eikna romance
Menu

The Faker Rulebook by Baylin Crow Review

Eikna Score: 6.8/10. Recommended with reservations.

The Faker Rulebook is a short, hot, low-angst MM romance about a gay college senior and the best friend he has loved since seventh grade, and its best scenes happen in one shared bed at a ski resort. It is also thin: the ex is a cardboard villain, the middle hurries, and Noah repeats his main worry so often that the tension turns into a loop.

Read it if you want a quick best friends to lovers story with fake dating, one bed and plenty of heat, or you like low-drama comfort reads with no homophobic family subplot. Skip it if you need a slow, detailed friendship arc, or a lead who keeps insisting his love interest must be straight would wear you down.

The Faker Rulebook by Baylin Crow book cover

The Faker Rulebook at a Glance

The Faker Rulebook is book 1 of Baylin Crow's Boyfriend Rules series, a self-published MM new adult romance first released in January 2021. It pairs a gay college senior with his best friend at a family wedding, mixes fake dating with friends to lovers and one bed, runs steamy and ends happily ever after.

AuthorBaylin Crow
SeriesBoyfriend Rules, book 1 (each book follows a new couple)
SubgenreLGBTQ romance (MM new adult, college, contemporary)
Main tropesFake dating, friends to lovers, one bed, pining, queer awakening
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsCheating ex, jealousy and possessiveness, alcohol, explicit sex (full list below)
POVDual POV, Noah and Rook
EndingHEA, with an epilogue
Pages182 (Kindle); 192 (paperback, 2022)
AudiobookNarrated by Iggy Toma, 5 hours 30 minutes (Tantor Media, 2023)
First publishedJanuary 3, 2021
PublisherSelf-published by Baylin Crow

What Is The Faker Rulebook About?

The Faker Rulebook follows Noah, a gay college senior who has spent years quietly in love with his best friend, Rook Oliveira. They have been inseparable since seventh grade. Rook is, as far as Noah knows, straight.

Now Noah's brother is getting married, and the best man is Noah's ex, the one who cheated on him. Rook's solution is simple: he will go as Noah's boyfriend. Noah agrees, but only with rules, a whole list of them, meant to protect his heart from a friend who is just pretending. Five days at a ski resort and one shared bed later, the rules are not holding up well.

What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work

The Faker Rulebook works because it pairs two of the most reliable tropes in romance and puts them under one roof. Friends to lovers supplies the history: a decade of inside jokes and the fear of losing everything. Fake dating supplies the excuse to touch. The rulebook itself is the hook on top, a list Noah writes to keep the pretending safe that the story then breaks one item at a time.

The setting helps. A wedding week at a ski resort means nowhere to retreat, an ex lurking in the wedding party and a single bed. Love Bytes Reviews singled out that forced proximity and the one-bed setup as part of the appeal, alongside the warmth of the friendship.

And it is gentle. Love Bytes noted there is no outside opposition: teammates and both families accept the couple without fuss. Readers who want friends to lovers stories without a homophobia subplot will find that a relief.

My Review

The Faker Rulebook is a book I enjoyed in the moment and forgot quickly. It is short, warm and very steamy, and Baylin Crow writes the physical comfort between two lifelong friends well. What it does not do is give the friendship or the conflict enough room to become more than a sketch.

Love Bytes Reviews gave it four and a half hearts and called it sweet, heartwarming and low angst. Goodreads readers are cooler, at an average of about 3.85 from roughly 3,000 ratings, and their complaints line up with mine.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is the strongest thing here. Noah and Rook have the kind of shorthand that only comes from years together, and the move from casual affection to something charged is believable. Rook in particular is fun to watch: he does not care much about labels, only whether what he feels is real. Love Bytes said he "only cares about the authenticity or truth of his feelings," and that refusal to agonize is refreshing.

The problem is Noah's side of it. For much of the book Noah keeps telling himself, and Rook, that Rook is straight and this cannot be real. Once is character. Several times is a stall. Goodreads readers named this as the most frustrating part of the book, and I agree: the conflict is not Noah's fear, which is understandable, but the way the book repeats it instead of developing it.

The Characters

Rook is the better drawn of the two, a confident athlete with a soft streak and no interest in drama. Noah is sympathetic but narrower. His hurt over the cheating ex should give him more depth, but the ex is so plainly awful that there is little to work through. The wedding party and families are pleasant background, and the decision to make everyone accepting keeps the book cozy while also draining it of stakes.

The friendship history is the part I wanted more of. The book tells us they met as kids and have been close ever since, and gives us flashes of that, but at under 200 pages there is no space to show it growing. Goodreads readers who wanted the book longer have a point.

Writing and Pacing

The prose is plain and easy, built for speed. Crow is good at the small physical beats of a scene: the shared bed, a hand on a knee, a kiss for an audience that is not entirely for the audience. The opening sets things up efficiently and the ending lands with a satisfying epilogue.

The middle is where it loses shape. Several Goodreads readers found it rushed or fragmented, and the fake dating angle fades faster than the setup suggests. The rulebook, which gives the book its title and its best idea, also drops out of focus for long stretches, and some readers felt it was more gimmick than device. That is a missed opportunity. A list of rules is a great engine for a romance if every broken rule costs something.

The ski resort is underused, too. Ski resort weddings are a gift to a romance writer, and apart from the bed and a few public displays for the ex, the setting could be any hotel. I wanted one scene on the slopes, one awkward rehearsal dinner, one moment where the pretending is tested by someone who knows them both well.

As a quick, hot read it delivers exactly what the blurb promises: high steam, low angst. As a friends to lovers story, it is a sketch of a better book.

The Faker Rulebook is a steamy, sweet and very quick MM fake dating romance whose chemistry outruns its thin plot and repetitive conflict. Read it if you want an evening of comfort and heat, not if you want the friendship explored in depth.

How Spicy Is The Faker Rulebook?

The Faker Rulebook is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The blurb promises high steam, Romance.io readers rate it 4 out of 5 for steam, and Love Bytes Reviews called the sex scenes seriously hot. The scenes are explicit and consensual, and they grow out of the fake relationship and the shared bed.

Noah and Rook are both college seniors, adults throughout; their childhood friendship appears only as backstory. For more in this heat range, see our spicy romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reviews and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Faker Rulebook?

The Faker Rulebook suits readers who want a short, spicy MM romance that combines best friends to lovers, fake dating and one bed, with accepting families and very little angst. It is less suited to readers who want a fully developed friendship arc or a conflict that changes as the book goes on.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Faker Rulebook has around 3,000 ratings on Goodreads with an average of about 3.85, and coverage is almost entirely MM review blogs and readers rather than trade critics.

Where they agree. The chemistry and the comfort. Love Bytes Reviews gave it four and a half hearts and praised the warm friendship, the low angst, the one-bed proximity and the heat. Goodreads readers who liked it highlight the sweet friends to lovers arc, the banter, the steamy scenes and a satisfying ending with an epilogue.

Where they split. Depth and repetition. The most common Goodreads complaint is Noah insisting over and over that Rook is straight. Readers also found the book too short, the middle rushed and the characters underdeveloped, and some felt the rulebook device added little. Love Bytes acknowledged the lack of any outside opposition, seeing it as a feature that keeps the focus on the leads; for other readers it removes the stakes.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Faker Rulebook scores 6.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best mark for heat, which delivers exactly what the blurb promises, and its lowest for writing and emotional impact, where reader reviews point to a rushed middle and low stakes.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Strong friendship chemistry, per Love Bytes Reviews; the repeated doubt stalls it.
Characters (15%)3.5Rook is fun; Goodreads readers call the leads underdeveloped.
Writing and pacing (15%)3Easy, quick prose; Goodreads readers find the middle rushed and fragmented.
Emotional impact (15%)3Warm but low stakes, with no outside opposition, as Love Bytes notes.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the high steam the blurb promises; Romance.io readers rate it 4 of 5.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A satisfying HEA and epilogue that readers enjoy, reached a little fast.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A comfort reread for the one-bed scenes more than the plot.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Faker Rulebook sits in the middle of the MM fake dating pack: hotter and sweeter than many, but thinner than the best friends to lovers books it invites comparison with, at a final Eikna Score of 6.8/10.

Boyfriend Rules Reading Order

The Faker Rulebook is book 1 of Baylin Crow's Boyfriend Rules series and works as a standalone with a complete HEA. The next book follows a different couple, so you can stop here or carry on in order.

  1. The Faker Rulebook (2021): Noah and Rook
  2. The Hater Playbook: basketball player Knight Jackson and his best friend's younger brother

Best format: the Tantor Media audiobook narrated by Iggy Toma runs about five and a half hours, short enough for a single long drive. Our series order guide covers more MM series.

If You Loved The Faker Rulebook, Read These Next

If you loved The Faker Rulebook, the closest matches are MM romances with fake relationships at weddings, a lot of heat and leads who fall for the person they are pretending with.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Faker Rulebook raises the same questions for most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and whether Rook is really straight. Short answers below.

Is The Faker Rulebook spicy?

Yes. The Faker Rulebook is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with multiple explicit, consensual scenes; the blurb calls it high steam, low angst.

Is The Faker Rulebook a standalone?

Yes. The Faker Rulebook is book 1 of Boyfriend Rules but has a complete story and HEA; book 2, The Hater Playbook, follows a new couple.

Does The Faker Rulebook have a happy ending?

Yes. The Faker Rulebook ends happily ever after for Noah and Rook, with an epilogue.

How old are the characters in The Faker Rulebook?

Noah and Rook are college seniors, adults throughout the romance; they met as children, which appears only as backstory.

Is Rook straight in The Faker Rulebook?

Rook begins the book identified as straight, and the story explores his feelings for Noah; he cares more about what he feels than about labels.

Is there a Faker Rulebook audiobook?

Yes. The Faker Rulebook audiobook is narrated by Iggy Toma for Tantor Media and runs about 5 hours 30 minutes.

The Bottom Line

The Faker Rulebook earns a 6.8/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a quick, steamy, low-angst MM romance with best friends, a fake relationship and one bed at a winter wedding. The one reason to pick it up is the ease between Noah and Rook: when the book lets them simply be two people who have loved each other for years, it is lovely.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.