Roomies by Christina Lauren Review
Eikna Score: 6.8/10. Recommended with reservations.
Roomies is Christina Lauren at their most theatrical: a shy woman, a subway busker and a green card wedding staged so he can play a Broadway pit. The backstage world and the awkward early weeks of the marriage are a pleasure, but the book never fully reckons with the immigration shortcut at its center, and Holland spends a long time doubting herself.
Read it if you love marriage of convenience setups and theatre settings, or you want a sweet, warm rom com with some open-door heat. Skip it if a fake marriage to dodge immigration law will bother you, or you get impatient with a heroine stuck in self-doubt.
Roomies at a Glance
Roomies is a standalone contemporary romance by Christina Lauren, published by Gallery Books on December 5, 2017. It is told by Holland Bakker in first person, runs on a marriage of convenience between Holland and an Irish street musician, has moderate open-door heat and ends with a happily ever after.
| Author | Christina Lauren (Christina Hobbs and Lauren Billings) |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Contemporary romance, romantic comedy |
| Main tropes | Marriage of convenience, green card marriage, forced proximity, secret crush, Broadway setting |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Subway assault, alcohol, immigration deception (full list below) |
| POV | First person, Holland only |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 368 (Gallery Books paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by K.C. Sheridan, 9 hours 35 minutes (Simon & Schuster Audio) |
| First published | December 5, 2017 |
| Publisher | Gallery Books, an imprint of Simon & Schuster |
What Is Roomies About?
Holland Bakker lives in Manhattan with a lot of help from her uncles and very little idea of what she wants from her own life. One of those uncles runs the music for a hit Broadway show. For months Holland has been going out of her way through one subway station to hear a guitarist play, without ever saying a word to him.
When she finally gets the busker, Calvin McLoughlin, an audition for her uncle's hit show, he blows everyone away. Then the problem surfaces: Calvin is Irish and his visa ran out long ago. Holland, who has been half in love with him since before they spoke, offers the obvious and very bad solution. She marries him. Then they have to live together, convince immigration officials, and find out whether any of it is real.
What Makes This Marriage of Convenience Romance Work
Roomies works because its marriage of convenience is lopsided from the first page. Holland has a crush and Calvin needs a visa, so every kind gesture lands differently for each of them, and the book gets a lot of mileage out of that gap. The fake marriage is a business deal for one partner and a quiet catastrophe for the other.
Forced proximity does the rest. Two near strangers share an apartment, rehearse their how-we-met story for immigration interviews and figure out where the other one keeps the coffee. Publishers Weekly singled out the sweet tension created by Holland hoping Calvin will come to love her, and that hope is the engine of the book.
The theatre setting is the other draw. Calvin goes from a subway platform to the orchestra pit of a hit show, and the backstage scenes, with their egos, understudies and long nights, give the romance a world to move through. The Terror of Knowing liked the backstage ensemble most of all. If you like marriage of convenience stories with a real job on the line, the hook is strong.
My Review
I came to Roomies after the later Christina Lauren books, and it reads like the duo finding the voice they would use in The Unhoneymooners: warm, chatty, a little self-mocking, built around a heroine who thinks she is the least interesting person in her own life. That is a lovable starting point. It is also the book's recurring problem.
Holland narrates everything, and her running commentary on her own inadequacy is funny for the first hundred pages and wearing by the second. Angela at Wicked Reads put it well when she found Holland's self-doubt emotionally involving but sometimes frustrating. I nodded at both halves of that.
Romance and Chemistry
The best stretch of Roomies is the first month of the marriage. Holland and Calvin barely know each other, and the book is smart about the small embarrassments of sudden cohabitation: the bathroom schedule, the questions you suddenly cannot ask, the moment you realize you have no idea how your spouse takes his tea. Tabs at Good Bad and Unread liked the ease and chemistry between them, and so did I. Calvin is open and affectionate in a way that keeps the tension from turning sour.
Where it wobbles is communication. Both of them hold back things the other deserves to know, and the late conflict depends on that silence. Tabs questioned the contrivance and the communication failures, and on r/RomanceBooks a reader named othgg objected to how unevenly the book holds each partner accountable for what they hid. I would not go that far, but the reckoning is lighter than the setup earns. The marriage turns real in a way that feels true. The path there feels managed.
The Characters
Calvin is the easier character to like. He is talented, a little reckless and sincerely grateful, and Christina Lauren give him enough history and ambition that he feels like more than a love interest with a guitar. He is seen only through Holland's eyes, though, and some of his inner life stays off the page because of that single point of view.
Holland's arc is about finding something she wants for herself instead of orbiting other people's talent, and the payoff is satisfying. Her uncles are wonderful, a loving and funny couple who give the book some of its warmest scenes. Gretchen at About That Story enjoyed Holland's voice but said the book took time to pull her in, which matches my experience: the first act is slow, and the book picks up once the wedding happens.
Writing and Pacing
The prose is clean and quick, with a lot of interior commentary and some lovely descriptions of music. The Broadway material is vivid enough to carry readers who do not know the world, though The Terror of Knowing was careful not to vouch for how accurate it is. The middle section, where the marriage settles into routine and attraction grows, is the strongest pacing in the book.
The weak point is the immigration plot. Llama Reads Books enjoyed the humor but found the wealth-assisted handling of the immigration problem jarringly tone-deaf, and that criticism has aged into the most common complaint about Roomies. The book knows the marriage is a crime of sorts. It mostly treats it as a romantic complication. Whether that reads as escapism or as a blind spot will depend on the reader.
Roomies is a warm, slightly uneven marriage of convenience romance with a great backstage setting and a heroine who takes too long to believe in herself. Read it if the green card premise does not bother you and you want an early Christina Lauren book with real heart.
How Spicy Is Roomies?
Roomies is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are a handful of open-door, consensual sex scenes once the marriage turns romantic, described with some frankness but not in great length. The first half is mostly tension and longing.
Reddit readers and Tabs at Good Bad and Unread both note the sexual content; it is moderate by Christina Lauren standards, a notch below their hotter books and a notch above In a Holidaze. For more books in this heat range, see our spicy romance list.
Content warnings, drawn from the publisher description and reader reviews:
- A frightening assault in a subway station early in the book
- Alcohol use
- A marriage arranged to get around immigration law, with the deception it requires
- Secrets kept between the leads, and one partner's feelings hidden for much of the book
- On-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Who Should Read Roomies?
Roomies suits readers who want a cozy, character-driven marriage of convenience romance set in New York's theatre world, with moderate heat and a guaranteed happy ending. It is a weaker fit for readers who want sharp conflict or who find green card marriage plots uncomfortable.
Best for:
- Fans of marriage of convenience and forced proximity stories
- Readers who love theatre, musicians and backstage settings
- Anyone who enjoyed The Unhoneymooners and wants more Christina Lauren
- Readers who like a heroine with a long-held secret crush
Not for:
- Readers who will be bothered by immigration fraud played for romance
- Anyone who wants both leads' points of view
- Readers impatient with self-doubting heroines
- Those who want a fast, banter-heavy opening
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Roomies has been a reliable reader favorite since 2017, and it remains one of the Christina Lauren titles most often recommended for marriage of convenience fans. Most coverage now comes from blogs and reader reviews rather than trade critics.
Where they agree. The chemistry and the setting. Publishers Weekly praised the sweet tension of Holland hoping Calvin will love her back, Tabs at Good Bad and Unread liked the couple's ease together, and The Terror of Knowing valued the backstage ensemble. Readers on r/RomanceBooks, including canquilt and Phoenix_RebornAgain, report a satisfying HEA and wished for more time with the couple at the end.
Where they split. The immigration premise and the communication. Llama Reads Books found the handling of Calvin's visa problem tone-deaf, Tabs questioned the contrivances, and othgg on Reddit objected to the uneven accountability between the leads, while another Reddit reader, sikonat, shared some concerns but defended Holland on one of the disputed points. Holland herself divides readers: Gretchen at About That Story enjoyed her voice, while Angela at Wicked Reads found her doubts frustrating at times.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Roomies scores 6.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for romance, writing and emotional pull, and its lowest for characters and reread appeal, where the heroine's long self-doubt and the soft handling of the immigration plot cost it.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Strong cohabitation chemistry, per Tabs at Good Bad and Unread; late conflict leans on withheld information. |
| Characters (15%) | 3 | Calvin and the uncles shine; Angela at Wicked Reads finds Holland's self-doubt frustrating. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Clean, warm prose and a vivid theatre world; the opening is slow, as About That Story notes. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Publishers Weekly praises the sweet tension of a secret crush; the stakes stay modest. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Delivers the moderate open-door payoff that Reddit readers describe; nothing gratuitous. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A clear HEA that readers on r/RomanceBooks enjoyed, though the reckoning is light. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | Comfortable to revisit for the backstage scenes; the immigration plot is harder to ignore twice. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Roomies sits in the middle of Christina Lauren's standalone rom coms, warmer than some but less polished than The Unhoneymooners, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 6.8/10.
Is Roomies a Standalone?
Yes. Roomies is a standalone novel, and the Christina Lauren author page lists it with no series. You can read it at any point in their catalogue.
If you want to read around it, these Christina Lauren standalones share its tone and are reviewed on Eikna:
- Roomies (2017)
- Josh and Hazel's Guide to Not Dating (2018)
- Love and Other Words (2018)
- The Unhoneymooners (2019)
- In a Holidaze (2020)
- The Soulmate Equation (2021)
- The True Love Experiment (2023)
Best format: the Simon & Schuster audiobook narrated by K.C. Sheridan runs about nine and a half hours, and hearing the music scenes read aloud suits the book. Our series order guide covers connected romance series if you want something longer.
If You Loved Roomies, Read These Next
If you loved Roomies, the closest matches are romances where a practical arrangement or shared space slowly becomes the real thing.
- The Wall of Winnipeg and Me by Mariana Zapata: another marriage to solve an immigration problem, with a much slower burn.
- The Unhoneymooners by Christina Lauren: the same authors, sharper banter and a fake marriage on a free honeymoon.
- Accidentally Engaged by Farah Heron: a fake engagement, a shared apartment and a lot of cooking.
- Josh and Hazel's Guide to Not Dating by Christina Lauren: a sillier, friends-to-lovers Christina Lauren with the same warmth.
- The Flatshare by Beth O'Leary: two strangers share one flat and fall in love through notes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Roomies prompts the same few questions from new readers: how spicy it is, whether it is a standalone, how it ends and whether the audiobook is worth it. Short answers below.
Is Roomies by Christina Lauren spicy?
Moderately. Roomies is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with a few open-door, consensual sex scenes after the marriage turns romantic.
Is Roomies a standalone?
Yes. Roomies is a standalone novel with no sequel, so you can start with it or read it at any point in Christina Lauren's catalogue.
Does Roomies have a happy ending?
Yes. Roomies ends with a happily ever after for Holland and Calvin.
What is the trope in Roomies?
Roomies is a marriage of convenience romance: Holland marries Calvin so he can stay in the country and play in a Broadway show, and they have to live together to make it convincing.
Who narrates the Roomies audiobook?
K.C. Sheridan narrates the Simon & Schuster Audio edition, which runs about 9 hours 35 minutes.
Is Roomies told from both points of view?
No. Roomies is told entirely in first person by Holland, so Calvin is seen only through her eyes.
The Bottom Line
Roomies earns a 6.8/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a sweet, moderately spicy marriage of convenience story with a theatre backdrop and do not mind a soft touch on the immigration plot. The one reason to pick it up is the first month of that marriage, when two strangers learn to share a flat and one of them is already in love.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Roomies, Simon & Schuster (edition details)
- Roomies, Christina Lauren official site
- Roomies audiobook, Libro.fm (narrator, length)
- Publishers Weekly review of Roomies
- Llama Reads Books; Tabs, Good Bad and Unread; The Terror of Knowing; Gretchen, About That Story; Angela, Wicked Reads (blog reviews)
- r/RomanceBooks reader discussion (canquilt, Phoenix_RebornAgain, othgg, sikonat)
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.