eikna romance
Menu

Faking Christmas by Kerry Winfrey Review

Eikna Score: 6.8/10. Recommended with reservations.

Faking Christmas is a snowbound holiday farce with a fake husband, a lying heroine and a farmhouse full of family who keep the con running, and as a comedy of errors it is great fun. As a romance it is thinner: the rival-to-husband chemistry arrives late and the ending wraps up faster than the lie deserves.

Read it if you want a cosy, clean Christmas farce in the spirit of a holiday movie, or you love fake relationships under one snowed-in roof. Skip it if secondhand embarrassment and escalating lies stress you out, or you need a slow, deep romance from your holiday read.

Faking Christmas by Kerry Winfrey book cover

Faking Christmas at a Glance

Faking Christmas is a standalone 2023 Berkley holiday romantic comedy by Kerry Winfrey. To keep her job, Laurel Grant pretends she owns her twin sister's farm outside Columbus, Ohio, and her rival Max Beckett plays her husband for one dinner, until a snowstorm traps everyone for the weekend. It is closed door and ends happily.

AuthorKerry Winfrey
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreHoliday romantic comedy, contemporary
Main tropesFake marriage, rivals to lovers, snowed in, grumpy sunshine, twin swap of sorts
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsInfidelity mentions, difficult childhood, lying and fear of exposure (full list below)
POVCentred on Laurel
EndingHappy ending
Pages288 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Jennifer Jill Araya, 7 hours 31 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio)
First publishedSeptember 26, 2023
PublisherBerkley

What Is Faking Christmas About?

Faking Christmas stars Laurel Grant, social media manager for Buckeye State of Mind, an Ohio tourism magazine and website. Through a misunderstanding, her recently divorced boss Gilbert comes to believe that Laurel owns Meadow Rise Farm, the property just outside Columbus that actually belongs to her twin sister, Holly. Laurel, afraid for her job, does not correct him.

Then Gilbert invites himself to the farm's Christmas Eve Eve dinner. Laurel needs the life she has been posting about, including a husband, so she recruits Max Beckett, her nemesis since Holly's wedding. It is supposed to last one evening. A snowstorm keeps everyone at the farm for the whole weekend.

What Makes This Fake Marriage Romance Work

Faking Christmas works because it commits to the farce. One small lie grows into a borrowed farm, a borrowed life and a borrowed husband, and every hour of the snowstorm adds a new way to get caught. Publishers Weekly, in a starred review, called it "a clever comedy of errors," and that is exactly what it is.

The family makes it cosy. Holly's farm and family become part of the con, and the holiday set pieces, cookie decorating, Christmas karaoke and a farmhouse full of food, give the lie plenty of chances to wobble. Good Books and Good Wine loved those festive details, and BookPage called the book hot chocolate in book form.

The romance is a rivals-turned-fake spouses setup, and readers who like a grumpy man softening under a shared roof will recognise the shape at once.

My Review

Faking Christmas is the most purely fun of Kerry Winfrey's books and the least romantic. I laughed at the escalating lie, winced at Laurel's close calls and enjoyed every minute at Meadow Rise Farm. I just did not feel that much between Laurel and Max until the book was nearly over.

Jen DeLuca's blurb called it a Hallmark Christmas movie in book form, and that is a good guide to what you get: a snowstorm, a farm, a family, a misunderstanding and a kiss under the right lights.

Romance and Chemistry

Max is a good grump. He has been needling Laurel since the wedding, and his deadpan cooperation with her scheme is the funniest thread in the book. Good Books and Good Wine enjoyed the grumpy-meets-sunny dynamic, and so did I. The problem is timing. GoodeyReads found the setup contrived and the romance late, and wanted more flirting and connection. Lucy D at EBookObsessed questioned the chemistry outright. The fake marriage keeps them busy performing for Gilbert, which leaves fewer scenes where they are simply honest with each other.

When those scenes come, they are sweet. Max is helpful and steady, a point Good Books and Good Wine made too, and the moment Laurel realises she likes him more than the role she cast him in is well judged. I wanted it fifty pages earlier.

The Characters

Laurel is a heroine who lies a lot, and your patience for her will decide the book. The Penguin Random House reader guide frames her story around comparison with her twin and the question of reinvention, and that is the most interesting layer: Laurel envies Holly's life enough to borrow it. Phoebe Wright at Read and Wright praised the dialogue and the ensemble, and the family cast, from Holly to the oblivious Gilbert, is consistently funny.

The StoryGraph reader amyradak enjoyed the hijinks but found the fear of exposure stressful and the relationship thin, which matches my own reading. Lucy D wanted more growth from Laurel by the end.

Gilbert deserves a word. A recently divorced boss who invites himself to Christmas is a gift to a farce, and Winfrey plays him as oblivious rather than villainous, which keeps the comedy warm. The stakes are his good opinion and Laurel's job, nothing darker, and that low ceiling is part of why the book feels so cosy and also why it never quite hurts.

Writing and Pacing

At 288 pages, the book moves briskly, and Winfrey's comic timing is at its sharpest here. Kirkus enjoyed the tenderness and mischief, and Entertainment Weekly said it sparkles with wit. The ending is the weak spot. Pawsitive Reads loved the farce but found the revelation and resolution too quick, and I agree: a lie this big deserved a more complicated reckoning than it gets. Jennifer Jill Araya's audiobook is short and lively; Good Books and Good Wine finished it in a day.

Faking Christmas is a bright, funny holiday farce with a great setup and a romance that warms up late. Read it for the comedy and the farm at Christmas; skip it if you want the love story to carry the book.

How Spicy Is Faking Christmas?

Faking Christmas is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. GoodeyReads mentions kissing, and Phoebe Wright at Read and Wright gave it zero on her personal spice scale. There are no sex scenes on the page.

It sits comfortably on our closed door romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from Read and Wright and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read Faking Christmas?

Faking Christmas suits readers who want a short, clean, funny holiday farce with a fake marriage and a snowed-in family Christmas. It is less suited to readers who want a slow-building romance or who struggle with heroines who keep lying.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Faking Christmas earned a starred review from Publishers Weekly, and Kirkus, BookPage and Entertainment Weekly were all warm. Reader reviews agree on the farce and split on the romance.

Where they agree. The comedy and the setting. Publishers Weekly praised the comedy of errors, Good Books and Good Wine loved the farm and the holiday details, and Phoebe Wright praised the dialogue and the ensemble.

Where they split. The romance and the ending. GoodeyReads found the romance late and the setup contrived, Lucy D at EBookObsessed questioned the chemistry and the growth, amyradak on StoryGraph found the relationship thin, and Pawsitive Reads thought the resolution came too quickly.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Faking Christmas scores 6.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best mark for a heat level that matches its clean promise and lower marks for emotional impact and the ending, which reviewers found rushed.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Max is a good grump, per Good Books and Good Wine; GoodeyReads finds the romance late.
Characters (15%)3.5Read and Wright praises the ensemble; Lucy D questions Laurel's growth.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5PW praises the clever comedy of errors; the farce sometimes crowds the couple.
Emotional impact (15%)3The twin envy is interesting, but amyradak finds the relationship thin.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the clean, kissing-only romance Read and Wright and GoodeyReads describe.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3A warm finish that Pawsitive Reads finds too quick for the size of the lie.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A short, festive comfort read many will revisit each December.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Faking Christmas is Kerry Winfrey's funniest book but sits below her other novels as a romance, with a final Eikna Score of 6.8/10.

Is Faking Christmas a Standalone?

Yes. Faking Christmas is a standalone holiday novel with no required reading. In Kerry Winfrey's publication order it comes fifth.

  1. Waiting for Tom Hanks (2019): duology book 1
  2. Not Like the Movies (2020): duology book 2
  3. Very Sincerely Yours (2021): standalone
  4. Just Another Love Song (2022): standalone
  5. Faking Christmas (2023): standalone

Best format: the Jennifer Jill Araya audiobook, at about seven and a half hours, is an easy holiday listen. Our series order guide has more.

If You Loved Faking Christmas, Read These Next

If you loved Faking Christmas, try holiday romances with farms, fake relationships and families that get involved.

Frequently Asked Questions

These are the most common questions about Faking Christmas.

Is Faking Christmas spicy?

No. Faking Christmas is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, with kissing and no sex scenes on the page.

Is Faking Christmas a standalone?

Yes. Faking Christmas is a standalone holiday romance and does not need any other Kerry Winfrey book.

Does Faking Christmas have a happy ending?

Yes. Laurel and Max end together, though some readers found the resolution quick.

Do Laurel and Max actually get married in Faking Christmas?

No. Max only pretends to be Laurel's husband; there is no real or legal marriage in the setup.

Who narrates the Faking Christmas audiobook?

Jennifer Jill Araya narrates the audiobook, which runs about 7 hours 31 minutes.

Where is Faking Christmas set?

Faking Christmas is set on Meadow Rise Farm, just outside Columbus, Ohio, over the holidays.

The Bottom Line

Faking Christmas earns a 6.8/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a quick, clean, laugh-out-loud holiday farce with a fake husband and a snowed-in family. The one reason to pick it up is the comedy of errors itself; come for the lie, and treat the romance as a bonus.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.