Not Like the Movies by Kerry Winfrey Review
Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.
Not Like the Movies is the better half of Kerry Winfrey's duology: funnier than Waiting for Tom Hanks, sadder too, and built around a heroine whose exhaustion feels real. Its meta joke about a movie made from her love life is clever, though the hero stays a little too quiet and one late choice will test some readers' patience.
Read it if you like rom-coms with real weight underneath, or you want a slow, workplace romance between two people who already know each other well. Skip it if you need dual POV and a fully drawn hero, or caregiving for a parent with dementia is too close to home right now.
Not Like the Movies at a Glance
Not Like the Movies is the second book in Kerry Winfrey's Waiting for Tom Hanks duology, a 2020 Berkley romantic comedy about Chloe Sanderson, a caregiver and coffee shop worker who falls for her boss while her best friend's film about them hits theaters. It is closed door and ends happily.
| Author | Kerry Winfrey |
|---|---|
| Series | Book 2 of a duology, after Waiting for Tom Hanks; can be read alone |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy, contemporary |
| Main tropes | Workplace romance, boss and employee, friends to lovers, slow burn, meta rom-com |
| Spice level | 1/5: Kisses only / closed door |
| Content warnings | Parent with early-onset Alzheimer's, caregiver burnout, parental abandonment (full list below) |
| POV | First person, Chloe only |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 320 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Reba Buhr, 8 hours 36 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio) |
| First published | July 7, 2020 |
| Publisher | Berkley |
What Is Not Like the Movies About?
Not Like the Movies belongs to Chloe Sanderson, Annie's best friend from Waiting for Tom Hanks. Chloe is an optimist with no time for romance. She is her father's only caregiver since his early-onset Alzheimer's diagnosis, she is finishing her degree online, and she works at a Columbus coffee shop she loves for Nick Velez, her gruff, steady boss.
Then Annie's screenplay becomes a movie, and the movie is plainly about Chloe and Nick. As the film builds buzz and strangers start rooting for a couple that does not exist, Chloe has to work out whether what she feels for Nick is real, and whether there is any room in her life for it.
What Makes This Workplace Romance Work
Not Like the Movies works because its romance has to fit into a life that is already full. Chloe is not waiting for love; she is running a household, and Nick is part of the furniture of her days. That makes the slow turn from boss and friend to something else feel earned rather than staged.
The meta layer gives it a hook no other rom-com has. Annie's film, inspired by the two of them, is out in the world, and everyone around Chloe has opinions about how the story should end. Publishers Weekly called it a "delightfully meta rom-com" in its starred review, and Kirkus said Winfrey excels at upending typical romantic comedy tropes.
Underneath the jokes is a family story. Chloe's care for her father is the emotional engine, and readers who like a slow burn grounded in daily life will find plenty here.
My Review
Not Like the Movies surprised me. I expected a victory lap for Annie's best friend and got a much more grown-up book: funnier in its banter, heavier in its subject and braver about letting the heroine be tired, short-tempered and sometimes wrong.
T.K. at Genie in a Novel said the caregiving shapes everything about Chloe, and that is the book's best quality. Romance novels often hand a heroine a sick parent as backstory. Here the illness sets the schedule, drains the bank account and decides what Chloe can say yes to.
Romance and Chemistry
Chloe and Nick's banter is the highlight. They argue about music at work, needle each other about the movie and fall into the kind of shorthand you get from working side by side for years. Emma at Books Real When Shared loved the workplace music fights, and so did I. Library Journal praised the sparkling dialogue, which is accurate.
The weak spot is Nick himself. The book is told only from Chloe's side, and Nick is a man of few words, so we get his kindness without much of his inner life. bookrecs and blooms wanted his perspective too, and Erin at The Smut Report found him underdeveloped. I liked him, but I liked him the way you like a nice coworker. The late conflict, which turns on Chloe pushing Nick away, is where readers split hardest. Erin rejected how the book handled it, and T.K. found one relationship choice frustrating. I understood Chloe's reasons, and I still wanted the repair to take longer.
The Characters
Chloe is a complicated heroine, and Kirkus used that exact word. She is warm with her father and prickly with almost everyone else, and her history with a mother who left the family explains a lot of the prickliness. A Publishers Weekly feature noted she is bisexual, which the book handles in passing rather than as a plot point.
April at Good Books and Good Wine found the character development credible, and the supporting cast is as strong as in book one. Annie and Drew drop by, which is a pleasure if you read the first book, and Michelle at Book Briefs noted these cameos reveal how their story turned out.
Writing and Pacing
Winfrey's prose is quick and funny, and Shelf Awareness praised the fast-paced, sparring banter. The film subplot gives the middle a shape: premiere, press, public expectation. Emma wanted more of the movie and a less predictable conflict, and I agree about the second part. The final act follows the usual rom-com grammar so closely that a book about defying the movies ends up feeling like one. Romantically Inclined Reviews called it an emotionally heavier comedy, and that is the right label.
Not Like the Movies is a funny, warm rom-com with a real caregiving story at its centre and a hero who could have used a few more lines. Read it if you want laughs with some weight; skip it if a predictable third-act breakup ruins a book for you.
How Spicy Is Not Like the Movies?
Not Like the Movies is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. Romantically Inclined Reviews and Erin at The Smut Report both describe the sex as closed door: the book cuts away, and the heat is in the banter and the slow build rather than on the page.
That makes it a good fit for our closed door romance list.
Content warnings, drawn from Kirkus and reader reviews:
- A parent with early-onset Alzheimer's disease
- Caregiver stress, financial strain and burnout
- Parental abandonment in the heroine's childhood
- A heroine who pushes her partner away under pressure
- Some strong language
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Who Should Read Not Like the Movies?
Not Like the Movies suits readers who want a romantic comedy that does not look away from hard family realities, told with banter and warmth. It is less suited to readers who want dual POV, spice or a hero whose thoughts we hear.
Best for:
- Readers who liked Chloe in Waiting for Tom Hanks
- Fans of workplace and friends to lovers romance
- Readers who want caregiving represented honestly
- People who love banter about music and movies
- Closed door romance readers
Not for:
- Readers who need the hero's point of view
- Anyone currently caring for a parent with dementia who wants pure escapism
- Readers allergic to a third-act breakup
- Readers looking for steam
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Not Like the Movies received a starred review from Publishers Weekly, and Kirkus, Library Journal, BookPage and Shelf Awareness were all positive. Reader reviews are warm about Chloe and the caregiving story and divided on Nick and on the final conflict.
Where they agree. The banter and the heart. Publishers Weekly praised its wit and quiet devotion, BookPage praised its richly developed characters and supportive friends, and Genie in a Novel and Good Books and Good Wine both found Chloe's growth convincing.
Where they split. The hero and the ending. Erin at The Smut Report understood Chloe's strain but rejected how the book handled boundaries and found Nick thin. bookrecs and blooms wanted his POV. A StoryGraph reader, sophir, objected to how Chloe assigns blame. Emma at Books Real When Shared wanted a less predictable conflict.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Not Like the Movies scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for characters, writing and emotional impact, and lower marks for the romance and the ending, where reviewers found Nick thin and the conflict predictable.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Great banter, per Books Real When Shared; Nick's inner life stays offstage, as bookrecs and blooms notes. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Kirkus calls Chloe complicated; Genie in a Novel finds her caregiving-shaped and real. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Shelf Awareness praises the sparring pace; Library Journal the sparkling dialogue. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | The father storyline gives real weight, as Romantically Inclined Reviews notes. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers exactly the closed door romance readers report, with the heat in the talk. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A clear HEA, per Good Books and Good Wine; Erin and T.K. dislike the late conflict. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Banter and cameos reward a reread; the third act stays predictable. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Not Like the Movies is the stronger book of Kerry Winfrey's duology and one of her best rom-coms overall, with a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.
Waiting for Tom Hanks Reading Order
Not Like the Movies is book 2 of the Waiting for Tom Hanks duology. It works as a standalone, but reading Waiting for Tom Hanks first is better: Annie's film only lands as a joke if you know her, and the cameos reveal how book one ends.
- Book 1: Waiting for Tom Hanks (2019): Annie and Drew
- Book 2: Not Like the Movies (2020): Chloe and Nick
Best format: April at Good Books and Good Wine listened to the Reba Buhr audiobook and enjoyed it, and the banter suits performance. Our series order guide covers more series.
If You Loved Not Like the Movies, Read These Next
If you loved Not Like the Movies, try contemporary romances where a heroine with real responsibilities finds love close to home.
- Waiting for Tom Hanks by Kerry Winfrey: the lighter first book, with Annie and a movie star.
- Just Another Love Song by Kerry Winfrey: a second chance romance with the same Ohio warmth and a famous musician.
- The Ex Talk by Rachel Lynn Solomon: workplace banter between radio hosts, with a fake relationship and more heat.
- Love Lettering by Kate Clayborn: a slow, quiet romance between two careful people.
- The Neighbor Favor by Kristina Forest: a gentle, bookish romance with a hero who shows up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Not Like the Movies cover reading order, heat, the ending and the audiobook.
Do I need to read Waiting for Tom Hanks before Not Like the Movies?
No, but it helps. Not Like the Movies works on its own, though it spoils how Waiting for Tom Hanks ends.
Is Not Like the Movies spicy?
No. Not Like the Movies is a 1 out of 5 on our scale; reviewers describe the intimate scenes as closed door.
Does Not Like the Movies have a happy ending?
Yes. Chloe and Nick reach a happily ever after after a late conflict.
Is Not Like the Movies dual POV?
No. Not Like the Movies is told only from Chloe's point of view, which some readers wish had included Nick.
Who narrates the Not Like the Movies audiobook?
Reba Buhr narrates the audiobook, which runs about 8 hours 36 minutes.
What is Not Like the Movies about?
Not Like the Movies follows Chloe Sanderson, who cares for her father with early-onset Alzheimer's and falls for her boss Nick while a film based on them is released.
The Bottom Line
Not Like the Movies earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want their romantic comedy with banter, a caregiving story told straight and a slow, familiar love. The one reason to pick it up is Chloe, a heroine whose tiredness and stubbornness feel lived in.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Not Like the Movies, Penguin Random House
- Not Like the Movies, Kirkus Reviews
- Not Like the Movies audiobook, Libro.fm (Library Journal series note)
- Not Like the Movies audiobook review, Good Books and Good Wine
- Publishers Weekly, Kirkus, Library Journal, BookPage and Shelf Awareness quotes as listed by Penguin Random House
- Publishers Weekly feature by Rachel Kramer Bussel (bisexual heroine)
- Reader reviews: The Smut Report, Books Real When Shared, Genie in a Novel, bookrecs and blooms, Book Briefs, Romantically Inclined Reviews, StoryGraph
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.