eikna romance
Menu

The Happy List by Briar Prescott Review

Eikna Score: 7.8/10. Recommended.

The Happy List is a funny, tender MM friends to lovers romance in which a buttoned-up workaholic writes a list of ways to be happier and his free-spirited best friend ends up on it. Kai's "it's just sex" holdout runs too long, but the banter is genuinely laugh-out-loud and Gray's slow awakening is handled with real care.

Read it if you love lifelong best friends, one of them pining, and a slow burn that turns into a lot of heat. Skip it if you want the romance to start on page one, or a miscommunication that drags makes you put books down.

The Happy List by Briar Prescott book cover

The Happy List at a Glance

The Happy List is Briar Prescott's self-published 2020 MM contemporary romance and book 1 of the Better With You series. Set in Boston, it pairs rigid, rule-following Gray with Kai, the best friend who has been away traveling for years, and ends with a happily ever after and an epilogue. The paperback runs 292 pages.

AuthorBriar Prescott
SeriesBetter With You, book 1 (connected standalones)
SubgenreMM contemporary romance, romantic comedy (Boston)
Main tropesBest friends to lovers, pining, slow burn, opposites attract, demisexual awakening
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsUnrequited love, a public proposal and breakup, parental loss in backstory (full list below)
POVDual POV, Gray and Kai
EndingHEA, with an epilogue set seven years later
Pages292 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Kirt Graves (Gray) and Joel Leslie (Kai), Tantor Audio, 2022
First publishedOctober 2020
PublisherSelf-published (audio by Tantor Audio)

What Is The Happy List About?

The Happy List follows Gray Quinn, who plans everything and enjoys almost nothing. He works too much, does what is expected of him and has a girlfriend of two years, Cee, whom he loves but is not in love with. When Cee proposes in front of everyone at a dinner, Gray says no, and his tidy life cracks open.

At the same moment his best friend Kai Morgan comes home to Boston after years of traveling, ready to settle down, start a furniture-making business and finally get over the crush he has had on Gray forever. After a drunken game of Never Have I Ever, Gray writes a list of risks and fun things to try. When Kai sees it, some of the items are not the kind you do alone.

What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work

The Happy List works because the friendship is real before anything else happens. Gray and Kai have known each other most of their lives, they make each other laugh, and Valerie at Love Bytes found the banter laugh-out-loud funny. You believe these two would be in each other's lives with or without a romance, which is what makes the shift scary.

The second hook is Gray's arc. He is not discovering a secret he always knew. He realizes slowly that he needs to know someone deeply before he wants them, and Love Bytes tagged the book as a demisexual awakening. Caz Owens at All About Romance praised his growth from rigid to open to risk.

And there is the list itself, which gives a slow burn a fun engine. Gray's motto for it is "Don't think, just do," which is the last thing he has ever been good at.

My Review

The Happy List made me laugh more than most rom-coms I read this year, and it did so without making either lead a punchline. Briar Prescott has a light hand with dialogue and a soft spot for her characters, and both show. It also has one problem that nearly every reviewer names, and I am going to name it too.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is a slow fuse, then an explosion. Kai has wanted Gray for years and has decided, firmly, to stop. Gray, for his part, notices his best friend gradually, and the book takes its time letting him. Valerie at Love Bytes, who gave it 4.75 hearts, noted the pace lags while the two wait to admit their feelings, then turns explosive once they do. That is accurate, and the explosive part is worth the wait.

The weak spot is Kai's insistence that what they are doing is just sex, or just Gray's curiosity. Caz Owens at All About Romance, in both her print and audio reviews, felt that belief went on longer than it needed to. I agree. Kai's fear makes sense, given how long he has been in love alone, but it stretches past the point where the reader can see how Gray feels. The book does avoid the silly big argument or breakup, which Caz appreciated and so did I.

The Characters

Gray is the heart of it. Raised to put work and duty first, he is deadpan and anxious and very funny about it, and his growth across the book feels earned rather than announced. Caz called it one of the book's strongest elements. Kai is warmer and simpler: upbeat, sweet, a little reckless. Caz noted he changes less than Gray does, and that is true, though he never needed to change much.

The supporting cast is small and good. Connor, the grandmother and Monica each get enough room to feel like people, per All About Romance, and Connor goes on to lead the next book, The Dating Experiment.

Writing and Pacing

Prescott's prose is quick and funny, with a lot of inner monologue that does as much comic work as the dialogue. Valerie praised a maturity in the writing she rarely sees in new authors. The opening is slow: Resch Reads found it too slow before enjoying the later exploration, and the first chapters spend a lot of time on Gray's dull life to make a point the reader gets quickly.

The epilogue, set seven years later, is sweet. Valerie found it satisfying, and while I am usually wary of time-jump codas, this one earns its place.

The Happy List is a funny, warm friends to lovers slow burn with a lovely awakening arc and a holdout that drags. Read it for the banter and Gray's growth; be patient with Kai in the middle.

How Spicy Is The Happy List?

The Happy List is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The first stretch is slow burn with a lot of tension, and once the list gets going there are several open-door scenes. Caz Owens rated it warm on All About Romance's scale and praised the sexual tension; Valerie noted it is not G-rated.

The intimacy is consensual and much of it is exploratory, with Gray working out what he wants at his own pace. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Happy List?

The Happy List suits readers who want a funny, steamy MM best friends to lovers rom-com with a slow-burn awakening and one lead who has been pining for years. It is less suited to readers who want a fast start or no miscommunication at all.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Happy List is a reader favorite among self-published MM romance, with an average of about 3.95 from more than four thousand Goodreads ratings. Coverage is mostly romance blogs and reader reviews.

Where they agree. The banter and Gray's growth. Valerie at Love Bytes called the humor laugh-out-loud and the chemistry clear on the page. Caz Owens at All About Romance graded the audiobook a B and called the book warm, funny and sexy.

Where they split. Pacing and Kai's doubts. Valerie and Resch Reads both found the opening slow, and Caz thought Kai's "just sex" stance overstayed. On audio, Caz praised Kirt Graves's deadpan Gray and Joel Leslie's vulnerable Kai, though she found Kai's accent occasionally hard to follow.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Happy List scores 7.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with strong marks for romance, characters, emotional impact, heat and ending, and lower scores for a slow opening and modest reread appeal.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Real friendship and an explosive payoff, per Love Bytes.
Characters (15%)4Gray's growth is the highlight, per All About Romance.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Funny and quick, but the opening is slow, per Resch Reads.
Emotional impact (15%)4Kai's years of pining give the payoff weight.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers steamy, consensual open-door scenes after the burn.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4An HEA with no silly breakup and a satisfying epilogue.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5The banter rereads well; the middle stretch less so.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Happy List is the strongest start to Briar Prescott's Better With You series and a standout self-published MM friends to lovers rom-com, with a final Eikna Score of 7.8/10.

Better With You Reading Order

The Happy List is book 1 of Briar Prescott's Better With You series. Each book follows a new couple, with characters from Gray and Kai's circle moving into the lead, so this is the right place to start.

  1. The Happy List (2020): Gray and Kai
  2. The Dating Experiment (2021): Jamie and Connor
  3. The Underdog (2021)
  4. The Inconvenient Love (2022)

Best format: the Tantor audiobook, which splits the chapters between Kirt Graves for Gray and Joel Leslie for Kai, so you always know whose head you are in. Our series order guide covers more MM series.

If You Loved The Happy List, Read These Next

If you loved The Happy List, the closest matches are MM romances where long friendships turn romantic, with humor up front and heat once it gets going.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Happy List raises the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and what comes next in the series. Short answers below.

Is The Happy List spicy?

Yes. The Happy List is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with a slow start and several open-door scenes once the list gets going.

Can I read The Happy List as a standalone?

Yes. The Happy List is book 1 of Better With You and tells a complete story with a happily ever after.

Does The Happy List have a happy ending?

Yes. Gray and Kai get a happily ever after, and the epilogue is set seven years later.

Is The Happy List a slow burn?

Yes. The friendship comes first, and the romance takes a good part of the book to start, then moves quickly.

Is there an audiobook of The Happy List?

Yes. Tantor Audio published it in 2022, narrated by Kirt Graves and Joel Leslie, one voice for each lead.

What is the Better With You reading order?

The Happy List, The Dating Experiment, The Underdog and The Inconvenient Love.

The Bottom Line

The Happy List earns a 7.8/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a funny, steamy MM best friends to lovers romance with years of pining on one side, a slow awakening on the other and a friendship strong enough to survive both, as long as they can be patient with a holdout in the middle. The reason to pick it up is the banter: Gray and Kai are simply fun to listen to.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.