Spectred Isle by KJ Charles Review
Eikna Score: 8.2/10. Recommended.
Spectred Isle is a rich, eerie 1920s occult romance about two men the war has already broken, and the slow, tender way they learn to trust each other while London's old magic goes wrong around them. The first chapters bury you in jargon and some side characters vanish just as they get interesting, but the atmosphere and the emotional repair work make it one of KJ Charles's most moving books.
Read it if you want MM romance with British folklore, haunted ground and two damaged heroes who actually talk to each other. Skip it if you need a fast opening, or you want every thread of a new series tied off in book one.
Spectred Isle at a Glance
Spectred Isle is KJ Charles's 2017 MM paranormal historical romance and the first Green Men book, self-published through KJC Books in August 2017. Set in England in 1923, a generation after The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal, it pairs Saul Lazenby with Randolph Glyde, was a 2018 RITA finalist for Paranormal Romance and ends with a happily ever after.
| Author | KJ Charles |
|---|---|
| Series | Green Men, book 1 (same world as The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal; reading that first is optional) |
| Subgenre | MM romance, paranormal and historical (England, 1923) |
| Main tropes | Antagonists to lovers, last of an old line, forced partnership, post-war trauma, occult investigation |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | Post-war trauma, past suicidal thoughts, homophobia, occult horror (full list below) |
| POV | Third person, Saul and Randolph |
| Ending | HEA for the couple; series threads stay open |
| Pages | 251 (KJC Books paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Ruairi Carter (Tantor, 2018) |
| First published | August 2017 |
| Publisher | KJC Books (self-published) |
What Is Spectred Isle About?
Spectred Isle is set in 1923, in an England that lost most of its occultists in the war and is now paying for it. Old things are stirring in the places where nobody is left to keep them quiet.
Saul Lazenby was an archaeologist until a disgrace during the war wrecked his career. Now he takes whatever work he can get, which currently means researching odd sites for an eccentric who believes in magic. Saul does not. Then strange and frightening things start happening wherever he goes, and he keeps running into Randolph Glyde, the arrogant last son of an ancient family of arcanists, who suspects Saul is either a victim or a villain. As the danger grows, so does something between them, and Randolph may be the only person who can save Saul's life, or his soul.
What Makes This Antagonists to Lovers Romance Work
Spectred Isle works because its two heroes start out suspicious of each other for good reasons and end up taking care of each other in ways that feel earned. Randolph thinks Saul might be dangerous. Saul thinks Randolph is a snob. Both are partly right, and both are carrying more damage from the war than they admit.
The second hook is the setting. KJ Charles builds her magic out of real English folklore and real, obscure places, and RogerBW at the firedrake blog praised exactly that: hidden magic tied to genuine sites with occult rumours around them. It gives the book a texture that most paranormal romance does not have.
And it is a romance about recovery. The Novel Approach singled out Saul's emotional recovery from a past betrayal, and Book Me Up! said the book made them cry repeatedly, per the author's site. If you want paranormal romance with emotional weight, this is a strong pick.
My Review
I have read Spectred Isle three times now, and the first chapter defeats me a little every time. There is so much occult vocabulary arriving at once that I end up skimming. Then Saul and Randolph are in a room together, snapping at each other, and the book takes off and does not let go. It is one of the most atmospheric romances I know.
Romance and Chemistry
The romance is a slow thaw, not a spark. Randolph is prickly and grand, Saul is defensive and exhausted, and they spend the early chapters assuming the worst of each other. What changes things is that they are both, underneath it, decent men who can talk. The Novel Approach praised the slow build between them, and I think the conversations are the heart of the book: two men who have been punished for who they are working out, carefully, how to be honest with each other.
Not everyone feels it. RogerBW at the firedrake blog found both leads broken and hard to like, and said he did not feel the romance's intended pull. I can see how a reader gets there, because Randolph in particular is not charming in the early chapters. For me that is what makes the later warmth land.
The Characters
Saul is the emotional centre. His wartime disgrace is handled with real tact, and the book takes his loneliness and his past suicidal thoughts seriously without turning them into a plot device. Randolph is harder work and more fun: arrogant, funny, frightened of what he owes his family name and very good at hiding it.
The supporting cast is where the book shows it is a series opener. Stevie at The Good, the Bad and the Unread, who gave it an A, loved how vividly drawn the backstories are, including those of characters who barely appear, and was eager to meet them later. RogerBW thought some minor characters, including survivors of wartime experiments, were dropped just as they became interesting. Both are true. The Green Men are set up beautifully and then left waiting.
Writing and Pacing
The prose is precise and often very funny, the dialogue is sharp, and the scary scenes are properly scary. The Novel Approach found the pacing gripping once the story got going, after a slow start weighed down by paranormal jargon. That matches my experience exactly.
What I admire most is the restraint. Charles never explains the magic more than she has to, and the folklore sits under the story like a layer of old earth. The book makes England itself feel haunted, in a specific post-war way, and the romance is part of that: two men trying to build something living on ground full of the dead.
Spectred Isle is a haunting, grown-up romance about two damaged men learning to trust each other, with a slow start and a few loose threads. Read it if you love folklore, atmosphere and emotional repair, and give it three chapters before you judge it.
How Spicy Is Spectred Isle?
Spectred Isle is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Once Saul and Randolph get together there are several explicit love scenes, and RogerBW at the firedrake blog felt they were woven into the story rather than dropped in. Some readers on StoryGraph found the jump in intensity abrupt after the slow build.
The scenes are consensual, and the emotional context, two men who have been punished for desire, gives them weight. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from KJ Charles's own notes and reader reports:
- Post-war trauma and references to wartime experiments
- Past suicidal thoughts
- Homophobia, including a past disgrace
- Occult horror and supernatural violence
- Vomiting
- Explicit sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Spectred Isle?
Spectred Isle suits readers who want an atmospheric MM paranormal romance set just after the First World War, with folklore, horror and two wounded heroes who learn to communicate. It is less suited to readers who need a quick start, a light tone or a series that wraps up neatly.
Best for:
- Fans of MM romance with ghosts, folklore and old magic
- Readers who like interwar settings and post-war trauma handled with care
- Anyone who enjoyed The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal
- Readers who like a prickly hero and a weary one
Not for:
- Readers who want a fast, low-jargon opening
- Anyone looking for a light, low-angst read
- Readers who need every series thread resolved
- Readers looking for closed-door romance (try our closed door picks)
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Spectred Isle was a 2018 RITA finalist for Paranormal Romance, according to the University of Birmingham's romance wiki. The Good, the Bad and the Unread gave it an A, The Novel Approach gave it five stars, and All About Romance called it a fantastic book, per the author's site.
Where they agree. The world. Reviewers consistently praise the setting, the folklore and the detailed backstories. Stevie at The Good, the Bad and the Unread called it an excellent start to a series, and RogerBW, though cooler on the romance, admired the research and the real-world sites.
Where they split. The leads and the threads. RogerBW found Saul and Randolph hard to like and thought some side characters were dropped. The Novel Approach found the opening slow. Some StoryGraph readers found the prose and emotional texture thinner than they hoped. And the second Green Men book has been long delayed, which frustrates readers who fell for the ensemble.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Spectred Isle scores 8.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its strongest mark for characters and steady marks elsewhere, held back by a slow opening and series threads left hanging.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | A slow, tender thaw praised by The Novel Approach; some readers felt less pull. |
| Characters (15%) | 4.5 | Vivid backstories, per The Good, the Bad and the Unread; Saul is beautifully drawn. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Sharp and atmospheric, but the opening is weighed down by jargon, per The Novel Approach. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Saul's recovery lands; Book Me Up! said it made them cry repeatedly. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers explicit scenes woven into the story, per the firedrake blog. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A true HEA for the couple, with the wider series left open. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 4 | Rereads well once the vocabulary is familiar and the folklore sinks in. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Spectred Isle is the most atmospheric of KJ Charles's paranormal novels and a fine companion to The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal, landing at a final Eikna Score of 8.2/10.
Green Men Reading Order
Spectred Isle is book 1 of KJ Charles's Green Men series, set in the same world as The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal a generation later. Charles has said it is not necessary to read the Secret Casebook first, but readers who do will recognise some names and references.
- The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal (2015): Simon Feximal and Robert Caldwell, Victorian and Edwardian casebook
- Green Men book 1: Spectred Isle (2017): Saul Lazenby and Randolph Glyde, 1923
There is also Remnant, a free crossover story KJ Charles wrote with Jordan L. Hawk, listed on her site with the Green Men world books. A second Green Men novel has been long delayed. Best place to start: either book works, but Simon Feximal first gives Spectred Isle extra resonance. Best format: print or ebook for the folklore; Ruairi Carter's audiobook suits listeners who like a British narrator for a very English book. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved Spectred Isle, Read These Next
If you loved Spectred Isle, look for MM romances with hauntings, old magic and wounded heroes, starting with the rest of KJ Charles's paranormal work.
- The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal by KJ Charles: the Victorian ghost-hunter romance set a generation before Spectred Isle.
- The Magpie Lord by KJ Charles: a cursed Victorian house, an exiled earl and a furious magician.
- Jackdaw by KJ Charles: magical Victorian London and a second chance built on betrayal.
- The Mysterious and Amazing Blue Billings by Lily Morton: a contemporary haunted house in York and a guide who can see the dead.
- The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy by Megan Bannen: a gentler, funnier fantasy romance full of the dead and the people who tend them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Spectred Isle prompts the same questions from most readers: whether you need Simon Feximal first, how spicy it is, how it ends and whether there is a sequel. Short answers below.
Do I need to read Simon Feximal before Spectred Isle?
No. KJ Charles has said it is not necessary to read The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal first, though it adds context to some names and references.
Is Spectred Isle spicy?
Yes. Spectred Isle is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit scenes once Saul and Randolph get together.
Does Spectred Isle have a happy ending?
Yes. Saul and Randolph get a happily ever after, while the wider Green Men series threads stay open.
When is Spectred Isle set?
Spectred Isle is set in England in 1923, after a war that killed most of the country's occultists.
Is there a sequel to Spectred Isle?
Spectred Isle is book 1 of the Green Men series, and a second novel has been long delayed.
Who narrates the Spectred Isle audiobook?
Ruairi Carter narrates the Spectred Isle audiobook, published by Tantor.
The Bottom Line
Spectred Isle earns a 8.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a haunted, folklore-rich MM romance set in 1920s England, with two damaged heroes, explicit heat and a real happily ever after, and who will forgive a slow first chapter. The reason to pick it up is the atmosphere: few romances make a whole country feel this haunted.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Spectred Isle, KJ Charles (author site: blurb, content notes, narrator, review quotes)
- Spectred Isle: new series, KJ Charles blog (via Goodreads)
- Review: Spectred Isle, The Good, the Bad and the Unread (Stevie)
- Review: Spectred Isle, The Novel Approach (Sammy)
- Spectred Isle, firedrake blog (RogerBW)
- Spectred Isle, University of Birmingham romance wiki (RITA finalist)
- Release day review: Spectred Isle, Love Bytes
- Spectred Isle audiobook, Audible
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.