Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words gave it five out of five, its reviewer "absolutely besotted with the characters." On StoryGraph, readers most often describe it as lighthearted and emotional, and Goodreads readers praise the humor, the banter and the audiobook narration.

Where they split. Christian and the plotting. Goodreads readers who disliked it found Christian's clumsiness and cringe moments too much, the family villains one-dimensional and the internal monologue repetitive. Some also called the third act rushed or melodramatic. Even Love Bytes conceded the plot is predictable and often ridiculous, though it felt the characters made up for that.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Husband Hoax scores 7.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with strong marks for romance, characters and comfort value, and lower ones for writing and the ending, where reader reviews point to repetition and a hurried third act.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4A real match, not just attraction, per Love Bytes Reviews.
Characters (15%)4Christian and the roommates shine; Goodreads readers find the family villains flat.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Fast and funny; Goodreads readers note repetitive internal monologue.
Emotional impact (15%)4Warm and joyful, with real hurt in Christian's estrangement.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers explicit scenes that fit the tone, as StoryGraph content tags show.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A happy ending, but readers call the third act rushed or melodramatic.
Reread appeal (10%)4Comfort read appeal and a series that keeps the roommates around.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Husband Hoax is a strong opener for Accidental Love and one of the more purely joyful books in Saxon James's catalogue, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.7/10.

Accidental Love Reading Order

The Husband Hoax is book 1 of Saxon James's Accidental Love series, and it works as a standalone with a complete HEA. Each later book follows a different couple from the same circle of friends, so read in order to watch the found family grow, but nothing is left on a cliffhanger.

  1. The Husband Hoax (2023): Christian and Émile
  2. Not Dating Material: Molly and Seven
  3. The Revenge Agenda
  4. Just Bromantically Invested
  5. Not Catching Love

Best format: the audiobook narrated by James Joseph and Teddy Hamilton is a good fit for a dialogue-driven comedy. Our series order guide covers more MM series.

If You Loved The Husband Hoax, Read These Next

If you loved The Husband Hoax, the closest matches are MM romances with fake relationships, weddings or warm found families, including more from Saxon James.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Husband Hoax raises the usual questions for MM rom com readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and who narrates the audiobook. Short answers below.

Is The Husband Hoax spicy?

Moderately. The Husband Hoax is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with explicit, consensual open-door scenes, though some readers find it less spicy than Saxon James's other books.

Is The Husband Hoax a standalone?

Yes. The Husband Hoax is book 1 of the Accidental Love series but has a complete story and HEA; later books follow other couples from the same friend group.

What is the Accidental Love series reading order?

Read The Husband Hoax, Not Dating Material, The Revenge Agenda, Just Bromantically Invested and Not Catching Love, in that order.

Does The Husband Hoax have a happy ending?

Yes. The Husband Hoax ends with a happily ever after for Christian and Émile.

Who narrates The Husband Hoax audiobook?

The Husband Hoax audiobook is narrated by James Joseph and Teddy Hamilton and runs about 7 hours 23 minutes.

What tropes are in The Husband Hoax?

The Husband Hoax combines fake dating, a marriage of convenience driven by an inheritance clause, opposites attract and a found family of roommates.

The Bottom Line

The Husband Hoax earns a 7.7/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a sweet, funny MM romance with a fake date that turns into a fake marriage and a found family that never lets the leads be alone for long. The one reason to pick it up is the pairing itself: a walking disaster and a man who finds the disaster charming is a simple idea, and Saxon James makes it very easy to root for.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.