eikna romance
Menu

Very Sincerely Yours by Kerry Winfrey Review

Eikna Score: 7.3/10. Recommended.

Very Sincerely Yours is the gentlest book Kerry Winfrey has written, a letter-writing romance between a lost toy-shop worker and a children's television host who is basically Mister Rogers with a crush. It is sweet to the point of softness, slow to start and kind in a way that will either soothe you or send you to sleep.

Read it if you love epistolary romance and kind, nerdy heroes, or you want a clean comfort read about starting over at thirty. Skip it if you need tension and spark from page one, or third-act breakups built on poor communication drive you up the wall.

Very Sincerely Yours by Kerry Winfrey book cover

Very Sincerely Yours at a Glance

Very Sincerely Yours is a standalone 2021 Berkley romantic comedy by Kerry Winfrey, set in Columbus, Ohio. Teddy Phillips starts writing letters to Everett St. James, host of a local children's show, and a pen pal friendship becomes a romance. It is closed door and ends happily.

AuthorKerry Winfrey
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreRomantic comedy, contemporary
Main tropesPen pals and letters, slow burn, sunshine hero, starting over after a breakup, local celebrity
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsDemeaning past relationship, breakup, some profanity (full list below)
POVTeddy and Everett, with letters between them
EndingHappy ending
Pages384 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Patti Murin, about 10 hours 6 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio)
First publishedJune 15, 2021
PublisherBerkley

What Is Very Sincerely Yours About?

Very Sincerely Yours opens with Teddy Phillips nearly thirty, freshly dumped by her longtime boyfriend and working at a vintage toy store while she tries to work out what she wants. Her one steady comfort is Everett's Place, a local children's show whose host gives gentle advice to kids, and to anyone else who happens to be watching.

Teddy works up the nerve to write Everett a letter. He writes back. Everett looks like a man with his dream job and a solid support system, yet he feels something is missing too. As the letters pile up, the two share more than either expected, and when their lives finally cross in person they have to face their fears and decide what they want.

What Makes This Pen Pal Romance Work

Very Sincerely Yours works because the letters let two shy people say what they would never say face to face. Teddy can be funny and honest on paper in a way she cannot manage in her real life, and Everett, who spends his days talking to children through a camera, finally gets someone talking back.

The hero is the other hook. Under the Covers summed him up as "Mr. Rogers, but for adults," and that is the appeal: a kind, earnest, slightly odd man whose job is literally helping people feel better. Kirkus called the book a cozy rom-com with a comfortably unfolding story, and that comfort is exactly why readers pick it up.

If you liked the letters in classic pen pal stories, or you want a slow burn where kindness is the sexiest thing on offer, this is your book.

My Review

Very Sincerely Yours made me feel looked after, which is a strange thing to say about a novel and also the best praise I can give it. It also made me impatient. For the first third, nothing much happens beyond Teddy feeling stuck and writing about it, and the book trusts the reader to be as charmed by that as Teddy's letters assume Everett will be.

Harlequin Junkie found the opening slow and some of the dialogue forced while still enjoying the "quirky nerdish moments," and that is a fair split. Novel Novice and Reading Ladies were warmer. My view sits in the middle.

Romance and Chemistry

The letters are the best part of the romance. They are funny, a little awkward and full of small confessions neither would make out loud. The book is smart to let the friendship grow on paper before the two share a room, and the first in-person scenes carry a nice charge because of it.

Once they are together, the chemistry is mild. That suits the book, but readers who want sparks will find more warmth than heat. Kate at Smexy Books flagged the third-act breakup, and the StoryGraph reader jdm1005 put the conflict down to communication failures, which is how it read to me too. Two people who wrote so honestly in letters suddenly stop talking, and the plot needs them to.

The Characters

Teddy is relatable in a quiet way. She is not a disaster heroine; she is someone who drifted, who spent years in a relationship that made her smaller, and who is starting to notice. Kirkus described the old relationship as demeaning, and the book is good at showing how long that kind of thing lingers.

The book is really about being nearly thirty and feeling behind. Teddy is not lost in a dramatic way; she simply never decided what she wanted, and the letters give her somewhere to think out loud. Readers who have had that particular year will recognise a lot, and that recognition does more for the book than any plot twist.

Everett is the reason most readers stay. Renee at Harlequin Junkie noted he works with puppets, and the details of his show give him a world of his own. He is earnest and kind, and Winfrey keeps him from becoming a saint by giving him his own sense that something is missing. The supporting friends are fun without stealing scenes.

Writing and Pacing

Winfrey's style is relaxed and funny, and Publishers Weekly called it "a sweet and fluffy rom-com." The pacing is the issue. At 384 pages, the book takes its time, and the slow start costs it momentum that the middle has to win back. Courtney at The Green Mockingbird noted the language ranges from mild to fairly strong, which may surprise readers who expect a children's TV host to keep it clean on and off the page.

Patti Murin's audiobook reading is a good way in; April at Good Books and Good Wine listened and noted how light the spice is.

Very Sincerely Yours is a kind, cosy pen pal romance with a hero you will want to protect and a start you may want to skim. Read it if gentleness is what you are after; skip it if you need spark and speed.

How Spicy Is Very Sincerely Yours?

Very Sincerely Yours is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. Carol at Reading Ladies and Courtney at The Green Mockingbird both describe the book as closed door, with sensual moments but no explicit scenes, and April at Good Books and Good Wine notes there is little spice.

For more books like this, see our closed door romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from Kirkus and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read Very Sincerely Yours?

Very Sincerely Yours suits readers who want a soft, slow, closed door romance built on letters and kindness. It is less suited to readers who want fast pacing, banter-driven tension or any heat.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Very Sincerely Yours had warm trade coverage: Publishers Weekly called it sweet and fluffy, Kirkus called it cozy, BookPage gave it a starred review and USA Today said readers would root for the quirky pair. Readers mostly agree on its kindness and split on its pace.

Where they agree. The hero and the heart. Under the Covers compared Everett to Mister Rogers, Harlequin Junkie found the romance fated and the characters well matched, and Novel Novice and Reading Ladies enjoyed the gentle tone.

Where they split. Pace and conflict. Harlequin Junkie found the beginning slow and some dialogue forced, Kate at Smexy Books flagged the third-act breakup, and the StoryGraph reader jdm1005 put the conflict down to miscommunication.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Very Sincerely Yours scores 7.3 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for a heat level and ending that match its gentle promise, and its weaker marks for a slow start and a communication-driven conflict.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5The letters build real warmth; in person the chemistry stays mild, as Harlequin Junkie notes.
Characters (15%)3.5Everett is memorable, per Under the Covers; Teddy is relatable but passive early on.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Relaxed, funny prose; Harlequin Junkie finds the opening slow and some dialogue forced.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Teddy's recovery from a demeaning relationship lands, per Kirkus; stakes stay low.
Heat level (10%)4Exactly the closed door sweetness readers report, from Reading Ladies to The Green Mockingbird.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A warm, fitting ending, which Harlequin Junkie calls two peas in a pod.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5The letters reward a reread; the slow start does not.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Very Sincerely Yours is Kerry Winfrey's softest book, behind Not Like the Movies and ahead of Faking Christmas in our ranking, with a final Eikna Score of 7.3/10.

Is Very Sincerely Yours a Standalone?

Yes. Very Sincerely Yours is a standalone and does not need any other Kerry Winfrey book. If you want to read her in order of publication, it comes third, after her two-book duology.

  1. Waiting for Tom Hanks (2019): duology book 1
  2. Not Like the Movies (2020): duology book 2
  3. Very Sincerely Yours (2021): standalone
  4. Just Another Love Song (2022): standalone
  5. Faking Christmas (2023): standalone

Best format: print, so you can see the letters on the page, or the Patti Murin audiobook if you want the gentle tone performed. Our series order guide has more.

If You Loved Very Sincerely Yours, Read These Next

If you loved Very Sincerely Yours, try other gentle romances with kind heroes, letters or a slow, careful build.

Frequently Asked Questions

These are the questions readers ask most about Very Sincerely Yours.

Is Very Sincerely Yours spicy?

No. Very Sincerely Yours is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, a closed door romance with sensual moments but no explicit scenes.

Is Very Sincerely Yours a standalone?

Yes. Very Sincerely Yours is a standalone and does not connect to Kerry Winfrey's Waiting for Tom Hanks duology.

Does Very Sincerely Yours have a happy ending?

Yes. Teddy and Everett end together after a third-act breakup.

Who narrates the Very Sincerely Yours audiobook?

Patti Murin narrates the audiobook, which runs about 10 hours.

Where is Very Sincerely Yours set?

Very Sincerely Yours is set in contemporary Columbus, Ohio.

Is Everett based on Mister Rogers?

The book does not say so, but reviewers, including Under the Covers, compare Everett and his children's show to Mister Rogers.

The Bottom Line

Very Sincerely Yours earns a 7.3/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a clean, slow, comforting pen pal romance with a hero whose whole job is kindness. The one reason to pick it up is Everett, who makes being decent look romantic; just be ready to wait for the story to get going.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.