eikna romance
Menu

Platonic Rulebook by Saxon James Review

Eikna Score: 6.8/10. Recommended with reservations.

Platonic Rulebook is a warm, low-angst best friends to lovers romance about two men in their forties, one freshly divorced and bisexual, who wake up in the same bed and try very hard to keep calling it casual. The friendship is lovely and the group chat is funny, but the stakes are thin and a secret kept from Griff's son never convinces.

Read it if you want MM romance with older leads and no years of secret pining, or you already love the Divorced Men's Club crowd. Skip it if you need real conflict to stay invested, or meddling friends who ignore boundaries make you grind your teeth.

Platonic Rulebook by Saxon James book cover

Platonic Rulebook at a Glance

Platonic Rulebook is Saxon James's 2022 MM contemporary romance and book 2 of the Divorced Men's Club series. It follows Griff, newly divorced after a long, happy marriage, and Heath, his best friend since high school, and ends with a happily ever after. Goodreads lists the Kindle edition at 290 pages, and Nick J. Russo narrates the audiobook.

AuthorSaxon James
SeriesDivorced Men's Club, book 2 (a new couple; reads as a standalone)
SubgenreMM contemporary romance
Main tropesBest friends to lovers, bisexual awakening after divorce, friends with benefits, older leads, meddling friends
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsDivorce, hiding the divorce from an adult child, friends overriding boundaries (full list below)
POVDual POV, Griff and Heath
EndingHEA
PagesAbout 290 (Kindle edition, per Goodreads)
AudiobookNarrated by Nick J. Russo, 7 hours 2 minutes (May Books)
First publishedJune 15, 2022
PublisherSaxon James (self-published; audio by May Books)

What Is Platonic Rulebook About?

Platonic Rulebook starts after the end of a marriage. Griff and his wife Poppy have split after about twenty years, on good terms, and still run their hotel together. Their son Felix is heading off to college. Griff is in his forties, single for the first time since he was young, and has no idea how to date.

So he asks Heath, his best friend since high school, to show him the bachelor life. Heath, who has never thought of Griff as his type, agrees. After one night out the two of them wake up in bed together, and Griff starts looking at his friend very differently. Heath suggests they keep it casual, since neither of them wants a relationship. Their friends in the Divorced Men's Club have opinions.

What Makes This Best Friends to Lovers Romance Work

Platonic Rulebook works for readers who are tired of angst. The two leads are adults with a long, easy friendship, and the book is more interested in how that friendship bends than in tearing it apart. Caz at All About Romance's audio site liked that there is no long-standing secret pining and that Griff's marriage was genuinely happy, which is rarer in divorce romance than it should be.

The second hook is age. Both men are in their forties, with grown children, businesses and history, and the book lets them be funny and horny and unsure without making a joke of it.

And then there is the group chat. Valerie at Love Bytes singled out the Divorced Men's Club texts as a highlight, and the found-family warmth of the series is a big part of why readers come back. If you want friends to lovers that is mostly comfort, this is it.

My Review

I liked Platonic Rulebook more in the first half than the second. The setup is charming, the leads are comfortable together in a way that reads like real long friendship, and Saxon James writes easy, funny dialogue. Then the book needs a conflict, and the one it picks is the weakest thing in it.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance is gentle. Griff and Heath already love each other as friends, so the question is never whether they care, only whether they will admit the caring has changed shape. Valerie at Love Bytes, who gave it 4.5 hearts and liked it more than book 1, found it sweet and fun, full of feels, and loved the shared history between the two men.

I agree about the warmth. I am less sure about the spark. Caz at All About Romance's audio site found the romance bland, with little chemistry and a relationship that changes mostly by adding sex. That is harsher than I would put it, but I see what she means: Heath and Griff are cozy from the start, and the book rarely makes their closeness feel risky. The friends with benefits stretch has heat without much tension.

The Characters

Griff is the more interesting lead. He is bisexual, figuring out what that means for him at forty-something after decades married to a woman he still likes, and the book handles his discovery with good humor and no shame. His friendship with Poppy is one of its quiet strengths.

Heath is easy company but less defined. Caz noted that the two leads sound similar on audio, and on the page they blur a bit too. The bigger problem is the plot device: Griff and Poppy hide their divorce from their son and from nearly everyone else, a choice Caz called ridiculous. I did not find it ridiculous so much as flimsy. It produces drama on schedule and then dissolves. Caz also found Felix annoying, which I would not go that far on.

Writing and Pacing

James writes quickly and cleanly, and the book moves. The Divorced Men's Club scenes are lively, though Caz pointed out that the friends push Griff into hookups he does not want and arrange a shopping trip he asked them to skip. Played as comedy, that is still a group ignoring a friend's boundaries, and it bothered me more than the book seems to expect.

The pacing suits the low stakes. A reader on Xtreme Delusions responded to the patient pace, and if you want a slow, easy read that never hurts, it delivers. If you want the friendship to be tested, it mostly is not.

Platonic Rulebook is a cozy, steamy best friends to lovers romance with likable older leads and very little at stake. Read it if you want comfort and the Divorced Men's Club banter; skip it if a flimsy family secret will annoy you.

How Spicy Is Platonic Rulebook?

Platonic Rulebook is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The two men sleep together early, and the friends with benefits arrangement means several open-door scenes through the middle of the book. Caz at All About Romance's audio site found the sex scenes underwhelming, though well narrated.

The intimacy is consensual and negotiated between the leads, and Griff's exploration of his bisexuality is treated warmly. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Platonic Rulebook?

Platonic Rulebook suits readers who want a low-angst, steamy MM best friends to lovers romance with leads in their forties and a funny friend group. It is less suited to readers who need strong conflict or who dislike secrets as plot devices.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Platonic Rulebook has a solid reader following, with an average of about 3.98 from nearly ten thousand ratings on Goodreads, and coverage is mostly reader reviews and romance blogs rather than trade press.

Where they agree. The friendship and the warmth. Valerie at Love Bytes called it a sweet, fun story she liked more than book 1, and readers repeatedly praise the long history between Griff and Heath and the group chat humor.

Where they split. Chemistry and stakes. Caz at All About Romance's audio site found it bland, with obstacles that are too easy and a divorce secret she could not believe, and she said she might be done with the author for now. A reader on Xtreme Delusions enjoyed the patient pace and chemistry instead. On audio, Nick J. Russo is praised for the secondary cast but criticized for making the two leads sound alike.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Platonic Rulebook scores 6.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for romance, characters, heat and ending, and lower scores for emotional impact and reread appeal, where low stakes hold it back.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Warm and easy, praised by Love Bytes; bland to All About Romance.
Characters (15%)3.5Griff's bisexual awakening works; Heath is thinner, per Caz.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Quick and funny, with a contrived divorce secret.
Emotional impact (15%)3Few real stakes; the obstacles fall too easily, per Caz.
Heat level (10%)3.5Delivers steady open-door heat, though not memorable.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A clean HEA after a conflict that dissolves quickly.
Reread appeal (10%)3Comfort read appeal, little reason to revisit beyond the group chat.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Platonic Rulebook sits in the middle of Saxon James's Divorced Men's Club, warmer than most but lighter on conflict, with a final Eikna Score of 6.8/10.

Divorced Men's Club Reading Order

Platonic Rulebook is book 2 of six in Saxon James's Divorced Men's Club. Each book follows a new couple, so it can be read alone, but the friend group recurs and the jokes land better if you start with book 1.

  1. Book 1: Roommate Arrangement (2022)
  2. Book 2: Platonic Rulebook (2022): Griff and Heath
  3. Book 3: Budding Attraction (2022): Payne and Beau
  4. Book 4: Employing Patience (2023): Art and Joey
  5. Book 5: System Overload (2023)
  6. Book 6: Forgotten Romance (2024)

Best format: the Nick J. Russo audiobook, at about seven hours, if you can live with the two leads sounding close; otherwise ebook. Our series order guide covers more MM series.

If You Loved Platonic Rulebook, Read These Next

If you loved Platonic Rulebook, the closest matches are MM romances with established friendships, adult leads and warmth over angst.

Frequently Asked Questions

Platonic Rulebook raises the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and where it sits in the series. Short answers below.

Is Platonic Rulebook spicy?

Yes. Platonic Rulebook is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several open-door scenes once the friends start sleeping together.

Can I read Platonic Rulebook as a standalone?

Yes. It is book 2 of the Divorced Men's Club, but Griff and Heath's story is complete; book 1 only adds background on the friend group.

Does Platonic Rulebook have a happy ending?

Yes. Platonic Rulebook ends with a happily ever after for Griff and Heath.

How old are the characters in Platonic Rulebook?

Both leads are in their forties. Griff has a son who is starting college.

Is there a Platonic Rulebook audiobook?

Yes. May Books published an audiobook narrated by Nick J. Russo, running 7 hours 2 minutes.

What is the Divorced Men's Club reading order?

Roommate Arrangement, Platonic Rulebook, Budding Attraction, Employing Patience, System Overload and Forgotten Romance.

The Bottom Line

Platonic Rulebook earns a 6.8/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a cozy, steamy MM best friends to lovers story with leads in their forties and a friend group that never stops texting, and who do not mind low stakes. The reason to pick it up is Griff: a man discovering something new about himself at forty-something, told with warmth instead of drama.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.