eikna romance
Menu

Reading the Signs by Keira Andrews Review

Eikna Score: 7.3/10. Recommended.

Reading the Signs is a sharp, sweaty baseball romance where the pitcher and catcher signals do double duty as flirting, and the light D/s grows naturally out of a rookie who needs someone to slow him down. Nico's temper and a by-the-numbers final conflict hold it back from greatness, but the chemistry is real.

Read it if you want a sports romance where the sport actually matters on the page, or you like a steady older hero teaching a hothead some patience. Skip it if anger-prone leads wear you out, or you want a twist ending rather than a familiar late-book wobble.

Reading the Signs by Keira Andrews book cover

Reading the Signs at a Glance

Reading the Signs is a standalone M/M baseball romance by Keira Andrews, first published by KA Books in September 2016 and reissued in 2024. It pairs a 34-year-old veteran catcher with a rookie pitcher, alternates between both men, carries steamy open-door heat with light D/s and ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorKeira Andrews
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreSports romance, M/M contemporary (professional baseball)
Main tropesAge gap, brother's teammate, rookie and veteran, coming out, light D/s
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsInternalized and family homophobia, a slur, past parental death, injury, explicit sex with spanking and restraint (full list below)
POVDual, alternating Jake and Nico (Jake has more chapters)
EndingHEA, with an epilogue
Pages294 (2016 KA Books paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Greg Boudreaux, about 8 hours 30 minutes (Tantor Audio, 2020)
First publishedSeptember 2016
PublisherKA Books (self-published by the author)

What Is Reading the Signs About?

Reading the Signs follows Nico Agresta, a rookie pitcher with a big arm, a bigger temper and a family name to live up to. His father and his older brother both won Rookie of the Year, and his Italian-American family expects him to do the same. Nico has also spent years deciding he will never act on his attraction to men.

Jake Fitzgerald is 34, a veteran catcher who plans to see out his contract and retire. He once played with Nico's brother, back when Nico was a gangly kid hanging around the clubhouse. Jake gets traded to Nico's team with one job: steady the new star on the mound. Neither man is ready for what happens off it.

What Makes This Age Gap Sports Romance Work

Reading the Signs works because the romance and the baseball are the same story. A catcher calls the game and a pitcher has to trust him, so every argument over signs and pitch selection is also an argument about control, patience and who gets to lead. Keira Andrews lets that tension carry straight into the bedroom.

That is the hook that sets it apart from sports romances where the game is set dressing. Nico's problem is discipline: he melts down when a pitch goes wrong, and Jake's job is to get him to breathe. The light D/s that develops between them is an extension of that work, not a sudden left turn. Lindsey at The Novel Approach admitted she does not even like baseball and still found the game details easy to follow, which tells you how well Andrews keeps the sport readable.

There is also the history. Jake was the man a teenage Nico quietly fixated on, and nothing ever happened. Meeting again as adults and teammates gives the forbidden pull a specific shape: a closeted rookie, a teammate's older friend and a clubhouse where neither can afford to be seen.

My Review

I came to Reading the Signs for the pitcher and catcher setup and stayed for Jake, who is one of the more likeable tired men in M/M sports romance. He is not brooding. He is just done, quietly, with a game he used to love and with risking his heart after driving away someone he cared about. Nico is the opposite, all nerves and noise, and the book is at its best when those two speeds collide.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is the reason to read this. Andrews builds the attraction through work: bullpen sessions, mound visits, Jake reading Nico's body language before Nico can read his own. When it turns physical, the shift makes sense, because Jake has already been the calm voice telling Nico what to do with his breathing and his arm. Lindsey at The Novel Approach singled out how openly the two men talk to each other once they get together, and I agree that it is refreshing. They negotiate. They check in. Nobody sulks for fifty pages over a misheard sentence.

The D/s element is light and it fits. It is about Nico handing over control he does not know how to manage, and Jake taking it carefully. Readers who want a hard power exchange will find this mild; readers nervous about kink will find it handled with consent and a lot of care.

The Characters

Nico is where readers split, and I understand why. He is 22, a perfectionist, frightened of his family's reaction and quick to explode. On the Love Bytes split review, Marieke found Nico the more developed of the two, while also wishing for more depth in the family storylines. I found him convincing and occasionally exhausting. His anger is the point of his arc, but there are stretches where I wanted to put the book down and go for a walk on his behalf.

Jake is easier company. His past, including a confrontation with a former best friend that Danielle at Love Bytes called out as a highlight, gives him weight beyond being the steady one. Marieke noted that Jake gets more chapters than Nico, and you can feel it. We spend more time in the head of the man who already knows who he is.

The family material is the most interesting part of the book outside the bedroom. Nico's father and grandmother are openly homophobic at points, and the father's effort to change is handled without making it easy. Danielle praised exactly this. I wished, like Marieke, that the siblings had been given more room.

Writing and Pacing

Andrews writes clean, plain prose that moves. The opening chapters are the weakest: Marieke called the start slow and heavy on telling, and I felt that too, with a lot of setup about Rookie of the Year and family legacy before Jake and Nico share real page time. Once they are working together the book picks up and stays up.

The final act is the soft spot. Lindsey found the ending predictable and a bit of a letdown in its last chapters, and Marieke thought the late conflict felt rushed and familiar. I would put it more gently: the crisis is the one you expect from a closeted athlete romance, and it resolves on schedule. The epilogue is warm. It just does not surprise you.

Reading the Signs is a hot, credible baseball romance whose best scenes happen sixty feet and six inches apart. Read it if you want a sports book where the game and the romance feed each other, and you can ride out a hot-tempered hero.

How Spicy Is Reading the Signs?

Reading the Signs is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The sex is open door and frank, it begins once the two men are past the early tension, and it includes first-time M/M exploration for Nico and a light D/s dynamic with spanking and restraint. Everything is between consenting adults: Jake is 34 and Nico is 22.

The power exchange is mild and negotiated, but there is also a workplace imbalance: Jake is the veteran brought in to manage Nico on the field. The book treats that seriously rather than glossing it. For more in this range, see our spicy romance books and the romance heat levels guide.

Content warnings, drawn from the publisher description and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Reading the Signs?

Reading the Signs suits readers who want an M/M sports romance with real game detail, a twelve-year age gap between adults and a gentle introduction to D/s. It is less suited to readers who dislike volatile leads, family homophobia on the page or familiar third-act conflicts.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Reading the Signs has a steady following among M/M readers, with a 3.93 average from about 4,500 Goodreads ratings. Bloggers agree that the chemistry and the baseball work; they split over the slow opening, Nico's temper and how predictable the ending is.

Where they agree. The relationship is the draw. Lindsey at The Novel Approach gave it four stars, praising the emotional and physical chemistry, the realistic angst and the leads' open communication. Danielle at Love Bytes, rating it 4.5, loved the slowly built trust and the sports story.

Where they split. On the same Love Bytes post, Marieke gave it 3.5, finding the opening slow, the writing not always engaging and the late conflict rushed. Lindsey, despite her high rating, thought the final chapters predictable. Goodreads readers who struggled with the book tend to point at Nico's anger and the pacing rather than the romance itself.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Reading the Signs scores 7.3 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. It earns its best marks for romance and heat, where bloggers praise the chemistry and the communication, and loses ground on characters, pacing and a predictable ending.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Chemistry built through the game; The Novel Approach praises emotional and physical connection.
Characters (15%)3.5Jake is strong; Nico's anger divides readers, and Love Bytes wanted more family depth.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Clean and readable, but Love Bytes found the opening slow and heavy on telling.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Family homophobia and the coming-out arc land; the crisis is familiar.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers frank open-door scenes and light D/s, as the publisher's mature tag signals.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A warm HEA and epilogue, though The Novel Approach found the ending predictable.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5Readers return for the chemistry; the plot has few surprises on a second read.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Reading the Signs sits in the solid middle of Keira Andrews's contemporary catalogue, hotter and more athletic than Honeymoon for One but less tender, and it lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.3/10.

Is Reading the Signs a Standalone?

Yes. Reading the Signs is a standalone novel with a complete romance and a happily ever after, so you can start here without reading anything else by Keira Andrews. It is not part of a series, and no sequel follows Jake and Nico.

If you want more from the author, her other contemporary standalones include Honeymoon for One, an age gap travel romance with a late-deafened hero. Her historical and adventure titles include Kidnapped by the Pirate and Beyond the Sea.

Best format: print or ebook if you want to follow the baseball detail at your own speed. The Tantor Audio edition, narrated by Greg Boudreaux, runs about eight and a half hours and suits the book's quick dialogue. Our series order guide covers longer sports series.

If You Loved Reading the Signs, Read These Next

If you loved Reading the Signs, look for M/M sports romances with an age gap, a closeted athlete or a careful power dynamic between adults.

Frequently Asked Questions

Reading the Signs prompts a handful of common questions about heat, ages, the ending, the audiobook and whether you need other books first. Short answers below.

Is Reading the Signs spicy?

Yes. Reading the Signs is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit open-door scenes and a light, consensual D/s dynamic that includes spanking and restraint.

How old are Jake and Nico in Reading the Signs?

Jake is 34, per the publisher description, and readers put Nico at 22. Both are adults throughout the romance; Nico's teenage crush on Jake was never acted on.

Is Reading the Signs a standalone?

Yes. Reading the Signs is a standalone with a complete story, so no other Keira Andrews book is needed first.

Does Reading the Signs have a happy ending?

Yes. Reading the Signs ends with a happily ever after and a warm epilogue.

Is there a Reading the Signs audiobook?

Yes. Tantor Audio released it in 2020, narrated by Greg Boudreaux, with a running time of about eight and a half hours.

Is there a love triangle in Reading the Signs?

No. The romance stays focused on Jake and Nico, though Jake's past relationship shapes how cautious he is.

The Bottom Line

Reading the Signs earns 7.3/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want an M/M baseball romance with steamy heat, light D/s and a calm veteran paired with a volatile rookie. The one reason to pick it up is how cleverly Keira Andrews ties the pitcher and catcher relationship to the romance: by the time the signs mean something else, you will have learned how to read them too.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.