The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings by Lily Morton Review
Eikna Score: 7.9/10. Recommended.
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings is Lily Morton's banter and big heart moved into a properly scary haunted house in York, and it works: a grieving man, a blue-haired ghost-tour guide who really can see the dead, and a slow burn that turns friendship into something tender. The mystery is easy to guess and both heroes make a daft decision near the end, but the warmth, the jokes and the creeping dread make it hard to put down.
Read it if you want a cosy-meets-creepy MM ghost story with a slow burn, British humour and two lovable leads. Skip it if you want a twisty whodunit, or you need the romance fully settled in book one of a series about the same couple.
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings at a Glance
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings is Lily Morton's 2019 MM paranormal romance and book 1 of her Black and Blue series, self-published on November 15, 2019. Set in present-day York, it pairs Levi Black with ghost-tour guide Blue Billings, runs 276 pages and ends on a hopeful note, with the same couple continuing through two more books.
| Author | Lily Morton |
|---|---|
| Series | Black and Blue, book 1 of 3 (same couple across the series) |
| Subgenre | MM romance, paranormal ghost mystery (York, England) |
| Main tropes | Slow burn, friends to lovers, haunted house, opposites attract, psychic hero |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Grief, teenage homelessness, gruesome historic murders, malevolent ghosts (full list below) |
| POV | Dual POV, Levi and Blue |
| Ending | HFN; the couple continues in books 2 and 3 |
| Pages | 276 |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Joel Leslie, 10 hours 15 minutes (2020) |
| First published | November 15, 2019 |
| Publisher | Lily Morton (independently published) |
What Is The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings About?
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings begins with Levi Black running out of road. His mother has died, his long relationship is over, and when he inherits a house in York he leaves London for a fresh start in a city he barely knows.
The house has other plans. Nobody who lives there stays long, and almost as soon as Levi moves in the noises start, then the cold spots, then things that are genuinely frightening. Desperate, he turns to Blue Billings, a blue-haired guide in Victorian dress who runs ghost tours around York and, unlike most people in that line of work, can actually see ghosts. Together they start digging into the house's history, which leads back to a nineteenth-century killer, while Levi tries to work out whether he can trust the strange, guarded man who keeps saving his life.
What Makes This Slow Burn Romance Work
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings works because the slow burn has a reason to be slow. Levi is grieving and raw, and Blue has spent most of his life learning not to rely on anybody. Their friendship comes first, and it is funny and kind and full of Morton's quick, rude British dialogue, so by the time it turns romantic you are completely on their side. Caz Owens at All About Romance called the slow-burn romance sweet and sexy, and praised how well two very different men fit together.
The second hook is York. Morton uses the city's narrow streets, the Minster and its ghost-tour trade so vividly that All About Romance said the city feels like a character. The ghost story is properly creepy, too, which gives the warmth something to push against.
If you like your slow burn with jump scares, this is the book.
My Review
I came to The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings as a Lily Morton reader who knew her for contemporary banter, and I was nervous about the ghosts. I need not have been. The jokes are all still here, the feelings are bigger than usual, and the haunted house made me turn the lights on.
Romance and Chemistry
Levi and Blue's chemistry is the gentle, teasing kind that grows out of shared fear and shared jokes. The book takes its time, and I liked that, because both men need it. All About Romance praised the banter and tenderness between them, and Lisa at The Novel Approach made a point of saying the romance is central to the story rather than a sideline to the ghost plot.
Not everyone agrees. Some reader reviewers say they loved each hero separately more than they loved them together, and that the ghost mystery crowds the romance in places. I can see it in the middle third, when the investigation takes over. But the quieter scenes between them, especially one involving stained glass that All About Romance singled out as lovely, are some of the most affecting things Morton has written.
The Characters
Blue is the reason the book has his name on the cover. He is bright, odd, prickly and funny, with blue hair and Victorian clothes, and underneath it he is someone who has been surviving alone for a very long time. Love Bytes noted that he was raised by a mentally ill mother and has been homeless or squatting since he was thirteen, and the book treats that history with care rather than melodrama.
Levi is quieter and easier to overlook, but I liked him a lot. His grief is handled sensitively, which All About Romance also praised, and he is kind to Blue in practical, unshowy ways that matter more than grand gestures. The supporting cast, including Blue's friend Will and his boss Tom, is warm and funny; The Novel Approach was already hoping for more of them.
Writing and Pacing
Morton's prose is fast and conversational, and her comic timing is excellent. The scary scenes are genuinely scary, which The Novel Approach found gripping, and the house's malevolent presence builds steadily. The York history, including the house's murderous past tied to a nineteenth-century killer known as the Devil of York, gives the plot a satisfying spine.
The weak points are the mystery and the climax. All About Romance found the mystery somewhat predictable and docked half a grade for a stretch near the end where both leads behave in a "too stupid to live" way. I guessed the solution early, and I winced at the decision that sets up the final act. Neither stopped me enjoying it.
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings is a warm, funny and properly spooky slow burn with a predictable mystery and a wobbly climax. Read it if you want ghosts with your banter and you are happy to follow Levi and Blue across three books.
How Spicy Is The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings?
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The slow burn means the physical relationship arrives late, and when it does there is on-page sex, but the book is far more interested in the emotional side. All About Romance rated the sensuality warm, and its reviewer described the romance as sweet and sexy. The sex is consensual and affectionate.
Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and our own read:
- Grief, including the recent death of a parent
- Teenage homelessness and a parent's mental illness, in Blue's past
- A history of sexual exploitation
- Discussion of gruesome historic murders
- Malevolent ghosts and frightening supernatural attacks
- References to suicide
- On-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings?
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings suits readers who want a slow-burn MM romance wrapped around a creepy haunted-house mystery, with British humour, grief handled gently and moderate heat. It is less suited to readers who want a clever whodunit, a fast romance or a couple whose story ends in book one.
Best for:
- Fans of slow burn and friends to lovers MM romance
- Readers who like ghost stories that are actually scary
- Lily Morton fans curious about her paranormal side
- Audiobook listeners (Joel Leslie's narration is widely praised)
Not for:
- Readers who want a twisty, hard-to-solve mystery
- Anyone who needs a full HEA in book one
- Readers who want high, frequent heat (try our spicy picks)
- Readers avoiding grief or frightening supernatural content
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings was well received, with coverage coming mostly from romance review blogs and reader reviews. Caz Owens at All About Romance gave the book a B+ and later highly recommended the audiobook; The Novel Approach gave it five stars; and Love Bytes gave the audiobook five hearts and called it one of Morton's best.
Where they agree. The leads, the humour and the atmosphere. Reviewers praise Levi and Blue as likeable and well rounded, the balance of humour, pathos and scares, and York as a vivid setting. The audiobook gets particular love: All About Romance praised Joel Leslie's comic timing and his accent for Blue, and Love Bytes said he gives every character a distinct voice.
Where they split. The mystery and the romance balance. All About Romance found the mystery predictable and the climax marred by poor decisions. Some reader reviewers enjoyed the heroes individually more than the romance between them, or felt the ghost plot dominated. Readers who want a single-book romance are sometimes surprised that the couple's story continues.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings scores 7.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its highest mark for characters and lower marks for a predictable mystery, a clumsy climax and an ending built to continue the series.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | A sweet, sexy slow burn per All About Romance; some readers felt the mystery crowded it. |
| Characters (15%) | 4.5 | Blue and Levi are likeable and well rounded, per All About Romance and Love Bytes. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Fast, funny and properly scary, per The Novel Approach; the mystery is guessable. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Grief is handled sensitively, with a standout stained glass scene. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Delivers moderate, late-arriving heat that suits the slow burn; warm by AAR's scale. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A hopeful HFN after a climax All About Romance felt relied on poor choices. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 4 | A comfort reread, and the audiobook makes a strong second visit. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings is the start of Lily Morton's most atmospheric series and one of her best-loved books, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.9/10.
Black and Blue Reading Order
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings is book 1 of Lily Morton's Black and Blue series, and all three books follow Levi and Blue, so read them in order. Each book has its own ghost story, while the relationship grows across the series.
- Book 1: The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings (2019): Levi Black and Blue Billings
- Book 2: The Quiet House (2021): Levi and Blue
- Book 3: Something Wicked (2024): Levi and Blue
Best place to start: here. Best format: audiobook, if you can. Joel Leslie's narration, about 10 hours 15 minutes, is praised by All About Romance and Love Bytes alike, and his comic timing suits Morton's dialogue. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings, Read These Next
If you loved The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings, look for MM romances with ghosts, magic or old houses, plus more of Lily Morton's banter.
- The Magpie Lord by KJ Charles: a Victorian haunted house, an heir who keeps nearly dying and the magician sent to save him.
- Spectred Isle by KJ Charles: 1920s ghosts and folklore, with two wary men who learn to trust each other.
- The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal by KJ Charles: a Victorian ghost-hunter and the man who chronicles him.
- After Felix by Lily Morton: no ghosts, but Morton's angstiest and funniest contemporary second chance.
- The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy by Megan Bannen: a warm, funny fantasy romance full of the dead.
Frequently Asked Questions
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it is a standalone, how it ends and what order the series goes in. Short answers below.
Is The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings spicy?
Moderately. It is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with a slow burn and on-page sex that arrives late in the book.
Is The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings a standalone?
No. It is book 1 of the Black and Blue series, and Levi and Blue continue in The Quiet House and Something Wicked.
Does The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings have a happy ending?
It has a hopeful, happy for now ending. Levi and Blue are together, and their story continues in the next two books.
Is The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings scary?
Yes, in places. The haunted house has a malevolent presence, and reviewers found the spooky scenes genuinely creepy.
Where is The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings set?
It is set in present-day York, England, in a house with a murderous nineteenth-century history.
Is there a Blue Billings audiobook?
Yes. Joel Leslie narrates the audiobook, which runs about 10 hours 15 minutes.
What order should I read the Black and Blue series in?
Read The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings, then The Quiet House, then Something Wicked.
The Bottom Line
The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings earns a 7.9/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a warm, funny, slow-burn MM romance inside a genuinely creepy ghost story, with moderate heat and a couple worth following for three books. The reason to pick it up is Blue himself: a guarded, generous, ridiculous man you will want to see safe.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings, Lily Morton (author site: blurb, release date, length)
- The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings, All About Romance (Caz Owens)
- The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings audiobook review, All About Romance (Caz Owens)
- Review: The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings, The Novel Approach (Lisa)
- Audiobook review: The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings, Love Bytes
- The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings audiobook, Audible
- The Quiet House (Black and Blue #2), Romance.io
- Something Wicked (Black and Blue #3), Love Bytes
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.