eikna romance
Menu

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal by KJ Charles Review

Eikna Score: 8.7/10. Highly recommended.

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal is a clever, spooky and quietly devastating love story disguised as a Victorian ghost-hunting casebook, told by the man who spent twenty years writing up the public version and leaving the important parts out. The episodic shape will not suit everyone, but the cases are inventive, the voice is perfect and the final pages hit harder than any romance this playful has a right to.

Read it if you love Sherlock Holmes pastiche, occult detectives and a love story told in glimpses across two decades. Skip it if you want a single continuous plot, or body horror and grotesque villains are not for you.

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal by KJ Charles book cover

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal at a Glance

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal is KJ Charles's 2015 MM paranormal historical romance, first published by Samhain on June 16, 2015 and reissued by KJC Books in 2017. It is a linked set of ghost-hunting cases framed as a private letter from Robert Caldwell, dated September 1914, and it belongs to the same world as her later Green Men series.

AuthorKJ Charles
SeriesGreen Men World (standalone; set a generation before Spectred Isle)
SubgenreMM romance, paranormal and historical (late Victorian and Edwardian England)
Main tropesOccult detective and his chronicler, partners to lovers, secret relationship, cursed hero, romance across decades
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsOccult horror and death throughout, body horror, villainy (full list below)
POVFirst person, Robert Caldwell
EndingHEA
Pages249 (2017 KJC Books paperback); 224 in the original Samhain edition
AudiobookNarrated by Gary Furlong
First publishedJune 16, 2015
PublisherSamhain Publishing (original); KJC Books (current edition)

What Is The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal About?

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal is presented as a letter. Robert Caldwell has spent twenty years writing up the adventures of Simon Feximal, the celebrated ghost-hunter, for an eager public. Now, in September 1914, he sends his editor the real story, the one that cannot be published until both men are dead.

That story begins when Simon arrives to deal with a haunting in the Caldwell family home, and it runs through case after case: hauntings, curses, rival occultists and some deeply strange villains. Each case is complete on its own, and each one also moves the two men closer, through attraction, partnership and a life together that the respectable Victorian world must never see.

What Makes This Occult Detective Romance Work

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal works because the frame does half the emotional work. You know from the first page that Robert and Simon spent twenty years together, and that Robert is writing this down because the world would not let him say it aloud. Every case after that is read through that knowledge, and every small tenderness counts double.

The second hook is the cases themselves. KJ Charles writes them as a loving riff on Sherlock Holmes and the Victorian occult detective story, with Robert as a Watson who is anything but a bumbler, as Stevie at The Good, the Bad and the Unread put it. The Novel Approach listed a macabre butterfly obsession and a demented Pied Piper among the horrors, per the author's site, and the inventiveness never flags.

If you like paranormal romance that reads like a cabinet of curiosities, this is one of the best.

My Review

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal is my favourite KJ Charles book, and it took me a second read to understand why. The first time, I read it as a run of clever ghost stories with a romance threaded through. The second time, knowing where it ends, I read it as a love letter, and it nearly broke me.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance is told in glimpses, and that is both its strength and its limit. Robert and Simon meet over a haunting in Robert's family home, and the first case gives them a reason to get very close very quickly. Stevie at The Good, the Bad and the Unread noted that the book includes intimate encounters used to lay a ghost to rest, which tells you a lot about its sense of humour.

After that, the relationship grows across years, not weeks. Lisa at The Novel Approach praised how realistically it develops, trials and miscommunications included, and how each chapter adds an emotional layer. Some readers want more continuous time with the couple and feel the episodic structure keeps them at a distance. I understand that, but I think the gaps are the point: Robert is choosing what to tell, and what he chooses to tell is how much he loves Simon.

The Characters

Robert is a wonderful narrator: wry, brave, sometimes ridiculous and always honest about himself in a way he never could be in print. Simon is harder to know, which suits a man carrying a curse and a lifetime of secrecy, but the glimpses Robert gives us make him vivid. The Novel Approach drew out the theme of storytelling itself, tied both to Simon's curse and to Robert's place in his life, and that idea ties the whole book together.

The wider cast is a pleasure. Stevie at The Good, the Bad and the Unread enjoyed the glimpses of other ghost-hunters and occultists, and they make the world feel crowded and lived-in, which pays off for readers who go on to Spectred Isle. The villains are memorable, sometimes grotesquely so.

Writing and Pacing

The voice is pitch-perfect late Victorian, fussy and funny and suddenly very sincere. The cases vary in length and tone, from creepy to absurd to properly horrible, and The Novel Approach singled out the eerie, mirror-translated runes as one of many inventive touches. All About Romance, which gave it an A and made it a Desert Isle Keeper, summed up its tone with a line about the pit looking back and sometimes winking, per the author's site.

The structure means the pace is uneven by design. Each case builds to its own climax, and the overarching story only gathers force in the later chapters, when Robert's public career collides with the private life he has been hiding. When it does, it gathers a lot of force. The ending is earned, sad in places and, in the way that matters for a romance, completely happy.

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal is a brilliant, inventive love story wearing a ghost-hunter's coat, and its episodic shape is part of its charm. Read it if you love Holmes pastiche and slow-revealed devotion; look elsewhere if you need one continuous plot.

How Spicy Is The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal?

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The sex is explicit, frank and sometimes plot-relevant in ways only a supernatural romance could manage. Romance.io readers rate the steam 4 out of 5. All intimacy between Robert and Simon is consensual, and Robert's past anonymous encounters with men are mentioned.

Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from KJ Charles's own notes and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal?

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal suits readers who want an inventive MM paranormal romance written as a Victorian casebook, with explicit heat, real scares and a love story that spans decades. It is less suited to readers who need a single plot line, constant time with the couple or a book without body horror.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal is one of KJ Charles's most admired books among critics. All About Romance gave it an A and a Desert Isle Keeper, per the author's site; The Good, the Bad and the Unread gave it an A; and The Novel Approach gave it five stars and called it one of the best books of 2015.

Where they agree. The voice and the inventiveness. Reviewers praise Robert as a narrator, the authentic Victorian atmosphere and the variety of supernatural ideas. The Novel Approach and The Good, the Bad and the Unread both admired how the separate cases connect into a larger arc.

Where they split. The structure. Some reader reviewers found too little continuous connection between the leads and some of the occult material confusing, even while praising the characters. Readers who come for a conventional romance plot are more likely to feel held at arm's length by the casebook format.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal scores 8.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for characters, writing, emotional impact and the ending, and a slightly lower mark for a romance told in glimpses.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4A lifelong love told in glimpses; The Novel Approach praised its realism, some readers wanted more.
Characters (15%)4.5Robert is a superb narrator, a Watson who is no bumbler, per The Good, the Bad and the Unread.
Writing and pacing (15%)4.5Inventive, pitch-perfect Victorian voice, per The Novel Approach and All About Romance.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5The frame makes every tenderness count; the late chapters land hard.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers explicit, sometimes plot-relevant heat, rated 4 of 5 on Romance.io.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4.5A complete, earned HEA across two decades.
Reread appeal (10%)4.5Rereads even better once you know how the letter ends.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal is the high point of KJ Charles's paranormal work and one of the most original MM historicals of the 2010s, landing at a final Eikna Score of 8.7/10.

Green Men World Reading Order

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal is a standalone, set in the same world as KJ Charles's Green Men series and a generation before it. It is the natural place to start, and Spectred Isle picks up the world in 1923.

  1. The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal (2015): Simon Feximal and Robert Caldwell, Victorian and Edwardian casebook
  2. Green Men book 1: Spectred Isle (2017): Saul Lazenby and Randolph Glyde, 1923

KJ Charles also lists Remnant, a free crossover story written with Jordan L. Hawk, alongside these books. Best format: print or ebook, because the casebook voice rewards slow reading; Gary Furlong's audiobook suits listeners who enjoy a Victorian narrator in full flow. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal, Read These Next

If you loved The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal, look for MM romances with ghosts, old magic and partnerships built on shared danger, starting with more KJ Charles.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal prompts the same questions from most readers: whether it stands alone, how spicy it is, how it ends and how it connects to Spectred Isle. Short answers below.

Is The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal a standalone?

Yes. It is a complete standalone, set in the same world as KJ Charles's later Green Men series.

Is The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal spicy?

Yes. It is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit scenes between Robert and Simon.

Does The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal have a happy ending?

Yes. Robert and Simon share a life together, and the book ends with a happily ever after.

How is The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal connected to Spectred Isle?

Spectred Isle is set in the same world a generation later, in 1923. You can read either first.

Is The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal a novel or short stories?

It is a novel built from linked cases, framed as Robert Caldwell's private letter to his editor, and two of the cases were published earlier as short stories.

Who narrates the Simon Feximal audiobook?

Gary Furlong narrates the audiobook of The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal.

The Bottom Line

The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal earns an 8.7/10 and a Highly recommended badge. It is for readers who want a clever, scary, explicit MM ghost-hunter romance told across twenty years, and who enjoy a casebook structure rather than one straight plot. The reason to pick it up is Robert's voice: a man finally telling the truth about the love of his life.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.