eikna romance
Menu

Just Another Love Song by Kerry Winfrey Review

Eikna Score: 7.0/10. Recommended.

Just Another Love Song is a sweet, slow second chance romance about high school sweethearts who meet again fifteen years later, and its small Ohio town is so lovable it nearly steals the book. The present-day love story is gentler than it needs to be, and the hero is so nice that the tension sometimes has nowhere to go.

Read it if you love small-town ensembles and second chance romance with a famous musician, or you want a clean, low-stakes comfort read. Skip it if you want angst, heat or a hero with rough edges, or flashback chapters pull you out of a story.

Just Another Love Song by Kerry Winfrey book cover

Just Another Love Song at a Glance

Just Another Love Song is a standalone 2022 Berkley romance by Kerry Winfrey. Greenhouse owner Sandy Macintosh reconnects with her high school sweetheart Hank Tillman, now a famous alt-country singer and single dad, when he comes home to Baileyville, Ohio. It is closed door and ends happily.

AuthorKerry Winfrey
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreSmall-town romance, contemporary
Main tropesSecond chance, high school sweethearts, famous musician, single dad, small-town festival
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsPast divorce, co-parenting tension, career regret (full list below)
POVSandy only, moving between past and present
EndingHEA
Pages336 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Justis Bolding, 9 hours 50 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio)
First publishedAugust 2, 2022
PublisherBerkley

What Is Just Another Love Song About?

Just Another Love Song follows Sandy Macintosh, who runs a successful greenhouse and helps at her parents' bed and breakfast in tiny Baileyville, Ohio. As teenagers, she and Hank Tillman planned to leave town together. Hank left for Boston and a music career; Sandy stayed. Fifteen years later he is a famous alt-country singer with a young son, and she is still in Baileyville.

When Hank comes home, the two are thrown together to organize the town's annual street fair. Sandy has to decide whether they are ready to start over, or whether their past is just an old song she keeps playing in her head.

What Makes This Second Chance Romance Work

Just Another Love Song works because it treats its second chance as a question about the whole life Sandy built, not only about Hank. She did not follow her old dream, and his return makes her wonder whether she settled or chose. That gives the reunion stakes beyond "do they still like each other."

The town is the other draw. Baileyville is full of nosy, funny neighbors who comment on everything, and the street fair gives them a reason to be in every scene. BookPage, in a starred review, praised the snappy dialogue and called Winfrey "the queen of charming and cozily sweet contemporary romances."

Readers who like second chance romance with small-town warmth and no villain will feel at home quickly.

My Review

Just Another Love Song is the most comfortable of Kerry Winfrey's books, and I mean that both ways. It is warm, easy and full of people you would want as neighbors. It is also short on friction, and by the end I was more invested in the town than in the couple.

Kirkus called it warm and heartfelt and praised Sandy's growth, Hank's kindness and the supporting cast, which is a fair list of what works. What it leaves out is the tension.

Romance and Chemistry

The flashbacks are the best romance in the book. The teenage Sandy and Hank are sweet and believable, and Suzanne at The Bookish Libra enjoyed how the past chapters mix with the present. Amanda Kay Oaks found the original breakup understandable, and so did I: two young people with different needs, not a villainous betrayal.

The present day is softer. Iby at Smexy Books liked the setting but was not sure why these adults belonged together now, and that question stayed with me. Hank is kind, attentive and a good father, and Virginia Kantra called him her new book boyfriend in a blurb. But he is so reasonable that the conflict has to come almost entirely from Sandy's doubts. BookPage argued they are better placed to make it work in their thirties, and I believe it; I just did not feel much doubt along the way. A reader on r/RomanceBooks, napamy, found the tension weak and objected to a late withdrawal tied to Hank's son.

The Characters

Sandy is the real subject. She is capable, funny and quietly convinced she missed her chance, and Harlequin Junkie focused on her self-doubt. The Penguin Random House reading guide points to her painting and the expectations she placed on herself, and that thread, about a talent set aside, is the most affecting part of the book.

Joanna at The Geekish Brunette found Hank too perfect, and Haley at Fangirl Fury questioned how little his fame seems to touch his life. Both are right. A famous musician whose fame barely gets in the way is a fantasy, and the book is happy to let it stay one. Amanda at Under the Covers liked Baileyville more than Sandy, which tells you how good the ensemble is.

Writing and Pacing

Winfrey writes easy, funny dialogue, and the townspeople's commentary is often laugh-out-loud. BookPage noted that the colorful locals sometimes crowd out the couple, and that the slow pace may feel too gentle for some readers. Joanna found the timeline switches disruptive; I found them welcome, because they carried the emotion the present lacked. Novelgossip described a slower-building courtship with community humor, and that is the honest pitch.

The street fair is a smart structural choice. It forces Sandy and Hank into meetings, lists and logistics, which keeps them in the same room without needing a contrived crisis, and it hands the town a project to fuss over. The downside is that a festival committee is not a high-stakes arena, so the book's tension has to come from inside Sandy, and on some pages there simply is not enough of it.

Just Another Love Song is a cosy small-town second chance romance with a lovely town, sweet flashbacks and not quite enough friction. Read it if you want a gentle reunion story to sink into; skip it if you need angst or a hero with flaws.

How Spicy Is Just Another Love Song?

Just Another Love Song is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. Haley at Fangirl Fury describes the book as closed door, and Library Journal called it a sweet, low-heat read. There are kisses and longing, and the book cuts away from anything more.

See our closed door romance list for more in this range.

Content warnings, drawn from Kirkus and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read Just Another Love Song?

Just Another Love Song suits readers who want a sweet, closed door second chance romance in a small town full of characters. It is less suited to readers who want tension, heat or a morally complicated hero.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Just Another Love Song had positive trade reviews: Kirkus called it warm and heartfelt, Library Journal sweet and low-heat, and BookPage gave it a starred review. Readers agree on the town and split on the couple.

Where they agree. Baileyville and the dialogue. BookPage praised the snappy dialogue and paced character development, Novelgossip enjoyed the community humor, and Amanda at Under the Covers liked the town more than anyone in it.

Where they split. The present-day romance. Suzanne at The Bookish Libra loved the flashbacks, while Joanna at The Geekish Brunette found the past underdeveloped and the hero too perfect. Iby at Smexy Books doubted why the adults belonged together, and napamy on r/RomanceBooks found the tension weak.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Just Another Love Song scores 7.0 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best mark for a heat level that matches its sweet promise and middling marks elsewhere, where reviewers praise the town but find the present-day romance low on tension.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Sweet flashbacks, per The Bookish Libra; Smexy Books doubts the present-day pull.
Characters (15%)3.5Sandy's self-doubt rings true; The Geekish Brunette finds Hank too perfect.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5BookPage praises the dialogue; the locals sometimes crowd out the couple.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5The thread about abandoned dreams lands; stakes stay low, as napamy notes.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the low-heat, closed door romance Library Journal and Fangirl Fury describe.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A clear HEA, per Smexy Books, though the final conflict is thin.
Reread appeal (10%)3A pleasant return to Baileyville, with few surprises on a reread.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Just Another Love Song sits in the middle of Kerry Winfrey's catalogue, below Not Like the Movies and level with her other gentle standalones, with a final Eikna Score of 7.0/10.

Is Just Another Love Song a Standalone?

Yes. Just Another Love Song is a standalone; Under the Covers labels it as such, and it does not connect to Kerry Winfrey's Waiting for Tom Hanks duology. Start here if you like small-town romance.

  1. Waiting for Tom Hanks (2019): duology book 1
  2. Not Like the Movies (2020): duology book 2
  3. Very Sincerely Yours (2021): standalone
  4. Just Another Love Song (2022): standalone
  5. Faking Christmas (2023): standalone

Best format: the Justis Bolding audiobook suits a book about a singer and a chatty town. Our series order guide has more.

If You Loved Just Another Love Song, Read These Next

If you loved Just Another Love Song, try second chance romances and small-town stories with warm communities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Readers ask these questions most often about Just Another Love Song.

Is Just Another Love Song spicy?

No. Just Another Love Song is a 1 out of 5 on our scale; reviewers describe it as closed door and low heat.

Is Just Another Love Song a standalone?

Yes. Just Another Love Song is a standalone and does not require any other Kerry Winfrey book.

Does Just Another Love Song have a happy ending?

Yes. Sandy and Hank get a happily ever after.

Is Just Another Love Song dual POV?

No. Just Another Love Song is told from Sandy's point of view, moving between the past and the present.

Who narrates the Just Another Love Song audiobook?

Justis Bolding narrates the audiobook, which runs about 9 hours 50 minutes.

Where is Just Another Love Song set?

Just Another Love Song is set in Baileyville, a small fictional town in Ohio.

The Bottom Line

Just Another Love Song earns a 7.0/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a sweet, clean reunion story in a small town where everyone knows your business. The one reason to pick it up is Baileyville itself, a community so warm and funny that you will forgive the romance for being a little too easy.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.