Snowed In by Catherine Walsh Review
Eikna Score: 7.5/10. Recommended.
Snowed In is a warm, funny Irish Christmas fake dating romance carried by two well-drawn leads and a lot of good banter. It takes its time getting to the kiss and to the snow promised in the title, and the village cast can crowd the second half, but the payoff is a grown-up couple worth rooting for.
Read it if you love fake dating, big nosy families and a long slow burn with sharp dialogue, or you want Christmas in a small Irish village. Skip it if you want snowbound isolation from page one, quick heat or a book with a small cast.
Snowed In at a Glance
Snowed In is a holiday fake dating romance by Catherine Walsh, first published by Bookouture in November 2023 and released in the US by Forever on October 1, 2024. Two people from the same Irish village pretend to date to survive Christmas at home, with alternating first-person chapters, a slow burn and a happy ending.
| Author | Catherine Walsh |
|---|---|
| Series | Catherine Walsh Christmas romcoms, book 2 (a companion to Holiday Romance; reads as a standalone) |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy, holiday contemporary set in Ireland |
| Main tropes | Fake dating, slow burn, runaway bride returns home, snowed in, small-town family pressure |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Past controlling relationship, small-town hostility and gossip, family conflict (full list below) |
| POV | Dual first person, alternating between Megan and Christian |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 336 (Forever paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Colm Gleeson and Roisin Rankin, 10 hours 38 minutes |
| First published | November 2023 (Bookouture); US edition October 1, 2024 |
| Publisher | Bookouture (UK); Forever (US) |
What Is Snowed In About?
Snowed In opens with a bride running from her own wedding, then jumps forward several years. Megan O'Sullivan left Isaac, the village golden boy, at the altar, moved to Dublin and built a life in marketing. Back home, she is still the woman who ran.
Christian Fitzpatrick grew up in the same village, though they were never friends. He manages luxury rental properties now, and after a disastrous date in a Dublin pub, the two strike a deal: they will pretend to be together over Christmas to keep their families and neighbours off their backs. Between village gossip, family dinners and a snowstorm, the pretending gets harder to keep fake.
What Makes This Fake Dating Romance Work
Snowed In works because the fake relationship protects both of them for real reasons. Megan needs armour against a village that never forgave her; Christian has his own family pressure, including a difficult relationship with his father. All About Romance noted that each lead uses the arrangement to withstand hometown scrutiny, and that mutual need gives the deal more weight than a typical holiday pretence.
The other draw is the voice. Walsh writes alternating first person with quick, conversational banter, and Lady Geek Girl and Friends called the writing sharp, thoughtful and very funny. Megan and Christian are adults who talk to each other, which makes the slow burn feel deliberate rather than stalled.
If fake dating at Christmas is your comfort trope, this is a satisfying version of it, with a little more bite than most.
My Review
Snowed In is the kind of holiday romance that rewards patience. The first half is a pleasure: two people who barely know each other building a convincing lie and discovering they like the company. The second half is slower and busier, and the snow arrives later than the title suggests. I still finished it smiling.
The strongest thing here is how adult it feels. Megan and Christian are not kids playing at love; they are working adults with histories and families that will not leave them alone.
Romance and Chemistry
The banter does most of the romantic work, and it is very good. Christian is attentive and charming, a former bad boy who has grown into someone who notices things, and Megan is defensive and funny in equal measure. Their chemistry builds through small kindnesses in public that start to mean something in private.
The burn is slow. All About Romance's Kayne Spooner pointed out that there is no real kiss until about 70 percent through, and the Bookish Wayfarer felt the delayed payoff made the title's promise feel overstated. I liked the wait more than they did, because the communication between the two is unusually mature, but readers who want early sparks should know it is coming late.
The Characters
Megan carries the book. The reason she ran from her wedding is held back until late, which frustrated All About Romance, and when it arrives it reframes her past as a controlling relationship rather than a whim. Her refusal to explain herself to people who have already judged her makes her prickly and sympathetic at once.
Christian is Andrew's brother from Holiday Romance, and Molly and Andrew return in supporting roles. Lady Geek Girl and Friends enjoyed those cameos; a StoryGraph reader found the interconnected cast a distraction. The village is the weak link. Books Etcetera felt Megan's treatment by the townspeople was over the top, and I agree that the hostility sometimes reads more like plot device than small-town reality.
Writing and Pacing
Walsh's prose is light and quick, and the holiday detail is lovely: All About Romance enjoyed the decorations and celebrations, and the Irish setting gives familiar traditions a fresh angle. The dual first person keeps the voices distinct.
The pacing dips in the back half. All About Romance found that the many friends and family members slow things down, and the Bookish Wayfarer noted that the snowstorm only arrives in the final quarter. Once it does, the snowed-in stretch is cosy, and the ending earns its happiness.
Snowed In is a funny, grown-up fake dating romance with a slow burn worth the wait and a village that sometimes gets in the way. Read it if you want banter and Irish Christmas warmth more than a snowbound thriller.
How Spicy Is Snowed In?
Snowed In is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The slow burn holds back intimacy until late in the book, and reviewers describe one or two steamy scenes once the couple finally gets together. All About Romance called the snowed-in stretch cosy and spicy.
Most of the book is banter and tension rather than heat. For more romance in this range, see our spicy romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from reviews:
- A past controlling relationship (the heroine's former fiance)
- Small-town hostility, gossip and public shaming
- Family pressure and a strained father and son relationship
- Consensual sex between adults
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Snowed In?
Snowed In suits readers who love fake dating, slow burns and holiday romances full of family and banter. It is less suited to readers who want quick heat, a snowbound story from the start or a small, focused cast.
Best for:
- Fans of fake dating at Christmas
- Readers who like dual first-person narration
- Anyone who wants an Irish holiday setting
- Readers who enjoy mature communication between leads
- Fans of Holiday Romance who want more of the Fitzpatricks
Not for:
- Readers who need an early first kiss
- Anyone expecting a full book of snowbound isolation
- Readers who dislike large supporting casts
- Those who want high heat
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Snowed In drew warm reviews for its banter, leads and holiday atmosphere. Critics agree the writing is funny and the couple is lovable; they split over the very slow burn, the late snowstorm and a crowded second half.
Where they agree. The voice and the couple. Lady Geek Girl and Friends called the writing sharp and very funny and praised both leads. All About Romance gave it a B and called it "a sweet, light, pleasant read." Books Etcetera loved the shift from fake to real feelings, and the Bookish Wayfarer praised the chemistry.
Where they split. Pacing and promise. All About Romance was frustrated by the late reveal of why Megan ran and by how long the first kiss takes. The Bookish Wayfarer felt the snowed-in premise is oversold, and a StoryGraph reader found the side cast slow. Books Etcetera thought the villagers' hostility was overdone.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Snowed In scores 7.5 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its romance, characters and ending score well, and it loses ground on a slow second half, a late snowstorm and a village cast that thins the emotional punch.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Banter-driven chemistry and mature communication, per the Bookish Wayfarer. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Lady Geek Girl and Friends praises two well-developed leads. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Funny dual first person; All About Romance finds the second half slow. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Megan's past lands, though All About Romance finds the reveal too late. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | A late, cosy payoff that suits a slow burn; not for heat seekers. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A warm, earned HEA after the snowed-in stretch. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | A good December comfort reread for the banter alone. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Snowed In sits comfortably in the upper half of recent fake dating holiday romances, more grown-up than most and slower than some, with a final Eikna Score of 7.5/10.
Is Snowed In a Standalone?
Yes. Snowed In is the second of Catherine Walsh's Christmas romantic comedies, but it has its own couple and a complete story, so it reads well as a standalone. Holiday Romance, the first, follows Molly and Andrew, who appear here in supporting roles.
Reading order:
- Holiday Romance: Molly and Andrew
- Snowed In: Megan and Christian
Start with Holiday Romance if you want the cameos to land; otherwise jump straight in. Best format: the audiobook, with Colm Gleeson and Roisin Rankin voicing the two narrators, suits the banter and the Irish setting. Our series order guide covers more holiday series.
If You Loved Snowed In, Read These Next
If you loved Snowed In, look for holiday romances with fake relationships, family pressure and a good dose of banter.
- Faking Christmas by Kerry Winfrey: a fake marriage, a snowstorm and a family Christmas that makes the lie harder to keep.
- The Holiday Swap by Maggie Knox: twin sisters trade lives for Christmas, with small-town romance on one side.
- A Holly Jolly Diwali by Sonya Lalli: a heroine escaping family expectations finds romance on a trip abroad.
- The Christmas Deal by Keira Andrews: an M/M fake dating holiday romance with steam and a happy ending.
Frequently Asked Questions
Snowed In raises a few common questions: how spicy it is, whether you need Holiday Romance first, how it ends and where it is set. Short answers below.
Is Snowed In by Catherine Walsh spicy?
Moderately. Snowed In is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with one or two steamy scenes late in a long slow burn.
Do I need to read Holiday Romance before Snowed In?
No. Snowed In has its own couple and a complete story. Holiday Romance adds context for the cameos from Molly and Andrew.
Does Snowed In have a happy ending?
Yes. Megan and Christian get a happily ever after.
Where is Snowed In set?
Snowed In is set in Dublin and in the small Irish village where Megan and Christian grew up, over the Christmas holidays.
Is Snowed In fake dating?
Yes. Megan and Christian agree to pretend to date over Christmas to handle their families and their hometown.
Is there a Snowed In audiobook?
Yes. The audiobook is narrated by Colm Gleeson and Roisin Rankin and runs about 10 hours 38 minutes.
The Bottom Line
Snowed In earns a 7.5/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a funny, grown-up fake dating romance at an Irish Christmas and can wait for the kiss. The one reason to pick it up is the banter between Megan and Christian, which makes even a crowded family dinner feel like a date.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Snowed In, Hachette Book Group (Forever edition)
- Catherine Walsh, author newsletter
- Snowed In review, All About Romance (Kayne Spooner)
- Snowed In review, Lady Geek Girl and Friends
- Snowed In review, Books Etcetera
- Snowed In review, The Bookish Wayfarer
- Snowed In reader reviews, StoryGraph
- Snowed In audiobook, Audible
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.