eikna romance
Menu

The Magpie Lord by KJ Charles Review

Eikna Score: 8.6/10. Highly recommended.

The Magpie Lord is a short, fast, nasty little Victorian ghost story wrapped around one of the best mismatched couples in MM romance: a tattooed, foul-mouthed earl back from Shanghai and a small, furious magician who has every reason to hate his family. It moves too quickly to give either man much room in the opening chapters, but the chemistry is immediate and the payoff carries you straight into book two.

Read it if you want MM historical romance with real magic, real menace and a power-exchange dynamic written with care. Skip it if animal death, a suicide attempt or questionable consent are hard limits, or you want a long, slow build before the leads fall into bed.

The Magpie Lord by KJ Charles book cover

The Magpie Lord at a Glance

The Magpie Lord is KJ Charles's first A Charm of Magpies novel, first published by Samhain on September 3, 2013 and reissued by the author's KJC Books imprint in 2017. It is a short MM paranormal historical romance set in Victorian England, pairing Lord Crane with the magician Stephen Day, and it ends on a hopeful note that the next two books build on.

AuthorKJ Charles
SeriesA Charm of Magpies, book 1 of 3 (same couple across the trilogy)
SubgenreMM romance, paranormal and historical (Victorian England)
Main tropesOpposites attract, family enemies, aristocrat and commoner, magical investigation, power exchange
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsAnimal death, suicide attempt, questionable consent, occult horror, homophobia (full list below)
POVThird person
EndingHFN for book 1; the couple continues through the trilogy
Pages202 (2017 KJC Books paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Cornell Collins (Audible Studios)
First publishedSeptember 3, 2013
PublisherSamhain Publishing (original); KJC Books (current edition)

What Is The Magpie Lord About?

The Magpie Lord opens with Lucien Vaudrey coming home. He has spent twenty years in exile in China, and he only returns to England because his father and brother have died in ugly, unexplained ways, leaving him the new Lord Crane and the owner of a house that seems to want him dead too.

Help arrives in the shape of Stephen Day, a magician who polices other magicians and who has a family grudge against the Vaudreys that is entirely justified. Stephen does not want to save a Vaudrey. He does it anyway, because it is his job, and then finds that Crane is nothing like the men who wronged his family. Someone is still trying to kill Crane, and the closer the two get, the more dangerous that becomes.

What Makes This Opposites Attract Romance Work

The Magpie Lord works because its two heroes are wrong for each other in every way the Victorian world cares about and right in every way the reader cares about. Crane is tall, rich, tattooed, vulgar and used to giving orders. Stephen is small, poor, proud, overworked and far more powerful than he looks. Neither of them is impressed by the other's credentials.

The second hook is the magic. KJ Charles does not write cosy magic. The horror in this book is physical and specific, the kind that makes you put the book down for a second, and that menace gives the romance something to push against. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books praised the Gothic atmosphere, the fast pacing and Crane's dry wit, and that combination is the reason readers keep handing this book to friends who say they do not read MM.

And it is short. At around 200 pages, it is an easy first step into a trilogy that many readers rank among the best in MM romance.

My Review

I first read The Magpie Lord in a single evening and spent the next morning ordering the sequels, which is roughly what happened to everyone I know who has read it. On a reread I see the seams more clearly: the opening rushes, and the magic gets explained as it goes rather than before you need it. But the book is so confident and so funny that the seams barely matter.

Romance and Chemistry

The attraction between Crane and Stephen is immediate, and the book does not pretend otherwise. What makes it more than heat is how quickly they become a team. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books, which gave it an A minus, singled out the way the two men balance each other's temperament and skills, and that is exactly right: Crane has money, nerve and a filthy mouth, Stephen has power and principles, and each keeps rescuing the other in ways neither expected.

The power-exchange side of the relationship is the part readers argue about. Crane likes to be in charge in bed, and Stephen likes him to be. Carrie S. at Smart Bitches felt that dynamic sat oddly given how abusive Crane's own family was, and given Stephen's history. I understand the objection. I also think the book handles it better than most, because Crane checks in, Stephen is never less powerful than he is in the rest of his life, and the one moment where Crane stops to make sure Stephen wants this is the most romantic beat in the book. Carrie S. thought so too.

The Characters

Crane is a joy. He has spent two decades in Shanghai, he speaks his mind, and he has no patience at all for English manners. Library Journal noted that his tattoos and merchant background make him an unusual lord, and Smart Bitches appreciated that he is not prejudiced against the Chinese people he lived among, which is a low bar for a Victorian hero that too many books still trip over.

Stephen is the one I love more on every reread. He is short and slight, which Carrie S. found refreshing in a genre full of towering heroes, and he is angry in a quiet, tired, working-class way that feels very real. He has a job to do, he is underpaid for it, and he has no reason to trust a Vaudrey. The book's best scenes are the ones where his anger and his decency fight each other.

The side cast is thin in this first book, and the villain plotting is more about mechanism than character. The Novel Approach still found plenty to like in the relationship arc, and so did I, but if you want a big supporting ensemble, it arrives later in the series.

Writing and Pacing

KJ Charles writes clean, quick, dryly funny prose. Publishers Weekly praised the witty dialogue and the inventive, unsettling magic, and called the climax satisfying. I agree on all three. The horror sequences are genuinely frightening, and Charles knows when to cut away.

The weakness is speed. In 200 pages the book has to set up a magic system, a murder plot, a family feud and a love affair, and the first few chapters feel compressed. Publishers Weekly flagged one plot contrivance; some readers, myself included on the first read, wanted a little more time inside Stephen's head before the romance took off. By the halfway mark none of that matters.

The Magpie Lord is a sharp, frightening, sexy opener with two heroes you will want to follow for the rest of the trilogy. Read it if you like your historical romance with real danger and real heat, and go in knowing the content notes are serious.

How Spicy Is The Magpie Lord?

The Magpie Lord is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The sex is on the page and frank, and it is woven into the plot rather than parked between chapters. Crane takes the lead in bed, and the dynamic between the men includes dominance and submission; the author's own content notes flag questionable consent and power-exchange dynamics. The book makes clear that Stephen wants what happens, and Crane checks in at a key moment.

Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from KJ Charles's own notes and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Magpie Lord?

The Magpie Lord suits readers who want a short, high-stakes MM historical with real magic, real horror and explicit heat, and who enjoy a cross-class couple that bickers its way into trust. It is less suited to readers who need a slow burn, or for whom animal death, suicide or power exchange are dealbreakers.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Magpie Lord was well reviewed from the start. Publishers Weekly praised its romantic tension, witty dialogue and inventive magic, Library Journal rated it highly recommended and called KJ Charles an exciting new voice in paranormal fiction, and Romantic Times made it a Top Pick, according to the author. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books gave it an A minus.

Where they agree. The chemistry and the atmosphere. Nearly every review praises the pairing of Crane and Stephen, the dry humour and the creepy, specific magic. Library Journal predicted crossover appeal for readers of several genres, and that has held up.

Where they split. Pacing and power. Publishers Weekly noted one contrivance in the plot. Smart Bitches questioned whether Crane's dominance in bed fits a man with his family history, and noted the all-white main cast. Some reader reviewers wanted more interiority early on and found the magic under-explained in the first chapters. Readers who come for the heat tend to find it, and readers who wanted a longer novel tend to say so.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Magpie Lord scores 8.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for romance, characters and writing, and lower scores for an ending that is deliberately the first act of a trilogy.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4.5Immediate chemistry and a real partnership, praised by Smart Bitches, Trashy Books.
Characters (15%)4.5Crane and Stephen are vivid and unusual, per Library Journal and Smart Bitches.
Writing and pacing (15%)4.5Witty, tight and frightening, per Publishers Weekly; the opening is rushed.
Emotional impact (15%)4Stephen's family history gives the romance weight; the short length limits depth.
Heat level (10%)4.5Delivers the explicit, power-exchange heat it promises, with care around consent.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A satisfying climax, but the romance ends on a hopeful note rather than a full HEA.
Reread appeal (10%)4.5Short enough to reread in an evening, and the sequels reward it.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Magpie Lord is the opener of one of KJ Charles's most loved series and still the best entry point to her paranormal work, landing at a final Eikna Score of 8.6/10.

A Charm of Magpies Reading Order

The Magpie Lord is book 1 of KJ Charles's A Charm of Magpies trilogy, and the same couple carries all three books, so read them in order. Jackdaw and Rag and Bone are set in the same world with new couples and can be read once you have finished the trilogy.

  1. Book 1: The Magpie Lord (2013): Lucien Vaudrey, Lord Crane, and Stephen Day
  2. Book 2: A Case of Possession (2013): Crane and Stephen
  3. Book 3: Flight of Magpies: Crane and Stephen
  4. Same world: Jackdaw (2015): Ben Spenser and Jonah Pastern, set after Flight of Magpies
  5. Same world: A Queer Trade (2016, novella), then Rag and Bone (2017)

KJ Charles also offers several free short stories about Crane and Stephen on her website, best read after the trilogy. Best format: print or ebook if you like to slow down for the magic; Cornell Collins's audiobook suits listeners who want the banter at full speed. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved The Magpie Lord, Read These Next

If you loved The Magpie Lord, look for MM and queer romances with magic, menace and couples who start out on opposite sides, beginning with more KJ Charles.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Magpie Lord prompts the same questions from most new readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and where it sits in the series. Short answers below.

Is The Magpie Lord spicy?

Yes. The Magpie Lord is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit scenes and a dominance and submission dynamic between the leads.

Is The Magpie Lord a standalone?

Not really. It solves its central mystery, but it is book 1 of a trilogy about the same couple, and the relationship continues in A Case of Possession and Flight of Magpies.

Does The Magpie Lord have a happy ending?

It has a hopeful, happy for now ending. Crane and Stephen are together at the end, and their happily ever after is built across the three books.

What order should I read A Charm of Magpies in?

Read The Magpie Lord, A Case of Possession and Flight of Magpies in that order, then Jackdaw and Rag and Bone, which are set in the same world.

Is there a Magpie Lord audiobook?

Yes. The audiobook is narrated by Cornell Collins and published by Audible Studios.

What are the content warnings for The Magpie Lord?

KJ Charles lists animal death, a suicide attempt, violence, questionable consent, power exchange, occult horror, homophobia and off-page references to sexual abuse and incest.

When is The Magpie Lord set?

The Magpie Lord is set in Victorian England, after Lord Crane returns from twenty years in China.

The Bottom Line

The Magpie Lord earns a 8.6/10 and a Highly recommended badge. It is for readers who want a short, scary, steamy Victorian MM romance with a cross-class couple and real magic, and who can handle dark content notes. The reason to pick it up is Crane and Stephen: two men with every reason to distrust each other who turn into one of the genre's great partnerships.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.