eikna romance
Menu

Waiting for Tom Hanks by Kerry Winfrey Review

Eikna Score: 7.2/10. Recommended.

Waiting for Tom Hanks is a love letter to Nora Ephron movies that wears its references on its sleeve and mostly gets away with it, thanks to a funny supporting cast and a hero who turns out kinder than his reputation. The romance itself is thinner than the homage, and the late conflict is the sort you can see coming from the opening credits.

Read it if you can quote Sleepless in Seattle from memory, or you want a clean, cosy rom-com you can finish in a weekend. Skip it if constant movie comparisons wear you out, or you need slow-building chemistry rather than a fast, formula-shaped romance.

Waiting for Tom Hanks by Kerry Winfrey book cover

Waiting for Tom Hanks at a Glance

Waiting for Tom Hanks is Kerry Winfrey's first adult romance, a 2019 Berkley paperback about an aspiring screenwriter who falls for the actor starring in the film shooting in her Columbus, Ohio neighborhood. It is closed door, ends happily and opens a two-book duology completed by Not Like the Movies.

AuthorKerry Winfrey
SeriesBook 1 of a duology; Not Like the Movies is book 2
SubgenreRomantic comedy, contemporary
Main tropesCelebrity romance, movie set, opposites attract, meet-cute gone wrong, best friend support system
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsParental death (past), a health scare, body shaming, strong language (full list below)
POVFirst person, Annie
EndingHEA
Pages288 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Rachel L. Jacobs, 8 hours 33 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio)
First publishedJune 11, 2019
PublisherBerkley

What Is Waiting for Tom Hanks About?

Waiting for Tom Hanks follows Annie Cassidy, a would-be screenwriter who wants to be the next Nora Ephron and who has spent years waiting for a man as decent as the characters Tom Hanks used to play. She lives in Columbus, leans on her uncle Don and has a best friend, Chloe, who is out of patience with her fantasy.

Then a romantic comedy starts filming in her neighborhood, and Annie talks her way onto the set. The lead is Drew Danforth, a famous actor with a prankster reputation, and their first meeting goes badly. The trouble is that their next few start to look like scenes from her favorite films, and Drew is leaving when the shoot wraps.

What Makes This Movie Set Romance Work

Waiting for Tom Hanks works because it lets a heroine who has studied romantic comedies all her life walk straight into one, and then makes her notice it. Annie keeps narrating her own meet-cute as if she were pitching it, which is a joke the book commits to from the first page.

The set gives the story a clock. Drew is in town for the length of the shoot, so every lunch break and late call is borrowed time, and the film crew supplies a ready cast of gossips. Publishers Weekly picked out the supporting players in its starred review, and that is fair: Uncle Don, Chloe and the crew carry a lot of the comedy.

The reference game is the hook for some readers and the problem for others. If you love romantic comedies that know they are romantic comedies, this is an easy book to pick up.

My Review

Waiting for Tom Hanks is a book I liked more as a mood than as a romance. It is warm, it is quick, and its jokes about the genre are often sharp. But for long stretches the movie references do the work that the relationship should be doing, and Annie talks about falling in love more than she seems to do it.

Kirkus enjoyed Drew and the steady stream of cultural references while doubting how serious the obstacles really were, and that is close to my reading. NPR called it a love letter to rom-coms, which is the right description and also the limitation. A love letter is about the thing it loves.

Romance and Chemistry

Drew is the best idea in the book. He arrives with a cocky public image and turns out to be thoughtful, patient with Annie's nerves and, in Kirkus's phrase, "fully Hanks-ian." Their banter on set is fun and the scenes where he simply listens to her are better than the big gestures. The issue is pace. The relationship moves from irritation to devotion with few steps in between, and the StoryGraph readers sarahjoyrussell and plovestoread both said the romantic connection never convinced them. Wendy at Book Scents went further and did not believe in the couple at all. I would not go that far, but I wanted two or three more ordinary conversations between them and fewer scenes that exist to echo a film.

The late conflict is a privacy breach that hurts Annie and threatens the relationship. Kirkus and Resch Reads both flagged it, and Resch Reads disliked how quickly it was repaired. Same here. It arrives on schedule and leaves on schedule.

The Characters

Annie is likeable and occasionally exhausting. She is clumsy, earnest and stubborn about her fantasy, and Allison Schroeder at KTSW noted how oblivious she can be. Pop! Goes the Reader made a better case for her: Annie's attachment to these movies is tied to memories of her late mother, and her arc is about taking some agency back. That gives the obsession a reason, and it is the most moving thread in the book.

The side characters are why I kept reading. Uncle Don is gentle and funny, Chloe is the friend who tells Annie the truth, and Bargain Sleuth singled out both of them. Chloe is good enough that Winfrey gave her the second book.

Writing and Pacing

The prose is clean and conversational, and the chapters move. GoodeyReads enjoyed the banter but found the film comparisons repetitive, and by the middle I agreed: once you get the joke that life is like a Nora Ephron movie, being reminded of it every few pages stops adding anything. The book is at its best when it forgets to be clever and lets Annie fumble through a scene.

The audiobook is worth a mention. Kirkus praised Rachel L. Jacobs for a lively reading with distinct supporting voices, and BookPage gave the audio a starred review. If the references wear on you in print, they go down easier when performed.

Waiting for Tom Hanks is a charming, quick homage to the classic rom-com that leans on its references harder than on its romance. Read it if you love the movies it quotes and want something sweet and clean; skip it if you need the couple to earn every step.

How Spicy Is Waiting for Tom Hanks?

Waiting for Tom Hanks is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. The romance is mostly kissing and flirting, and GoodeyReads reports one sex scene that happens off the page. There is nothing explicit, which makes it an easy pick for readers who want closed door romance.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reviews from GoodeyReads, Bargain Sleuth and Kirkus:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read Waiting for Tom Hanks?

Waiting for Tom Hanks suits readers who want a light, clean romantic comedy soaked in classic movie love. It is less suited to readers who want deep chemistry, high stakes or a fresh take on the formula it celebrates.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Waiting for Tom Hanks earned a starred review from Publishers Weekly, which praised its endearing, klutzy heroine, and Booklist and NPR were both warm about its charm. Kirkus liked Drew and the references but was less sure about the obstacles, and reader reviews split along the same line.

Where they agree. Almost everyone likes the supporting cast and the hero. Publishers Weekly highlighted the ensemble, Bargain Sleuth praised Chloe and Uncle Don, and Kirkus thought Drew lived up to the Tom Hanks standard. Lisa at Remarkably Lisa and others confirm the happy ending.

Where they split. The romance and the references. GoodeyReads found the film comparisons repetitive, Wendy at Book Scents did not believe the relationship, and StoryGraph readers called the formula and heroine unpersuasive. Resch Reads enjoyed the tender moments but not the late disruption. Allison Schroeder at KTSW enjoyed the movie-like momentum while noting Annie's blind spots.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Waiting for Tom Hanks scores 7.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for a heat level that delivers exactly the closed door sweetness it promises and an ending that lands, and its weakest for reread appeal.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Drew is lovely, but StoryGraph readers and Book Scents doubt the couple; the build is quick.
Characters (15%)3.5Uncle Don and Chloe shine, per Bargain Sleuth; Annie's obliviousness splits readers.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Breezy and funny, though GoodeyReads finds the film comparisons repetitive.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Pop! Goes the Reader ties Annie's grief to the movies; the late conflict feels staged.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the clean, kisses-first romance it promises, with sex kept off the page.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A clear HEA, reported by Remarkably Lisa, after a predictable last-act wobble.
Reread appeal (10%)3Comfort read for movie fans; the plot holds few surprises a second time.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Waiting for Tom Hanks is the lighter of Kerry Winfrey's duology; its sequel Not Like the Movies has more emotional weight, and this first book lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.2/10.

Waiting for Tom Hanks Reading Order

Waiting for Tom Hanks is book 1 of a two-book duology and can be read alone. Not Like the Movies follows Chloe and opens after this book, so read Waiting for Tom Hanks first; the sequel shows how this couple ended up.

  1. Book 1: Waiting for Tom Hanks (2019): Annie and Drew
  2. Book 2: Not Like the Movies (2020): Chloe and Nick

Kerry Winfrey's later Berkley novels, Very Sincerely Yours, Just Another Love Song and Faking Christmas, are standalones. Best format: the Rachel L. Jacobs audiobook, which Kirkus and BookPage both praised. Our series order guide has more reading orders.

If You Loved Waiting for Tom Hanks, Read These Next

If you loved Waiting for Tom Hanks, look for romantic comedies that play with the genre, celebrity love interests and heroines with big, specific dreams.

Frequently Asked Questions

Readers usually ask the same things about Waiting for Tom Hanks: how clean it is, whether it is part of a series, how it ends and whether the audiobook is good.

Is Waiting for Tom Hanks spicy?

No. Waiting for Tom Hanks is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: mostly kissing, with one sex scene that happens off the page.

Is Waiting for Tom Hanks a standalone?

It can be read alone, but it is book 1 of a duology. Not Like the Movies, about Annie's friend Chloe, is book 2.

Does Waiting for Tom Hanks have a happy ending?

Yes. Annie and Drew get a happily ever after after a late conflict.

Who narrates the Waiting for Tom Hanks audiobook?

Rachel L. Jacobs narrates the audiobook, which runs about 8 hours 33 minutes. Kirkus praised her lively performance.

Is Tom Hanks in Waiting for Tom Hanks?

No. Tom Hanks is Annie's ideal of a romantic lead; the love interest is a fictional actor, Drew Danforth.

Where is Waiting for Tom Hanks set?

Waiting for Tom Hanks is set in Columbus, Ohio, where a movie is filming in Annie's neighborhood.

The Bottom Line

Waiting for Tom Hanks earns a 7.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who grew up on Nora Ephron and want a quick, clean, funny romance with a kind hero and a family worth visiting. The one reason to pick it up is the joy it takes in the genre itself; just do not expect the romance to surprise you.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.